westprog
Philosopher
- Joined
- Dec 1, 2006
- Messages
- 8,928
I would like to point out in counterpoint to the 'racist' accusation, that several thousand Italian families (and a few German) were also interned on the West Coast following the same pattern and target as Japanese families. Not that there wasn't an element of racism in the internment, but it was not as exclusive as some have made it out to be.
There's no doubt that but for Pearl Harbor, anti-Japanese racist sentiment wouldn't have been able to have the Japanese farmers run out of California. But if racism hadn't been an element, it's unlikely that the mass internments would have taken place.
There was also the little fact that it was not impossible to be allowed to leave the internment camps. You would be allowed to leave (whatever your ancestry) if you pronounced loyalty to the US and agreed to move elsewhere in the USA. This ruined many people's established businesses and disrupted lives but it was more of an option than victims of the concentration camps ever had.
Exactly so. The American internments were wrong. The Jewish camps were horrendously worse, to the extent that they can't really be meaningfully compared.
Some 40,000 of the 110,000 Japanese Americans did relocate.
And a substantial number of young men went off to get shot at in Europe while the government kept their families imprisoned.
Things could have been similar with German Americans on the East Coast had Hitler posessed a Japanese size Navy and a threat of invasion existed. It might have been impractical given the sheer numbers of Americans with German ancestry. But doubtless German citizens would have been rounded up. As it was, many German organizations were watched like a hawk lest they start some kind of East Coast Niihau incident.
There's also the fact that the Japanese in Hawaii weren't interned. This was again for practical purposes. In spite of the critical importance of Hawaii to the war, it was decided that actually locking up about a third of the population would be detrimental. Hoover had already advised that there was no need for internment.