[Moderated]The Holocaust never happened!

I would like to point out in counterpoint to the 'racist' accusation, that several thousand Italian families (and a few German) were also interned on the West Coast following the same pattern and target as Japanese families. Not that there wasn't an element of racism in the internment, but it was not as exclusive as some have made it out to be.

There's no doubt that but for Pearl Harbor, anti-Japanese racist sentiment wouldn't have been able to have the Japanese farmers run out of California. But if racism hadn't been an element, it's unlikely that the mass internments would have taken place.

There was also the little fact that it was not impossible to be allowed to leave the internment camps. You would be allowed to leave (whatever your ancestry) if you pronounced loyalty to the US and agreed to move elsewhere in the USA. This ruined many people's established businesses and disrupted lives but it was more of an option than victims of the concentration camps ever had.

Exactly so. The American internments were wrong. The Jewish camps were horrendously worse, to the extent that they can't really be meaningfully compared.

Some 40,000 of the 110,000 Japanese Americans did relocate.


And a substantial number of young men went off to get shot at in Europe while the government kept their families imprisoned.

Things could have been similar with German Americans on the East Coast had Hitler posessed a Japanese size Navy and a threat of invasion existed. It might have been impractical given the sheer numbers of Americans with German ancestry. But doubtless German citizens would have been rounded up. As it was, many German organizations were watched like a hawk lest they start some kind of East Coast Niihau incident.

There's also the fact that the Japanese in Hawaii weren't interned. This was again for practical purposes. In spite of the critical importance of Hawaii to the war, it was decided that actually locking up about a third of the population would be detrimental. Hoover had already advised that there was no need for internment.
 
I would like to point out in counterpoint to the 'racist' accusation, that several thousand Italian families (and a few German) were also interned on the West Coast following the same pattern and target as Japanese families. Not that there wasn't an element of racism in the internment, but it was not as exclusive as some have made it out to be.

There's no doubt that but for Pearl Harbor, anti-Japanese racist sentiment wouldn't have been able to have the Japanese farmers run out of California. But if racism hadn't been an element, it's unlikely that the mass internments would have taken place.

There was also the little fact that it was not impossible to be allowed to leave the internment camps. You would be allowed to leave (whatever your ancestry) if you pronounced loyalty to the US and agreed to move elsewhere in the USA. This ruined many people's established businesses and disrupted lives but it was more of an option than victims of the concentration camps ever had.

Exactly so. The American internments were wrong. The Jewish camps were horrendously worse, to the extent that they can't really be meaningfully compared.

Some 40,000 of the 110,000 Japanese Americans did relocate.


And a substantial number of young men went off to get shot at in Europe while the government kept their families imprisoned.

Things could have been similar with German Americans on the East Coast had Hitler posessed a Japanese size Navy and a threat of invasion existed. It might have been impractical given the sheer numbers of Americans with German ancestry. But doubtless German citizens would have been rounded up. As it was, many German organizations were watched like a hawk lest they start some kind of East Coast Niihau incident.

There's also the fact that the Japanese in Hawaii weren't interned. This was again for practical purposes. In spite of the critical importance of Hawaii to the war, it was decided that actually locking up about a third of the population would be detrimental. Hoover had already advised that there was no need for internment.
 
MaG(got)Z is getting perfunctory, typing in little pieces of neo-Nazi boilerplate as if they were conclusive rejoinders. IOW, he's just repeating dogma that he's learned in what passes for Sunday school in his little set.

Did I say Sunday school? Sorry, I meant Scumday school.

I never use the Iggy button, but I believe I'm done with MaG. Sieg heil, and have a nice day.
 
Norway also had a government that cooperated with the germans. If I spit on Denmark, I defecate on Lithuania, Letland and Estonia But's thats a different subject.

I'm a bit disturbed, mate.

Either you're a lot older than me and take this personally, or you've just got yourself twisted up for no reason.

WWII was an extraordinary event and stands [so far] as the supreme example of human inhumanity and atrocities happened on all sides. Some were worse than others.

What point is there in harbouring resentment over half a century after the event? Yugoslavia provided a lovely example of what happens when those feelings are allowed to fester.

Isn't there sufficient hatred and animosity between countries without dragging up ones which now go back almost 70 years?

I agree with you on the facts, and I'm in the luxurious position of coming from a country with an almost impeccable balance sheet in both WWs (and the bloody Boer War, we just love fighting everyone else's battles) - high participation and casualty rates; praised on both sides for honesty and ferocity, with the sole atrocity committed at home.

War is an indescribable [and to my mind, inexplicable] blot on human history. WWII is the worst war we've had. Let it sit in the history class. I had an uncle killed in WWII and my father, grandfather, mother and other family members were active participants.

Ask a South African from the high veldt which country invented concentration camps and what the death-rate was in British ones.

Trade unionists, gypsies, homosexuals, and even a number of roman catholics also died in the holocaust. They should not be forgotten.

They aren't, but what I find interesting - as in every Holocaust discussion - the fags*, Gyppos and commies always get brought up straight after the Jews. "Don't forget the fags!" Glad you got as far as "a number of christians". Yes, it was "a number". A ####ing big one: >3M.

I did notice one person hadn't forgotten the other Europeans, but in numerical terms, as always, it's the Polacks who miss out. Not content with being the butt of an enormous number of jokes, the Poles gave 20% of their population to the death-machine. Let's not forget that the Holocaust wasn't just six million Jews, it was also six million Poles. Half of the Poles were Jewish, just as half the Jews were Polish.

Colour me cynical, but it is rarely presented that way. Not to mention, that once Poland had been "liberated" by Russia, they were subjected to a further half-century of joy.

People (and not just from one camp, people IN GENERAL) tend to exaggerate. That pretty much covers this issue.

And almost every other issue that gets heated discussions for that matter.
(Bolding mine)

Very Zen. People tend to generalise too.

Which overstatement/exaggeration are you referring to?

The numbers? Hell, so they may be a little overstated and only three million died.

Does that make the Holocaust half as bad we thought it was yesterday?

See, the utter bollocks of your statement is similar to those who would have evolution and ID as 50:50 options. If the exaggeration is saying 6 million and the real number was only 4.3M, does that count the same as MaGz's exaggeration, reducing that 4,300,000 down to 237? After all, he's only exaggerating his case, eh?


*N.B. I am demonstrably gay-friendly and non-racist, epithets used for illustrative purposes only.
 
I'm just waiting for MaGz or any other Nazi to say, "the Holocaust didn't happen, because the Nazis had no reason to kill the Jews. The Jews were innocent victims and the Nazis saw them as such".

Deep down in MaGz's heart and soul, he knows the Holocaust happened, he is glad it happened, and he only wishes they had finished the job.
 
The Nazi holocaust was a conspiracy. Holocaust deniers are denying a conspiracy. Those who accept the holocaust are accepting a conspiracy.

The OP constructs the story using opposite semantics, characterizing holocaust denial as a conspiracy. Whatever your views on the holocaust and whatever your views on 9/11, it is much more semantically consistent to do as I have done, and that is call the holocaust what it was - a conspiracy.

English is widely used

You should learn it.
 
Yes, the Holocaust was a conspiracy. It was a conspiracy because it involved thousands of people conspiring to commit mass murder.

...But we all know..thats not what a "conspiracy theory" means in the modern day. The TRUE conspiracy theory involving the Holocaust..is that it DID NOT happen. The Holocaust was faked by rich Jewish bankers and Soviet kommisars inorder to get support for Israel. This is the real "conspiracy theory" when it comes to the Holocaust.

So stop playing stupid games..."Truthseeker". You are no truth seeker. labeling yourself that doesn't make it so.
 
You're not alone. New Zealand did exactly the same, putting all Japs into concentration camps.
As did Canada - Japanese-Canadian citizens were also put into internment camps for the duration of the war. It was not that long ago that the Canadian government officially apologized for that action. If I recall correctly, there were also ongoing negotiations for a financial compensation package of some kind for those who had been interned and their families.
 
So this Dane and Norwegian walk into a bar....

No, really! Last night in Hong Kong. I didn't bring up the topic but my two co-workers (Henrik from Cph / Anders from Oslo) were comparing notes on their own collaborationists from WWII.

Purely anecdotal, but Henrik's dad had six brothers. Three of them were fishermen who did the '43 escape run. Two of them were not involved at all, and the youngest joined the local Nazi party. The family legend is that the three fishermen were caught and shot returning to Denmark after making the trip to Sweden. (The other side of the legend is that no one speaks of the Nazi uncle.)

Like I said, ... purely anecdotal, but I was surprised to stumble on this conversation the evening after reading this thread, and intending to post on the below topics when I had some free time.



What's with the Dane-bashing? Really? The worst thing is the horrible legend of Kind King Christian and the Star, but that's somewhat akin to Americans wanting to believe that Betsy Ross sewed the flag on her front porch in a rocking chair, or many other such patriotic legends around the world.. The facts of the Danish occupation speak for themselves. They emigrated, illegally and at risk, around 7000 Danish Jews. Of the roughly 500 who were deported for internment, the "government" kept up a vocal public relations pressure on the Germans so that all but 51 of them were eventually repatriated to Denmark. Those numbers don't sound huge when you're counting 3 versus 6 million dead, but the number of Jews in Denmark was tiny. The numbers "saved" nearly equal to the entire Jewish population of the country.

Also, the fact that any major Danish resistance started in '43 is misleading. In retrospect, the Russian reversals were the beginning of the end, as we're now aware, but Western Europe was solidly defended. Anzio wasn't until early '44. There were no fronts anywhere that would indicate to a local Dane that liberation was near. It's much more logical to assume that it wasn't until '43 that the Germans started applying the iron fist a little more and thus any simmering resistance found more support.

Everyone in occupied Europe has embroidered their valiant resistance movement. In the 50s and 60s you couldn't meet a Frenchman over 35 who hadn't personally blown up a troop train or saved some important papers from the evil clutches of Les Bosches! Yeah! the French idea of "resistance" when the Germans marched into Paris was to raise the prices of the wine in the bistros! "Hey, hey, we'll show zem.... I just charged him 180 francs for a '33 Chateu D'Yqem! 1933! Can you imagine? Oh, zey are so, 'ow you say... gullible? Vive La France!"
 
One of the more interesting inside looks at the Japanese internments, that I've read, was George Takei's autobiography To The Stars. http://www.amazon.com/Stars-Autobio...6438425?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1184349033&sr=1-1

His childhood memories of how it affected his family are vivid, and his reaction and thoughts about the apology and reperations are heartfelt and bluntly honest.

I don't wanna buy any movie star biographies, can you give me the gist of his feelings?
 
As the war continued, the Final Solution to the Jewish problem was to relocate them outside Europe toward the east. There never was a planned program of extermination.


No. This was (allegedly) the original plan--when the war started going badly, and there was no place to expel the Jews, then the Nazis decided on extermination. See the Wannsee ConferenceWP.

Jews were placed in relocation camps for the same reason Japanese, Germans, and Italians, were placed in camps in the US.

No. The Jews were not citizens (or children of citizens) of countries with which Germany was at war.

Look at what happened in the Andersonville POW camp in Georgia during the Civil War.


Apples and oranges. There were huge advances in medical knowledge and sanitation in the 75 years between the American Civil War and World War II.
 
Apples and oranges. There were huge advances in medical knowledge and sanitation in the 75 years between the American Civil War and World War II.
I half expect MaGZ to come back, read your comment, and proceed to tell us the U.S. Civil War was also the fault of the Jews.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom