[Merged]Scott Forbes powerdown revisited

All these people knew about the powerdowns since before 9/11. It is not new information.

Actually my question was in relation to our previous correspondence, from 2006, when I asked him for any other information than mentioned in the Killtown interview he had given then. Eg, anything not mentioned there, including 30 coworkers coming forward, would be new information.
 
He said on the radio he was working with a group.

He is actually working with a group of over 30 fellow WTC employees who witnessed the power downs, to have this evidence officially acknowledged.

Scott mentioned no such thing in this interview:
http://www.americanfreedomradio.com/Barrett_09.html
Perhaps you could direct us to the radio show in which you heard him make the statement you're referring to?


Panoply: If possible, please pass along my questions from post #335 to Mr. Forbes. I'd be very interested to know his answers.

It would also be worth asking if he is currently "working with a group of over 30 fellow WTC employees who witnessed the power downs, to have this evidence officially acknowledged". (And if so, acknowledged by whom?)
 
Guys, not to beat a dead horse, but does anyone remember this argument against a tower-wide powerdown on the weekend such was charged?

Okay, here is what I found.

There are at least two witnesses who recall the Observation Deck being open (with power) during the same time-frame that Scott Forbes claims the upper half of WTC2 was powered down.

One website has a personal account by Melissa Papke who relates her visit to the Observation Deck on that "power-down" weekend (9/8/01). She visited the WTC with her friends late in the day, after the last ferry to the Statue of Liberty had departed (i.e. squarely within the period Scott Forbes placed the power downs). She related this: "Brian held my hands in his and stared into my eyes trying to keep me calm as the express elevator climbed and climbed to the observation deck on the 107th floor. We walked around, looked through the telescopes, watched a movie on the history of the buildings, and even pressed a couple of commemorative pennies in one of those little machines". Clearly, there was power on the 107th Floor at that time.

Another blog presents this photo of a ticket to the Observation Deck during the very time that Forbes claims there was no power to that part of the building:

ticketfd7.jpg


ticket2mi0.jpg


Also, there was a public free outdoor festival at 7:00 pm on 9/8/2001 in the World Trade Center Plaza between the two buildings (New York Times, September 7, 2001, E-3), featuring the Twyla Tharp dance troupe. So if there was a power down and massive preparation for building demolition, it would've been in the midst of this public event.

I still would love to see a photo of the buildings at night on 9/8/01 as that would clearly show if any floors, and which floors, experienced a shut-down of power.

I mean... I realize this doesn't account for the whole building. But still... the point is that any argument about that weekend being used to "install demolitions" is absurd because there were plenty of people around to notice. A good deal of them within the building itself. And again, the "power down" excuse can only be used for the South Tower.
 
Easy way to solve this. Ask the janitors who clean the buildings on the weekends. They would have noticed something.

I'm sure some of them had friends who lost their lives or their jobs, and would really be pissed off and a bit suspicious by this time, had they seen something really out of place going on.

There is no way you are going to prevent that sort of operation from producing horrendous piles of dust that somebody with a vaccuum cleaner and a feather duster is going to have to remove even if the blasting crew cleans up after themselves. It takes a while for drywall dust to settle out onto surfaces.
 
Easy way to solve this. Ask the janitors who clean the buildings on the weekends. They would have noticed something.

I'm sure some of them had friends who lost their lives or their jobs, and would really be pissed off and a bit suspicious by this time, had they seen something really out of place going on.

There is no way you are going to prevent that sort of operation from producing horrendous piles of dust that somebody with a vaccuum cleaner and a feather duster is going to have to remove even if the blasting crew cleans up after themselves. It takes a while for drywall dust to settle out onto surfaces.

I've noticed that there's no "Janitors for 9/11 Truth" club.
 
Yeah well why not just ask all the people who Willie or Scott worked with what they think and then just because you find out that a lot of them are dead you can proclaim them all to be on your side?

I mean it's not like you vamp... I mean debunkers are above that or anything.

Just think. Those people were the closest ones to the collapse. If you can get them on your side there would be no debate.

Too bad Willie and Scott lived huh? They could be on your side too.
 
Yeah well why not just ask all the people who Willie or Scott worked with what they think and then just because you find out that a lot of them are dead you can proclaim them all to be on your side?
Isn't it you guys who claim dead people support you? How many of the "Patriots for truth" are dead?

Just think. Those people were the closest ones to the collapse. If you can get them on your side there would be no debate.

Too bad Willie and Scott lived huh? They could be on your side too.
Wasn't Forbes at home on 9/11?
 
Willie hasn't said "boo" about a power down. The janitors work at night. Day porters like Willie are a very small part of the housekeeping staff. A lot of large firms have in-house staff or contract out. I really doubt that a lot of janbitors got killed in the attack. They are usually not in the building during business hours, but would have been when the alledged demolition prep was going on.

The lack of janitors supporting da twoof on this issue says a lot more, and has better evidentiary value than does Miller's lame attempt to claim Orio Palmer as a Patriot for Da Twoof.
 
Ok, I wrote Scott again. I asked the following questions:

Could I rephrase my question?

Are you working with a group of over 30 fellow WTC employees who witnessed the power downs, to have this evidence officially acknowledged?
And got this reply:

I'm not part of any group like that. Has someone used this phrase or suggestion online somewhere?
 
Galileo -

A friend of mine has been in contact with Scott Forbes. He is actually working with a group of over 30 fellow WTC employees who witnessed the power downs, to have this evidence officially acknowledged.

Scott Forbes said:
I'm not part of any group like that.

Please explain.
 
Panolpy - since you're in touch with scott...I've got a few questions that I'd like to know his answers to, if you wouldn't mind passing them along:

- Was his company the only one affected by this "power down"?
- How many people in his company were notified of the power down or of any servers/systems being offline?
- Does he or his HR department have any timesheets for the employees who worked that weekend to verify his claims?
- Why is it that all of the communications about this supposed power down are missing? Were the e-mail servers not backed up? Was no one in any of the other offices (London?) notified via e-mail about this power down?
- Why does he believe the other people who worked with him are refusing to corroborate him? (Especially the ones who no longer work there)
- Who, specifically, at the Port Authority, notified Scott and/or his team/company of the power down?
 
Panolpy - since you're in touch with scott...I've got a few questions that I'd like to know his answers to, if you wouldn't mind passing them along:

- Was his company the only one affected by this "power down"?
- How many people in his company were notified of the power down or of any servers/systems being offline?
- Does he or his HR department have any timesheets for the employees who worked that weekend to verify his claims?
- Why is it that all of the communications about this supposed power down are missing? Were the e-mail servers not backed up? Was no one in any of the other offices (London?) notified via e-mail about this power down?
- Why does he believe the other people who worked with him are refusing to corroborate him? (Especially the ones who no longer work there)
- Who, specifically, at the Port Authority, notified Scott and/or his team/company of the power down?

I've given him the link to this thread, perhaps he'll answer it himself. If not, PM me and I'll give you his email address.
 
I find it funny how Galileo has abandoned this thread after it was proven conclusively that he lied.
 
I communicated about a year ago with Scott Forbes, who now resides in the UK.

Scott Forbes gave me the name and email of a person he says could corroborate his story.

Despite diligent and repeated attempts to contact said person, I was never able to get a reply from him at all.
 
I communicated about a year ago with Scott Forbes, who now resides in the UK.

Scott Forbes gave me the name and email of a person he says could corroborate his story.

Despite diligent and repeated attempts to contact said person, I was never able to get a reply from him at all.
The fact is that even if there was any type of powerdown that weekend, it's irrelevant. Since it did not happen that day and there is no evidence that there is any link to 9/11, the commission didn't need to even mention it. Only twoofers manipulate it into something it's not.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom