[Merged]Scott Forbes powerdown revisited

Thank you for making my point. You are a 9/1 denier and it is not cleared up for you.

That's what I said.

But you said that Forbes' statements had been "cleared up", whatever that means.

So you were making ◊◊◊◊ up. Again.
 
That's a bunch of crap. He has not been smeared here. We've said that he was mistaken, but not smeared.

ya right, he was so upset with what he read here that I heard he went and hurt himself.
 
Derail, anyone? I won't give the obvious answer to Gal here, so I'll just say 'derail', which is a teensy bit hypocritical of me, but, hey-ho.

Bananaman.
 
Galileo, Leonardo da Vinci he aint.

Back on topic. Are you going to address Scott Forbes 5 year inconsistency?
Because this wont fly Galileo.
Its natural for people to have changing opinions
Opinions? Five years ago he states he was "convinced immediately" but now he recalls "I didn't think at the time that anything suspicious was happening". Thats not a change in opinion. Thats caught in a lie!


Scott Forbes cannot remember the lies he told in an email 4/19/04
http://www.911review.com/errors/wtc/forbes.html
I was at home on the morning of 9/11 on the
shore of Jersey City, right opposite the Towers, and watching events unfold
I was convinced immediately that something was happening related to the
weekend work ...
But in 4/11/09 at 69:40 in this interview
http://www.americanfreedomradio.com/...32k-041109.mp3
he says

after 9/11 occurred, A lot of people didn't put A and B together. For a lot of people the power down meant nothing, And actually at the time to me, I didn't think it was anything unusual , it was unusual in that we have never had a power down. But it wasn't unusual to work a weekend, we did that regularly. Um and, I didn't think at the time that anything suspicious was happening. It was only in retrospect that you wondered, what was all that about. And particularly, when, um, the information wasn't being taken on board by the 911 commission, And more particularly when the port authority would not acknowledge that it occurred, And they now deny that it occurred. so, now that is very suspicious to me
What a difference 5 years makes. huh?

Oh what a tangled web we weave when at first we practice to deceive.
 
Last edited:
Back on topic. Are you going to address Scott Forbes 5 year inconsistency?
Because this wont fly Galileo.
Opinions? Five years ago he states he was "convinced immediately" but now he recalls "I didn't think at the time that anything suspicious was happening". Thats not a change in opinion. Thats caught in a lie!


Scott Forbes cannot remember the lies he told in an email 4/19/04
http://www.911review.com/errors/wtc/forbes.html
But in 4/11/09 at 69:40 in this interview
http://www.americanfreedomradio.com/...32k-041109.mp3
he says

What a difference 5 years makes. huh?

Oh what a tangled web we weave when at first we practice to deceive.

Its natural for people to have changing opinions.
 
Its natural for people to have changing opinions.


So on 9/11 he "knew immediately" but last week ""I didn't think at the time that anything suspicious was happening".???? He is talking about what his opinion and suspicions were on the day of the event. Thats not something that changes. You have an unresolvable conflict.
 
The attack was on Tuesday. Therefore he is not a survivor. By your logic Im a wtc survivor because I was in the buildings in the fall of 2000. And my ex father in law worked there as a port authority engineer but retired in the late seventies. So by extension. HE'S a survivor. Are you a moron?


and my uncle and aunt, who were near the Towers when the first plane hit were survivors, because they were on the property that day.


gee, and I dont see their names on the list; or received benefits....
 
36 hours or 27 hours? make my mind up!!

More Scott Forbes inconsistencies

On the weekend of 9/8,9/9 there was a 'power down' condition in WTC tower 2,
the south tower. This power down condition meant there was no electrical
supply for approx 36hrs from floor 50 up. I am aware of this situation since
I work in IT and had to work with many others that weekend to ensure that
all systems were cleanly shutdown beforehand
But towards the end of the 4/11/2009 Barratt interview @ 82:20 , He claims the IT team anticipated a 48-36 hour power down, But that it was actually closer to 26-27 hours from noon Saturday to approximatly 3 pm Sunday.

http://www.americanfreedomradio.com/archive/Truth-Jihad-32k-041109.mp3


Just occurred to me. He said he was "called in early" Sunday. So he wasn't even there to see the comings and goings and bustle of activity. And why would the IT team be there anyway if there was no power to shut down or bring up the computers as he alleges? Were they twiddling their thumbs waiting in the dark?
 
Last edited:
More Scott Forbes inconsistencies



But towards the end of the 4/11/2009 Barratt interview @ 82:20 , He claims the IT team anticipated a 48-36 hour power down, But that it was actually closer to 26-27 hours from noon Saturday to approximatly 3 pm Sunday.

http://www.americanfreedomradio.com/archive/Truth-Jihad-32k-041109.mp3

Your point?

A power-down in a financial computer facility involves so many people, so many memos at so many locations and several companies. For Forbes to not be able to get people or find paperwork do help his case says be is making ◊◊◊◊ up.

Forbes and all the other frauds of the "Truth Movement" are terrified of having to address polite, relevant questions from people with relevant expertise.

The idea that a crew used the power-down to place demolition explosives in a way that is consistent with the evidence and eyewitness accounts is also stupid.
 
Your point?


My point is he is making **** up and changing his story. When confronted with the facts that people were there and witnessed no power down that weekend. ( observation deck ticket stubs etc. ) he shortens his power down time line. in an attempt to fit it in between the cracks of his story.
 
Last edited:
More Scott Forbes inconsistencies

...

Just occurred to me. He said he was "called in early" Sunday. So he wasn't even there to see the comings and goings and bustle of activity. And why would the IT team be there anyway if there was no power to shut down or bring up the computers as he alleges? Were they twiddling their thumbs waiting in the dark?

None of this Scott Forbes story makes a lick of sense.
 

Couple of things from that interview that caught my attention:

- None of the other people supposedly involved in this massive power down have come forward according to Mr. Forbes (despite what Galileo says)

- Scott claims that the Port Authority notified them via memo AND e-mail and strangely both of those are missing.

- Scott claims that his team formed an action or project plan to deal with this. I don't know how things work in his company, but most companies where I've worked, an outage like this has a SIGNIFICANT paper trail. Everyone who relied on the computer systems in that office should have been aware of the upcoming outage.

- Scott made a few comments about people "buying the official story", which would indicate to me that he's a truther. (instant reduction in his credibility)


If anyone can get in touch with Mr. Forbes, I've got a few questions for him..namely the following:

- Was his company the only one affected by this "power down"?
- How many people in his company were notified of the power down or of any servers/systems being offline?
- Does he or his HR department have any timesheets for the employees who worked that weekend to verify his claims?
- Why is it that all of the communications about this supposed power down are missing? Were the e-mail servers not backed up? Was no one in any of the other offices (London?) notified via e-mail about this power down?
- Why does he believe the other people who worked with him are refusing to corroborate him? (Especially the ones who no longer work there)
- Who, specifically, at the Port Authority, notified Scott and/or his team/company of the power down?


Even if this power down did take place, it doesn't prove that explosives were planted, etc. I *suspect* that there may have been some maintenance done that may have involved Scott's company and required some server admins to shut down and restart some servers that weekend. Such a thing would not be unusual. Given Scott's propensity to follow the truthers, it's entirely possible that he believed the situation to be something other than it was, and is trying to make something fit with his truther theories. I'm not claiming that he's deliberately lying, it's just that his story doesn't add up.
 
Couple of things from that interview that caught my attention:

- None of the other people supposedly involved in this massive power down have come forward according to Mr. Forbes (despite what Galileo says)

- Scott claims that the Port Authority notified them via memo AND e-mail and strangely both of those are missing.

- Scott claims that his team formed an action or project plan to deal with this. I don't know how things work in his company, but most companies where I've worked, an outage like this has a SIGNIFICANT paper trail. Everyone who relied on the computer systems in that office should have been aware of the upcoming outage.

Advance notice would go to ALL employees so that nobody wouldn't plan on coming into the office on that weekend to catch up on any work.

On the Friday prior to the shut-down, a memo would be placed on every desk reminding people of the shutdown.

There would be paperwork at the contractor's office and the union for the actual electrical work plan and manpower. There would be pay records, etc, etc.
 
A friend of mine has been in contact with Scott Forbes. He is actually working with a group of over 30 fellow WTC employees who witnessed the power downs, to have this evidence officially acknowledged.

I contacted Scott and asked him (as you can see from earlier in this thread I have been emailing with him before). He replied today:

No, I have'nt founded any group, nor do I have any new information. Sorry!

Scott
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom