[Merged]Scott Forbes powerdown revisited

Well, that explains alot!
Gal's A Lier!
Who knew?:rolleyes:
its an interesting conundrum, do you believe Galileo's anonymous third hand statement about forbes, or Panoply_Prefect's anonymous second hand statement

of course if you choose to believe neither the default conclusion is there is no group of 30 people lol
 
its an interesting conundrum, do you believe Galileo's anonymous third hand statement about forbes, or Panoply_Prefect's anonymous second hand statement

of course if you choose to believe neither the default conclusion is there is no group of 30 people lol

I think Gal must have mis-understood Scott in that radio interview. He made a statement during that interview specifically mentioning "30 or so" people who worked with him during this supposed powerdown, however there was no indication that any of them had "come forward". Supposedly the ones who still work there were afraid, and those who didn't work there anymore didn't want to talk about it. (How convenient)
 
I never said Scott founded a group. You are a liar. Scott is a truth-teller.

Ah, sigh. Yes, I should have expected we'd get into semantics. Soon you'll be claiming it wasn't THAT Scott Forbes you meant, but another one, who was working together with 30 people.

I quoted your post to Scott with a link to this forum.

(Oh, and no, I haven't presented myself as a "debunker", since I'm not claiming to be one. Now Scott might identify me as such if he by reading my posts here thinks so, but previously there has been no connection between my nym here and my real identity. EDIT, a well, at least not an obvious one. He COULD have read this thread and made the connection, but is not bloody likely).
 
Last edited:
Ah, sigh. Yes, I should have expected we'd get into semantics. Soon you'll be claiming it wasn't THAT Scott Forbes you meant, but another one, who was working together with 30 people.

I quoted your post to Scott with a link to this forum.

(Oh, and no, I haven't presented myself as a "debunker", since I'm not claiming to be one. Now Scott might identify me as such if he by reading my posts here thinks so, but previously there has been no connection between my nym here and my real identity. EDIT, a well, at least not an obvious one. He COULD have read this thread and made the connection, but is not bloody likely).

You are the one playing word games. You are dishonest and can't be trusted. I never said Forbes founded a group. You just made that up. You are a liar.
 
You are the one playing word games. You are dishonest and can't be trusted. I never said Forbes founded a group. You just made that up. You are a liar.
False. Scott deduced that you were claiming that from the post that was emailed to him. Again, no evidence on your part. So it's obvious you heard the number on the interview and decided to make it into a phony claim. That's dishonest.
 
You are the one playing word games. You are dishonest and can't be trusted. I never said Forbes founded a group. You just made that up. You are a liar.

In the below quote, are you claiming your friend is working with the "group"?
If so, I think you can see how it was misunderstood.
If so I apologise, however I think you did this purposely!

A friend of mine has been in contact with Scott Forbes. He is actually working with a group of over 30 fellow WTC employees who witnessed the power downs, to have this evidence officially acknowledged.
 
A friend of mine has been in contact with Scott Forbes. He is actually working with a group of over 30 fellow WTC employees who witnessed the power downs, to have this evidence officially acknowledged.

I never said Scott founded a group. You are a liar. Scott is a truth-teller.

[Ultima1] Its so fun and easy to prove you are a liar with facts your own words[/ultima1]

Damn Dog chased me down, bit me on the ankle, and beat me to the punch.
 
Last edited:
You are the one playing word games. You are dishonest and can't be trusted. I never said Forbes founded a group. You just made that up. You are a liar.

No I'm not. Now, if Scott was working, as you claimed in your post, with a group of 30 people, don't you think he would say he had new information? I asked him that as a direct question see.

Or, if you like, formulate a question I can ask Scott. I will forward it to him and if and when he replies, I'll post it here. Agreed?
 
No I'm not. Now, if Scott was working, as you claimed in your post, with a group of 30 people, don't you think he would say he had new information? I asked him that as a direct question see.

Or, if you like, formulate a question I can ask Scott. I will forward it to him and if and when he replies, I'll post it here. Agreed?
You may want to rephrase the question to ask him if any of his co-workers that he mentioned in his latest interview contacted him about the power down.
 
In the below quote, are you claiming your friend is working with the "group"?
If so, I think you can see how it was misunderstood.
If so I apologise, however I think you did this purposely!

He said on the radio he was working with a group.
 
No I'm not. Now, if Scott was working, as you claimed in your post, with a group of 30 people, don't you think he would say he had new information? I asked him that as a direct question see.

Or, if you like, formulate a question I can ask Scott. I will forward it to him and if and when he replies, I'll post it here. Agreed?

All these people knew about the powerdowns since before 9/11. It is not new information.
 
You may want to rephrase the question to ask him if any of his co-workers that he mentioned in his latest interview contacted him about the power down.

Is there a quote I could use? If so I'd be more than happy to write him again. For the record, Scott haven't been anything but nice and open in our brief correspondence.
 
All these people knew about the powerdowns since before 9/11. It is not new information.
Oh, so you've meet these people and know thier stories? Oh wait, a friend that knows a guy the may or may not have talked to these people. Gotya. :rolleyes:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom