Medicine should be taught in high school

Absolutely!

I have always thought how STUPID it's not,...er, at least wasn't when I was in school.

To get sick, hurt, die needlessly from lack of basic knowledge is rather stupid, if you learn technical stuff, only to get hurt or die ahead of time because you were never schooled in some of those things which cause people to have to go to emergency rooms or cause problems in their life that shouldn't have happened (therby needlessly running up health care/insurance costs also!) if they had some knowledge.

They need to look at all doctor/emergency visits and then list things/subjects that may be nice to cover. It has to be very selective as to not overwhelm and be forgotten. Better to say less and repeat thru the course, than to say too much only one time, if it will just be forgotten after graduation. Or better, medicine class should maybe be taught every year.

Wouldn't it be nice for them to cover basic first aid and even teach how to stop an arterial bleed? Practicing the Heimlich maneuver. Practicing CPR.

What can wear out joints/cartlidge prematurely. What sports likely can cause knee injuries and rotator cuff injuries and exactly why these happen?

Identifying early signs of skin cancers and pictures of the different types. Telling redheads they are more prone.

Explaining differences between the common cold and flu and what to do for each and when to concern yourself that maybe you have neither but something more serious in need of attention (like Leukemia! Ever hear of all the people going to the doctor for "flu" only to be told they have leukemia?)

Proper dental health.

Awareness of CO poisoning and symptoms, and to be vigilant in certain circumstances about this. (Why get your PH.D., if you are going to overlook the trailer exhaust pointing toward your tent at a music event and die? This happened up here recently). Lead poisoning.

Tips on all sorts of things: Like making sure you don't let storm doors slam on your heel behind you and sever your archilles tendon.) How not to drink grapefruit juice with certain meds.

Nutrition and what role certain nutrients play and what we know now how simply mega-dosing on one nutrient really requires combinations of interactions between other nutrients to be effective. What women need to avoid certain women maladies, and nutritional advice during pregnancy and things to avoid.

The importance of knowing if you are diabetic and what commonly happens to diabetics that don't ususally occur as often in other people.

Diseases that affect black people more.

Lymes disease symptoms and pictures of the rash. Poison ivy. And other things one can stumble on in the outdoors. The probably of rabies/bats. What causes tetonis, why and where and what to do. Jelly fish while swimming in Gulf/ocean.
Wow. I was prepared to agree with your entire post.

Then you ruined it with...
I feel NOW I have learned a lot and become a half a doctor just from what I've learned over the years.

If you think you have learned half the stuff doctors know then you have a very poor understanding of what doctors are required to know.
 
As for Dabljuh's position, all I can say is that I fell for it. I thought you were serious but now I can see you are just teasing us. Doing that once is one thing, but I suggest not making a habit of it.
 
Yup. I agree that this was poorly phrased in the last GCSE and SATs courses in the UK, but their last revision attempted to address this. In Australian states it forms the very basis of the curriculum. In fact, in my current school it forms the foundation of all science classes.

One possible distinction in Canada is that in most provinces natural sciences such as biology, physics, and chemistry, are elective courses after grade eight, and esoteric concepts such as the demarkation problem and epistemology are a bit above thirteen-year-olds.

[dream mode on]
I'd like to see science as a mandatory course up to the end of grade 12. This would increase the respect for the scientific and applied scientific professions, and certainly benefit the goals of skeptics by reducing vulnerability to fraud.
[dream mode off]

The reality, though, is that if a kid isn't into science, he isn't into any of the things suggested in above posts. A highschool kid looks at course material through a lens that says, "How is this going to get me laid?"

There are two more problems with in-depth physiology or medicine: as technical fields, they are rapidly changing. By the time a real problem arises, the highschool graduate's knowledge is certainly obsolete.

I'll give you an example: CPR. The CPR I learned in highschool is inappropriate today. Granted, the layperson won't be criminally liable, but if any of my staff were to use 1980s-style CPR (stack-four) or choking victim management (back-blows, abdominal-thrusts, &c) today, I'd fire them on the spot. And that's a "basic" skill that in principle takes fifteen minutes for an adult to learn, and a whole year for an average teenager to get straight, practicing fifteen-minutes a week.
 
I'm not with you, sorry. The point of this thread was to discuss whether education should focus on 'medical' issues, right? I'm arguing it already does.

Athon

The OP works in the marketing dept. for a homeopathy and colon irrigation company. It looks more like the point of this (and any other thread she/he is involved in) is to reinforce the disinformation campaign, rather than discussion.

Linda
 
Well, I dunno...teaching high school students about pharmacology and drugs. Really not feasible...however, might give the teacher a few interesting demos.:D

I agree with blutoski, four years of science (and math) should be mandatory. However, it would cost money and schools wouldn't be able to implement the extra curriculum. In the US, only about 65% of high school students take chemistry and about 30% take physics. And those courses are basic for the most part. Medical knowledge could only start after those and other classes. A little bit of knowledge could be very dangerous.

glenn
 
One possible distinction in Canada is that in most provinces natural sciences such as biology, physics, and chemistry, are elective courses after grade eight, and esoteric concepts such as the demarkation problem and epistemology are a bit above thirteen-year-olds.

That's a good point. However, this is more of an issue to do with general administration of science courses rather than the nature of its content.

[dream mode on]
I'd like to see science as a mandatory course up to the end of grade 12. This would increase the respect for the scientific and applied scientific professions, and certainly benefit the goals of skeptics by reducing vulnerability to fraud.
[dream mode off]

Indeed. In Australian states it's compulsory until year 10, then strongly advised (in other words, only those kids who really look to be struggling are given advice to perhaps leave it) to keep it through senior.

Athon
 
The OP works in the marketing dept. for a homeopathy and colon irrigation company.

I think the OP was being sarcastic about that.

ETA:

Or are you using some kind of weird reverse psychology here? Show 'em what it feels like?
 
The OP works in the marketing dept. for a homeopathy and colon irrigation company. It looks more like the point of this (and any other thread she/he is involved in) is to reinforce the disinformation campaign, rather than discussion.

Linda

Really? Where did you learn this? (not saying I don't trust you - just curious to know where this is posted)

Athon
 
Thanks Kelly. Well, I wish I could be surprised that somebody working in a homeopathy clinic attempts to demonstrate knowledge of a system they have no experience in...but... :rolleyes:

Athon
 
I think the OP was being sarcastic about that.

ETA:

Or are you using some kind of weird reverse psychology here? Show 'em what it feels like?

He/she is playing a part in the disinformation campaign that supports a billion dollar industry, even though I realize that I don't really know the specifics of their role (it just gives me an out to use what they said). I'm just wondering if there is a better way to deal with this than playing along with their pretense that this is a legitimate discussion. Or maybe the stupid no longer burns, it just bores.

Perhaps I am overly cynical. It could be postulated that progress is being made as he/she must recognize he/she is losing, since they've had to move to the fall-back position of "tainted evidence" when their position was disproved by the evidence. What comes after we disprove the "tainted evidence" stance? Is that when post-modern constructivism gets trucked out? I can't remember.

Linda
 
I think "how to recognize when someone is feeding you a load of bull" should be taught in high school.

That, or spinning (per Ghandi).

Linda


Right On!!! and thank you. I can just see some of the kids setting up their own little secret labs to concoct new ways of getting high with the help of school teaching them about the main pharmaceutical ingredients in drugs and their affects on the human body and brain. That's all we need. Last related story I heard on tv is kids using cold medicine (maybe mixed with something else or not, I don't know) to get a quick fix. As a matter of fact, one kid died working to get the best high he can get using it, that's what the story was about. If they managed to use such basic generic medicine to get messed up, one can only imagine what they will figure out when properly taught and equipped.

Kids need to learn the importance of preventive medicine as in eating healthy food, exercising to strengthen the body and immune system. Learning the body "mechanics" is also fundamental. Working to plug them with chemicals right from the start and condition them to seek them even when there's no need for them is rather as callous and dishonest.

Regardless, if adults mis-use drugs on constant basis, what stop kids when given the green light, from heading down that road? Nothing.
Also, basic emergency medical intervention such what the EMT's get trained for will come in handy should a kid need help when the parents are not around or there is no access to the medics.
 
Last edited:
In the UK medical schools are providing courses for students with _no_ science background. They add a single foundation year onto the standard 5-year course. I therefore think that the claims of some that learning medicine requires a significant knowledge of scientific subjects, such as chemistry or biology is incorrect, though obviously it would be an advantage.

I have recently purchased several medical books. From what I have read of them so far the concepts are not particularly difficult to understand, but just the sheer volume of information that needs to be memorized and linked together is what makes it a hard subject to learn, excluding the clinical and surgical skills.

Perhaps there could be an option to focus on human biology and/or chemistry in high school? This would allow medical topics and the clinical significance of them to be more heavily focussed on compared with more generalized study of biology or chemistry.
 
to Kellyb,

I don't think he/she does what he/she said they do:
For all you care, I work in the marketing department of a company that manufactures and distributes homeopathic remedies and equipment for colon hydrotherapy.

the context within which the above quote has been said indicates that the poster was being sarcastic or what not. Maybe I am wrong. If it started with "I work..." that would have been different.
 
Yeah, I think it was sarcasm, but then again, with other posts by said poster, it's hard to know anything.
 
Yeah, I think it was sarcasm, but then again, with other posts by said poster, it's hard to know anything.

You are right, the Poster could also be setting up the reader to think he is not telling the truth about what he does when in fact he is. You are right.
 
You are right, the Poster could also be setting up the reader to think he is not telling the truth about what he does when in fact he is. You are right.

Now I'm not sure if you are sarcastic or not. :D I need to calibrate my sarcasto-meter. ;)
 
...
Perhaps there could be an option to focus on human biology and/or chemistry in high school? This would allow medical topics and the clinical significance of them to be more heavily focussed on compared with more generalized study of biology or chemistry.

Well the point of high school is to prepare one for more school (not life). This is why in high school one studies just the broad basics of a large variety of subjects. The courses taken in high school are to ensure that one knows a little something about everything. And when the student gets to college or a trade school they can decide what field of study they wish to focus on.
 
Oh Please,...

My reaction to the OP

The little knowledge that is passed on is already misunderstood or not understood at all, twisted. Not to mention keeping up with progress in medicine. Educating people on simple basic things is already difficult without them missing the message completely, like the OP has demonstrated in several threads already.

Medical textbooks are made simple to explain one single subject. The difficulty is using this knowledge in practice when many more factors are involved from different subjects that may all influence your final decision in diagnosis and for treatment. Basic physiology is something that can be explained and taught well to some level in high school, and already is in biology. Pathology, diagnosis and treatment is something else altogether. You need some understanding of basic science to comprehend what is taught and to look at the science behind it. It's still an academic education with good reason, based in science.

There are people who don't understand this, they often think homeopathy is a good idea too and the supernatural is something that they are part of.

Sad, really...

SYL :)
 
Apparently some sports medicine courses are taught at one of our high schools. Funny thing though, the two people I know who took them have a great understanding of anatomy, but think random herbal remedies are better for you than going to a doctor and getting a standardized dosage of a med that is specific for your condition.

I'm also taking a year-long course that is supposed to train me to work as a unit coordinator in the hospital. I learn a lot of terms and anatomy too, but the teachers are also telling us that "big pharma" is suppressing cancer cures.

There doesn't seem to be any control on who can teach the classes and whether or not they have a scientific background.

Anyone can teach that the heart has 4 chambers, but they can also tell you that all doctors are just random pill pushers in the same lesson. They also read us random emails from other laypersons that are supposed to scare us away from "chemicals" (apparenlty someone figures stuff in plastic will kill you if you freeze something in it).

I'm quickly learning that there is no standard for who teaches beginner level "medical" courses to the general public. They are still allowed to add in whatever opinion on the medical establishment they want to. The material is not in-depth enough on other sciences (organic chemistry, other biological systems that work with anatomy in the body) to keep them from figuring methanol is just another random cancer-causing toxin that the body supposedly can't handle without routine herbal deotoxification (via enemas or some weird mushroom concoction to drink).

I'm understandably horrified, and frustrated, but what can you do *grumbles*
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom