Medicine should be taught in high school

Dabljuh said:
I claim that teaching basic pharmacology would result in LESS drug-related disasters than the way we handle it now. I.e. scientifically unsound scare-tactics about the dangers of cocaine on the one side, but mandatory ritalin prescriptions on the other.
Why would it? You think cocaine is safer than ritalin? I think you have a skewed perspective on what is the standard of medicine. Forcing a child to take ritalin is not part of medicine. That would be school policy or the parents choice. I also think scare tactics never worked and don't work (very often). In addition that is government policy and not medicine. Kids who are smart enough will figure out it's a lie and kids who are dumb enough will just ignore it. To replace science and accountability in such a way you would have willy nilly drug use and no accountability.
 
I think "how to recognize when someone is feeding you a load of bull" should be taught in high school.

That, or spinning (per Ghandi).

Linda
 
Yes medicine is a rather broad topic. I'm thinking of

- The normal function of the human body (this often gets overlooked. You can't tell what's wrong when you don't know what's normal and benign)
- Conditions, such as hereditary, infectious etc
- Treatment, drugs, safety etc
- Living healthy, nutrition, how not to catch a cold etc
- Theoretical Science, how good studies differ from bad ones, what to look out for in Pharmaceutical Marketing etc
- You know, what *you* think every person should know about "medicine"

What the subject of the new "medicine" classes should be, may also be discussed here.

Even those topics are broad. The first item is 'the normal function of the human body'. This is not medicine, but physiology, which is a dedicated department of its own in any university. There's a four-year batchelor's, also masters and doctorates, with increasing focus.

In principle, there's nothing wrong with your suggestion that people learn more about their bodies. I support this. However, this does not translate into the non sequitir about dropping certification as a requirement for writing prescriptions.

The discussion really is about the depth of discussion, and the appropriateness for the existing knowledge.

Again: I teach first aid. The majority of teens can't take a pulse correctly for trying. In comparison, palpating an abdomen is much, much, more difficult, and requires a history of a range of patients in order to get a grasp of what is a 'normal' sounding for an adult, senior, child, pregnant... This is a pretty common diagnostic technique, and takes about two years of regular exposure to master competently. And even then, the error rate is so high that the findings of a med student would be confirmed by staff before diagnosis was signed off.
 
In addition to physical diagnosis, in order to understand pharmacology reasonably you need to learn some chemistry, organic chemistry, physiology, biochemistry, mathematics and microbiology. This is really not a feasible thing in high school.
 
So, which grade shall we start a full course of Organic Chemistry with? I say 8th grade at the latest.
 
Yes, and when adults are told this by their doctor they still want her/him to make an exception in their case. Perhaps the students will nod and agree, but I wonder what they will do next time they get tonsillitis.
"Make an exception" - They think antibiotics-resistant strains is a problem only on the scale of civilization. But that's not the case, they have to be made aware that their personal, own bacteria are going to be antibiotica-resistant, not anybody elses. *They*, and at the very best their loved ones, are going to pay the price if they use AB lightheartedly. Its their decision, leave people their freedom. Besides, tonsillitis is pretty serious. I recommend gargling sage tea.
And that's just antibiotics. What about tranquillizers? Opiates? You really think some High School classes would cause people not misusing them?
Do you think no one misuses them right now? Outlawing the drugs causes more problems than it solves.
How many semester-hours should be devoted to this topic?
No idea.
ETA: Will these classes include how to draw blood, how to do a blood cell count, how to culture a bacteria, and the dozens of other things necessary to reliably produce an accurate diagnosis?
You have to be able to tell educative measures and the "trained and certified to do" apart from each other. They don't need to be able to do any of these things in my opinion, but if it helps their education, it shouldn't be banned from the classrooms either. Did you never blow something up in chemistry in school? That doesn't mean you now know how to blow stuff up.
Are there any countries where this approach has been successfully used?
Not to my knowledge
Why not teach architecture and structural engineering in high school? Let any HS grad design bridges and sky scrapers!
Because medical literacy is required to keep your own butt alive. Building skyscrapers is something that only very few people need to be competent at, and that conversely, endangers also very many people.
Calculus and organic chemistry are prerequisites. These are 2nd year programs. A highschool student is nowhere near ready to tackle even the basics.
Basic medicine? "If you have a cold, stay in bed" ? I think we need medicine in elementary school, actually. How the human body functions, how to treat basic conditions, nutrition, whatever else is not something you need a doctorate in molecular biology in to understand, dammit.
My colleagues took mechanics in highschool - I would never let those jokers near my car. And mechanics is a lot easier than medicine.
Funny, I think medicine is a lot easier than mechanics or engineering. Because "health" automagically works on its own most of the time, while you need to build all those damn machines from scratch.
Why would it? You think cocaine is safer than ritalin?
If the FDA's classification is any indication, its about the same.
 
Last edited:
there is nothing wrong with teaching medical education to high schoolers. Medical education itself does not mean they will be doctors or any other type of clinician. There is no reason why student can not learn A&P, first aid, CPR, sex ed, nutrion before graduation. They aren't going to be performing surgery.

Anyway I was an certified EMT working on an ambulance before I had a hs diploma.
 
Dabljuh,

I have real problem with legalizing all medications to be used by people as they please, and history backs me up on this. Lets take one example: morphine.

When it was legally available (in the states), its abuse was rampant. Drug companies would sell cure-all elixers whose active ingrediants were nothing but morphine! People would take it for anything and everything. We have history to tell us, that legalizing this powerful drug is a bad idea, in fact criminally stupid.
 
The FDA classifies topical cocaine (as a topical anesthetic) the same as ritalin due to it's probability of abuse if it gets in the wrong hands.
 
Dabljuh,

I have real problem with legalizing all medications to be used by people as they please, and history backs me up on this. Lets take one example: morphine.

When it was legally available (in the states), its abuse was rampant. Drug companies would sell cure-all elixers whose active ingrediants were nothing but morphine! People would take it for anything and everything. We have history to tell us, that legalizing this powerful drug is a bad idea, in fact criminally stupid.
Yet we have 100s of legal pain killers, and alcohol (also used this way) is still legal, and abuse is rampant. Did civilization collapse when morphine was legal? And again: Making stuff illegal doesn't keep people from taking the dope. It just makes sure that only the mafia reaps the profits.

Hey, What you need is a gramme of soma.
 
Funny, I think medicine is a lot easier than mechanics or engineering. Because "health" automagically works on its own most of the time, while you need to build all those damn machines from scratch.
If this is your belief then why bother with drugs?
 
Yes medicine is a rather broad topic. I'm thinking of

- The normal function of the human body (this often gets overlooked. You can't tell what's wrong when you don't know what's normal and benign)

Huh? This forms the basis of most biology courses I know of. While I'm only familiar with the board curricula in a few US states, the UK, Canada, New Zealand and Australia (I'm only familiar with these systems so can't comment on others, but I'd suspect most countries are similar), all of these go into quite a bit of detail on the normal functioning of the human body systems.

- Conditions, such as hereditary, infectious etc

See above.

- Treatment, drugs, safety etc

The school I currently teach in has complete units on this. Most schools I've taught in have drug and alcohol safety units and/or courses.

- Living healthy, nutrition, how not to catch a cold etc

Again, this is in most school curricula.

- Theoretical Science, how good studies differ from bad ones, what to look out for in Pharmaceutical Marketing etc

Yup. I agree that this was poorly phrased in the last GCSE and SATs courses in the UK, but their last revision attempted to address this. In Australian states it forms the very basis of the curriculum. In fact, in my current school it forms the foundation of all science classes.

What the subject of the new "medicine" classes should be, may also be discussed here.

There might be systems in the world that don't address these. My feeling is that they are in the minority. Which school system are you referring to which doesn't have any of the above? I'm curious.

Whether educators teach it adequately is another issue altogether, and one I'll venture to say does need to be fixed. This is an inherent problem with education in general, though.

I agree with your sentiments, but have to inform you that if you're suggesting we need to include 'medicine' in the curriculum, in the form you suggest it already exists there.

Athon
 
Last edited:
Dabljuh,

I don't think you understand the complexities of pharmacology. My sister is a pharmacist, and it is way more in depth than just knowing what pills treat what. Also consider a HS students schedule, they aren't going to be learning about 'medicine' their entire time, maybe an hour and a half a day at most. Even if all the HS student did was learn about 'medicine', they still wouldn't have a clue in reality.

A little bit of knowledge is a dangerous thing.



ETA: If the general public was allowed to self prescribe, I'd put all of my money in Vikodin stock.
 
Last edited:
I agree with your sentiments, but have to inform you that if you're suggesting we need to include 'medicine' in the curriculum, in the form you suggest it already exists there.

Athon

That you are correct is irrelevant. The point of this thread was not to discuss the issue, but to provide an outlet for marketing the "big-bad-medical-industrial-complex" idea that snake-oil salespeople depend upon. It is not possible for them to look good on their own merits, after all.

Have we already forgotten the lesson learned in this thread?

Linda
 
Teaching the mechanism behind the action of AZT to school kids would be interesting since they would need to understand organic chemistry certianb areas of biochemistry and cell metabolism to quite a high level.

Some of the gentic dissorders would be even more complex.

As for proper functioning of the body the action of metal centred enzymes could be the topic for an entire module at degree level.
 
That you are correct is irrelevant. The point of this thread was not to discuss the issue, but to provide an outlet for marketing the "big-bad-medical-industrial-complex" idea that snake-oil salespeople depend upon. It is not possible for them to look good on their own merits, after all.

Have we already forgotten the lesson learned in this thread?

Linda

I'm not with you, sorry. The point of this thread was to discuss whether education should focus on 'medical' issues, right? I'm arguing it already does.

Athon
 
Medicine should be taught in schools.

Absolutely!

I have always thought how STUPID it's not,...er, at least wasn't when I was in school.

To get sick, hurt, die needlessly from lack of basic knowledge is rather stupid, if you learn technical stuff, only to get hurt or die ahead of time because you were never schooled in some of those things which cause people to have to go to emergency rooms or cause problems in their life that shouldn't have happened (therby needlessly running up health care/insurance costs also!) if they had some knowledge.

They need to look at all doctor/emergency visits and then list things/subjects that may be nice to cover. It has to be very selective as to not overwhelm and be forgotten. Better to say less and repeat thru the course, than to say too much only one time, if it will just be forgotten after graduation. Or better, medicine class should maybe be taught every year.

Wouldn't it be nice for them to cover basic first aid and even teach how to stop an arterial bleed? Practicing the Heimlich maneuver. Practicing CPR.

What can wear out joints/cartlidge prematurely. What sports likely can cause knee injuries and rotator cuff injuries and exactly why these happen?

Identifying early signs of skin cancers and pictures of the different types. Telling redheads they are more prone.

Explaining differences between the common cold and flu and what to do for each and when to concern yourself that maybe you have neither but something more serious in need of attention (like Leukemia! Ever hear of all the people going to the doctor for "flu" only to be told they have leukemia?)

Proper dental health.

Awareness of CO poisoning and symptoms, and to be vigilant in certain circumstances about this. (Why get your PH.D., if you are going to overlook the trailer exhaust pointing toward your tent at a music event and die? This happened up here recently). Lead poisoning.

Tips on all sorts of things: Like making sure you don't let storm doors slam on your heel behind you and sever your archilles tendon.) How not to drink grapefruit juice with certain meds.

Nutrition and what role certain nutrients play and what we know now how simply mega-dosing on one nutrient really requires combinations of interactions between other nutrients to be effective. What women need to avoid certain women maladies, and nutritional advice during pregnancy and things to avoid.

The importance of knowing if you are diabetic and what commonly happens to diabetics that don't ususally occur as often in other people.

Diseases that affect black people more.

Lymes disease symptoms and pictures of the rash. Poison ivy. And other things one can stumble on in the outdoors. The probably of rabies/bats. What causes tetonis, why and where and what to do. Jelly fish while swimming in Gulf/ocean.

..............

I could go on and on. I am old enough that I feel NOW I have learned a lot and become a half a doctor just from what I've learned over the years. But one really should not have to go all thru life learning these things thru bad experience first or die first, and it should be taught so you know a lot when you are young.
 
Last edited:
[rant on]

You'll notice how few people make comments like 'mechanics really should check the oil in your car. Travesty how they don't - should be common practice', or 'doctors should be able to do surgery. It's a travesty how in modern medicine trained doctors can't cut stuff out of you'.

So why do people profess to be experts in education without having anything more than their own personal experience? Nobody walks out of a doctor's surgery knowing how medicine works, or way from the mechanic comfortable they can fix most types of car.

Knowing a little about you're talking about makes a good start for a discussion

[/rant off]

Athon
 
Basic medicine? "If you have a cold, stay in bed" ? I think we need medicine in elementary school, actually. How the human body functions, how to treat basic conditions, nutrition, whatever else is not something you need a doctorate in molecular biology in to understand, dammit.

You're changing your claim, now. First, you said we should teach medicine. Then, it was maybe just first aid and physiology or something. Now your suggestions sound like basic hygene. Here's news: we teach hygene in school.

As an example, here in BC, the provincial ministry of health distributes a health guide to every household in the province, in three languages. Its content is covered in every year of K-12. As I also mentioned, in BC, first aid is a mandatory course in highschool. It used to be Industrial First Aid, but now I think it's the St. John's Ambulance Basic First Aid module, plus CPR-C level (for babysitters, basically).

This is 200-pages of 'the basics,' and I'm not sure why you think it's necessary to delve much deeper.



Funny, I think medicine is a lot easier than mechanics or engineering. Because "health" automagically works on its own most of the time, while you need to build all those damn machines from scratch.

As an ex-mechanic married to a doctor: you're completely wrong. The body has more moving parts, and the manufacturer didn't give us a manual.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom