Medical and Healthcare phishing

Saline computation:

1 cup = 8 oz = 240 cc

1 tsp = 5 cc = 11 gm ( assume 2.2 gm/cc for either sodium chloride or bicarbonate, to simplify )

4 cups = 960 cc , 11/960 ~ 0.01145...

each teaspoon makes a 1.1% solution, normal saline is 0.9%

the percentage will range from 2.2 to 5.5 % following my patient's recipe
So, could you answer the question you posed in post #223, "What is the tonicity/osmolarity of my Pt's recipe?"?
 
Believe it or not a group of physicians complained that some of the first nurse practitioners were practicing medicine without a license. The AMA also opposed nurse practitioners not so long ago. Since injuries to patients were not occurring, the likely conclusion was the MDs saw nurse practitioners as competition they preferred not to have.
That's crazy. Nurse practioners are very valuable. There aren't enough doctors and nurse practioners can fill the niche that doctor's don't have enough time for. It's gotten ridculous in this country where you have to wait about 6 months to see a specialist. If I had a suspicious mole, I could have widespread cancer by the time I get to see a specialist.
 
See also: guild socialism.

All manner of licensure for for which there is no demonstrable need, and serves only to protect from competition.

Nail technicians and hairdressers/stylists/barbers, for example.

Cheers,
Dave

ETA: Not intended as a direct comparison with life-safety professions. :)
Well some of the licenses of which you speak here are for ensuring a few standards, especially in infection control are met. It isn't hard to get the licenses in the above cases so keeping out competition is not a relevant issue. Having the health inspector visit your nail salon to ensure you are cleaning everything properly between clients is.

BTW, any of you thinking about pedicures might want to skip the soak.

Mycobacteria in Nail Salon Whirlpool Footbaths, California
No study has been published on the prevalence of mycobacteria in whirlpool footbaths. To determine the prevalence of nontuberculous mycobacteria in this common nail salon equipment, we undertook a mycobacteriologic survey of footspas in nail salons in California from November to December 2000.

Mycobacteria were isolated from virtually all pedicure spas surveyed, the sole exception being the footspa that had only been in service for 11 days. Mycobacteria were recovered whether or not disinfectants were reportedly used and whether or not debris was visible behind the recirculation screen.
 
Well some of the licenses of which you speak here are for ensuring a few standards, especially in infection control are met. It isn't hard to get the licenses in the above cases so keeping out competition is not a relevant issue. Having the health inspector visit your nail salon to ensure you are cleaning everything properly between clients is.

BTW, any of you thinking about pedicures might want to skip the soak.

Mycobacteria in Nail Salon Whirlpool Footbaths, California
OK, my mistake. You win.:D

I reckon, if one digs deeply enough, one can find some hypothetical threat to SOMEONES life in any misused or misapplied occupation. The media loves these: find some poor sap who was injured or otherwise greivously harmed by some malicious or incompetent practicioner, trumpet it loudly and repeatedly, and above all, get something done so it never happens again.
"World to End: Innocent Women, Children, and Minorities Hardest Hit!":D

Soon, anything, if not required by law, will be forbidden by law.

But even if some low probability hazard might be cited, there are many cases where licencing was instituted primarily because some entrenched group convinced lawmakers that only their guild could ensure these threats-to-the-public-welfare would never happen. The facts say otherwise: even with licencing these horrific events still occur, but only to licencees.

Cheers,
Dave
 
I am checking the thread on at least a weekly basis.
What for, if you're still unable or unwilling to answer all those questions? In my view you've made yourself irrelevant to the discussion you tried to start.

Hey -- check away, for what it's worth. But the debate has moved on while you've been immobilized. (An awfully cheap kind of evasion, IMO.)
 
....
But even if some low probability hazard might be cited, there are many cases where licencing was instituted primarily because some entrenched group convinced lawmakers that only their guild could ensure these threats-to-the-public-welfare would never happen. The facts say otherwise: even with licencing these horrific events still occur, but only to licencees.

Cheers,
Dave
I totally agree with what you said about the media latching on to single events then reporting as if we should all be hiding under the bed. But...with the licensing thing, regulating certain industries is necessary because people are one, uniformed and two, often unethical. Licensing is just one piece in the regulating process. Sometimes it's needed, sometimes not.

You state the problems still occur. Yes, but they are also discovered and stopped. And they occur less often. I would like to see a lot more regulation and especially a lot more enforcement. The infections from the foot soaks is just the latest problem.

Multisite Outbreak of Norovirus Associated with a Franchise Restaurant --- Kent County, Michigan, May 2005
The outbreak investigation described in this report underscores the challenges associated with preventing norovirus transmission. Small restaurants might have difficulty operating when an employee is absent and might not be able to afford paying leave for illness. However, employees who become ill and continue to work can place the public's health at risk.

The results of these investigations suggest that the illness of one food handler might have been linked to the illnesses of at least 100 persons in multiple settings. Illnesses at a publishing company, school, social service group, and among members of the public resulted in closure of a warehouse, employee absences, pay for substitute teachers, loss of wages, and loss of revenue to the restaurant during a week-long closure.


These outbreaks demonstrate a general lack of education regarding norovirus. Restaurant owners in Michigan are required to review the state food code; however, no free training was offered to them to interpret this lengthy legal document. To facilitate education, online training programs for food handlers and managers are being developed by Kent County public health sanitarians.

Previously, no work exclusion requirements in the Michigan food code specifically targeted norovirus. An employee was required to report Salmonella, Shigella, Escherichia coli 0157:H7, and hepatitis A infections or illnesses such as diarrhea, vomiting, fever, jaundice, or sore throat with fever. Employees were required to provide written medical documentation that they were free from the four specified infectious agents via stool testing (3); no such requirement existed for norovirus. However, the 2005 FDA Food Code included norovirus containment recommendations for states requiring food service employees to be excluded from work if symptomatic with vomiting or diarrhea and, if they have been ill with suspected norovirus, not to return to work until they have been asymptomatic for 24 hours (2). In one study, viral shedding began approximately 15 hours after exposure to norovirus and peaked 25--72 hours after exposure (4). However, in this outbreak, one specimen tested positive for norovirus 14 days after exposure. The new Michigan guidelines, issued in 2005, recommend that employees who have been ill with suspected norovirus not return to work for 48--72 hours after symptoms have ended.

PS: What do I win? :wink:
 
Last edited:
I totally agree with what you said about the media latching on to single events then reporting as if we should all be hiding under the bed. But...with the licensing thing, regulating certain industries is necessary because people are one, uniformed and two, often unethical. Licensing is just one piece in the regulating process. Sometimes it's needed, sometimes not.
I mostly agree, but governments and regulatory agencies are made up of...


...people!

They are every bit as prone to ignorance and corruption as those they are regulating. I would argue that due to the rigid beaurocratic culture and pay scale, that they are often even more inclined toward blind, thoughtless officiousness or possibly predatory corruption and greed.
They gain no reward for excellence in performing their work: Taking bribes may be their only path to wealth and excitement.

You state the problems still occur. Yes, but they are also discovered and stopped. And they occur less often. I would like to see a lot more regulation and especially a lot more enforcement. The infections from the foot soaks is just the latest problem.
I just lean toward the attitude that competition is better than enforcement. What about a salon that hired an independant agent (maybe a practicioner such as yourself) to train their employees, regularly test their facilities, implement QA procedures, and certify their business as conforming to current best practices, so that they could advertise the excellence of their salon, and thereby gain a competitive advantage over the others. Those others would then have a strong incentive to match or surpass the diligence of the other to stay competitive. The rising tide would lift all the boats.:)

I have long been convinced that "minimum acceptable standards" tend to guarantee that the "standard practice" will be the "minimum acceptable".:mad:

PS: What do I win? :wink:
How about my respect and high regard for your intelligence?
Some people I know believe that is a worthwhile reward.:D :D

Cheers,
Dave

Edit spelling.
 
Last edited:
I'm still waiting for that restaurant to open that advertises great hand washing and attention to infection control.

You have to add a whole big dose of education and shift in risk avoidance priorities people don't have in order for competition to improve infection control. And, then you need a business that depends on repeat business. If they have a constant flow of new customers such as in a resort, then they could merely offer false advertising.

Let me tell you about false advertising. Two words, Listerine and Lysol. Very popular products that are completely useless and they have both been around for decades. If we didn't have a gutless FTC (controls advertising), or if the FDA regulated the claimed effectiveness of products instead of just the safety of them, people wouldn't be using either of these.

I would like to see the education about infectious diseases improve. So in an ideal world maybe competition would work better than regulation. But for now, we need the regulations and enforcement.
 
I'm still waiting for that restaurant to open that advertises great hand washing and attention to infection control.
I would figure that, as more and more media attention is given to disease outbreaks from restaurants and other establishments, there will be a niche market appear for private, for-profit certififation agencies to grow into. These would have a vested interest in assuring that their subscribers upheld the highest standards of sanitary practice and employee compliance.

You have to add a whole big dose of education and shift in risk avoidance priorities people don't have in order for competition to improve infection control.
Just as an example, the National Association of Realtors has an ad campaign going, educating the public in the benefits of contracting with their members.
The AMA, NSF (national sanitation foundation), Underwriters Laboratory, and many other agencies seem to be filling their niches.
If a corporation were to arise, which offered franchises area, state, or nationwide, which offered it's seal of approval to compliant members and maybe even arrangements with insurance providers to give reduced liability premiums to certified members, I think there would be many opportunities for mutual rewards.

And, then you need a business that depends on repeat business. If they have a constant flow of new customers such as in a resort, then they could merely offer false advertising.
Yeah, but to offer the peace-of-mind that you were giving your custom to a business that went the extra mile to PAY to have their practices scrutinized and had invested above-and-beyond the minimum standards in emploee training and excellence of sanitation, I think would be worth paying extra for.
There are many current examples: Restaurants that serve only Organic, or Raw, or hand made by a famous chef, or untouched by human hands. A copyrighted service mark or trade mark, accompanied by an aggressive policy of civil/legal protection of its use only by members would minimise the "false" use

Let me tell you about false advertising. Two words, Listerine and Lysol. Very popular products that are completely useless and they have both been around for decades. If we didn't have a gutless FTC (controls advertising), or if the FDA regulated the claimed effectiveness of products instead of just the safety of them, people wouldn't be using either of these.
Goes to show just how effective government agencies are, doesn't it?:D

I would like to see the education about infectious diseases improve. So in an ideal world maybe competition would work better than regulation. But for now, we need the regulations and enforcement.
So, start a company. Recruit other NPs. Find investors. Start an advertising/education campaign. Open branch offices. You evidently have a successfull buisiness, already, so you know how to do it. Your company would benefit by your awareness of the latest information in infection control. Your company would be years ahead of the bureacratically hide-bound government agents.

Live the American Dream. Don't give in to the trend for everything to be taken care of by Big Brother, which never delivers satisfactory results. Think outside the box.

I KNOW you can do it.:)

Cheers,
Dave
 
Just as an example, the National Association of Realtors has an ad campaign going, educating the public in the benefits of contracting with their members.
The AMA, NSF (national sanitation foundation), Underwriters Laboratory, and many other agencies seem to be filling their niches.
If a corporation were to arise, which offered franchises area, state, or nationwide, which offered it's seal of approval to compliant members and maybe even arrangements with insurance providers to give reduced liability premiums to certified members, I think there would be many opportunities for mutual rewards.

A corporation or association provides that seal of approval. But who approves the association? How does the client/customer know which association to trust? How much research does the client/customer have to do?
 
A corporation or association provides that seal of approval. But who approves the association?
For a proper agency, their public record and reputation will suffice for most people (UL, FM, AMA, Consumers Union, etc.). If one believes their methods or morality are suspect, then one is free to create one's own alternative group. Can you show how government agencies are superior? Show your work. You will be graded on your logic.:)

How does the client/customer know which association to trust?
How does any individual know, for certain, that anyone, even their own family members, are trustworthy? At some point, experience, historical evidence, and judgement must be relied upon. Why in the world would someone trust a Government, If they can trust noone else?

How much research does the client/customer have to do?
How much research does the citizen have to do to trust the public agencies? Governments have proven time and again that they cannot gaurantee anything to anybody except lots of jobs for otherwise unemployable persons.

---------------------------

I don't know which specific ones, but I think every one of your questions fell under one or another logical fallacies. I trust that others here will name them.

Cheers,
Dave
 
or if the FDA regulated the claimed effectiveness of products instead of just the safety of them, people wouldn't be using either of these.

Yeah, well, people wouldn't be buying a lot of the "alternative" medicines then, would they?

I completely agree with you that the FDA should be doing this.
 
It is time for my weekly mortification!

Looking back it seems that the "subordinate" comment is what inflamed most thread readers/contributors.

I can only come up with the analogy of the military chain of command, it is inflexible but rarely mentioned unless there is a breach. I will venture that if the superiors reminded the subordinates that they have to follow orders, it would not help morale. The military relies instead in brainwashing and propaganda to maintain order, the foot soldiers (cannon meat) are not just following orders, they are "freedom fighters" ( please excuse the American bias, what goes on elsewhere? ).

Last time I checked, nurses still have to follow the orders written by doctors.
 
Last time I checked, nurses still have to follow the orders written by doctors.

This week, the Infection Control Nurse wrote "orders" for the resident doctor on my ward to repeat test swabs for MRSA and prescribe an MRSA eradication regimen for a patient.

Last time I checked, he had complied with gratifying alacrity.
 
Don't you practice in the UK? It is different in my corner of the USA.

I may consult the enterostomal therapy nurse, who writes orders under MY NAME for the floor nurses to follow.
 
It is time for my weekly mortification!

Looking back it seems that the "subordinate" comment is what inflamed most thread readers/contributors.

I can only come up with the analogy of the military chain of command, it is inflexible but rarely mentioned unless there is a breach. I will venture that if the superiors reminded the subordinates that they have to follow orders, it would not help morale. The military relies instead in brainwashing and propaganda to maintain order, the foot soldiers (cannon meat) are not just following orders, they are "freedom fighters" ( please excuse the American bias, what goes on elsewhere? ).

Last time I checked, nurses still have to follow the orders written by doctors.

Oh, nice save.

Get the topic off your remarks about nursing, and instead show a complete misunderstanding of military culture along with insulting those of us who serve (or have served).

I'd suggest you cut your losses, "doc".
 
Please illuminate me, what is the military chain of command?

Isn't it unidirectional?

I try to keep in perspective the nature of this Forum, when some members are brutal to somebody as distinguished as Dr. Shermer, I just have to ignore some comments.

Overall, I like this Forum, it has been very helpful in many ways ( my koi problem, for example ), I have no plans to cut any losses, because there are none!
 
Last edited:
Overall, I like this Forum, it has been very helpful in many ways ( my koi problem, for example ), I have no plans to cut any losses, because there are none!


If I were you, I'd look in the cupboard where I store the remains of my credibility and dignity ... :rolleyes:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom