Medical and Healthcare phishing

Fund raising idea for the JREF

How about anybody that doubts that I am a practicing physician from this moment on, donates a $100 or euro equivalent to the JREF.

I will forward my documents to the Forum administrators and Mr. Randi proving beyond a reasonable doubt that I am a practicing physician in private practice.

If you insist that I am not a physician, you get banned or make the donation.

How many are willing to put their money where their mouths/mind/typing fingers are? :jaw-dropp
 
How about anybody that doubts that I am a practicing physician from this moment on, donates a $100 or euro equivalent to the JREF.

I will forward my documents to the Forum administrators and Mr. Randi proving beyond a reasonable doubt that I am a practicing physician in private practice.

If you insist that I am not a physician, you get banned or make the donation.

How many are willing to put their money where their mouths/mind/typing fingers are? :jaw-dropp
What BS.

I posted a wealth of information about the profession of nursing which you dismissed with some crap about nurses were there merely to follow doctors orders. You dismissed the entire profession of nursing even making stupid comments that a doctorate degree in nursing didn't make one a doctor. As if someone who had completed a doctorate in nursing had any desire in the least to be a medical doctor.

Even if you had a license as a physician, there is nothing you've posted that gives anyone here (except maybe a sock puppet) confidence you are competent.

Why don't you start by reading through the thread without your facade of superiority which no one here gives a s#$@ about and make an attempt to reply to the posts you have been confronted with? No one likely cares whether or not you are an MD except it would shock a few of us that you actually see patients, and we might have a bit of sympathy for them. Other than that, it's your posts that represent you, not your papers.
 
How about anybody that doubts that I am a practicing physician from this moment on, donates a $100 or euro equivalent to the JREF.

I will forward my documents to the Forum administrators and Mr. Randi proving beyond a reasonable doubt that I am a practicing physician in private practice.

If you insist that I am not a physician, you get banned or make the donation.

How many are willing to put their money where their mouths/mind/typing fingers are? :jaw-dropp


Last I checked, the burden of proof is on the person making the claim. That means it is your job to provide evidence you are a doctor.

Last I checked you are not in any position to decide who is to be banned from this forum and why.

Last I checked, anyone could copy their boss' diploma from the wall and mail/fax it.

Try again.
 
So much anger.....

I've worked enough in the medical industry to know that people do get a little emotional when it comes to the issue of health.

Funny that, doc. I'd imagine you'd understand. Then again, I've also worked without enough doctors to not be surprised that it might be a mystery to you.

Athon
 
serious recapitulation

1) If you are a healthcare provider send me a PM

2) Doctors and Nurses take care of patients, most of the time Doctors write orders that Nurses follow, some Advanced Practice Nurses write orders that subordinate Nurses follow

3) boiling water kills pathogens if you wait long enough

4) An Armistice Offer:
s'girl, we have proved we can be nasty to each other in a public forum.
I am sure you are a caring and competent healthcare provider. I re-read your posts in this thread, and we probably agree on most healthcare issues. We can fight the Doctor-Nurse Practitioner battle somewhere else, I don't think JREFers care about or understand the issues in our little battle.

5) Originally Posted by skeptigirl :
"Doctors want to cure you. They want to give you something to make you better. Sometimes that's not what you need." Who does not want to be cured if a cure is possible?

6) Intellectually I am probably a rationalist, materialist atheist, I don't even fall for the "we are startdust" ideas, even fecal matter came from "starstuff". Emotionally I am an agnostic with some belief tendencies, I hope there is something else beyond death because I would like to continue to enjoy the Universe.


"posted by Deetee:
Oh, and BTW I find it interesting to see you glibly admit to prescribing drugs to your patients which you acknowlege have personality-altering side effects, and which culminated in destroying the marriage of 2 of your patients. What were you doing all this time - sitting on your backside taking notes while their whole world fell apart? I hope your insurance premiums are up to date if this is your usual standard of medical care."

Somebody stated Deetee is a Gynecologist, I am surprised at his/her unfounded conclusions. I would like to give a clearer picture, the wife is still my patient, she tried to convince her husband to become my patient in order to change his medications prescribed by a different physician who had prescribed OxyContin for several years. The husband was seen twice, cancelled several appointments and returned to his previous narcotic prescriber, the husband did not want to consider antidepressants and CNS modulators to help manage the chronic back pain and marital relationship issues.

I was under the impression that the main driving force for the JREF is the truth, is this the right forum? Am I mistaken?

I do not understand fowlsound's attitude and personality, as a physician and a human, I do not wish to inflict , or allow the continuation of, pain and suffering on ANYBODY. My moral compass is to try to follow the Golden Rule.

There is no blindness worse than the refusal to see the evident.
 
2) Again repeats statement showing no concept of what the nursing profession is or does. Now adds "Advanced Practice Nurses" have authority to "order" but has no clue that nurses practice nursing, not medicine. Has no clue what practicing nursing means.

3) Has it been established that tap water contains pathogens which present a risk to immunocompetent persons when squirted into one's nose?

4) I reply according to what is posted, not to personal feelings about the author. If you'll notice, s'doc, when you posted something rational in the Chiropractor thread in the Skeptic forum, I replied accordingly. As well I replied accordingly to your posts in the "Did Randi Die" thread in this forum. There I agreed with your definition of death and [smug] in my opinion, articulated what you were saying a bit better than you had. [/smug, couldn't help it ;) ]

Whether other members care about our exchange in the phishing thread, I do think at least a few of them find it amusing.


5) Multiple examples of patients who needed nursing care rather than medical care have been presented in this thread. Those examples included patient situations where a medical cure was not worth the cost in terms of risk and/or accompanying side effects, examples where cure was no longer a reasonable expectation and further medical interventions were not worth the cost. Many physicians recognize such situations. Many physicians practice nursing in such situations. But the medical model can interfere with physician decision making at times and lead some physicians to offer a less than useful medical treatment for lack of knowing what else to offer the patient.


Re the patient example in the exchange with Deetee: From just the description in the above post as I don't recall the other details, I'd say the husband needed a chronic pain clinic where they have expertise in treating drug addicted chronic pain patients. Such a patient needs a complex treatment plan involving both extensive nursing care and medical intervention. You cannot treat drug addiction and hope for even a hint of success with a mere recommendation of changing from an addictive narcotic to an antidepressant.

Just taking that example alone, as presented, should open your eyes, s'doc, to the benefits of learning a little about the nursing profession and what it has to offer the medical profession in terms of expertise.

Treating drug addiction including alcoholism and chronic pain patients is a specialty that every GP should be informed about, and if not interested in treating these patients, have a referral source for them. Many an opportunity to recognize an addicted patient, especially an alcoholic, is missed in the GP's office when patients present with complaints that should elicit suspicion but don't. A simple ALT and CBC can tell you you have an alcoholic patient yet most GPs don't know that, let alone order the tests when indicated.


S'doc: "There is no blindness worse than the refusal to see the evident."
S'girl: "Physician heal thyself." Boy did you set yourself up for that one.
 
Last edited:
Well, at least Neil seems to have retired. Maybe the fact that the obvious sock was recognised as an obvious sock put a bit of a crimp in that plan.

What does he take this forum for? That one would have been spotted by a forum of slightly dim pre-teens.

Rolfe.
 
1) If you are a healthcare provider send me a PM

Back ot only dealing with healthcare providers? Careful, we might start thinkging you were elitist again.

2) Doctors and Nurses take care of patients, most of the time Doctors write orders that Nurses follow, some Advanced Practice Nurses write orders that subordinate Nurses follow

Been over this.

3) boiling water kills pathogens if you wait long enough

Been over this also. You're still evading any substantive questions put to you


4) An Armistice Offer:
s'girl, we have proved we can be nasty to each other in a public forum.
I am sure you are a caring and competent healthcare provider. I re-read your posts in this thread, and we probably agree on most healthcare issues. We can fight the Doctor-Nurse Practitioner battle somewhere else, I don't think JREFers care about or understand the issues in our little battle.

You're repeating yourself, and it is the same old thing.

5) Originally Posted by skeptigirl :
"Doctors want to cure you. They want to give you something to make you better. Sometimes that's not what you need." Who does not want to be cured if a cure is possible?

Strawman. Did you read up on your fallacies? It was a strawman when you said it, it is a strawman now.

6) Intellectually I am probably a rationalist, materialist atheist, I don't even fall for the "we are startdust" ideas, even fecal matter came from "starstuff". Emotionally I am an agnostic with some belief tendencies, I hope there is something else beyond death because I would like to continue to enjoy the Universe.

Oops. Still can't figure out whether you're agnostic or athiest, eh?


"posted by Deetee:
Oh, and BTW I find it interesting to see you glibly admit to prescribing drugs to your patients which you acknowlege have personality-altering side effects, and which culminated in destroying the marriage of 2 of your patients. What were you doing all this time - sitting on your backside taking notes while their whole world fell apart? I hope your insurance premiums are up to date if this is your usual standard of medical care."

Somebody stated Deetee is a Gynecologist, I am surprised at his/her unfounded conclusions. I would like to give a clearer picture, the wife is still my patient, she tried to convince her husband to become my patient in order to change his medications prescribed by a different physician who had prescribed OxyContin for several years. The husband was seen twice, cancelled several appointments and returned to his previous narcotic prescriber, the husband did not want to consider antidepressants and CNS modulators to help manage the chronic back pain and marital relationship issues.

They are not unfounded, you didn't disclose that information. Which means you either just made it up, or you purposely left it out hoping to bait someone into that conclusion.

I was under the impression that the main driving force for the JREF is the truth, is this the right forum? Am I mistaken?

I do not understand fowlsound's attitude and personality, as a physician and a human, I do not wish to inflict , or allow the continuation of, pain and suffering on ANYBODY. My moral compass is to try to follow the Golden Rule.

Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. You can discuss truth in a philosophy class all you want.

As for my attitude, you keep saying I have so much anger, yet clearly don't understand you don't impress me enough to be angry about. You have trolled this forum. You have started a thread on questionable intent given the OP title, you can't seem to decide if you're athiest or agnostic or pantheist, you have a ridiculous manifesto that clearly shows you are not athiest, and is a pretty good indication you're not agnostic, but you certainly work to convince us you are. You don't answer direct questions or statements, and you ignore anything that doesn't fit into what you think people should be saying. It seems you opened a sock-puppet account to defend yourself here, and haven't responded to that accusation either. We have another poster like that. Her name is Kurious_Kathy, and no one takes her seriously, but at least she never resorted to sock-puppetry. Sad that you don't even live up to her standards.

There is no blindness worse than the refusal to see the evident.

Irony.
 
Last edited:
Believe what you want to believe, the administrators know who is who.

On a serious note, plase let me know here or in a PM who was your surgeon. I would not hesitate to refer anybody to your surgeon that would need spinal instrumentation. Your surgeon must be one of the best in the nation, if you don't need narcotics.
 
Believe what you want to believe, the administrators know who is who.

On a serious note, plase let me know here or in a PM who was your surgeon. I would not hesitate to refer anybody to your surgeon that would need spinal instrumentation. Your surgeon must be one of the best in the nation, if you don't need narcotics.
That must be one of the most jaw-droppingly offensive posts it has ever been my misfortune to read.

Rolfe.
 
OK, that's it. Not A Doctor.

Boiling water kills some pathogens, if you wait long enough. Kind of an important distinction, no?

Rolfe.

Oh, perhaps he missed the class on autoclaving and spore forming microbes.
 
Last edited:
Believe what you want to believe, the administrators know who is who.

On a serious note, plase let me know here or in a PM who was your surgeon. I would not hesitate to refer anybody to your surgeon that would need spinal instrumentation. Your surgeon must be one of the best in the nation, if you don't need narcotics.


:rolleyes:

As a matter of fact, he is one of the best in the nation. Your insinuations and snarky coy act is insulting to everyone on this forum. Why would you think I would need narcotics a year and a half after my surgery?

Certainly an anesthesiologist like yourself has worked with many great surgeons? Oh, right you were a family doctor. Or both. You work in a hostpital. You work in a private practice. Those, along with your atheism/agnosticism/pantheism is another glaring inconsistency you never explained.

Whatever.
 
Last edited:
s'doc:
For me, this whole thread has been almost not-at-all about any professional degrees or credentials you may or may not possess, but about your behavior and treatment of others.

If you will review the thread as a whole from the beginning, I'm sure that you will see that the "attacks", as you see them, began after your attitude of condescention reared its head. I don't believe anyone was particularly hostile until you [bridge lingo]broke the suit[/bridge lingo], then it became a free for all.

Yes, there were some questions as to your sincerity (due to the misleading thread title and your first few posts) and sometimes these were pointed. What would you expect from a group calloused by Posers, Pretenders, Trolls, and Sockpuppets far beyond the norm? We are not a bad group, but we have grown intolerant of some of the buffoonery we seem to attract by our very stated goals: ie. rooting through all the falsehoods to catch the nuggets of truth.

Some of us responded harshly to you, but I will contend that it was only in response to what we percieved as a bigoted, contentious, self righteous, and egotistical prick. You have been given repeated opportunities to correct this perception, but have mostly chosen to dig your own pit deeper.

If I had been in your presence, and you treated someone I knew the way you have treated some of the members here, I would probably slap you so hard that your ears would ring. I have never yet, in fifty-one years, struck anyone like that, but you would tempt me.

Cheers,
Dave
 
OK, that's it. Not A Doctor.

Boiling water kills some pathogens, if you wait long enough. Kind of an important distinction, no?

Rolfe.

He's claimed to be a GP? That would explain it; a lot of GP's I've worked with have had a pretty poor grasp of any pathology that's advanced past the '101' stage. Not all of them, mind you, however with all of the text-book knowledge crammed into a medical practitioner's education career pathology plays a surprisingly small part.

I don't see this as a problem until doctors start to undervalue the knowledge of their colleagues in other medical fields, such as specialtist knowledge or the pathology, or even the nursing staff. As often happens.

Athon
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom