Major_Tom's Features Lists [split from: Discussion of femr's video data analysis]

Status
Not open for further replies.

Major_Tom

Graduate Poster
Joined
Oct 19, 2007
Messages
1,995
Edited by kmortis: 
Removed off topic content


Isn't it a bit hypocritical to ask how measurements contradict the NIST collapse initiation scenario for WTC7 when you were given the answer for WTC1 already and watched as the thread was removed?

The logic was already established for WTC1 and 2, removed, then you want the same for WTC7?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Edited by kmortis: 
Removed off topic content


Isn't it a bit hypocritical to ask how measurements contradict the NIST collapse initiation scenario for WTC7 when you were given the answer for WTC1 already and watched as the thread was removed?

The logic was already established for WTC1 and 2 then you want the same for WTC7?

<------- Math & Science forum is that way


The complaining forum is over there--------->

Neither are in this forum.

Answer NoahFences question on WTC7, or don't, and never understand why you fail to understand....
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Is there a point to only discussing a subset when you are attempting to find the reason for the whole? I can see your point but, he has not been able to explain why these are the "observations" that are "significant"(instead of others).



I do. No one has actually presented a theory.

The NIST presented a theory on the collapse initiation sequences of all 3 buildings. It has been shown that the theory is contradicted by observables for WTC1. It can easily be shown for WTC2 and I had a thread to do that.

Femr is doing so for WTC7 in this thread.
........................

The forum as a whole tends to support the false belief that the NIST theory is "good enough". That is not true but forum members keep repeating it like a mantra.

DGM, I already know you couldn't even tell me what the NIST initiation scenarios are. You do not even know what the NIST theory is for each building, yet you defend it.

This is the nature of the current discussion, people defending a theory they can't even explain. It is not a discussion based on reason but on advertising core false concepts by repeating them over and over.
 
Last edited:
...Femr is doing so for WTC7 in this thread...
..are you sure of that claim?
...The forum as a whole tends to support the false belief that the NIST theory is "good enough"....
WRONG - and you should be aware that you are misrepresenting. The forum members in general do not agree that '......the NIST theory is "good enough" is a false belief'. Take that wrong word out and your claim is probably acceptable to most.

If we remove that one word which makes your claim UNTRUE I think that you can validly claim this:
...The forum as a whole tends to support the .... belief that the NIST theory is "good enough"...
I suggest that the majority of members would support that statement.* Speaking for myself I hold to the opinion that '...the NIST theory is "good enough"... FOR ME' and I have explained at least several times why that is so. I could probably tell you which regular posting members here also hold that '...the NIST theory is "good enough"... FOR [THEM]'.

You will not progress any acceptance of the valid portions of your claim - the position that you hold on these matters - whilst you persist in misrepresenting many of us despite having had our positions clearly explained many times.

The reality is that many members here hold to the global position put by NIST that impact damage and accumulating fire damage caused the collapses of WTC1, WTC2 and WTC7.

Your work and femr2's work as posted here and as limited by you and femr2 respectively does no more that suggest possible alternate mechanisms which resulted in the collapse. If you were to change the global position to add some form of 'MIHOP' to 'impact damage plus fire damage' then the game would change - but you do not have 'MIHOP' in the scope of your current discussion so forget it at this stage.

So all that you are discussing is details within that global position - impact damage plus fire damage. Until and unless you change that global position you have no basis for your false claims such as:
...That is not true but forum members keep repeating it like a mantra.
That claim is a lie by inference. The "That" of "That is not true" refers to the clause '...the NIST theory is "good enough"...' you cannot say it is "not true" unless you specify "for who?"

It may not be "good enough" for you and you are entitled to that view. you cannot claim that is it "NOT good enough" for me or for any other member posting here.

From that point your post degenerates into the type of snide criticisms of other members which degrade many of your posts. I need not comment on your choice of tactics.


* Yes, I know, they may not if you as an alleged truther made the statement the need to disagree with the truther would probably override the actual issue in question....but that is a different subject which I have posted about several times - keywords 'the sky is blue' - :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
You proved it yourself:

[qimg]http://femr2.ucoz.com/_ph/5/2/786877858.gif[/qimg]

The whole point of disagreement is in whether the columns buckled even if the assemblies didn't. It's not flimsy, it's the whole point over whether NIST got it right or not. If you define "column" in a way different to that used by NIST, then you are cheating.

What part of the conclusions stated in chapters 8 and 9 of NIST's NCSTAR 1 would be affected if they referred to the assemblies and these assemblies actually didn't buckle?

Here is a map. Care to mark the X?

ncstar-1-chapters-8-9-collage.jpg


Only 7 items on the WTC1 feature list are necessary to show that the collapse initiation scenario given by the NIST cannot be true. That was already shown in the removed thread.

I can also show that the WTC2 collapse initiation scenario contradicts observables, and was doing that in the thread that was removed.

Pgimeno, if you actually read the information in the introduction of each of those reports, it clearly states that the primary goal of the report is to describe the "how and why" of each of the collapses.

They tell you the primary goals themselves. Please try to understand that. If the explanations for the collapse initiations for all 3 buildings contradicts the visual record, they the failed to identify the "how and why" of any of the buildings.

Identification of the "how and why" of the collapses is not my criteria, it is clearly written in each report as being the primary goal.

I am sure you will cling to your beliefs as you are still convinced the Bazant papers BV, BL and BLGB contain no major flaws. I am certain I will never see the day where an argument convinces you of anything, since your beliefs are clearly set as firmly as the course of the northern star.

Sail on, brother.
 
Last edited:
To me it is stunning that I can answer these questions pretty easily using the same feature lists that were removed from this forum.

I posted the first one about 1 year ago and your simple discussion shows me you never read it.

We cannot have a technical argument if you pretend the information in the feature lists does not exist and then have the lists removed from the forum. I posted them so people would not remain so ignorant of how the actual buildings moved. They were removed, and your posts show me that regular posters remain quite ignorant of the actual motion of both buildings.

This is just simple WTC1 and 2 knowledge. Your comments show how ignorant many people remain of the actual visual record and of the information in the feature lists.

A pile of features is no more an explanation than a pile of bricks is a house.
 
You need to look at the initiation process as a whole to understand it, instead of removing the only thread in which the event is studied in detail from this forum.

[...]

Surely the hypocrisy is visible for all to see?
Says the man who tried to restrict discussion to only the visual record, and only certain hand-picked parts of that.
 
To review, my approach to studying WTC1 and 2 was quite simple.

First, I gathered the largest and most complete visual record possible (and linked to the best sets of video through CTV, Xenomorph and Femr)

Second, I pieced together the visual record to determine the collapse mode and global mass flow. This is summarized in the WTC Twin Towers Collapse Dynamics.

With the complete visual record and a detailed knowledge and mapping of global mass flow,

Third, I put together an detailed list of observations, expecially of the crucial moments during collapse initiation by using the best work on this forum. These observations are compiled as a "feature list" or "roadmap" on each building.
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

These were complied using the measurements of femr as one source.

Notice how the lists are assembled from the complete visual record.

You would have to be a simpleton to imagine that the videos and images used were cherry-picked. Anyone is welcome to assemble a record of any visual observation from the complete visual record and add it to the list of observations to either confirm or contradict anything on the list but posters are too lazy to do that, so they somehow blame me for their own inability to assemble visual evidence.

Edited by kmortis: 
Removed off topic content
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Third, I put together an detailed list of observations, expecially of the crucial moments during collapse initiation by using the best work on this forum. These observations are compiled as a "feature list" or "roadmap" on each building.

But you still can't explain what makes the moments "crucial" other than you asserting they are.

So, How exactly did you decide what were the "crucial moments"? We keep asking this and you never answer. It's OK to say they support you possition best, the thing is you have to actually state your position.
 
But you still can't explain what makes the moments "crucial" other than you asserting they are.

So, How exactly did you decide what were the "crucial moments"? We keep asking this and you never answer. It's OK to say they support you possition best, the thing is you have to actually state your position.

We all agree that the collapse initiation sequence and the moments leading up to it are the most critical moments to look for evidence of foul play.

I have been saying LOOK AT COLLAPSE INITIATION very, very clearly since first posting the OOS thread. It is clearly mentioned on the first page of that thread and I have repeated it countless times since then.
 
Last edited:
We all agree that the collapse initiation sequence and the moments leading up to it are the most critical moments to look for evidence of foul play.

I have been saying LOOK AT COLLAPSE INITIATION very, very clearly since first posting the OOS thread. It is clearly mentioned on the first page of that thread and I have repeated it countless times since then.

By "foul play" we have to assume you mean controlled demolition via explosives.*

Having said that, there is precisely zero items in your exhaustive list of technobabble that even hints at a collapse initiation caused by anything other than aircraft impacts and fire.

Am I wrong? If so, please post in clear non technobabble language that a monkey like me can translate -

what is it I should be looking at to change my mind? I see aircraft impacts and fire. What is it about your babble and graphs that prove otherwise?




*Since you'll never actually come out and say you mean explosives, we have to assume.
 
By "foul play" we have to assume you mean controlled demolition via explosives.*

Having said that, there is precisely zero items in your exhaustive list of technobabble that even hints at a collapse initiation caused by anything other than aircraft impacts and fire.

Am I wrong? If so, please post in clear non technobabble language that a monkey like me can translate -

what is it I should be looking at to change my mind? I see aircraft impacts and fire. What is it about your babble and graphs that prove otherwise?

Even though I have posted the information on each list a while ago, you remain ignorant of the collapse initiation processes of all three buildings.

If you remain ignorant of basically every feature I have posted, what can I do to help you become less ignorant of the collapse initiaton processes at this stage of the exchange?

My answer is simple: Don't remain proud of your own ignorance and educate yourself on the initiation processes. The information you now request has been in front of you for a long time.
Edited by kmortis: 
Removed off topic content



I cannot answer that type of a question to a person who remains ignorant of basically all the information already presented. If you effectively brag of your own inability to examine evidence or retain any information, why would you demand I overcome that problem for you?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Even though I have posted the information on each list a while ago, you remain ignorant of the collapse initiation processes of all three buildings.

I certainly do not. I know what initiated the collapses. Aircraft impacts and fire.

If you remain ignorant of basically every feature I have posted, what can I do to help you become less ignorant of the collapse initiaton processes at this stage of the exchange?

How about telling me what part of it leads you to conclude something other than aircraft impacts and fire was the culprit? You've yet to do this. Just because you SAY you did it, doesn't make it so. I was the first man on the moon. If i say that another say, 100 times, will it be any more true? Nope.

My answer is simple: Don't remain proud of your own ignorance and educate yourself on the initiation processes. The information you now request has been in front of you for a long time.
Edited by kmortis: 
Removed off topic content

Long, winded way of saying "wahhh". I know what the initiation process was. I knew for a FACT what it was before the 1st building even hit the ground.

I cannot answer that type of a question to a person who remains ignorant of basically all the information already presented. If you effectively brag of your own inability to examine evidence or retain any information, why would you demand I overcome that problem for you?


Let me make it simple for you. It's a two part statement. I'll do the first, and you can do the second part, mmmkay?

"The towers fell because ..... "


Two choices - aircraft impacts and fire, or explosives.

NOTHING YOU HAVE PRESENTED has EVER come close to contradicting what the rest of us knew before the 1st building even hit the ground.

Nothing. No amount of childish whining and complaining will change that fact. Only hard, concrete evidence presented in an adult manner in clear, proper language will.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
We all agree that the collapse initiation sequence and the moments leading up to it are the most critical moments to look for evidence of foul play.

I have been saying LOOK AT COLLAPSE INITIATION very, very clearly since first posting the OOS thread. It is clearly mentioned on the first page of that thread and I have repeated it countless times since then.
We saw the "foul play". It's the airplanes hitting the buildings.

Until you can explain why we should look for something else, you're nowhere.

GET IT!
 
Am I wrong? If so, please post in clear non technobabble language that a monkey like me can translate -

what is it I should be looking at to change my mind? I see aircraft impacts and fire. What is it about your babble and graphs that prove otherwise?

Even though I have posted the information on each list a while ago, you remain ignorant of the collapse initiation processes of all three buildings.

If you remain ignorant of basically every feature I have posted, what can I do to help you become less ignorant of the collapse initiaton processes at this stage of the exchange?

My answer is simple: Don't remain proud of your own ignorance and educate yourself on the initiation processes. The information you now request has been in front of you for a long time, in the threads that were removed.

I cannot answer that type of a question to a person who remains ignorant of basically all the information already presented. If you effectively brag of your own inability to examine evidence or retain any information, why would you demand I overcome that problem for you?

I like how someone specifically asking for evidence to change their mind is willfully ignorant in your sad little world.
 
Even though I have posted the information on each list a while ago, you remain ignorant of the collapse initiation processes of all three buildings.

If you remain ignorant of basically every feature I have posted, what can I do to help you become less ignorant of the collapse initiaton processes at this stage of the exchange?...
Major_Tom you have a major disconnect in most of these posts.

What "collapse initiation processes" are you talking about? You have never described these "collapse initiation processes" whilst you keep referring to a list of "features".

You continue to talk about features BUT have NEVER shown where they fit in any "collapse initiation processes". You then insult us because we cannot see the "collapse initiation processes" which you have hidden from view in the deep recesses of your mind.

If you want to be taken seriously stop insulting us as readers and tell us what these "collapse initiation processes" are. AND, if you wish us to have any regard for your much vaunted "features", show how the "features" relate to the "collapse initiation processes" you are claiming.

"Features" are not a process. The ball is in your court - your burden of proof if you prefer that language. We are not mind readers.

If there is any relationship between your selected "features" and a "process" that relationship is clearly of your construction. How can we comment in any meaningful way if you won't tell us what the "collapse initiation processes" are that you keep us in the dark about then have the effrontery to insult us for not reading your mind.
 
What "collapse initiation processes" are you talking about? You have never described these "collapse initiation processes" whilst you keep referring to a list of "features".

I map the event itself instead of drifting off into La La land to "invent" yet another theory.

Why en the objects were tracked and measured, I found out that basically everything the NIST says about the initiation processes was untrue.

I posted this a while ago butr I can see in the currnet posts that nobody understood the information contained or even understood the NIST explanations well enoutgh to see a contradiction.

Even when contradictions are posted directly in front of the readers face, they are ignored. Even today posters remain ignorant of the actual movement while somehow imagining they "have studied the building ".



Collapse Initiation Sequence WTC1
Drift and Drop Movements Traced and Plotted: Summary
Upper West Wall Pulls Inward 9.5s before Collapse
Antenna Base Shifts Eastward 9.5s before Collapse
Fire Flair-up along E Face 3s before Collapse
Antenna Sags 2 ft into Roofline before Falling
Concave Roof Deformity Measured by Drop Curves
Earliest Ejections from fl 95, W Face, S Side
Over-pressurization of fl 98 before Falling Begins
Minimal Tilt: Less than 1 Degree before Falling
Both N and W Perimeter Walls Fail Within 0.5s Interval
NW Corner: Upper Slides over N Face, Behind W Face
NE Corner: Upper Assembly Snaps Over Lower Portion
Jolts Detected in Earliest Antenna, NW Corner Drops
88th Fl S Face Light Grey Ejection
77th Fl Over-pressurization Timing Inexplicable

Edited by kmortis: 
Removed off topic content


Femr is one of the sources I use for measurements.

This is the best mapping of physical movement during the WTC1 collapse initiation process on the planet. Ignored.

Ozeco, if you actually learn what has been posted over and over again I wouldn't have to keep pointing out what I have posted many times.

In the case of WTC2, I just posted a collapse initiation model based on a sequence of 5 distinct observable phenomena. FEMR MENTIONED ONLY ONE OBJECT ON A LONG LIST POSTED EARLIER.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Concerning WTC2 I have explained that the initiation sequence contains 5 distinct features

WTC2_IZ_model2.jpg

ejection__locations.jpg


Including 7 symmetric ejections that appear in the red ovals along the 78th floor.

I posted that the wall broke along an identifiable bolted seam shown in purple over 2 years ago. That seam was know known or identified before I was discovered by ...me. Notice how the staggered bolt line in purple line up with the red ovals. They line up perfectly with the low step in staggered purple line. The break is sequenced with the symmetric ejections.

Edited by kmortis: 
Removed off topic content


Also, the mechanical floors with perimeter panels attached are ejected from the building just as the "hinge" is broken.

The small line marked in blue pulled inward along with the east face, and the NIST model cannot possibly explain why that happened while a failing core can explain it and many other observed phenomena besides.

I FOCUS ON COLLAPSE INITIATION, while the posters here seem incredibly ignorant of the processes.

Edited by kmortis: 
Removed off topic content
 
Last edited by a moderator:
To review, my approach to studying WTC1 and 2 was quite simple.

First, I gathered the largest and most complete visual record possible (and linked to the best sets of video through CTV, Xenomorph and Femr)

Second, I pieced together the visual record to determine the collapse mode and global mass flow. This is summarized in the WTC Twin Towers Collapse Dynamics.

With the complete visual record and a detailed knowledge and mapping of global mass flow,

Third, I put together an detailed list of observations, expecially of the crucial moments during collapse initiation by using the best work on this forum. These observations are compiled as a "feature list" or "roadmap" on each building.

You did two more steps; not necessarily in that sequence, but I'll mention them as 4th and 5th:

Fourth, you discarded, without stating reason all the non-visual record, such as the audio record, the eye witness record, the forensic engineering record, etc.

Fifth, you discarded nearly all of the visual evidence and instead focussed on a tiny set of quirks heavily biased towards your goal, without stating a good reason why you picked these and not any others.


These were complied using the measurements of femr as one source.

Notice how the lists are assembled from the complete visual record.

I notice how you introduce all your discussions by presenting a tiny tiny subset of the complete visual record.

You would have to be a simpleton to imagine that the videos and images used were cherry-picked.

Is this supposed to be an argument to support your particular and personal taste in cherry-picking? Then be informed that it fails to convince.

Anyone is welcome to assemble a record of any visual observation from the complete visual record and add it to the list of observations to either confirm or contradict anything on the list but posters are too lazy to do that, so they somehow blame me for their own inability to assemble visual evidence.

Incorrect. I think I had at least half a dozend posts where I suggested the amendment of some observations (not all of them visual). You completely ignored them.

Edited by kmortis: 
Removed off topic content and response to same
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Ozeco wrote to femr about one link to a set of features on my website:

Thanks. This is probably the first bit of detail I have seen for some time that has struck me as relevant to and affecting my own understanding of the events. Intriguing for understanding of initiation>>progression.

It was posted with many other details for a long time now. Why is it suddenly interesting when you have been ignoring long lists of these features including this one for a long time?

Why when he writes of one feature is it useful, while when I write of the exact same feature at just one part of a long sequenced list of observations it is worth ignoring?

THIS IS NOT NEW MATERIAL.
Edited by kmortis: 
Removed off topic content
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom