Oystien, pretty much any long time poster on the 9/11 forum knows where ther lists came from.
I am not a poster on the911foruim at all. So I do not know where the lists came from. I am a poster at JREF. YOu are a poster at JREF. On May 19th, you opened a thread a JREF. I replied a few hours later a the JREF. I expect you to discuss the topic with which you opened a thread at the JREF at the JREF.
Try looking at my website and you will find a menu titled "aircraft impacts" next to the feature lists.
I am not interested in any menu titles at your website. I interested in how you arrived at the selection of features with which you opened your thread here at JREF in May 19th.
Maybe that is a clue where to find impact information? Think about it.
I am not particularly interested in airplane impact information. I interested in the reasons why you left them out when you opened your thread here at JREF in May 19th.
Oystien, Achimspok and femr must find your comments about cherry picking observables to be humorous.
I am not interested in the peculiar sense of humour you believe is Achimspok's and femr's. I am only interested in the criteria that lead you to include a small number of particular visual features and leave out a great many other visual features, and all the non-visual features.
The features lists are not mine. They are a compilation of the work of other people. If you bothered to read the lists you would have seen that many of the features link back to the original discussions.
I am not interested in whose features these are. I am only interested in why you posted those featutes on May 19thm, and not any others.
If you bother to actually read the 9/11 Forum for comprehension instead of your usual reading habits, you will be able to find most every feature as the topic of its own thread.
I'll be happy to read about and discuss the features, but only after you have explained to me why I should read about and discuss particularly those specially selected visual features, and not any other visual or non-visual features. First things first.
"Cherry pick" is yet another on those hypnotic mantras you keep repeating to yourself in order to dream up some imaginary defence.
When did I say "cherry pick" with regard to your feature list? I don't think I did. I am also not defending anything at all.
I just want to know whart criteria you used for the selction of features. You are not denying that you DID take your pick, right? The feature list IS a selection from a much larger pool of candidate features, isn't it?
In a forum in which observables are studioned carefully, each item on the list would have its own thread. In this forum, most every observable feature worthy of study for WTC1 and 2 is crammed into 1 thread and moved out of the forum.
But it was you who opened the WTC2 feature list thread on May 19th by cramming a number of features into the OP of a single thread.
Now please explain why you put those features in the thread, and not any others!
...Notice that the list is compiled from the work of other people after the most complete visual record is gathered and the collapse modes are already identified.
This is why I posted a thread called "OOS Propagation Model" before I posted any feature lists.
Ah! This seems to be hinting at a criterion: You picked those features that support the already identified collapse mode! Does this already identified collapse mode include the reasons for initiation? Are there any besides foires and plane impacts?
May I conclude from the fact that you left out both fires and plane impacts from the feature list that explains the collapse mode that you already concluded that neither fires nor plane impacts played a role in bringing about the collapse of WTC2? If so, it would be nice if you had the guts to clearly say so.
If not, please explain why you left out so many very obvious visual features.
I am very aware that it is probably beyond your capacity to do so, but please try to understand that the lists are not compiled "out of the blue" but only after readers are aware that the collapse initiationsequence and the MER floor activity are the most important places to look, as determined in the OOS model.
You listed visual feature before, during and after collapse initiation.
But you did not list ALL visual features before, during and after collapse initiation. For example, you left out the visual feature of planes slamming into the tower, of the visual feature of fires burning very near the collapse initiation zone. All I want is a an explanation for this..
Or did you believe on May 19th, when you opened a fresh thread at the JREF, that every reader would already have read and understood everythunbg you ever wrote at the JREF, at the911forum and on your website? What then was the poibt of your thread?
be informed that you may get new readers when you open a new thread, and I expect that YOU can explain YOUR reasons, and I expect you to NOT expect that I already know your mind, or can read it.
If you have reasons and criteria for your selection, you ought to be able to write them down.
How much time and energy have we both wasted in this exchange, when you could have just written down your reasons nearly 3 months ago? I suspect you HAVE NO reasons and criteria, or are ashamed of them. Care to prove me wrong?