Made Up Science Facts

tkingdoll said:

A lit cigarette isn't hot enough to ignite petrol, let alone a mobile phone spark.

Excuse me? The "flash point" of petrol ("gasoline") is about -40C (or -40F, if you prefer that). In your engine, gasoline vapor is routinely ignited by a spark -- that's why they're called "spark plugs." See the US-mandated MSDS here for more details.

But it's daylight madness to suggest that a lit cigarette isn't hot enough to light petrol.

Similarly, the MSDS specifically says that petrol vapors "may be ignited when exposed to heat, spark, open flame, or other source of ignition," and that "flowing product may be ignited by self-generated static electricity."

As far as using a mobile phone, or any kind of electrical equipment, goes, it's very easy to make sparks by opening or closing an electrical switch, for example, by pressing buttons. If the button sticks slightly or is slightly out of true, a spark is likely to jump across the air gap as the button is pressed (or released), If the air near that gap has more than 1.4% but less than 7.6% petrol vapor, and is warmer than -40C, then the vapor will ignite, presumably with negative consequences.
 
new drkitten said:
Excuse me? The "flash point" of petrol ("gasoline") is about -40C (or -40F, if you prefer that). In your engine, gasoline vapor is routinely ignited by a spark -- that's why they're called "spark plugs." See the US-mandated MSDS here for more details.

But it's daylight madness to suggest that a lit cigarette isn't hot enough to light petrol.

Similarly, the MSDS specifically says that petrol vapors "may be ignited when exposed to heat, spark, open flame, or other source of ignition," and that "flowing product may be ignited by self-generated static electricity."

As far as using a mobile phone, or any kind of electrical equipment, goes, it's very easy to make sparks by opening or closing an electrical switch, for example, by pressing buttons. If the button sticks slightly or is slightly out of true, a spark is likely to jump across the air gap as the button is pressed (or released), If the air near that gap has more than 1.4% but less than 7.6% petrol vapor, and is warmer than -40C, then the vapor will ignite, presumably with negative consequences.
A lit cig tossed into a full pail of gasoline (petrol) will likely go out.
Atomize the gas through a fuel injector and a cig might ignite it.
Toss the cig into a pail with 1cm of gas on the bottom that's been standing for five minutes in the hot sun, and who knows.
Sounds like a winning Science Fair entry at the Richard M. Nixon High School annual competition.
 
Just to add to the gasloine/cell phone issue, there is no recorded instance of a gasoline fire being ignited by a cell phone. None. Zero. Zip. No reliable reports of investigations have ever pointed to a cell phone as the culprit.

"Mythbusters" on Discovery did tests on this one as well. They even went so far as to short out a cell phone battery, expose wires, and several other methods to cause an explosion. Didn't happen.

The major cause of fires at the gasoline pump is static electricity. You get out, start pumping, then sit back in the car. When you get out, you can build up a static charge from brushing against the seat. If you don't ground out before you go pick up the pump handle, then you'll get a spark from your hand to the car right above the gas port, igniting the vapors coiming from around the pump spout. Of course, the reaction of most people is to pull the pump handle out, which then sprays gasoline everywhere, making a larger fire.

So, don't lerave the pump once you start pumping. Always make sure that you touch the metal frame of the car when you get out. If a fire does start, leave the pump handle where it is and get away (notifying others at the station, of course).
 
Even if the cigarette itself isn't hot enough to ignite the gas, the lighter or match used to light it damn well is. Plus the cigarette can catch something else on fire that burns hot enough to ignite the gas.
 
Paulhoff said:
Fatbat

"Pumping gas" you have to fill me in. My imagination goes too far. :cs:

It means, in certain vulgar circles, to break wind, to fart or to "squeeze cheese", as I believe some Americans say.
 
Licorice actually cleans your teeth.

If you swallow gum, it will stay in your stomach for seven years.


Every time I hear the phrase "old wives' tale", I picture my aunt telling me these as REAL TRUE FACTS.
 
When I was a kid, my older sister used her status as a nursing student to get us to believe all kinds of stuff. Among them:

* Chewing too much gum will give you TOOTH CANCER!!

* The "Tingler" in the old Vincent Price movie is REAL! So DON'T GET SCARED!

(For those of you who haven't seen the movie -- the Tingler was a made-up microscopic creature that lives in the spinal cord of all humans, growing into a large, indestructable centipede when they are scared to death.)
 
* Coca-Cola is so acidic that it will dissolve a tooth overnight.

One of my younger siblings did an experiment in elementary school where a tooth was soaked in a cup of Coke. I don't think it dissolved in a day, but within a few days it had broken apart. This was a long time ago, but I still remember him bringing home the cup with the pieces of tooth in it.
 
Eating meat builds up 5 lbs. of fibers and fat in the small and large intestines.

Paul

:) :) :)
 
new drkitten said:
Excuse me? The "flash point" of petrol ("gasoline") is about -40C (or -40F, if you prefer that). In your engine, gasoline vapor is routinely ignited by a spark -- that's why they're called "spark plugs." See the US-mandated MSDS here for more details.
...
If the air near that gap has more than 1.4% but less than 7.6% petrol vapor, and is warmer than -40C, then the vapor will ignite, presumably with negative consequences.
These figures are the Lower and Upper Explosive limits (LEL and UEL) from the MSDS you linked. When the concentration of vapor is within this range a spark or flame WILL cause explosive combustion. (See Fuel/Air Bombs for a practical demonstration of this effect). Outside this range the vapor may ignite, but it will burn rather than explode. Don't know what the upper limit is for flammability. Obviously at 100% vapor it will not burn (no oxygen).

For a cell phone a few feet from the pump nozzel, the chance of having vapor in this concentration range is small, especially if there is any breeze at all.
 
patnray said:
These figures are the Lower and Upper Explosive limits (LEL and UEL) from the MSDS you linked. When the concentration of vapor is within this range a spark or flame WILL cause explosive combustion. (See Fuel/Air Bombs for a practical demonstration of this effect).

I would consider this to be a "negative consequence," yes. But perhaps your experience is different.

But that's rather my point. The physics and chemistry of gasoline explosions are well-understood, and it's simply not true to say that, for example, "a lit cigarette isn't hot enough to light petrol."

It's quite legitimate to point out that there have been no confirmed/recorded instances of a spark from a cell phone causing a fire at a petrol station. But that's not the way safety engineers, and safety regulations, work, nor should it be. Part of the reason for the MSDS is to prevent conditions that are known to be dangerous before someone gets hurt.

It's unlikely that gasoline vapors will pool in such a way as to be lit by a cell phone. But it's also unlikely that any given plane will have to make an emergency landing in water, and airlines still put the life vest under the seats. How unlikely does something have to be before safety precautions -- especially safety precautions that are essentially without cost, like telling people to "hang up your (rule 8) cell phone" -- are inappropriate?
 
new drkitten,

The physics and chemistry of gasoline explosions are well-understood, and it's simply not true to say that, for example, "a lit cigarette isn't hot enough to light petrol."

OK, my bad. I should have referenced my source for my assertion that a lit cigarette isn't hot enough to ingite petrol in my original post, instead of the follow-up post. This information is from Dr Adam Burgess, of the University of Kent, in the following article http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/england/kent/4366337.stm

He has, according to the article, recently undertaken a study into the mobile phone/petrol station 'myth'.

"A lit cigarette was not hot enough to ignite petrol on a filling station, let alone the low voltage of a mobile phone, he claimed. "

I have no idea if this guy is a credible source for scientific information, he's a Sociology professor, but he does seem to know his stuff when it comes to mobile phones. There is a much more comprehensive article here:

http://economist.com/science/displayStory.cfm?story_id=3786384

Which includes the claims:
"By the late 1990s, however, phonemakers—having conducted their own research—realised that there was no danger of phones causing explosions since they could not generate the required sparks. But it was too late. The myth had taken hold."

and

"A further complication was the rise of the internet, where hoax memos, many claiming to originate from oil companies, warned of the danger of using mobile phones in petrol stations. One e-mail contained fictitious examples of such explosions said to have happened in Indonesia and Australia. Another, supposedly sent out by Shell, found its way on to an internal website at Exxon, says Dr Burgess, where it was treated as authoritative by employees. "

I would, however, like to point out that this is a thread to list popular made-up science facts, and my assertion that:

*Using a mobile phone at a petrol station will cause an explosion/fire/spontaneous combustion.

is a common misconception is still valid.

Also, please note the humour in my original post, this thread is clearly supposed to be light-hearted and I don't like being accused of 'daylight madness'. Thank you.
 
You can never know when you will open a Pandora’s box. :j2:

Paul


:) :) :)
 
* It's colder in the winter because the Earth is futher from the sun.

* You swallow 8 spiders a year.

* The moon is larger in the sky during certain months.
 
The moon is larger when it rises then when it is overhead.

Paul

P.S. I eat 10 spiders a year.

:) :) :)
 
Zamzara said:


* You swallow 8 spiders a year.


Hear hear! People that say this haven't thought it through. It's usually 'in your sleep' too. In which case, you must nearly swallow lots, too. And when was the last time you woke up with a spider on your face? Or a half-chewed spider in your mouth? Using a leg as a toothpick?

And if 8 is an average, that means that some people swallow zero spiders per year, and some people swallow hundreds. :D
 
Zamzara said:
* It's colder in the winter because the Earth is futher from the sun.

The bit I'm on is further away in winter (but that's not the reason its colder, no)

Zamzara said:
* The moon is larger in the sky during certain months.

It was at its closest to earth in June than it had been for several years.


One I often hear people say is that the crescent appearance of the moon is caused by the earth's shadow.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom