Made Up Science Facts

aggle-rithm said:
Yes, I had heard that it was the many layers that made it sharp and strong. I was never sure how that followed.

The basic problem with steel working in general -- hard steel holds an edge really well, but is brittle (for example, will break when dropped), while softer steel is very flexible, but won't hold an edge. (Goldilocks and the Three Swordsmiths -- this steel is too hard, this steel is too soft, this one is "just right.") The trick is to get the carbon content "just right," no mean feat in an age where you smelt steel in a charcoal (= carbon-burning) furnace. So Japanese swordsmiths would hammer together pieces of high-carbon and low-carbon steel, then fold them together over and over and over to distribute the carbon evenly enough to make a uniformly high-quality blade.

This re-working also drives out impurities and air bubbles that would otherwise weaken the sword.

In Europe, this technique was called "pattern welding," but had been lost during the Dark Ages and hadn't been re-discovered until the age of gunpowder had made swords obsolete. So Japanese swords were, in fact, typically of higher quality than the medieval swords with which they were so often compared.

So D&D did get it at least partially right. A typical (non-pattern welded) medieval European sword wouldn't have the same uniformity of carbon throughout the blade, and the areas of high carbon would be brittle, making the sword as a whole more likely to break. Partly as a result, the overall carbon content was usually lower, making the sword less sharp. So a katana was, in fact, typically both stronger and sharper than its European equivalent.
 
new drkitten said:
The basic problem with steel working in general -- hard steel holds an edge really well, but is brittle (for example, will break when dropped), while softer steel is very flexible, but won't hold an edge. (Goldilocks and the Three Swordsmiths -- this steel is too hard, this steel is too soft, this one is "just right.") The trick is to get the carbon content "just right," no mean feat in an age where you smelt steel in a charcoal (= carbon-burning) furnace. So Japanese swordsmiths would hammer together pieces of high-carbon and low-carbon steel, then fold them together over and over and over to distribute the carbon evenly enough to make a uniformly high-quality blade.

This re-working also drives out impurities and air bubbles that would otherwise weaken the sword.

In Europe, this technique was called "pattern welding," but had been lost during the Dark Ages and hadn't been re-discovered until the age of gunpowder had made swords obsolete. So Japanese swords were, in fact, typically of higher quality than the medieval swords with which they were so often compared.

So D&D did get it at least partially right. A typical (non-pattern welded) medieval European sword wouldn't have the same uniformity of carbon throughout the blade, and the areas of high carbon would be brittle, making the sword as a whole more likely to break. Partly as a result, the overall carbon content was usually lower, making the sword less sharp. So a katana was, in fact, typically both stronger and sharper than its European equivalent.

Well said, Dr. k. However, I think you may have missed one interesting aspect of this, which - unless you're a fanatic like me - you may not be aware of. :)

Japanese katana's were indeed formed the way you describe, but with a difference. The initial folding process was designed to create exactly what you described - a blade flexible enough to withstand impact without shattering, but strong enough to resist or prevent bending. "Mild" steel, as it were.

Once the primary blade was made, further folding and tempering took place. Harder steel was folded in at the cutting edge of the blades, and tempered to a higher degree of hardness than the rest of the blade. (Harder edge, softer, "springier" spine.) Clay was used to protect the softer steel while the tempering process was performed... Repeated tempering (plus the steel "mix") adjusted the edge of the steel to the desired level of hardness.

This allowed the sword to take and keep a much finer edge than would have been possible with the milder steel... yet allowed the blade to remain "springy" enough to prevent shattering. Once this step was completed, the tip of the blade was likewise treated using an even harder steel to create a point to capable of penetrating period armor during a thrust.

The end result was the appearance of a "hamon line" - a wavey line following the curve of the edge and the tip where the harder steel was folded in with the milder steel.

(People should note that the hamon line doesn't simply appear as a result of the forging; the blade has to be treated with acid to bring it out. The line has to do (apparently) with the difference between crystallization of the different steels in the blade that is created during the tempering process.)

Not all Japanese smiths knew how to do this; it was a jealously guarded secret of a number of famous smithing families whose blades were sought out by nobility and the rich. This added to the legend of the katana's sharpness, etc... and as you said correctly, period katana's were substantially sharper and more resilient than period European weapons, including the sabre.

A reasonable amount of good information can be found at http://swordforum.com/ ... and specifically this page in this article:

http://swordforum.com/fall99/lineup-4.html
 
Coca-Cola is an excellent medicine in hot countries where the cleanliness is dubious. Not only does it destroy nasty bugs that might be inside a person, it also replaces lost salts and minerals caused by excessive sweating.

This isn't a myth. It's tried and tested. I drank loads of the stuff when I was in Egypt and didn't go down with 'Pharoah's Revenge' as the rest of the ship did. I was completely healthy.

Patsy.
 
crimresearch said:
...the myth comes in the form of thinking that ONLY Japanese swords were that way.

In medieval Japan, steel was precious stuff. So if you're going to make a sword, you make it as good as you possibly can. In contemporary Europe, everybody had a sword, and many of them were crap. So it is true that a typical Japanese sword was better than a typical European sword. At the same time, it is also true that the good Japanese swords were comparable to the good European swords.
 
songstress said:
Coca-Cola is an excellent medicine in hot countries where the cleanliness is dubious. Not only does it destroy nasty bugs that might be inside a person, it also replaces lost salts and minerals caused by excessive sweating.
Well it replaces water and sugar inside a person (it can't replace any of the minerals it doesn't contain).

More to the point drinking sealed mass-produced drinks such as Coke and Mineral water is a very good idea in countries where hygiene is not at a premium as it going to be much safer than local water and drinks diluted from tapwater.
Not having ice is also a good idea as that is usually made with tapwater.

And Coca Cola has no antibacterial effect that I am aware of.

In fact according to this website quite the opposite is the case.
James A Howenstine M.D.
A Physician's Guide to Natural Health Products That Work

"In an interesting experiment the sugar from one soft drink was able to
damage the white blood cells' ability to ingest and kill gonococcal bacteria
for seven hours."

"Soft drinks also contain large quantities of phosphorus, which when
excreted pulls calcium out of the bones. Heavy users of soft drinks will
have osteoporosis along with their damaged arteries."
Dr. Earl Mindell
"Soft drinks can decrease the antibacterial action of penicillin and
ampicillin."

You probably remained healthy because you avoided coming into contact with any particularly nasty bugs, not because you drank Coca Cola.
And to be honest it seems unlikely you were the only person drinking Coca Cola during your trip.

Interestingly it is probably this kind of incorrect connection assumption that allows homeopathy to continue being so popular.

ETA: Some more myths about Coke
 
songstress said:

This isn't a myth. It's tried and tested. I drank loads of the stuff when I was in Egypt and didn't go down with 'Pharoah's Revenge' as the rest of the ship did. I was completely healthy.

Patsy.

Tried and tested by...anecdote?
 
songstress said:
Coca-Cola is an excellent medicine in hot countries where the cleanliness is dubious. Not only does it destroy nasty bugs that might be inside a person, it also replaces lost salts and minerals caused by excessive sweating.

This isn't a myth. It's tried and tested. I drank loads of the stuff when I was in Egypt and didn't go down with 'Pharoah's Revenge' as the rest of the ship did. I was completely healthy.

Patsy.

I prefered the Egyptian Beers (Stella, Shakara gold) myself, the alcohol was much more leathal to bugs than Coke and didn't require ice cubes (which might contain all kinds of nasty things in the ice that would melt).

Probably everybody else ate the uncooked vegetables.
 
phildonnia said:
In medieval Japan, steel was precious stuff. So if you're going to make a sword, you make it as good as you possibly can. In contemporary Europe, everybody had a sword, and many of them were crap. So it is true that a typical Japanese sword was better than a typical European sword. At the same time, it is also true that the good Japanese swords were comparable to the good European swords.

Apparently the government still only allots so much of the native metal (more like iron sand than ore) to their 'living treasure' swordsmiths, who then have to decide how much to dole out per project, apprentice, etc.

One question that I could never get answered at SF or elsewhere, was if the available metal situation was different in the Okinawan/Ryukyu islands.
(It would provide some interesting insight into the Sai origination myths).
 
phildonnia said:
In medieval Japan, steel was precious stuff. So if you're going to make a sword, you make it as good as you possibly can. In contemporary Europe, everybody had a sword, and many of them were crap. So it is true that a typical Japanese sword was better than a typical European sword. At the same time, it is also true that the good Japanese swords were comparable to the good European swords.

This doesn't make any sense because broken or damaged swords do not cease to exist. They can be re-melted and remade without losing the steel. Also if steel was so rare they would have been melting down all that steel that was just laying around in the den in the shape of swords. It would have been too valuable to keep. I don't see how the quantity of steel would have any bearing whatsoever. I think it had much more to do with the Japanese considering their swords an extension of their soul, thus wanted them to be as good as possible and not just good enough as perhaps the Europeans favored.
 
tkingdoll said:
....

And if 8 is an average, that means that some people swallow zero spiders per year, and some people swallow hundreds. :D

Maybe thats why my all cheeseburger diet isn't working.

LLH
 
BronzeDog said:
One myth a fanboy touted was that katanas were stored blade-up because gravity would make them cut through the bottom, otherwise. Probable reality I've heard: It's for the quick draw techniques. Other possibility: It's my understanding that the edge is actually quite brittle. My dad suggested that blade-up storage might prevent shattering if the sword is dropped.

The blade-up form is used exclusively by foot soldiers. And yes, as far as I am aware, it came about due to the development of quick-drawing techniques (iaido). Earlier blades were carried blade-down.

Cavalry carried their swords blade-down too, and again this was for ease of drawing. European sabers were carried blade-down. You didn't want to collide with your horse's head when you drew the sword.
 
El_Spectre said:
They're good swords, but a whole lot of that has to do with the fact that they are designed for 2 kinds of attacks (slashing and armor piercing). Most swords are really designed for 1 purpose (slash, bash or stab).

By about the 16th century in Eurpoe, the rapier was in vogue, and this was a sword that was designed for one purpose only - thrusting. Prior to this time, either the point or the edge of the sword could be used. The English master George Silver advocated using the cutting edge of the sword, while Italians were advocating the use of the point. Silver used a heavier weapon with a more robust cutting edge and a narrow point. The term "cut and thrust sword" describes the dual purpose of these blades.

My personal favourite, Royal Armouries Manuscript I.33 (unknown author, dated to the late 13th century) describes both cutting and thrusting techniques. The longsword techniques of Talhoffer and Ringneck included both cutting and thrusting.

The European sword was almost always a dual-purpose weapon, up until the development of the rapier.
 
Vagabond,

In medieval Japan, steel was precious stuff. So if you're going to make a sword, you make it as good as you possibly can. In contemporary Europe, everybody had a sword, and many of them were crap. So it is true that a typical Japanese sword was better than a typical European sword. At the same time, it is also true that the good Japanese swords were comparable to the good European swords.
This doesn't make any sense because broken or damaged swords do not cease to exist. They can be re-melted and remade without losing the steel. Also if steel was so rare they would have been melting down all that steel that was just laying around in the den in the shape of swords. It would have been too valuable to keep. I don't see how the quantity of steel would have any bearing whatsoever.
You're not considering the issue of price. Consider the following hypothetical examples:

Situation A:
The metal for a long sword costs $10,000. The labor costs range from $200 to $2,000.

Situation B: The metal costs $1,000. The labor costs range from $200 to $2,000.

In the first case, where the metal is very expensive, there is very little relative savings in having cheap swords made. In the second case, the relative savings is huge. In the first case, for example, you have the choice between 6 crappy swords, or 5 top-quality swords. In the second case, for the same money, the choice ranges from 50 crappy swords, to 20 top-quality swords.

That's a pretty big difference. Now consider the value of the soldiers. In a situation where swords are extremely expensive, only the most highly trained elite soldiers are going to be issued them. So now you have the cost of their training and upkeep to consider as well, not to mention the importance of them being able succeed in the tasks assigned to them. You want to give them the highest quality equipment possible. In a situation where swords are cheap, you issue them to all your soldiers. It is just another peice of equipment. You not going to spend money on high-quality swords when you could use that extra money to train, equip, and feed a large number of additional soldiers.


Dr. Stupid
 
You want to give them the highest quality equipment possible. In a situation where swords are cheap, you issue them to all your soldiers. It is just another peice of equipment. You not going to spend money on high-quality swords when you could use that extra money to train, equip, and feed a large number of additional soldiers.<<<<

You are making many fallicious assumptions. First of all you are making the assumption that a soldier with a higher quality sword is necessarily any better in combat than one with a lessor sword. Against unarmored or lightly armored opponents it doesn't matter for crap. Probably not a whole lot against heavily armored but the Japanese didn't wear full plate mail like the Europeans did and the ones who did were exceedingly rare.

You make another false assumption when you figure more men is necessarily better. Tell this to Hannibal or Alexander or Ceasar. In Japanese battles in which units would often change sides during the battle, numbers are far less important than loyalty and quality. A smaller outmatched army does not fight it flees. If a smaller army fights it's because they think they can and usually do win anyway. Or they fight a defensive campaign in which numbers don't matter so much.

A peasant with a sword in his hands is no better than a peasant with a hoe in his hands in combat. At least he is familiar with a hoe. Without training a sword is an expensive club and more likely to get you killed than to kill anybody else particularly an armored and trained Samurai. Only way you would slow him down is if he slips in your blood when he goes by.

A German Tiger tank took 300,000 man hours to make thus they could only make 1300 of them. Quality or quantity doesn't automatically give you an advantage. It might, it might be meaningless.

In war it doesn't matter how much something costs. You pay whatever it is during, confiscate it if they won't give you credit and worry about how much it costs afterward.
 
Vagabond said:
This doesn't make any sense because broken or damaged swords do not cease to exist. They can be re-melted and remade without losing the steel. Also if steel was so rare they would have been melting down all that steel that was just laying around in the den in the shape of swords. It would have been too valuable to keep. I don't see how the quantity of steel would have any bearing whatsoever. I think it had much more to do with the Japanese considering their swords an extension of their soul, thus wanted them to be as good as possible and not just good enough as perhaps the Europeans favored.

Not precisely. Once a sword has been forged of different types of steel, smelting it down and reforging it to the same exact characteristics as the orginal would probably be impossible.

In my post, I identified that the core of the sword was made of "milder" steel; it has somewhat different levels of carbon and trace ingredients than the edge and point, which are made from a "harder" steel. Also, the process of tempering changes the characteristics of the steel involved. I'm not sure if those changes from tempering are permanent or not, but I'm sure that mixing the two steels by smelting them together would yield a steel with different characteristics than the smith would want for a blade.

So the steel of a broken blade - while probably useful for other things, perhaps even other weapons - wouldn't likely meet the standard for a "new" blade.
 
Vagabond said:
This doesn't make any sense because broken or damaged swords do not cease to exist. They can be re-melted and remade without losing the steel.

Not quite. As I pointed out above, "steel" is not a monolithic term, and one of the things that made Japanese swords so good was the ability of the smith to control the exact kind of steel(s) used and their relative proportions. (The Goldilocks effect, again : This steel has too much carbon, this one doesn't have enough, this one is "just right.")

Melting down an old sword will largely destroy the carbon balance (as well as the crystal structure); the metal resulting from that wouldn't work well as any part of a new sword.


Also if steel was so rare they would have been melting down all that steel that was just laying around in the den in the shape of swords. It would have been too valuable to keep.

Again, no. Only if the steel you got from melting down swords was a useful kind.
 
Vagabond said:


You make another false assumption when you figure more men is necessarily better. Tell this to Hannibal or Alexander or Ceasar. In Japanese battles in which units would often change sides during the battle, numbers are far less important than loyalty and quality. A smaller outmatched army does not fight it flees. If a smaller army fights it's because they think they can and usually do win anyway. Or they fight a defensive campaign in which numbers don't matter so much.

You, um, don't know much Japanese history, do you?
 
You, um, don't know much Japanese history, do you?<<<<

First of all that is not an arguement unless you are an idiot. Secondly, there is no doubt whatsoever I know far more Japanese history than you do.
 
Again, no. Only if the steel you got from melting down swords was a useful kind.<<<<<

I am not an expert on sword smelting and it is obvious neither are either of you. Your just talking out your asses to no purpose.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom