new drkitten said:
The basic problem with steel working in general -- hard steel holds an edge really well, but is brittle (for example, will break when dropped), while softer steel is very flexible, but won't hold an edge. (Goldilocks and the Three Swordsmiths -- this steel is too hard, this steel is too soft, this one is "just right.") The trick is to get the carbon content "just right," no mean feat in an age where you smelt steel in a charcoal (= carbon-burning) furnace. So Japanese swordsmiths would hammer together pieces of high-carbon and low-carbon steel, then fold them together over and over and over to distribute the carbon evenly enough to make a uniformly high-quality blade.
This re-working also drives out impurities and air bubbles that would otherwise weaken the sword.
In Europe, this technique was called "pattern welding," but had been lost during the Dark Ages and hadn't been re-discovered until the age of gunpowder had made swords obsolete. So Japanese swords were, in fact, typically of higher quality than the medieval swords with which they were so often compared.
So D&D did get it at least partially right. A typical (non-pattern welded) medieval European sword wouldn't have the same uniformity of carbon throughout the blade, and the areas of high carbon would be brittle, making the sword as a whole more likely to break. Partly as a result, the overall carbon content was usually lower, making the sword less sharp. So a katana was, in fact, typically both stronger and sharper than its European equivalent.
Well said, Dr. k. However, I think you may have missed one interesting aspect of this, which - unless you're a fanatic like me - you may not be aware of.
Japanese katana's were indeed formed the way you describe, but with a difference. The initial folding process was designed to create exactly what you described - a blade flexible enough to withstand impact without shattering, but strong enough to resist or prevent bending. "Mild" steel, as it were.
Once the primary blade was made, further folding and tempering took place. Harder steel was folded in at the cutting edge of the blades, and tempered to a higher degree of hardness than the rest of the blade. (Harder edge, softer, "springier" spine.) Clay was used to protect the softer steel while the tempering process was performed... Repeated tempering (plus the steel "mix") adjusted the edge of the steel to the desired level of hardness.
This allowed the sword to take and keep a much finer edge than would have been possible with the milder steel... yet allowed the blade to remain "springy" enough to prevent shattering. Once this step was completed, the tip of the blade was likewise treated using an even harder steel to create a point to capable of penetrating period armor during a thrust.
The end result was the appearance of a "hamon line" - a wavey line following the curve of the edge and the tip where the harder steel was folded in with the milder steel.
(People should note that the hamon line doesn't simply appear as a result of the forging; the blade has to be treated with acid to bring it out. The line has to do (apparently) with the difference between crystallization of the different steels in the blade that is created during the tempering process.)
Not all Japanese smiths knew how to do this; it was a jealously guarded secret of a number of famous smithing families whose blades were sought out by nobility and the rich. This added to the legend of the katana's sharpness, etc... and as you said correctly, period katana's were substantially sharper and more resilient than period European weapons, including the sabre.
A reasonable amount of good information can be found at
http://swordforum.com/ ... and specifically this page in this article:
http://swordforum.com/fall99/lineup-4.html