Made Up Science Facts

tkingdoll said:
I'm pretty sure this one is true, isn't it something to do with hormones?

It's certainly seems true from observation, I've experienced this many times. But please provide me with some evidence to the contrary, I'd really like to know for certain one way or t'other. I had a quick e-look but couldn't find anything debunking it.
I, too, would like to see some evidence debunking this, if such exists. When I was in living in the dorm in college, after awhile it certainly seemed as though we were all on the same cycle judging by the trash baskets in the restroom stalls. If this was just a matter of selective memory and only noticing that the baskets were full when I needed to use them, I'd like to know.
 
richardm said:
The problem with the ring-of-roses thing is that the rhyme was first recorded in Mother Goose, which is a collection from the late 19th Century, at least 200 years too late for the bubonic plague. Plus, sneezing is not a symptom of the plague, anyway.

It doesn't seem credible that kids were reciting it for a couple of hundred years without anyone writing it down, and much more likely that it is part of the general 19th Century puritan distaste on enjoying yourself that resulted in dances without musical accompaniment (much like the puirt-a-beul we got as a result of the ban on traditional instruments in Scotland). It resulted in a big increase in the number of these kind of rhymes (hence the rise in popularity of rhyme books around that time, Mother Goose et al)


Edited to add:

* If you hold a Guinea Pig upside down its eyes will fall out.



Hmmm- Well, it doesn't seem incredible to me. Also the earliest surviving record need not be the earliest record. It could be a copy of an earlier (now lost) record.


"Little Jack Horner" of greater antiquity survives. Horner was Henry VIII's agent sent to collect the title deeds of the the abbeys from Somerset and Devon. The plum he pulled out was the title to estates which are (I believe) still in the Horner family.

ETA- Mind you, here's a subtly different version.
http://www.grovepublishing.co.uk/index/page5e.htm
 
Forty-Two said:
I, too, would like to see some evidence debunking this, if such exists. When I was in living in the dorm in college, after awhile it certainly seemed as though we were all on the same cycle judging by the trash baskets in the restroom stalls. If this was just a matter of selective memory and only noticing that the baskets were full when I needed to use them, I'd like to know.

I dug up a credible survey of the existing literature:

McClintok, Marha K, Annual Review of Sex Research
 
This thread needs to be on a wiki :D

*The speed of light can be broken just like the speed of sound.

*Pi is 22/7

* GOD = G_uv

* There's a tribe somewhere in Papua New Guinea where the women rule over the men

* Einstein plagiarized Special Relativity from Lorentz/Poincare/someone else

* Vitamin C helps fight against the common cold

* St John's Wort is a natural remedy for depression

* The MMR vaccine causes autism/ Multiple vaccines can "overload" the immune systems of infants
 
Ladewig said:
*The full moon drives people crazy, as evidenced by more activity in emergency rooms and police stations.


My wife works with kids and she says this same type of thing quite often. That is, that kids are more roudy during a full moon. I've also heard it attributed to animals. I searched snopes and couldn't find an article on this. Do you know of a site that explains this myth. (Not that I would have the guts to argue with my wife.)
 
aargh57 said:
My wife works with kids and she says this same type of thing quite often. That is, that kids are more roudy during a full moon. I've also heard it attributed to animals. I searched snopes and couldn't find an article on this. Do you know of a site that explains this myth. (Not that I would have the guts to argue with my wife.)

:)

We were given a copy of this as an example of a research paper on Monday.

"Lunar Phases and Crisis Center Telephone Calls' - James E Wilson II and Jerome J Tobacyk.

'ABSTRACT - the lunar hypothesis, that is, the notion that lunar phases can directly affect human behaviour, was tested by a time-series analysis of 4,575 crisis center telephone calls (all calls recorded for a 6 month interval). As expected, the lunar hypothesis was not supported.
The 28 day lunar cycle accounted for less than 1% of the variation of frequency of crisis center calls. Also, as hypothesized from an attribution theory framework, crisis center workers reported significantly greater belief in lunar effects than a non-crisis center worker comparison group.'

I haven't looked for a copy online, but I've read it twice before - once for this class that I'm doing and the other for an intro to research techniques.

In class, we suggested that similar studies should be done for the following statements said by teachers:

'The kids are acting up because there is a storm coming...'

'The kids are acting up because it is windy....'

Pretty much any 'weather related' phenomena that we teachers come up with is ripe for a bit of scientific analysis. :)
 
aargh57 said:
My wife works with kids and she says this same type of thing quite often. That is, that kids are more roudy during a full moon. I've also heard it attributed to animals. I searched snopes and couldn't find an article on this. Do you know of a site that explains this myth. (Not that I would have the guts to argue with my wife.)
The Skeptic's Dictionary has this detailed entry.

Plus when you think about it, why would the fact that the moon is showing slightly less shadow than the previous night have any effect on anything?

I think people believe that a full moon is somehow exerting different gravitational effects or something.
But how could it? The only difference from any other night is the angle we are seeing sunlight reflected off it, and the amount of reflected light as a result.

Why would that affect anything? Especially since we have been able to produce our own light for over a quarter of a million years. (Reference)
 
Kiless said:
In class, we suggested that similar studies should be done for the following statements said by teachers:

'The kids are acting up because there is a storm coming...'

'The kids are acting up because it is windy....'

Pretty much any 'weather related' phenomena that we teachers come up with is ripe for a bit of scientific analysis. :)

That's a *very* common saying in schools I've worked in - we say wind is worth about 20% off of good behaviour, rain is worth another 20% - and if it starts snowing, forget about teaching.

I don't really go with the numbers, but my gut reaction has always been that it's pretty much true.
 
* The space shuttle Challenger exploded on takeoff in 1986.

According to NASA's investigation, the following sequence of events occurred:

1. The shuttle lost power
2. Turbulance tore the shuttle apart
3. The fuel spilled out and caught fire.

Since 2 and 3 were almost simultaneous, it looked like an explosion, but it wasn't.
 
Ashles said:
The Skeptic's Dictionary has this detailed entry.

Plus when you think about it, why would the fact that the moon is showing slightly less shadow than the previous night have any effect on anything?

I think people believe that a full moon is somehow exerting different gravitational effects or something.
But how could it? The only difference from any other night is the angle we are seeing sunlight reflected off it, and the amount of reflected light as a result.

Why would that affect anything? Especially since we have been able to produce our own light for over a quarter of a million years. (Reference)

This myth is possibly still around because people are aware that the word 'lunatic' is from 'lunar' and they just run with it. I've had conversations that go along the lines of:

Them: "My kid/dog/menstruating wife gets crazy during a fool moon"

Me: "The moon doesn't have any effect on your mood, it's a myth"

Them: "Course it does! That's where we get the word 'lunatic' from!

And the burden of proof is satisfied for them, leaving me to weep quietly into my hands.
 
About the full moon.

The standard so-called legion is that the gravity of the moon is as it strongest at the full moon. The moon’s gravity of never changes. They like to point out the ocean tides are high at the full moon, and we are made of water so the moon will affect us too. Well the ground moves up about a foot but we don’t see that. If the gravity of the moon did affected us, the new moon would be worse, with the pull of the sun and moon working together, the tides are at their highest.

The full moon is just another story that gets going with no truth to it, but will never stop, because of poor logic thinking. Logical thinking is never taught is school or at home.

A lot of people still believe that it is a $5 fined to kill a praying mantis.

http://skepdic.com/fullmoon.html

http://www.enchantedlearning.com/subjects/astronomy/moon/Tides.shtml

Paul

:) :) :)
 
aggle-rithm said:
* The space shuttle Challenger exploded on takeoff in 1986.

According to NASA's investigation, the following sequence of events occurred:

1. The shuttle lost power
2. Turbulance tore the shuttle apart
3. The fuel spilled out and caught fire.

Since 2 and 3 were almost simultaneous, it looked like an explosion, but it wasn't.

Say waaah? Everything I've seen shows the SRB blew (actually cracked) a seal, letting exhaust escape and burned into the nearby main tank.

Methinks thou doth jest.
 
El_Spectre said:
Say waaah? Everything I've seen shows the SRB blew (actually cracked) a seal, letting exhaust escape and burned into the nearby main tank.

Methinks thou doth jest.

Right -- at which time the shuttle lost power.

Without power, the complex adjustments made by the onboard computers to keep the shuttle from shaking itself apart were impossible to maintain.

I picked up a video at the Houston space center a few years ago that summarized the investigation into the accident. It wasn't a documentary, but a cold, unbiased analysis produced by the investigation team. I can go back and watch it again to be sure, but I think they specifically said, "The vehicle did not explode, but broke up due to turbulence when it lost power."

In other words, Challenger met the same fate Columbia did; the only difference was Columbia wasn't loaded down with fuel.
 
tkingdoll said:
*if you cut a worm in half, both halves will live.

(especially untrue if you cut it lengthways )
I heard this when I was young as, "If you cut a worm in two only the longest piece will live."

Which leads to the obvious question,"How do they know which is the longest piece?"
 
aggle-rithm said:


I picked up a video at the Houston space center a few years ago that summarized the investigation into the accident. It wasn't a documentary, but a cold, unbiased analysis produced by the investigation team. I can go back and watch it again to be sure, but I think they specifically said, "The vehicle did not explode, but broke up due to turbulence when it lost power."

Well, something sure exploded..

According to this sight:

http://www.people.virginia.edu/~dhb3k/shuttle.html

The crew cabin became detached from the orbiter in the explosion.. I guess you could stretch, and say it was turbulence.. But I don't think it could be compared to the way Coumbia came apart..

Challenger_explosion_jan28_86.jpg


Also, this news story describes the explosion of the main fuel tank..

http://msnbc.msn.com/id/3078062/

One solid booster broke free, its huge flame a cutting torch across Challenger, separating a wing. Enormous G-loads snapped free the other wing. Challenger came apart — but the crew cabin remained essentially intact, able to sustain its occupants.
 
I got my worm information/confirmation from here:

http://www.bbc.co.uk/dna/h2g2/A531983

which is actually a page for kids :o

It's a common myth that if you cut a worm in half the two halves will grow into worms, leaving you with two worms instead of one. This is untrue. If a worm loses a small part of its body, it will live, but if you cut it in half it will almost certainly die. So please don't do it. It's not pleasant.
 
Blood in the arteries (going away from the heart, towards the tissues and organs) is red because it has oxygen attached to the hemoglobin. Blood in the veins (going away from the organs and back to the heart) has used up all the oxygen, and has turned blue. If you look at your wrists you can see the blue blood flowing in your veins.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom