Made Up Science Facts

Raja said:
I was going to type up a longwinded explanation of what they wrote, but that might be against the "no explaining magic tricks" rule...so I'll just describe it.
Tellmetellmetellme!

Surely this isn't really a magic trick. More a practical joke.

I think it should be okay to explain - does anyone have any objections?
 
athon said:
Dammit, I was going to mention the 'tongue-map' and saw it was already done. Bollocks!

...I'm pretty sure there's no bollocks map, either :D
 
Ashles said:
That reminds me of the (sort of) opposite myth:

* Tapping the top of a can of fizzy drink will stop it frothing over when you open it

Yet I still do this! It's just a habit, and one that started because my father used to do it. People ask me why, and I have no good answer other than 'habit'.

Athon
 
athon said:
Yet I still do this! It's just a habit, and one that started because my father used to do it. People ask me why, and I have no good answer other than 'habit'.

Athon
A perfect example of superstitious behaviour in a skeptic.:)

[derail]I reckon we all have the odd little thing like this ( I do) - it just demonstrates again how scepticism isn't a personality thing, we all apply it unevenly and inconsistently.

When we say "just habit", what we really mean is that there is an actual compulsion to do it (albeit a faint one). A feeling that something nonspecific but 'bad' might happen if we don't.
And obviously such a feeling is irrational and devoid of critical thinking or logical analysis.

I used to have a habit where if I touched something with my right hand I'd have to touch something with my left to 'balance it up'.

Then it was the same everywhere - kick somethnig with my right foot, I'd have to do it with my left.

But it got to the stage where if I banged my shin hard, I would have to bang the other one to. So I decided I had to break the habit and just stopped doing it.

It actually physically wasn't easy - it felt really 'wrong' not to be balancing everything up.

But after a short period of not doing it, the habit just went away and so did the feeling of 'wrongness'.

Out of interest Athon, try not tapping the can and tell us how you feel (if anything).
[/derail]
 
*if you cut a worm in half, both halves will live.

(especially untrue if you cut it lengthways )
 
Ashles said:

Out of interest Athon, try not tapping the can and tell us how you feel (if anything).
[/derail]

Wow. And here I thought I was some OC freak. Ashles...I bow down.

I can easily not do it; if I don't think about what I'm doing, I occasionally find myself doing it before I open the can. I realised just now that I never really knew why people did it. Actually I might have assumed it made the drink less fizzy by giving it a 'micro-shake', in the form of a tap, but I can't say I ever really thought about it much.

Interesting; my father never tapped his cigarettes, but I've seen a lot of others do it. I'll have to ask what difference they think it makes.

Funny the habits we do simply because we pick them up through non-critical observation. As you said, we're not exempt simply because we know how to address it critically. We're all human, afterall.

Athon
 
Ashles said:
I used to have a habit where if I touched something with my right hand I'd have to touch something with my left to 'balance it up'.


[/B]

You realise this exact same behaviour is described as a characterstic of the protagonist in The Wasp Factory? (Who, if memory serves, is a weirdo murderer she/he). Anything to tell us...?
 
Re: Re: Made Up Science Facts

Dr Adequate said:
* The sea is blue because it reflects the sky.
And, of course:

* The sky is blue because that's what colour ozone is.

This one came from the Time Out "Health" section (a good place to spot exciting new woo ideas), via Ben Goldacre's bad science column.
 
thaiboxerken said:
Women's menstrual cycle is punishment from some god because of Eve.

Hey that reminds me;

* The menstrual cycle used to be linked to the lunar cycle, hence the '28 day' similarity.

Athon
 
Well, hell...if you're going to bring religion into the mix...

*man was made from clay

*women have one more rib than men do

*The Bible..yep just about every bit of it.

ANd back to the non-religious:

* Philogiston

*Spontaneous Generation
 
*The menstrual cycles of co-habiting women will become synchronized over time.
 
Huntsman said:
Well, she was almost right...it's water that made with dueterium instead of standard hydrogen, rather than water with an extra hydrogen. IN case you don't know, dueterium is a hydrogen atom that has a neutron and proton in the nucleus (as opposed to just a proton for standard hydrogen).

On a second note, I wouldn't say that you looked like a poor sceptic. In fact, I'd say that's a good example of scepticism in action. You heard something that sounded odd, and instead of dismissing it outright or accepting it without question, you looked for the answer for yourself and searched for evidence of it. Excellent example :)

I was sure I'd replied to this but my post went AWOL. Anyhoo, I stand by my assertion that I was a lousy sceptic in this instance, because I only looked for the answer to prove my mother wrong. She comes out with some of the worse gubbins imaginable, and I did, in fact, dismiss her claim outright, based on previous experiences (an great example of this was when, in the '80s, she stated, quite matter-of-factly, that in her considered opinion, Gorbachev would turn out to be the 'anti-christ').



And let's not forget that, when presented with information that was opposite to his initial view... he changed his mind and admitted error!

...tkingdoll is the female of the species ;)
 
tkingdoll said:
...tkingdoll is the female of the species ;)
Ooh that's reminded me of another one:

* Women can change their mind and admit error.



It's a joke A JOKE!
 
ReFLeX said:
*The menstrual cycles of co-habiting women will become synchronized over time.

I'm pretty sure this one is true, isn't it something to do with hormones?

It's certainly seems true from observation, I've experienced this many times. But please provide me with some evidence to the contrary, I'd really like to know for certain one way or t'other. I had a quick e-look but couldn't find anything debunking it.
 
"A burning candle placed inside an glass jar set upside down in water will cause the water level to rise because it uses the oxygen in the jar."
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom