Made Up Science Facts

The issue of restarting a heart...

I'm not a doctor, so I'm sure ThirdTwin or others could give a better answer (and I hope they'll correct any mistakes I make), but here's my understanding:

Drugs and internal massage are the primary means to restart a stopped heart. However, often times the heart restarts without a rythm, in a haphazard fashion (in other words, it starts up already in fibrillation). At that point, a defibrillator is used to synchronize the electrical activity and produce a proper sinus rythm.

So, technically, both answers are correct. Drugs are used to initiate activity, and shock to make that activity functional and productive. So, while the drugs technically start the heart, the shock starts the heart actually working.
 
Huntsman said:
The issue of restarting a heart...

I'm not a doctor, so I'm sure ThirdTwin or others could give a better answer (and I hope they'll correct any mistakes I make), but here's my understanding:

Drugs and internal massage are the primary means to restart a stopped heart. However, often times the heart restarts without a rythm, in a haphazard fashion (in other words, it starts up already in fibrillation). At that point, a defibrillator is used to synchronize the electrical activity and produce a proper sinus rythm.

So, technically, both answers are correct. Drugs are used to initiate activity, and shock to make that activity functional and productive. So, while the drugs technically start the heart, the shock starts the heart actually working.

Not necessarily drugs -- plain old CPR can work as well, if the patient isn't already on the operating table. However, a cardiac arrest patient is (reportedly) successfully revived only 5 percent of the time. If the heart stops, there's usually a good reason for it.
 
aggle-rithm said:
Not necessarily drugs -- plain old CPR can work as well, if the patient isn't already on the operating table. However, a cardiac arrest patient is (reportedly) successfully revived only 5 percent of the time. If the heart stops, there's usually a good reason for it.

Well, I was considering specifically the case of surgury, where direct massage of the heart (a form of CPR) would be used. And typically this will always be done in combination with drugs, because of that 5% rate you quoted :)

Sometimes a patient's heart will spontaneously restart during CPR, but I don't necessarily agree that the CPR is the cause. Not denying it either, just not sure either way. The primary purpose of CPR, though, is not to restart the heart (as you said, if it stops, there's a reason). Performing CPR is mainly to keep some level of oxygenated blood moving to the body tissues. You manually take over the function of lungs and heart to keep blood moving through the body, reducing the risk of damage from oxygen deprivation.
 
* "Micro-gravity" explains weightlessness in space

* Raindrops have a pointy end

* "Volts tickle, amps kill."

* "Lead crystal" is a crystal

* Vitamin A is good for your eyes
 
OK. I have always believed the ring-of -roses one.

Can someone enlighten me as to the true origin?
 
Soapy Sam said:
OK. I have always believed the ring-of -roses one.

Can someone enlighten me as to the true origin?

The problem with the ring-of-roses thing is that the rhyme was first recorded in Mother Goose, which is a collection from the late 19th Century, at least 200 years too late for the bubonic plague. Plus, sneezing is not a symptom of the plague, anyway.

It doesn't seem credible that kids were reciting it for a couple of hundred years without anyone writing it down, and much more likely that it is part of the general 19th Century puritan distaste on enjoying yourself that resulted in dances without musical accompaniment (much like the puirt-a-beul we got as a result of the ban on traditional instruments in Scotland). It resulted in a big increase in the number of these kind of rhymes (hence the rise in popularity of rhyme books around that time, Mother Goose et al)


Edited to add:

* If you hold a Guinea Pig upside down its eyes will fall out.
 
On defibrillators

A defibrillator (defib) is simply a device that delivers a DC shock in order to cause a “critical mass” of functioning myocardium (heart muscle) to depolarise and stop contracting. The hope is that when it repolarises and starts contracting again it will do so in an organised, rhythmic pattern that allows the heart to pump blood.

Currently there are two main ways of delivering that shock: monophasic (either a damped sine or truncated exponential waveform) and biphasic (a truncated exponential waveform). The biphasic method is newer and evidence suggests that it is more effective at lower energy levels than the older system. Biphasic machines also use smaller capacitors, which makes them easier to carry around. The next generation of defibrillators are likely to be triphasic and feature all kinds of extra waveform analysis to make defibrillation more effective.

Delivered energy from defibs is measured in Joules and for external defibrillation monophasic machines usually use sequences of 200 J, 200 J, 360 J (although US influenced medics might choose 200 J, 300 J, 360 J) with all subsequent shocks at 360 J. Biphasic machines either use the same escalating scale or three non-escalating shocks at 150 J, depending on the manufacturer.

The theory behind the escalating energy is that the first shock is likely to work and even if it doesn’t it will reduce transthoracic impedance allowing more energy to reach the myocardium (heart muscle) with the second shock. If that second shock doesn’t do the job then more energy is needed but the only way to achieve it is to increase the energy delivered. Biphasic machines are able to get round the need to use more energy because they can measure transthoracic impedance and adjust the shape of the delivered waveform to compensate.

One thing to note is that despite delivering all that energy to the chest only about 4% will actually flow through the myocardium. The rest will earth through the patient’s body and anything touching it (hence the “stand clear” order that is given before a defib is discharged).

By the way, you don’t have to be dead to be defibrillated. Although it is most commonly associated with resuscitation it’s actually more commonly used to restore regularity to hearts with irregular or too rapid rates. The patient is sedated and then cardioverted (you cardiovert the living and defibrillate the dead) using the same technique that is used for resuscitation, although the energy levels used are often less.

Internal defibrillation (used most commonly during cardiac surgery) is slightly different; although it uses the same waveforms the direct contact between the paddles and the myocardium means much lower energy can be used. Most defibs are limited to 50 J or less if they are connected to internal paddles to prevent accidental cooking of the heart.

Although there are two waveforms to choose from there are actually three different types of defibrillator available: manual, automated and implantable.

Manual defibs are operated entirely by the user, they are the ones most commonly seen in the media, although the hand-held paddles that you see being pressed to the patient’s chest are now being phased out and replaced by sticky pads that don’t have to be held in place. The advantages of manual defibs are speed and flexibility – a skilled operator can deploy one very quickly and they can be used for planned cardioversions. Their disadvantages are that they require a skilled operator and are thus largely limited to areas where medical professionals work.

Automated external defibrillators (AED’s) work by analysing the waveform they detect. If it is “shockable” they will charge themselves to the appropriate energy and instruct the operator to make sure everyone is clear and then press the discharge button. AED’s have the advantage that they can be used with very little training; because they talk to their operator and tell them what to do and because they do all the analysis themselves people with no medical background can use them. Their main disadvantage is that they lack the flexibility of manual machines, which limits their use to emergencies only. It is AED’s that are placed in public places such as airports, train stations, shopping centres (malls), gyms etc.

Implantable cardioverter-defibrillators (ICD’s) are essentially AED’s that are implanted in someone’s chest. They are commonly used in people who suffer regular episodes of life threatening cardiac arrhythmias. The main differences between them and AED’s is that ICD’s are much smaller and are fully automatic. The patient has no control over when the machine will fire; the ICD detects the fatal arrhythmia and immediately delivers the corrective shock. Modern machines are very safe and reliable, some of the older types used to go off if you brushed your teeth over-enthusiastically.
 
Cardiac surgery

During cardiac surgery the heart is stopped by using extremely cold fluid and then restarted by rewarming the patient (via the cardiac bypass machine). As the heart warms up it begins to fibrillate (although sometimes a machine called a fibrillator is used) and is then shocked back into a more normal rhythm. This is usually accompanied by a dose of adrenaline (epinephrine) to increase cardiac contractility and get as much of the muscle contracting as possible.
 
* Pedophiles have more genes in common with crabs than they do with people, there’s no real evidence for this, but it is a scientific fact.
 
CPR

Cardiopulmonary resuscitation, in its present form, has been around since the early 1960’s. It can be divided into two tiers: basic life support (BLS), which consists of external chest compressions and exhaled air ventilation (mouth-to-mouth), and advanced life support (ALS), which concerns itself with finding and reversing the cause of the cardiac arrest while maintaining artificial circulation and ventilation.

The purpose of BLS is to buy time for ALS providers to arrive and do their stuff. It is extremely unlikely that BLS will restart someone’s heart, although it is not unheard of in cases of drowning, drug overdose or trauma.

ALS providers are hoping that when they arrive the patient will be in either ventricular fibrillation (VF) or pulseless ventricular tachycardia (pVT). Both these rhythms indicate a functional myocardium and can be treated with defibrillation. Luckily they are also the commonest rhythms (70%) seen in cardiac arrests caused by heart disease. Unluckily they deteriorate rapidly to rhythms that are much harder to treat.

If you are in VF or pVT and you get defibrillated within 90 seconds of the onset of your cardiac arrest you’ve got a 70% chance of survival. For every 60 seconds after that your chance of survival drops by about 10% if you get no BLS and about 7% if do get BLS. It’s this dependence on time that has been behind the push to put AED’s into public places and train people to use them.

If you have a cardiac arrest in hospital you’re more likely to have a cardiac arrest caused by your heart actually stopping, either asystole or pulseless electrical activity (PEA). In asystole the heart stops working completely while in PEA the electrical system still works but the muscle doesn’t contract. The outcome from both of these is very bad because unless there is a reversible cause there is nothing that can be done to get your heart going again.
 
Soapy Sam said:
OK. I have always believed the ring-of -roses one.

Can someone enlighten me as to the true origin?

Richardm pretty much covered it, I just wanted to add the Snopes link... as always, it's a good read.
 
Thanks Camillus - I actually found it harder than I expect to find that information on the internet.

The detailed explanation is appreciated.
 
El_Spectre said:
No, the volts make it HURT, amps make you dead.

Incidently, how isn't this true?

I always thought that volts and amps were proportional to each other.

The sensation, whether tickling or pain, is caused by electrical current. The thing that injures or kills you is when the current continues over a time. So maybe, amps tickle, energy kills?
 
phildonnia said:
I always thought that volts and amps were proportional to each other.

The sensation, whether tickling or pain, is caused by electrical current. The thing that injures or kills you is when the current continues over a time. So maybe, amps tickle, energy kills?

Thet teach electricity (the subject, not the electrons) with the water-in-a-pipe analogy. EMF (voltage) is the water pressure, while current (amps) is the volume of water.

They are not proportional, but they are related. You're probably thinking of amps and watts.
 
Re: On defibrillators

Camillus said:
Implantable cardioverter-defibrillators (ICD’s) are essentially AED’s that are implanted in someone’s chest. They are commonly used in people who suffer regular episodes of life threatening cardiac arrhythmias. The main differences between them and AED’s is that ICD’s are much smaller and are fully automatic. The patient has no control over when the machine will fire; the ICD detects the fatal arrhythmia and immediately delivers the corrective shock. Modern machines are very safe and reliable, some of the older types used to go off if you brushed your teeth over-enthusiastically.


I read a news story once about a major drawback to this technology -- many patients, as their hearts become weaker, start to experience more and more frequent shocks, until finally it is going off almost constantly. The quality of life for these patients is zilch. They have the option of continuing the torture, or turning off the unit and dying.

Not something I'd wish on my worst enemy. :(
 
El_Spectre said:
Thet teach electricity (the subject, not the electrons) with the water-in-a-pipe analogy. EMF (voltage) is the water pressure, while current (amps) is the volume of water.

They are not proportional, but they are related. You're probably thinking of amps and watts.

I'd second this (although I think he was using the term energy in a generalized sense...close enough for partial credit :)).

Power (watts) is determined by P=IE (current times voltage). Combining that with Ohm's Law nets you P=I^2R (current squared times resistence). That's where the saying arose from...doubling the amps gives you four times the power (all other things being equal, increasing amperage generally increase voltage as well-think more water in the same size pipe). Of course, it all inter-relates, but I would suspect the other part of this is that typical electrical work is done at household voltages (120V and 220V in the states), and at these levels death or disability is dependant on the amperage.

Oops, missed the proportional bit. However, amps and watts are proportional, just not directly. The power is proportional to the square of the current. Course, been too long since math to now if proportional can be correctly applied.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom