Vagabond,
You want to give them the highest quality equipment possible. In a situation where swords are cheap, you issue them to all your soldiers. It is just another peice of equipment. You not going to spend money on high-quality swords when you could use that extra money to train, equip, and feed a large number of additional soldiers.
You are making many fallicious assumptions. First of all you are making the assumption that a soldier with a higher quality sword is necessarily any better in combat than one with a lessor sword. Against unarmored or lightly armored opponents it doesn't matter for crap.
Of course it matters. Having your sword break means your dead. Having a sword which is less likely to become fouled (stuck in your enemy) is also a significant combat advantage. Not to mention that a higher quality sword can be lighter, and better balanced.
Probably not a whole lot against heavily armored but the Japanese didn't wear full plate mail like the Europeans did and the ones who did were exceedingly rare.
Armor is hardly even a relevant issue. Swords aren't the ideal weapons to use against heavily armored opponents anyway. The primary issues are how likely the weapon is to break, how fast and maneuverable it is, and how much damage it can inflict.
You make another false assumption when you figure more men is necessarily better. Tell this to Hannibal or Alexander or Ceasar.
I made no such assumption. A small group of highly trained (and well equipped) soldiers can be extremely effective, as can a large group of poorly trained and poorly equipped soldiers. There are pros and cons to both strategies. Cheap steel just tends to favor the large army strategy more than the small elite army strategy.
In Japanese battles in which units would often change sides during the battle, numbers are far less important than loyalty and quality. A smaller outmatched army does not fight it flees. If a smaller army fights it's because they think they can and usually do win anyway. Or they fight a defensive campaign in which numbers don't matter so much.
How is this relevant to my argument?
A peasant with a sword in his hands is no better than a peasant with a hoe in his hands in combat.
This is a gross overstatement.
At least he is familiar with a hoe. Without training a sword is an expensive club and more likely to get you killed than to kill anybody else particularly an armored and trained Samurai.
It doesn't take very much training to get somebody to the point where they can be more effective with a sword than with a club. In fact, for anybody with any kind of fighting experience at all, it shouldn't take more than a few hours. And if you don't think that a dozen peasants with crappy swords and a few weeks training can overwhelm and kill a trained Samurai, then you have been watching too many movies.
A German Tiger tank took 300,000 man hours to make thus they could only make 1300 of them. Quality or quantity doesn't automatically give you an advantage. It might, it might be meaningless.
Again, I do not see how this is relevant to my argument. Are you saying that giving a high-quality sword to a highly trained soldier does not give him an advantage? Are you saying that a dozen ordinary soldiers with crappy swords are not going to be more effective than 11 soldiers with clubs and 1 soldier with a really good sword? Exactly which part of my argument are you disagreeing with?
In war it doesn't matter how much something costs. You pay whatever it is during, confiscate it if they won't give you credit and worry about how much it costs afterward.
This is nonsense. Costs are a huge factor during war.
BronzeDog,
If we're talking about coolness, I'd favor swords. But if we're just talking about putting holes into people, guns win. Substance is better than style.
I'd like to see a Jedi block a phaser set to wide dispersal.
Or a shotgun, for that matter. Jango Fet would be alive today if he'd been packing a twelve gauge.
Dr. Stupid