Made Up Science Facts

sea blue

Mojo said:
And, of course:

* The sky is blue because that's what colour ozone is.

This one came from the Time Out "Health" section (a good place to spot exciting new woo ideas), via Ben Goldacre's bad science column.

Reading the link posted earlier about the "blue" colour of water, why is it odd that ozone is said to have a colour? Water being H20 and all.

The Mediterranean Sea off the coast of Southwest Spain. The sea is vibrant blue because the intrinsic blue color of water is reflected back from the light-colored sand.
(bolding mine)
see: http://webexhibits.org/causesofcolor/5.html

I'm still pretty confused about why the sea is blue.
I can go with the other explanation that the water absorbs red light, leaving blue (and Co.) to get to your eyes, but surely reflection of the sky comes into it too? I've watched patches of blue correspond to patches of sky breaking through the clouds.
 
Vagabond,

You want to give them the highest quality equipment possible. In a situation where swords are cheap, you issue them to all your soldiers. It is just another peice of equipment. You not going to spend money on high-quality swords when you could use that extra money to train, equip, and feed a large number of additional soldiers.
You are making many fallicious assumptions. First of all you are making the assumption that a soldier with a higher quality sword is necessarily any better in combat than one with a lessor sword. Against unarmored or lightly armored opponents it doesn't matter for crap.
Of course it matters. Having your sword break means your dead. Having a sword which is less likely to become fouled (stuck in your enemy) is also a significant combat advantage. Not to mention that a higher quality sword can be lighter, and better balanced.

Probably not a whole lot against heavily armored but the Japanese didn't wear full plate mail like the Europeans did and the ones who did were exceedingly rare.
Armor is hardly even a relevant issue. Swords aren't the ideal weapons to use against heavily armored opponents anyway. The primary issues are how likely the weapon is to break, how fast and maneuverable it is, and how much damage it can inflict.

You make another false assumption when you figure more men is necessarily better. Tell this to Hannibal or Alexander or Ceasar.
I made no such assumption. A small group of highly trained (and well equipped) soldiers can be extremely effective, as can a large group of poorly trained and poorly equipped soldiers. There are pros and cons to both strategies. Cheap steel just tends to favor the large army strategy more than the small elite army strategy.

In Japanese battles in which units would often change sides during the battle, numbers are far less important than loyalty and quality. A smaller outmatched army does not fight it flees. If a smaller army fights it's because they think they can and usually do win anyway. Or they fight a defensive campaign in which numbers don't matter so much.
How is this relevant to my argument?

A peasant with a sword in his hands is no better than a peasant with a hoe in his hands in combat.
This is a gross overstatement.

At least he is familiar with a hoe. Without training a sword is an expensive club and more likely to get you killed than to kill anybody else particularly an armored and trained Samurai.
It doesn't take very much training to get somebody to the point where they can be more effective with a sword than with a club. In fact, for anybody with any kind of fighting experience at all, it shouldn't take more than a few hours. And if you don't think that a dozen peasants with crappy swords and a few weeks training can overwhelm and kill a trained Samurai, then you have been watching too many movies.

A German Tiger tank took 300,000 man hours to make thus they could only make 1300 of them. Quality or quantity doesn't automatically give you an advantage. It might, it might be meaningless.
Again, I do not see how this is relevant to my argument. Are you saying that giving a high-quality sword to a highly trained soldier does not give him an advantage? Are you saying that a dozen ordinary soldiers with crappy swords are not going to be more effective than 11 soldiers with clubs and 1 soldier with a really good sword? Exactly which part of my argument are you disagreeing with?

In war it doesn't matter how much something costs. You pay whatever it is during, confiscate it if they won't give you credit and worry about how much it costs afterward.
This is nonsense. Costs are a huge factor during war.


BronzeDog,

If we're talking about coolness, I'd favor swords. But if we're just talking about putting holes into people, guns win. Substance is better than style.

I'd like to see a Jedi block a phaser set to wide dispersal.
Or a shotgun, for that matter. Jango Fet would be alive today if he'd been packing a twelve gauge.


Dr. Stupid
 
Re: sea blue

Donn said:


I'm still pretty confused about why the sea is blue.
I can go with the other explanation that the water absorbs red light, leaving blue (and Co.) to get to your eyes, but surely reflection of the sky comes into it too? I've watched patches of blue correspond to patches of sky breaking through the clouds.

But in that case couldn't you equally argue that the sky is blue because it's reflecting the sea?

The patches of blue you observe could be explained by the sunlight breaking through the clouds and simply illuminating areas of the sea.
 
Ashles said:
Don't forget:
* An unprotected human in space will

Would a human in space explode? There would be a fairly severe imbalance in pressure. Im quite interested in what would explode and what wouldnt.

If a given human didnt explode, would its cells/organs/etc?

r
 
latsot said:
Would a human in space explode? There would be a fairly severe imbalance in pressure. Im quite interested in what would explode and what wouldnt.

If a given human didnt explode, would its cells/organs/etc?

r

No, apparently a human would not explode although a sudden decompression would rupture capillaries and otherwise damage exposed soft tissue. You would get brain damage due to low oxygen levels before you’d succumb to any sever physical trauma.

There was one account that I read of a man being exposed to near vacuum in a chamber. He reported feeling his saliva boiling before blacking out.

--http://imagine.gsfc.nasa.gov/docs/ask_astro/answers/970603.html
 
The Odd Emperor said:
No, apparently a human would not explode although a sudden decompression would rupture capillaries and otherwise damage exposed soft tissue. You would get brain damage due to low oxygen levels before you’d succumb to any sever physical trauma.


That is really interesting, thanks for this. I find the bit about the dying from low oxygen dubious, but I'll ask around.

Can anyone supply references explaining why people wouldn't explode? I'm a little worried about the 'apparently' and I'm afraid I don't accept what is written on an apparently random web page.

I'm just not convinced either way at the moment.

Cheers

r



There was one account that I read of a man being exposed to near vacuum in a chamber. He reported feeling his saliva boiling before blacking out.

--http://imagine.gsfc.nasa.gov/docs/ask_astro/answers/970603.html
[/QUOTE]
 
Re: Re: sea blue

tkingdoll said:
But in that case couldn't you equally argue that the sky is blue because it's reflecting the sea?

The patches of blue you observe could be explained by the sunlight breaking through the clouds and simply illuminating areas of the sea.

Yeah. I guess 'm good with the absorbs red, reflects blue thing.
What I'm not so sure about is why ozone cannot be "intrinsically" blue, but water can be. I don't understand that web-site that was posted that describes water as having a kind of natural blue colour all it's own!
 
latsot said:
That is really interesting, thanks for this. I find the bit about the dying from low oxygen dubious, but I'll ask around.

Can anyone supply references explaining why people wouldn't explode? I'm a little worried about the 'apparently' and I'm afraid I don't accept what is written on an apparently random web page.

Random? It's part of the NASA portal. How much more informed would you like a source to be?

I'm just not convinced either way at the moment.
I'll admit I'm quite intrigued to find out who you wll be asking about this if you don't consider NASA knowledgeable enough on the subject.

There are also other references on that page. Is there anything wrong with those?

Perhaps it might be better to ask why do you think someone would explode?
 
Re: Re: Re: sea blue

Donn said:
Yeah. I guess 'm good with the absorbs red, reflects blue thing.
What I'm not so sure about is why ozone cannot be "intrinsically" blue, but water can be. I don't understand that web-site that was posted that describes water as having a kind of natural blue colour all it's own!
It's my understanding that absorbing red and reflecting blue is what blue-colored things do, pretty much by definition.
 
latsot said:
That is really interesting, thanks for this. I find the bit about the dying from low oxygen dubious, but I'll ask around.

Can anyone supply references explaining why people wouldn't explode? I'm a little worried about the 'apparently' and I'm afraid I don't accept what is written on an apparently random web page.

I'm just not convinced either way at the moment.

Cheers

r



There was one account that I read of a man being exposed to near vacuum in a chamber. He reported feeling his saliva boiling before blacking out.

--http://imagine.gsfc.nasa.gov/docs/ask_astro/answers/970603.html
[/B][/QUOTE]

Ambiant air pressure is a little over 14 PSI at sea level. 14 PSI is not very much! A diver coming up from a few dozen feet underwater experiences a pressure change much greater than that. Not all at once mind you, if a man were to experience pressure in a deep saturation diving rig and suddenly be taken to the surface he would experience (probably) a hundred times the pressure difference of a man being exposed to vacuum from sea level. I think you might see some physical trauma, ruptured skin and the like. The victim would go into the bends and die very quickly from air bubbles in their bloodstream.

Also remember that on a spacecraft, the pressure would already be somewhat less than 14.6 PSI, around 11 PSI if memory serves me. A person with preparation might survive several minutes in space. Not taking radiation into account.

Arthur Clark wrote a number of short stories about people transitioning between spacecraft without using their suits. One artifact is the space-pod sequence from 2001: A Space Odyssey.

BTW, I’m slightly amused at what you call a random web page. Why do you seem to want people to explode when exposed to vacuum?
 
The Odd Emperor said:
BTW, I’m slightly amused at what you call a random web page. Why do you seem to want people to explode when exposed to vacuum?
I suspect a lot of sci-fi B movies look a lot sillier if you don't believe it.
 
Ashles said:

Random? It's part of the NASA portal. How much more informed would you like a source to be?


I'll admit I'm quite intrigued to find out who you wll be asking about this if you don't consider NASA knowledgeable enough on the subject.

There are also other references on that page. Is there anything wrong with those?

Perhaps it might be better to ask why do you think someone would explode? [/B]

You could ask the writers of ‘Outland’ or ‘Saturn Three.” There were a bunch of movies that got this all wrong. What was that bit in the Disney film ‘Mission to Mars?’ No a person would not explode, they would freeze solid in seconds? (yah right!)

I know I’m forgetting some…
 
The Odd Emperor said:
You could ask the writers of ‘Outland’ or ‘Saturn Three.” There were a bunch of movies that got this all wrong. What was that bit in the Disney film ‘Mission to Mars?’ No a person would not explode, they would freeze solid in seconds? (yah right!)
Ah yes, the film in which highly trained astronauts can't figure out a way to recover their colleague who is just out of reach. Even though they were already moving towards him and actually stopped themselves!

Also isn't it the film in which they look at the planet through a telescope and one of the characters says something like
"There were six of them. But there are only 5 graves - one of them must still be alive!"

Under what circumstances exactly could there have been six graves?
 
Sorry, I have been jumping around 5 Forums, sending messages to James Johnston about digit filtering. I got lost, sorry.

Paul

:) :) :)
 
Ashles said:
Ah yes, the film in which highly trained astronauts can't figure out a way to recover their colleague who is just out of reach. Even though they were already moving towards him and actually stopped themselves!

Also isn't it the film in which they look at the planet through a telescope and one of the characters says something like
"There were six of them. But there are only 5 graves - one of them must still be alive!"

Under what circumstances exactly could there have been six graves?

That wasn’t the worst one but few people picked it up.

OK, the spacecraft is about change delta-v so that they can get into Mars orbit right? Their fuel line explodes, they bail out in their space suits and swim to a nearby *orbiting!!* space habitat (or some such. )

WTF!!!

They never went into orbit! Their relative velocity would be on the order of 2500 MPH! They might see a Mars satellite as it flashes by but if they got skin contact with it they would explode, just like anything with that much kinetic energy.

Sorry, that kind or writing just drives me batty.

The five graves thing is understandable, hell anyone would dig their own grave, climb in and bury themselves alive. What’s the problem with that?
 
Re: sea blue

Donn said:
I'm still pretty confused about why the sea is blue.
I can go with the other explanation that the water absorbs red light, leaving blue (and Co.) to get to your eyes, but surely reflection of the sky comes into it too? I've watched patches of blue correspond to patches of sky breaking through the clouds.
By your thinking, if the sea becomes more blue when the sun shines on it, that should lead you to the opposite conclusion. When the sun's light gets filtered through the atmosphere, direct sunlight is more yellow-colored, the blue having been partially taken away.

Yeah. I guess 'm good with the absorbs red, reflects blue thing. What I'm not so sure about is why ozone cannot be "intrinsically" blue, but water can be.
If something absorbs red but reflects blue (or passes blue light as water does), that's pretty much the definition of what we mean when we say something has a color.

The difference between that, and why the sky is blue, is that the sky doesn't absorb any color. What it does is just scatter the blue portion of light, while letting the red end of the spectrum pass through. When you look up in the sky, the sun will appear a yellowish because its blue light has been stripped away, and the blue takes an indirect path to your eye, so the area not directly towards the sun appears blue. Instead of passing blue light like water does, it passes red light.
 
Scientific American published some misconceptions about the big bang a while back. I remember this one:

"The universe was only three feet in diameter when the Big Bang occurred."

Correction: The observable universe was that size. No telling how much else was there.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom