I almost hope you are a troll - I'd hate to think this is your real personality.
But keep on like this and you will be suspended and/or banned soon. Your attitude is consistently appalling.
My vote is that he's a teenager, used to the shallow attitudes of his fellow teenagers, and thus is considered amongst that crowd (and certainly considers
himself in comparisson), smart... Hey, who didn't think they knew it all at that age, especially if everyone else was out partying, eh? Especially when you realise, as I did at that age too, that you can get by with being seen as intelligent by merely appearing intelligent. Use the right words, and you too can appear wise! And of course, deep down you know you are actually wise, because look how you outwit these idiots...
However, this cannot work forever, even if market forces ensure academic standards slip endlessly lower it seems. For instance, he repeats the time old staple of simplistic history everywhere by reducing issues down to Quantity/Quality... of course, you have to put the rhetorical flourish of "But I'm smarter than that! You have to look at the individual situation too!" on the end to really fool the foolish... You might as well slap a sign on yourself saying "I'm one step above wisdom!"; except, the example he uses is not only directly contradictory to the argument he tries to make later, but the individual example he gives is not even
historically true or even accurate. Which is why he's getting angry perhaps; because now he's being challenged to show that he knows more than just empty platitudes to appear intelligent... and he's not doing very well in that respect.
You see... The historical layman might imagine German tanks as mighty war machines, and the most famous, and therefore the most
German of them all to be the most advanced... And indeed, the argument he gives us is that these tanks were
so advanced, the German's just couldn't build enough of them. You've seen it countless times in pre-University text books, on the Hitlery... I mean History Channel Documentaries For Joe Public, and countless RTS computer game manuals. Futuristic German Tech beaten by mass armies, yes?
Except the Tiger tank
wasn't Quality. It was not only hideously expensive, but it was so heavy and fuel guzzling it had to be moved around by railroad to avoid it collapsing bridges, sinking into soft ground, or wasting precious German fuel. It had slow movement speed, and very slow turret transverse speed... it did have excellent 100mm armor, but it wasn't sloped, because that looked too Russian to Hitler... Where as the Russian T34/85 was cheaper, moved faster and across almost any terrain too, was incredibly easy to build, repair, and operate, had sloped AND thicker armor (110mm)... and on top of which had a big enough gun to punch through the Tiger's army from all angles. And there were loads of them. The Tiger was the
inferior tank. Oh, there
was superior German equipment in a direct unit to unit comparison to
any Allied equivalent. But the Tiger wasn't one of them.
But that's not what you see in amateur history hour. Every German tank is not just a Tiger, but a King Tiger; and they go romping merrily all over Europe and around the shrinking Third Reich, raining destruction like confetti upon the endlessly inferior. But Germany just couldn't build enough of them, apparently, which is why they ultimately lost the War. You hear the same line about the ME-262. the V-2 and so on; Everywhere people want to seem wise about WWII history, but don't actually know any of it, you find them claiming "Well, Germany just didn't have the time to build enough wonder weapons... "
Such arguments however are merely the form, the language of wisdom. When examined deeply, they are no more wise than any other idle gossip of the uninformed.
This was the best bit though; Watching Vagabond try and actually
think instead of repeat the commonly accepted words.
In war it doesn't matter how much something costs. You pay whatever it is during, confiscate it if they won't give you credit and worry about how much it costs afterward.
So here we have the Vagabond theory of Warfare. Resources just spontaneously appear. The only limitation is upon man-hours. Anyone can build anything! So it was merely
time that Germany lacked!
Except... And this is the really chortlesome thing, why didn't Japan have any Tigers? For someone who supposedly knows more Japanese history than everyone here, the abscence of a Japanese Tiger is most unusual. Considering how long Japan was fighting a land war in China, you'd think they'd have one... and the Manchukuo-Mongolian border war with the Soviet Union in 1939 had clearly revealed the appalling inferiority of Japanese armor to Soviet... so they knew if they were going to be fighting a major power, they'd
need one. So where was the Japanese requisitioning for the Tigers then? Hitler was quite happy to give them all sorts of German technology, and would have loved for them to attack the USSR again. So they probably knew
how to build one. But for some reason, they preferred to use the Imperial Japanese Navy to strike south... and didn't requisition a single Tiger at all.
Perhaps... perhaps because they realise requisition just didn't spontaneously appear? That even with all that time, and knowledge, building Tigers wasn't an option?
Perhaps it was the same reason why they invaded Manchuria in the first place, and had an early attempt to take Mongolia?
Perhaps for the same reason why they fought against Russia in 1905?
For the same reason that the Imperial Court became such anglo-philes decades before that perhaps?
For the very same reason, swords were highly expensive, and weren't just "requisitioned" in the Feudal period perchance?
Could it be that our historical master is somehow ignorant of the fact that
Japan is notoriously bare of most of the resources for heavy industry, steel included? And that it doesn't matter how much you beat up the peasants if they simply don't have that much steel to give you in the first place?
Could the wise one be unaware that his mediatitions on the Japanese perception of swords is completely ridiculous when he doesn't realise that most of Japanese history has been a constant attempt to use the few swords they actually could build as effectively as possible to gain access to more sword building? That swords, in Japan, are NOT just a matter of time?
Or, for that matter, that cod-wisdom on German tank production, on the Quality/Quantity cliché, just makes you look very, very silly indeed when you don't even know which German weapons were superior? And someone with merely the slightest inclining that you are wrong can google up the relevant facts?
But hopefully these display's of temper, when his own arrogance and ignorance are shown up, is just another sign of his immaturity; admittedly, there are rather a lot of them... I recognised his name from where I've come across him before, trying to argue against the existance of extra-solar system planets here...
http://www.randi.org/vbulletin/show...366&perpage=40&highlight=planets&pagenumber=1
Oh, and evolutionary theory too, which was the original topic. But hey, as I said, we all thought we knew best once... Some of us
never stop believing that, thus our immaturity is proven therefore. But still, let's try and be a little understanding, shall we? Normally during life's education processes, Vagabond wouldn't be meeting people who would challenge his simplistic understandings and posturings until his mind, and more importantly, his self confidence and maturity level, were able to adapt to deeper and more detailed thinking; at the risk of choking on my own cynicism, he'd not be arguing at this level until at least University level, say. Instead however, like everyone with access to the internet, he's found the entire world suddenly right there with him... and for some people that's just too much... or far too soon. I'd tend to say, it's probably too soon in his case.
But just to leave this reply as something more than just a focus on one person; This is for you JMercer...! Water is blue eh? EH? Not around here it's not! Observe the heavenly waters off Brighton Pier... and this is on a GOOD day!
Admittedly, there's probably a lot more than just water in there; when I was last at that spot, it was almost a flourescent green, and not the poetical green and pleasant kind either...