Made Up Science Facts

new drkitten said:

Melting down an old sword will largely destroy the carbon balance (as well as the crystal structure); the metal resulting from that wouldn't work well as any part of a new sword.



Again, no. Only if the steel you got from melting down swords was a useful kind.

I saw a documentary about recycling recently, and it said that metal recycling is something that's been going on since metalworking has existed.

Granted, the metal is not always used in the same way it was originally -- swords could be literally made into plowshares, for instance. In the early days, though, any refined metal was extremely valuable.

One statement that stuck in my mind is that old battlefields dug up by archeologists tend to be completely devoid of metal. Almost as soon as the battle is over, civilians would sweep over the dead bodies and take anything of value, especially metal, and adapt it to different uses.
 
jmercer said:

So the steel of a broken blade - while probably useful for other things, perhaps even other weapons - wouldn't likely meet the standard for a "new" blade.

I think it's a telling point that when old ships are broken up for scrap metal in India, the metal is not used to make new ships, but to make rebar for building -- probably the most unglamorous use of steel there is. It seems that entropy takes it's toll on alloys as they are recycled again and again.
 
aggle-rithm said:
I saw a documentary about recycling recently, and it said that metal recycling is something that's been going on since metalworking has existed.

Granted, the metal is not always used in the same way it was originally -- swords could be literally made into plowshares, for instance. In the early days, though, any refined metal was extremely valuable.

One statement that stuck in my mind is that old battlefields dug up by archeologists tend to be completely devoid of metal. Almost as soon as the battle is over, civilians would sweep over the dead bodies and take anything of value, especially metal, and adapt it to different uses.

Key phrases highlighted in the above.

Yes, sword steel was still valuable -- just as (used) printer paper is still valuable, but not for the original purpose. Used printer paper can be recycled to make newsprint, or similar "low quality" papers -- but the processing process for making paper will invariably break the paper fibers, so you end up with much cheaper paper than you put in.

Similarly, sword steel could be melted down and applied to other purposes; for example, a spear-head doesn't typically need the same high degree of flexibility or sharpness that a sword blade does. (A spear head will typically not be used for parrying, so it won't be subjected to the same amount of flexion --- and it's also typically used almost purely for thrusting, with enough muscle behind it that it will work just as well even if it's not honed to a razor edge.) Plowshares are another typical -- indeed, even "classical" -- application where the steel requirements aren't as rigorous. One could even make steel cooking pots if one wanted, but the price/value of steel in Japan was high enough that those were almost never made.

However, it was very difficult to make swords from melted/recycled sword steel, for the reasons of the carbon balance detailed above.
 
Vagabond said:
You, um, don't know much Japanese history, do you?<<<<

First of all that is not an arguement unless you are an idiot. Secondly, there is no doubt whatsoever I know far more Japanese history than you do.

I think they meant real history...like how the Japanese swords were made, who they learned it from, where the swordmakers got their material from, how much was accessible, what was done with broken blades, how the Japanese conducted combat, and so forth.
 
Vagabond said:
I am not an expert on sword smelting and it is obvious neither are either of you. Your just talking out your asses to no purpose.

While I myself am not an expert in the true sense of the word, I have had direct access to many real experts, both on the history of sword-forging and contemporary smiths. I am, as I stated, somewhat of a fanatic on swords; I use swords in my arts, and have always required as much historical realism combined with high quality in my swords as possible. I am not rich; therefore, every sword I have ever acquired has been an investment to me, and not simply a purchase.

As a result, I have had many face-to-face discussions with experts; phone conversations; written correspondence; etc., about the science and art of forging metal. I have studied the subject with a great deal of seriousness, and I can tell you the difference between various carbon steels, their characteristics, shortcoming, and so forth. I can tell you the difference between starting a sword from bar stock; pouring into a clay mold; and welding bar. I can tell you how folding steel can affect the character of the metal; I can tell you how additional carbon is introduced; what quenching does (saltwater versus fresh, in fact), and a host of other details that I will spare the rest of us from reading.

So while I am not an expert on steel smelting, I am informed and knowledgeable on the subject. What I stated is exactly correct.
 
crimresearch said:
I think they meant real history...like how the Japanese swords were made, who they learned it from, where the swordmakers got their material from, how much was accessible, what was done with broken blades, how the Japanese conducted combat, and so forth.

Thanks Crim, I am already well aware of your overt stupidity, so anybody you agree with I can safely disagree with. Also I seriously doubt anybody wants you to back them up on anything.
 
So while I am not an expert on steel smelting, I am informed and knowledgeable on the subject. What I stated is exactly correct.<<<<

No, at best you MIGHT be correct. It would depend on how you were going to use the steel. Like I said I am not an expert but I see no reason why metal forged together cannot be unforged. It might be more difficult but not impossible. Also what would be the purpose of melting down swords to make more swords? I never said that, I meant using them for other metal goods for which the content wouldn't matter so much.
 
Vagabond said:
Thanks Crim, I am already well aware of your overt stupidity, so anybody you agree with I can safely disagree with. Also I seriously doubt anybody wants you to back them up on anything.

So, basically, you have no evidence to support your opinions about swordmaking, steel smelting, or the tactics used (and the role of untrained peasant levies) in Japanese history, and instead resort to abuse and insult.

Well, I must say that that's probably a very effective and convincing discussion technique.

.... in the same world in which "Hannibal or Alexander or Ceasar" are representative examples of Japanese generals or warlords.
 
Vagabond said:

I see no reason why metal forged together cannot be unforged.

Ignorance on your part does not constitute evidence on ours.



. Also what would be the purpose of melting down swords to make more swords? I never said that,

Didn't you?

roken or damaged swords do not cease to exist. They can be re-melted and remade.
 
Ignorance on your part does not constitute evidence on ours.<<<<

As with most idiots you need to take your own advice far more than anybody you give it to. Save it you can't insult me because I already hold your opinion in no regard whatsoever.
 
new drkitten said:
So, basically, you have no evidence to support your opinions about swordmaking, steel smelting, or the tactics used (and the role of untrained peasant levies) in Japanese history, and instead resort to abuse and insult.

Well, I must say that that's probably a very effective and convincing discussion technique.

.... in the same world in which "Hannibal or Alexander or Ceasar" are representative examples of Japanese generals or warlords.

Another pathetic housewife with no life pretending she has some intellect. Bait me some more troll, I have better things to do than argue with your childish ass. Another possible interesting discussion crushed by brute morondom.
 
"...Save it you can't insult me because I already hold your opinion in no regard whatsoever."

Which oddly enough, is the same regard you seem have for facts and reality.

Allergy, or choice?
 
Vagabond said:
Another pathetic housewife with no life pretending she has some intellect.

Perhaps. Of course, if I were actually wrong, you could cite evidence to disprove a single thing I said.

Another possible interesting discussion crushed...

Yeah. It's a pity.

Of course, it would be interesting indeed if there were a single statement I made in the course of this discussion that you could actually discuss with contrary evidence. You've only got the entire Internet at your disposal as a research tool, plus whatever you can dig out of the local college library.
 
Sorry to interrupt, since I haven't gone all the way back and caught up on this thread.

Anyhow, if someone has a specific question regarding metallurgy, I'd be glad to run it by someone at work, as I work with some of the most knowledgable metallurgists in the US.

I'd rather do that than see y'all bickering.
 
Vagabond said:
Another pathetic housewife with no life pretending she has some intellect. Bait me some more troll, I have better things to do than argue with your childish ass. Another possible interesting discussion crushed by brute morondom.

I don't know why you're being belligerant, but it's the wrong attitude to have around here. Disagree if you like, but don't be a jerk. This ain't AOL or Slashdot, so cool it.

As it happens, there are LOTS of materials that cannot be easily recycled or reused for the original purpose. It has to do with molecular structure... Not everything can just be melted down and reformed.

It sounds like jmercer knows her stuff... so unless you can refute specific claims, you'd best be quiet.
 
Vagabond said:
Another pathetic housewife with no life pretending she has some intellect. Bait me some more troll, I have better things to do than argue with your childish ass. Another possible interesting discussion crushed by brute morondom.
Vagabond, can you tell me, please, what provoked you to write this? :confused:
 
Vagabond said:
Another pathetic housewife with no life pretending she has some intellect.

You've got a little bigot in your argument there, chief. Uncalled for. Totally uncalled for.
 
El_Spectre said:
It sounds like jmercer knows her stuff... so unless you can refute specific claims, you'd best be quiet.

Just a nit... but it's "knows his stuff..." ;)
 
jmercer said:
Just a nit... but it's "knows his stuff..." ;)

Damn, sorry... thought I remembered from an earlier thread...

I don't know too many women who are into swords, come to think of it...
 
They are called kitchen knifes, so watch your back.

By the way, I do most of the cooking in my house.

Paul

:) :) :)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom