Lily the Muppet Loves Free Food

Teen girls have told me that's their goal, have a kid and get welfare so they can be "independent."

Well I'll be darned. Are you saying that you've met a stupid teenager? Well, there goes my whole argument that there are in fact people in need of help feeding their families. Can you provide evidence that the percentage of people who behave in this manor is large enough to justify cutting benefits, or evidence that cutting these benefits would reduce te number of single mothers out there?

Just to give you an idea of where I'm coming from, here are some stats from Canada regarding the percentage of single parent families.
http://www4.hrsdc.gc.ca/[email protected]?iid=37
Keep in mind that there are higher benefits in Canada than the US, and thus, by your logic, a higher incentive for women to have babies to get on welfare.

Let's see how it compares to these stats for the US
http://www.prb.org/pdf10/single-motherfamilies.pdf
 
Last edited:
You see it in Black Markets because Black Markets are illegal. Happens rarely for very long in a legal free market. Somebody always comes up with a better mouse trap at a cheaper price. End the War on Drugs, for example, and "weed" would cost about what a weed should cost -- next to nothing.

Oh good. This kind of tatic only happens with black market operations and nobody in the free market ever breaks the rules? Nick Leeson, did nothing illegal? Robert Maxwell? Enron? There is no insider trading, price fixing, or anything else?

Sure... it must all be "Government intervention" right? Pesky governments intervening to allow and sustain monopolies. That must be why questions are being asked about the market dominance and practices of News International... the government!
 
Example? Monopolies generally can only exist with government involvement. Back in the day, I can remember Milton Friedman addressing this shibboleth and he could only cite the De Beers Intl. Diamond Cartel. Here he adds the NY Stock Exchange. But other than that, none that ever last, if there is freedom, including Free Trade. Professor Friedman explains it all for you here:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tdLBzfFGFQU

HAHAHAHAHA

the same man who ADVOCATED monopolies because he thinks they are a sound business practice!


HAHAHAHAHA
 
Yeah, well that one man's coat tails brought in the dregs of humanity in the congress causing tremendous damage to the economy, which not even the 2010 Tea Party success can undo till the next election.

Gosh a mighty, do you have any real statements or just talking points... coat tails work both ways and it was GWB that ruined the economy and Obama what brought in the republicans to the HoR...
 
And people promoting it are made to look even stupider by recent revelations that teen pregnancies are at RECORD lows. Lower than at any time in the 70 years records have been kept.

It would probably be even lower if the bible thumping prudes would stop attacking sex ed & PP. Sex exists, hand out condoms and deal with it.
 
Many single women have babies because Uncle Sugar pays her to have babies.
Teen girls have told me that's their goal, have a kid and get welfare so they can be "independent."


Let's assume for the moment (and it's a big assumption) that your claim is true. What is one to make of the fact that the rate of teenage births is much higher in the U.S. than it is in the other developed OECD countries that have more extensive social welfare systems? Shouldn't it be the other way around? Shouldn't those European countries, with all that socialized medicine and social welfare benefits, have higher rates of teenage births than the U.S.?
 
Shouldn't those European countries, with all that socialized medicine and social welfare benefits, have higher rates of teenage births than the U.S.?
This is especially ironic given the openness of the sex trade, the availability of porn and the loose sexual mores of some countries, like Germany and France.
 
This is especially ironic given the openness of the sex trade, the availability of porn and the loose sexual mores of some countries, like Germany and France.

If the right wing see single mothers as a bad thing, why are right wing groups so supportive of anti-abortion and anti-sex education groups? Surely educating young men and women so they can make informed choices and do something about unplanned pregnancies would reduce the rate of teen births?
 
Let's assume for the moment (and it's a big assumption) that your claim is true. What is one to make of the fact that the rate of teenage births is much higher in the U.S. than it is in the other developed OECD countries that have more extensive social welfare systems? Shouldn't it be the other way around? Shouldn't those European countries, with all that socialized medicine and social welfare benefits, have higher rates of teenage births than the U.S.?

Post hoc ergo propter hoc fallacy.
 
That would only be correct if those facts were used to argue that the additional welfare benefits CAUSED a slowdown of teenage births.

Instead, the argument is that your predicted correlation failed to appear.
 
Gosh a mighty, do you have any real statements or just talking points... coat tails work both ways and it was GWB that ruined the economy and Obama what brought in the republicans to the HoR...

History of America's economic demise -- The Slippery Slope: G.H. (Read My Lips) Bush begot (Slickster) Clinton. Clinton begot RINO G.W. Bush. G.W. Bush begot Marxist Obama. Obama begot worst depression since Socialist FDR.
 
Teen girls have told me that's their goal, have a kid and get welfare so they can be "independent."

So teen girls told this you, really? What do you do, hang around high schools and just go up and start talking to teenagers?
 
Post hoc ergo propter hoc fallacy.
Horse feathers.

Kids who go through ignorance-only sex education have a higher pregnancy and STD rate.

Clear causal relationship.

Friedman's pile of cow flops remains unproven.

You are not reasoning logically, or even on facts.
 
History of America's economic demise -- The Slippery Slope: G.H. (Read My Lips) Bush begot (Slickster) Clinton. Clinton begot RINO G.W. Bush. G.W. Bush begot Marxist Obama. Obama begot worst depression since Socialist FDR.

A few questions for you. Easy ones first.

-When did the 2007 recession begin?
-When did Obama take office?
-When did the Great Depression begin?
-When did Roosevelt take office?

Essay Questions (harder):

Describe Obama's Marxist policies, and cite their basis in Marx's works.

Contrast Obama's Marxist policies against FDR's Socialist policies.

You might want to get some facts straight before you start giving history lessons.
 
Last edited:
History of America's economic demise -- The Slippery Slope: G.H. (Read My Lips) Bush begot (Slickster) Clinton. Clinton begot RINO G.W. Bush. G.W. Bush begot Marxist Obama. Obama begot worst depression since Socialist FDR.
Cow cookies. The idiot who became POTUS in 1981 cut everybody's taxes and bathed the budgety in red ink, and Bush the Geezer tried the idiotic remedy of budget cuts and piddling tax increases. Clinton started turning things around, and the Bush the Lesser dumped a whole tool box full of spanners into the works of government so that everything siezed up just before Obama got elected.

I wish Obama were another FDR and had told the rightwing whackos to shut up and pass his bills from day one so that he could cleanse the government of the pile of crap that Bush the Lesser left him.

The turnover in the House in 2010 is just what you get for playing nice with sociopaths and dimwits.
 
When asked for evidence that teens get pregnant to get government money, RP replies

Teen girls have told me that's their goal, have a kid and get welfare so they can be "independent." <snip>
I must say I am completely baffled for a response. Of course, it is idiotic on a skeptics board. But it gets worse. No adult of any political persuasion would offer this up as a serious response. So is RP mentally impaired? Is RP some high school kid(s) seeing how outrageous then can get? Is this level of discourse intentionally bad or is someone trying going for low humor? I think simple troll is, well, too simplistic an answer but maybe Occam says it should be considered.

The issue for me is whether to continue to react to his views or to just let him have free rein and sit back in stunned wonderment. As stated, I really am baffled.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom