Lily the Muppet Loves Free Food

Who says anything about absence of government? Governments are supposed to exist to preserve the freedom and liberty of its citizens. That means allowing freedom in business to flourish, and to prosecute those who would deny that freedom to others.

Whuh-? How does this in any way answer the question? The question was:
In the absence of government and law enforcement what would stop unethical entrepreneurs from simply killing their competition to create a monopoly?
Instead of answering what would stop a monopoly resorting to absoulte means in the absence of government you talk about what you think a government is for.

Is there any chance of actually answering the question? It does have a direct implication on your earlier statement that Government Interjection is a requirement of a monopoly.
 
Wow. Talk about naivete. Many single women have babies because Uncle Sugar pays her to have babies.

You know this how?

I have extensive experience with people in non-advantageous economic situations. I have never, ever encountered this either first hand or by rumor. In fact the only place I ever hear about it is in right wing echo chambers.

So maybe you can be the first one to actually provide some evidence that this happens?
 
Wow. Talk about naivete. Many single women have babies because Uncle Sugar pays her to have babies.

Please provide some kind of evidence for this statement.

Failing that, could you provide evidence that the $ amount of social benefits received by a single mother from the government is greater then the cost of raising that child?
 
The closest to the truth this claim comes in my own experience is knowing at least one person that seems not to be worried about birth control because they know that other people (either family or the state) will do the financial heavy lifting.

I could understand this being an issue for a non-trivial part of the population.
 

Teen girls have told me that's their goal, have a kid and get welfare so they can be "independent."

and

"In fact, the number of children born to single mothers is on the rise and has been since the 1960s. In 1964, fewer than 10 percent of babies were born to single mothers. Today that number is above 40 percent for the overall population and even higher among Hispanics and African Americans (50 and 70 percent, respectively)...

Women in low-income communities desire to have children and do so, yet fathers quickly drop out of the picture. To these women and men, marriage is regarded as a middle-class institution, something to enter into only when a couple has made it financially and proven that their relationship will last. Of course, having a baby as a low-educated, single woman is more likely to lead to a life of poverty and welfare dependency than to reaching any level of affluence and building a stable family."

http://blog.heritage.org/2010/12/22/fewer-teen-moms-but-more-babies-born-to-single-moms-than-ever/
 
You claimed that government was a requirement for monopoly creation, clearly that is false. In the absence of government and law enforcement what would stop unethical entrepreneurs from simply killing their competition to create a monopoly? We do see this happen in real life black markets. Your claim is absurd.

You see it in Black Markets because Black Markets are illegal. Happens rarely for very long in a legal free market. Somebody always comes up with a better mouse trap at a cheaper price. End the War on Drugs, for example, and "weed" would cost about what a weed should cost -- next to nothing.
 
Teen girls have told me that's their goal, have a kid and get welfare so they can be "independent."
Well, you gotta admit that's some rock solid scientific data. Not subject to confirmation bias, not anecdotal and it can be replicated. Good job. Still, I call BS.

"In fact, the number of children born to single mothers is on the rise and has been since the 1960s. In 1964, fewer than 10 percent of babies were born to single mothers. Today that number is above 40 percent for the overall population and even higher among Hispanics and African Americans (50 and 70 percent, respectively)...

Women in low-income communities desire to have children and do so, yet fathers quickly drop out of the picture. To these women and men, marriage is regarded as a middle-class institution, something to enter into only when a couple has made it financially and proven that their relationship will last. Of course, having a baby as a low-educated, single woman is more likely to lead to a life of poverty and welfare dependency than to reaching any level of affluence and building a stable family."
http://blog.heritage.org/2010/12/22/fewer-teen-moms-but-more-babies-born-to-single-moms-than-ever/Poor people have more babies period. Through out the world this holds true. It tells us absolutely zero about your claim.

Source?
 
Robert (ignoring the hilariously poor sampling methods), what does this:
Teen girls have told me that's their goal, have a kid and get welfare so they can be "independent."

Have to do with this:
"In fact, the number of children born to single mothers is on the rise and has been since the 1960s. In 1964, fewer than 10 percent of babies were born to single mothers. Today that number is above 40 percent for the overall population and even higher among Hispanics and African Americans (50 and 70 percent, respectively)...

Women in low-income communities desire to have children and do so, yet fathers quickly drop out of the picture. To these women and men, marriage is regarded as a middle-class institution, something to enter into only when a couple has made it financially and proven that their relationship will last. Of course, having a baby as a low-educated, single woman is more likely to lead to a life of poverty and welfare dependency than to reaching any level of affluence and building a stable family."
???

Is this another case of a reading comprehension failure? Do you just read things and pretend they agree with what you've already come up with in whatever universe you live in?
 
Last edited:
Who wants to bet that the number of "teen girls" RP has actually talked to in person is around 0.
 
Nope, I've got insurance against loss of earnings either due to illness or loss of contracts.

OK. I have had something like this in the past through my employer (long-term disability insurance). Mine would have paid around 70% of my earnings until age 65. But I've never heard about insurance for "loss of contracts?" Why wouldn't everyone start a business just to buy this fabulous insurance? How does this work?

How much did your policy cost, and how much of your salary will it pay for how long?
 
Nope, I've got insurance against loss of earnings either due to illness or loss of contracts.

OK. I have had something like this in the past through my employer (long-term disability insurance). Mine would have paid around 70% of my earnings until age 65. But I've never heard about insurance for "loss of contracts?" Why wouldn't everyone start a business just to buy this fabulous insurance? How does this work?

How much did your policy cost, and how much of your salary will it pay for how long?
Damn, I lost a 7 year contract 2 years ago. I would have loved to have had that windfall. I might have lost it earlier. ;)
 
Not at all. But I do loath liars, looters, con men, bureaucrats, thieves, professional povertarians and persons who say, "I'm from the government and I'm here to help you."

So what about all those commercial rigs on the highway and all those cars?

i have asked you this before, why should THAT be subsidized, why should THAT be payed for out of general revenues, doubling the gas tax would cover what the highways actaually cost.

So what about that Robert, hmmm.
Do you support that free hand out?

That is robbing from every person who pays income tax but doesn't drive a car or a commericial rig.
 
If you haven't saved enough you couldnt afford kids. If you can't afford them don't have them.

Tell you what, why don't we just sterilize everybody, and then you can only have a child if you earn enough to pay for the surgery to reverse it. Then you can have your Utopia in which people can always afford children when they have them.
 
There is only one purpose for a business, namely, to make as much money as possible. In a free unfettered market, that means marketing the very best product at the lowest possible price.
Except all those products that are dangerous and toxic and the free market does nothing about.

So you are not a real libertarians but just a feel good one. For years people made products that killed and maimed the customer, why did the free market not address that.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom