Kinetic energy at atmospheric reentry from lunar mission

We call the form "Modern" dance at the ballet school. The difference between Modern and Jazz dance forms from a dad's perspective, is that Modern spends time on the floor getting costumes dirty and Jazz doesn't.

Not a choreographer, but I could work with one to develop this piece. The dancers that are the air never actually touch the dancers that are the CM, because the ablative shield dancers are in the way. It's totally doable.
 
"Apollo re-entry: The musical" is born!

We need songs - Jumping Jack Flash it's an ablating gas!
 
Ablation! Ablation! That's what keeps you cool,
If you can't see this you're some sort of fool.
[With apologies to Tom Lehrer.]
 
Ablative heat shields work because the ablation at lower temperatures as the shockwave begins to form creates a layer of cooler gas that protects them from the shockwave temperatures.


Among the functions of the ablative heat shield is to generate a coolant fluid to carry away heat. Decomposition of the shield material isn't the entire energy budget. It's just one stage in the process of shedding the incoming heat. The gasses generated by decomposition absorb heat from the shockwave and carry them away, hotter than they were when cooked off.


How could ~ 100 kg = 2p1 kg of such a "coolant fluid" vaporizing already at a relatively low temperature be responsible for carrying away relevant parts of total reentry heat which is ~ 300 Gigajoule = 11p3 Joule? Gases emerging at a rather low temperature from such a coolant fluid cannot have a relevant cooling effect, since heat capacity of gases cannot be high enough.

How should such gases protect the heat shield? They are rapidly heated by a continuous high-speed bombardment with atmospheric particles. Imagine concretely these magic gas particles in front of the heat shield being bombarded by atmospheric particles! (#308, #336)

If we do not believe in miracles then such a decomposing "cooling fluid" also cannot absorb relevantly more energy by breaking apart or by ionizing than normal (parts of) atmospheric molecules.

On the other hand, low vaporization temperature of such a coolant fluid has a serious drawback: It reduces working temperature of the heat shield, relevant to radiative cooling. A heat shield of 3500°K = 5 ∙ 700°K radiates away 5 ∙ 5 ∙ 5 ∙ 5 = 625 times more energy than an analogous heat shield of only 700°K. (#403)

The NASA movie Apollo 4: The first flight of a Saturn V launch vehicle claims (at 4:42) that the reentering spacecraft was "cooling as it climbed back towards space" after a first heating phase. According Figure 7c of NASA TN D5399: Entry aerodynamics at lunar return conditions obtained from the flight of Apollo 4, deceleration was around 0.3 g ≈ 3 m/s2 during cooling maximum (deceleration minimum) at t ≈ 30240 sec. According to Figure 7b, "Earth relative velocity" at t ≈ 30240 was ~ 22000 ft/s = 6.6 km/s = 3p66 m/s. Thus, heating power due to deceleration results in as much as P = E / t = F ∙ s / t = m ∙ a ∙ s/t = m ∙ a ∙ v ≈ 3p54 kg ∙ 3 m/s2 ∙ 3p66 m/s ≈ 8p1 kg m2/s3 = 8p1 Watt = 100 Megajoule/sec even during so-called "cooling" maximum.

Since vaporization of the heat-shield epoxy AVCOAT 5026-39 could have absorbed maximally ~ 7p6 Watt-second = 60 Megajoule (#471), this coolant fluid could not even have absorbed the heat emerging during only one second of the "cooling phase".
Momentum-change per second during this "cooling phase" is p = m ∙ a ∙ t ≈ 5400 kg ∙ 3 m/s. From a spacecraft speed of ~ 6600 m/s relative to the atmosphere we can calculate* an atmospheric mass of 5400 kg ∙ 3/6600 ≈ 2.5 kg = 0p25 kg bombarding every second the "protective layer" of the heat shield with a speed of ~ 3p66 m/s = 6600 m/s ≈ 24000 km/h ≈ 11000 mph.

* Simplifying assumption: Via inelastic collision, atmospheric mass is accelerated to speed of decelerating spacecraft. Then atmospheric mass leaves region before heat shield laterally, i.e. without influencing spacecraft momentum.

Thus, the assumption that gas particles stemming from ~ 100 kg of a magic coolant fluid (vaporizing during ~ 600 sec deceleration time) can somehow create a protective layer between heat shield and atmospheric bombardment, cannot be much more than wishful thinking resp. disinformation.

See also other thread: Simulation of lunar gravity on Earth

Cheers, Wolfgang
All my previous posts of this thread
Declaring to have debunked is not the same as debunking
 
Last edited:
Why are you relying on your fictional school of maths to prove something didn't happen when the videos you post show that it did?

See also your other thread, where your other nonsense is also disposed of.

Declaring something is fake is not the same as it being fake.
 
How should such gases protect the heat shield?

Such gasses and their heat transfer properties via all modes, not just the few you consider, are part of an overall heat shield design that is both far more sophisticated and far more effective than your high-school level model suggests. This has been explained to several times, but you are unwilling to let go of the premise that you already know it all so that you can absorb it.
 
Meteors either burn up (almost) entirely, or they or their fragments still have huge kinetic energy per mass when reaching surface.

That's not true at all. Most meteorites that reach the surface do so by falling at terminal velocity, not with "huge kinetic energy". They don't hit any harder than they would if you tossed them off a tall building.


My statement of #44 may be prone to misunderstanding, but what I wanted to say is that on average only quite small mass portions of meteors reach the Earth' surface with "terminal velocity".

Collectable meteorites are the result of selection. Meteors and parts of disintegrating meteors or asteroids normally do not become collectable meteorites if they still have "huge kinetic energy" at impact. They get destroyed instead.

Small pieces entering the atmosphere mostly vaporize. They arrive with at least terrestrial escape velocity of 11.2 km/s = 4p112 m/s and therefore with a kinetic energy of at least ½ v ∙ v ≈ 9n5 ∙ 4p112 m/s ∙ 4p112 m/s ≈ 7p63 Joule/kg = 63 MJ/kg. For comparison, vaporization energy of iron is only 6p609 Joule/kg = 6.09 MJ/kg.

The Chelyabinsk meteor of 2013 is probably the best documented meteoritic impact. Total known weight (TKW) of all collected pieces is approximately 1000 kg = 3p1 kg. Yet initial mass is estimated to be more than 10000 metric tonnes = 7p1 kg. Thus initial mass is around four decimal powers = 4p1 times higher than collected mass.

This example clearly shows: The assumption that collectable meteorites are representative of the initial objects entering the atmosphere is simply wrong. The by far biggest mass portion of the Chelyabinsk meteorite dissolved into a thermal debris cloud.


As to meteorites: it depends on the size, of course, but the average pea sized meteorite one might collect probably had a terminal velocity of 200 mph or somewhat higher at impact As noted by phunk above, the same speed as if someone threw it off of a tall building (terminal velocity, right?). Essentially the same speed as the Apollo capsule after its atmospheric braking and just prior to the release of its drogue parachutes (200 to 300 mph). So they both shed most of their velocity through atmospheric braking, released as heat.

But I am not really certain what your overall point is here. My point was that objects traveling much, much faster than Apollo when they enter the atmosphere can reach the Earth's surface without being destroyed, even in the absence of the many engineering and tactical solutions that were employed in Apollo to control the effects of the re-entry and to ensure the safety of the crew.


I hope you are unprejudiced and intelligent enough to understand now.

In any case, you were right insofar as Apollo's reentry would have been quite similar to a normal meteor (suffering substantial vaporization and disintegration) due to its flimsy heat shield (#471, #487)).

Cheers, Wolfgang

All my posts of this thread (dealing with all serious counter-arguments)
 
They get destroyed instead.

And as I've mentioned several times, our understanding of why that happens, developed in the 1950s, is the basis of our entry heat shielding designs today, which are a combination of an accurate understanding of the problem dynamics and a synergistic multi-discipline approach to the engineering.

The astronomy paper I speak of is widely known. You don't know about it. Just like you pontificated at length about Apollo photography without really knowing much about it. Further, you don't seem to know much about how heat shields are actually built and how they actually work. You keep relying upon a simplistic model that relies upon correct individual principles of physics but grossly misses how they can be used together to achieve a result that is greater than the sum of the individually-considered parts. You're going to have a very hard time convincing people here -- many of whom have actual qualifications in the relevant sciences -- that you're coming at this issue from a position of knowledge and authority.

I hope you are unprejudiced and intelligent enough to understand now.

No, the reason your critics do not agree with you is not because they are biased and stupid.
 
My statement of #44 may be prone to misunderstanding, but what I wanted to say is that on average only quite small mass portions of meteors reach the Earth' surface with "terminal velocity".
That's flat out odd. By definition, all meteors must reach earth with terminal velocity much like skydivers, who must also reach terminal velocity, or a rock you toss in the air which must also reach terminal velocity.

Take a coin out of your pocket and drop it. It will have a terminal velocity. Somehow, you cannot figure that out.

Collectable meteorites are the result of selection. Meteors and parts of disintegrating meteors or asteroids normally do not become collectable meteorites if they still have "huge kinetic energy" at impact. They get destroyed instead.
OK That is utter bollocks. Google Murchison for example. We know straight out of the box that this is untrue.

Small pieces entering the atmosphere mostly vaporize. They arrive with at least terrestrial escape velocity of 11.2 km/s = 4p112 m/s and therefore with a kinetic energy of at least ½ v ∙ v ≈ 9n5 ∙ 4p112 m/s ∙ 4p112 m/s ≈ 7p63 Joule/kg = 63 MJ/kg. For comparison, vaporization energy of iron is only 6p609 Joule/kg = 6.09 MJ/kg.
I can't be bothered unpicking your math nonsense which is likely wrong as we have demonstrated. You have provided no reason for anyone to care.

The Chelyabinsk meteor of 2013 is probably the best documented meteoritic impact. Total known weight (TKW) of all collected pieces is approximately 1000 kg = 3p1 kg. Yet initial mass is estimated to be more than 10000 metric tonnes = 7p1 kg. Thus initial mass is around four decimal powers = 4p1 times higher than collected mass.
Horribly wrong.

This example clearly shows: The assumption that collectable meteorites are representative of the initial objects entering the atmosphere is simply wrong. The by far biggest mass portion of the Chelyabinsk meteorite dissolved into a thermal debris cloud.
If you choose to be incoherent, that is your choice. There is not much anyone can do about it.

I hope you are unprejudiced and intelligent enough to understand now.
Yay. You want to just wheel out gross insult. Don't do that.

In any case, you were right insofar as Apollo's reentry would have been quite similar to a normal meteor (suffering substantial vaporization and disintegration) due to its flimsy heat shield (#471, #487)).

Cheers, Wolfgang

Nope. Still abjectly wrong. I have no idea why it is that you are unable to work out basic physics, all I know for sure is that you cannot.
 
My statement of #44 may be prone to misunderstanding, but what I wanted to say is that on average only quite small mass portions of meteors reach the Earth' surface with "terminal velocity".

Collectable meteorites are the result of selection. Meteors and parts of disintegrating meteors or asteroids normally do not become collectable meteorites if they still have "huge kinetic energy" at impact. They get destroyed instead.

Small pieces entering the atmosphere mostly vaporize. They arrive with at least terrestrial escape velocity of 11.2 km/s = 4p112 m/s and therefore with a kinetic energy of at least ½ v ∙ v ≈ 9n5 ∙ 4p112 m/s ∙ 4p112 m/s ≈ 7p63 Joule/kg = 63 MJ/kg. For comparison, vaporization energy of iron is only 6p609 Joule/kg = 6.09 MJ/kg.

The Chelyabinsk meteor of 2013 is probably the best documented meteoritic impact. Total known weight (TKW) of all collected pieces is approximately 1000 kg = 3p1 kg. Yet initial mass is estimated to be more than 10000 metric tonnes = 7p1 kg. Thus initial mass is around four decimal powers = 4p1 times higher than collected mass.

This example clearly shows: The assumption that collectable meteorites are representative of the initial objects entering the atmosphere is simply wrong. The by far biggest mass portion of the Chelyabinsk meteorite dissolved into a thermal debris cloud.





I hope you are unprejudiced and intelligent enough to understand now.
In any case, you were right insofar as Apollo's reentry would have been quite similar to a normal meteor (suffering substantial vaporization and disintegration) due to its flimsy heat shield (#471, #487)).

Cheers, Wolfgang

All my posts of this thread (dealing with all serious counter-arguments)
I still and fully understand that your arguments are conflating very different things and distort or deny the actual physics and facts in egregious ways. As the more detailed rebuttals by other posters emphasize, do not think that your selective distortions and errors are not extraordinarily evident to the other members reading and posting in this thread. They have repeatedly and generously explained to you the problems with your arguments, yet this has not caused you to change your expressed viewpoint at all. Okay by me if you don't mind continuing to be so visibly wrong.
 
Using a meteor to work out the capabilities of an Apollo heatshield makes about as much sense as using a house brick to work out the aerodynamics of an F22.
 
It's said that the F14 was the Navy's demonstration that if you could put big enough engines on a brick it would fly (it can accelerate straight up). I think the F14 is a bit more aerodynamic than a brick, though.
 
It's said that the F14 was the Navy's demonstration that if you could put big enough engines on a brick it would fly (it can accelerate straight up). I think the F14 is a bit more aerodynamic than a brick, though.

The F-14 was designed by the Lunar Module team. Draw your own conclusions. (All seriousness aside, I love the F-14. I got to help prepare one for display at the Oakland air museum.) The F-15 still wins in the thrust-to-weight ratio. It can go supersonic while accelerating straight up. My first flight instructor was an F-15 driver.
 
The F-14 was designed by the Lunar Module team. Draw your own conclusions. (All seriousness aside, I love the F-14. I got to help prepare one for display at the Oakland air museum.) The F-15 still wins in the thrust-to-weight ratio. It can go supersonic while accelerating straight up. My first flight instructor was an F-15 driver.

Considering that the F-15 can fly with wings..... I think it wins.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom