My statement of #44 may be prone to misunderstanding, but what I wanted to say is that on average only quite small mass portions of
meteors reach the Earth' surface with "terminal velocity".
Collectable
meteorites are the result of selection.
Meteors and parts of disintegrating meteors or asteroids normally do not become collectable meteorites if they still have "huge kinetic energy" at impact. They get destroyed instead.
Small pieces entering the atmosphere mostly vaporize. They arrive with at least terrestrial escape velocity of 11.2 km/s
= 4p112 m/s and therefore with a kinetic energy of at least ½ v ∙ v ≈
9n5 ∙ 4p112 m/s ∙ 4p112 m/s ≈ 7p63 Joule/kg = 63 MJ/kg. For comparison,
vaporization energy of iron is only
6p609 Joule/kg = 6.09 MJ/kg.
The
Chelyabinsk meteor of 2013 is probably the best documented meteoritic impact. Total known weight (
TKW) of all collected pieces is approximately 1000 kg
= 3p1 kg. Yet initial mass is estimated to be more than 10000 metric tonnes
= 7p1 kg. Thus initial mass is around four decimal powers
= 4p1 times higher than collected mass.
This example clearly shows:
The assumption that collectable meteorites are representative of the initial objects entering the atmosphere is simply wrong. The by far biggest mass portion of the Chelyabinsk meteorite dissolved into a thermal debris cloud.
I hope you are unprejudiced and intelligent enough to understand now.
In any case, you were right insofar as
Apollo's reentry would have been quite similar to a normal meteor (suffering substantial vaporization and disintegration) due to its flimsy heat shield (#471, #487)).
Cheers, Wolfgang
All my posts of this thread (dealing with all serious counter-arguments)