Kinetic energy at atmospheric reentry from lunar mission

"Friendly" researches receive carefully selected,
Your proof of this is.....?
maybe even freshly doctored small samples from NASA
"Maybe" is wogoga speak for "Completely made up idea with no evidence to back it up".
, normally in order to deal with one single question.
The word in English that describes such a thought is not allowed o this forum. It involves the waste product of a bovine meal.
It may be unlikely that no one of the receivers has become suspicious, yet outing suspicions representing scientific taboos is not everyone's hobby.
For 50 years!?!?

Take e.g. 9/11.
Oh boy here we go...
Every unprejudiced scientist with common sense
Science is interested in scientifically sound evidence, not seat of the pants 'sense'.
comes to the conclusion that the twin towers and WTC7 have been brought down by explosives,
Oddly enough scientists are not the people to call to make such a determination. Structural engineers with forensic experience are the people for that job AND THE extreme, vast, majority of such people conclude that the towers came down due to damages wrought by the aircraft impacts and subsequent unfought, fuel accelerated, office fires.
whereas the rest of the WTC buildings such as the Marriott hotel were destroyed in a way expected for steel-frame buildings in the absence of explosives.
Because all steel framed buildings are all exactly the same. Right wogoga? Do you have any idea at all of the differences in construction between those towers and, for instance, the Marriot Hotel?
Comparing the result of structure being impacted from above by steel and concrete components of a one million ton building (your picture demonstrates the result after only one tower had come down. The marriot was essentially hit by debris from both towers. I know this picture was taken between collapses because the photographer died in the second collapse) to the result of a structure being impacted by a 100 ton aircraft and subsequent large area office fires is beyond ridiculous and into the realm of insanity.
Nevertheless, if you When you rely on peer reviewed articles and the mainstream media you get a completely different picture (i.e. a fully disinformative one).
FTFY
 
Last edited:
wogoga: A quote from an obviously deluded "scienceagainstevolution" web site

Quote from ...
17 November 2016 wogoga: A quote from an obviously deluded "scienceagainstevolution" web site.

Of course the demand for Moon rocks was high - they came from the Moon :eye-poppi! They are also a limited resource so not everyone has had the chance to study them. It is a paranoid lie that "a few select scientists" gained access.

SAO/NASA Astrophysics Data System (ADS) returns 1137 abstracts for 'analysis moon rock sample' - maybe 5000 or more authors.
 
A credible source but then you quote mine it and add trivial highlighting. This is s source stating that Moon rocks come from the Moon!
Apollo Moon rocks reveal new secrets
Forty-five years after the historic Apollo 11 landing of Neil Armstrong and Buzz Aldrin on the surface of the Moon, the priceless Moon rocks brought back by that legendary expedition are back in the news, revealing new evidence confirming the theory that the Moon was formed by a Mars-sized planetesimal slamming into the young molten Earth.

In the four decades since the Apollo Moon landings, scientists have studied only about ten percent of the lunar rocks and dust collected by astronauts from 1969 to 1972. In 1972 the breccias brought back by John Young and Charlie Duke from their Apollo 16 mission revealed that the lunar surface features were formed primarily by meteoric impacts, not volcanism as originally thought.

In 2008, study of the Apollo 15 Moon rocks confirmed for the first time the existence of water on the Moon. Now samples from the Apollo 11, Apollo 12, and Apollo 16 missions reveal the chemical signature of the planetesimal, known as Thea, which is believed to have struck the Earth about 4.5 billion years ago, blasting a blob of molten slag into space which solidified and formed the Moon.
You highlighted the trivial fact that only about ten percent of the rock and dust has been studied over the last 40 years.
 
"Different gravity" at cooling is quite irrelevant. ...
An ignorant statement, wogoga, since it is gravity that determines the pressure (as you put it "weight above" :eye-poppi). Different gravity = different "weight above" = different gas pockets when molten rock cools.
The Moon has no atmosphere which makes the composition of gas pockets different (just gases from the rock, not air) :eek:!
 
Last edited:
wogoga: Thinks that water will be different on he Moon

17 November 2016 wogoga: Thinks that water will be different on he Moon.
With the usual irrelevant highlighting!

High Pre-Eruptive Water Contents Preserved in Lunar Melt Inclusions
The Moon has long been thought to be highly depleted in volatiles such as water, and indeed published direct measurements of water in lunar volcanic glasses have never exceeded 50 parts per million (ppm). Here, we report in situ measurements of water in lunar melt inclusions; these samples of primitive lunar magma, by virtue of being trapped within olivine crystals prior to volcanic eruption, did not experience post-eruptive degassing. The lunar melt inclusions contain 615 to 1410 ppm water, and high correlated amounts of fluorine (50 to 78 ppm), sulfur (612 to 877 ppm) and chlorine (1.5 to 3.0 ppm). These volatile contents are very similar to primitive terrestrial mid-ocean ridge basalts and indicate that some parts of the lunar interior contain as much water as Earth's upper mantle.
 
wogoga: A lie about Herwartz et.al which points out different composition

17 November 2016 wogoga: A colorful, highlighted lie about Herwartz et.al which points out different composition (oxygen isotopes) between lunar and terrestrial rocks.
Identification of the giant impactor Theia in lunar rocks
An analysis of motes of the Moon maker
How did the Moon form? According to the prevailing hypothesis, a Mars-sized body known as Theia smashed into Earth. Herwartz et al. analyzed fresh basalt samples from three Apollo landing sites and compared them with several samples of Earth's mantle. The oxygen isotope values measured in these lunar rocks differ significantly from the terrestrial material, supporting the giant-impact hypothesis.
Science, this issue p. 1146

Abstract
The Moon was probably formed by a catastrophic collision of the proto-Earth with a planetesimal named Theia. Most numerical models of this collision imply a higher portion of Theia in the Moon than in Earth. Because of the isotope heterogeneity among solar system bodies, the isotopic composition of Earth and the Moon should thus be distinct. So far, however, all attempts to identify the isotopic component of Theia in lunar rocks have failed. Our triple oxygen isotope data reveal a 12 ± 3 parts per million difference in Δ17O between Earth and the Moon, which supports the giant impact hypothesis of Moon formation. We also show that enstatite chondrites and Earth have different Δ17O values, and we speculate on an enstatite chondrite–like composition of Theia. The observed small compositional difference could alternatively be explained by a carbonaceous chondrite–dominated late veneer.

His colorful, highlighted "paradox of identical isotopic compositions of Earth and the Moon" text does not appear in the paper.
 
Last edited:
... namely that Apollo samples are in fact terrestrial.
Writing lies about science as in that post, wogoga. does no harm to science - just your reputation.

What you cited is that Apollo samples are in fact different in composition from terrestrial rocks as anyone who can read "The oxygen isotope values measured in these lunar rocks differ significantly from the terrestrial material, supporting the giant-impact hypothesis." understands.
 
Last edited:
"Friendly" researches receive carefully selected, maybe even freshly doctored small samples from NASA,
Evidence for this claim?

Take e.g. 9/11. Every unprejudiced scientist with common sense comes to the conclusion that the twin towers and WTC7 have been brought down by explosives,
Nope. Just a small fringe of conspiracy nuts who need to believe.


Yeah, the lunatic fringe.
:rolleyes:

"Different gravity" at cooling is quite irrelevant.
:rolleyes:
 
Evidence for this claim?


Nope. Just a small fringe of conspiracy nuts who need to believe.


Yeah, the lunatic fringe.
:rolleyes:


:rolleyes:

Rather than deal with wogoga on a point by point basis, I find it economical to read the post as a singular, holographic whole and accept deep on my heart that Wogoga will never follow the links and read the papers.

I try to share the awesomeness of the Lunar Samples with hoax believers and landing doubters but it's like sharing Leonard Cohen songs with a middle schooler: they lack the life experiences to fully appreciate the value.
 
Again, this [insulating the spacecraft against radiative heat transfer] was not new technology for Apollo. This was developed in the 1950s for ICBMs.


In case of intercontinental ballistic missiles (ICBM), the objective is to reduce atmospheric friction in order not to lose speed. In case of a reentry, the objective is to get rid of kinetic energy by means of atmospheric friction. The goals are almost as different as "efficient braking" versus "reduction of frictional losses" in case of cars.

I must admit that the values of a reentry from ISS with a Soyuz capsule are closer to the alleged Apollo reentry values than I would have thought. But in case of a return from ISS, heating rate can easily be made as low as needed by increasing reentry time, and current efficiency resp. short reentry time can result from experience and optimization.

In any case, I do not think that lunar reentry is impossible for a spacecraft with form and total weight of the Apollo Command Module. I only think that it is beyond NASA's technology of the 1960s.
Cheers, Wolfgang
My previous posts of this thread
We humans tend to believe what we want to be true, and we want to be true what we already believe
 
In any case, I do not think that lunar reentry is impossible for a spacecraft with form and total weight of the Apollo Command Module. I only think that it is beyond NASA's technology of the 1960s.

What a curious statement. The only key variables in re-entry profile, surely, are the weight, form (i.e. shape and composition) and trajectory of the re-entering object. Since you've already conceded the first two of these, are you therefore arguing that NASA's control of trajectory was the only thing beyond the technology available to them in the 1960's? If so, I'd be interested to see how you support that claim.

Dave
 
In any case, I do not think that lunar reentry is impossible for a spacecraft with form and total weight of the Apollo Command Module. I only think that it is beyond NASA's technology of the 1960s.

So they could do it with something they had in the 1960s, but not in the 1960s...

Riiight....
 
wogoga said:
In any case, I do not think that lunar reentry is impossible for a spacecraft with form and total weight of the Apollo Command Module. I only think that it is beyond NASA's technology of the 1960s.

Why exactly do you think this? Your personal opinion is irrelevant, since you've already demonstrated you don't understand how reentry actually works, and are largely unfamiliar with the actual Apollo record.
 
Originally Posted by JayUtah in #387
Again, this [insulating the spacecraft against radiative heat transfer] was not new technology for Apollo. This was developed in the 1950s for ICBMs.
In case of intercontinental ballistic missiles (ICBM), the objective is to reduce atmospheric friction in order not to lose speed. In case of a reentry, the objective is to get rid of kinetic energy by means of atmospheric friction. The goals are almost as different as "efficient braking" versus "reduction of frictional losses" in case of cars.
What makes this a response to JU's post?
Are you of the opinion that ICBM's do not require heat shielding?

I must admit that the values of a reentry from ISS with a Soyuz capsule are closer to the alleged Apollo reentry values than I would have thought.
Gee, who'd have figured that the Russians were using the same physics as the Americans!
But in case of a return from ISS, heating rate can easily be made as low as needed by increasing reentry time, and current efficiency resp. short reentry time can result from experience and optimization
OK, and....?

In any case, I do not think that lunar reentry is impossible for a spacecraft with form and total weight of the Apollo Command Module. I only think that it is beyond NASA's technology of the 1960s.
Good to know you admit that it's not impossible. Now all you need do is support your seat-of-the-pants opinion that it was not possible in the 1960s.
 
The goals are almost as different as "efficient braking" versus "reduction of frictional losses" in case of cars.

The goal is the effective management of heat from aerodynamic heating. You don't understand the mechanisms by which it is done. You can fling all the ignorance and doubt you want, but there are landmark academic and professional papers from the 1950s and 1960s that discuss this in great depth, including the ways in which it was incorporated into Apollo. These do not go away simply because you are unaware of them. They are common knowledge in the field.

I only think that it is beyond NASA's technology of the 1960s.

And that is an ignorant opinion, and is therefore worthless. You don't understand the problem NASA was trying to solve, as scientists understand it. You don't understand the technology that was available at the time, the way engineers understand it. You are not an unsung genius.
 
If I expected a useful answer from wogoga, I might ask what specific technology that now exists makes reentry an easier task today than in 1969.

But as Ive learned to expect no useful reply from wogoga I'll ask JayUtah: does the Orion/constellation stuff use substantially different technology for reentry shielding? The capsule is bigger, and designed for larger payloads up and down, does it still use slow-charring epoxy for an ablative reentry shield? I've not really followed the thing because it seems like NASA was designing a tool for a job that doesn't exist.
 
Given that the rest of the system appears to be an upmissioned crossbreed between Saturn/Apollo and an American engineer's interpretation of Soyuz, I'm not surprised.

It's also, chemically, what we use for auto brakes now instead of asbestos and metal fibers.

Just because technology is mature, wogoga, does not mean it is useless. Only if it's superseded, like using space-age composite materials in car brake pads instead of SotA 1865 mineral chemistry. But even then, there are still applications for crude old crappy tech like lead acid batteries, because their characteristics fit the job.

Still, I would expect the Orion shield to be less manually labor intensive to create than Apollo's. Hand squirting goop in a gajillion little holes falls into my category "patching together leaky boats to see what's on the next island."
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom