Kinetic energy at atmospheric reentry from lunar mission

In any case, I do not think that lunar reentry is impossible for a spacecraft with form and total weight of the Apollo Command Module. I only think that it is beyond NASA's technology of the 1960s
Which is rather delusional because Apollo Command Modules did reentry to Earth's atmosphere from the Moon using NASA's technology of the 1960s :jaw-dropp!
Apollo 4 which had the highest reentry speed of the Apollo missions (as you know!) was launched on November 9, 1967. Apollo 17 was launched on December 7, 1972. The design started around a decade before so it was 1960's technology.

28 November 2016 wogoga: What looks like a delusion that Apollo missions did not return from the Moon because he thinks they could not reenter with 1960's technology.
The thousands of people who watched the Apollo Command Modules reenter during 1967 - 1972 and collected the astronauts from the modules during 1967 - 1972 would disagree - as world the astronauts :eek:!

Not unexpected since we have had:
20 October 2016 wogoga: Quote mining + a lie of "a reentry similar to a Apollo reentry has never been successfully repeated"
27 October 2016 wogoga: The truth about ablative heat shields that wogoga denies
31 October 2016 wogoga: A lie about the issue of reentry heat being ignored 31 October 2016 wogoga: Repeats ignorance about ablative heat shields
31 October 2016 wogoga: A "PR" lie about the APOLLO EXPERIENCE REPORT – THERMAL PROTECTION SUBSYSTEM
31 October 2016 wogoga: A lie about the Apollo missions being easily faked with 1960s technology
17 November 2016 wogoga: Paranoiac conspiracy theory leads to a fantasy of "doctored", "selected" , "small" samples.
17 November 2016 wogoga: A quote from an obviously deluded "scienceagainstevolution" web site.
17 November 2016 wogoga: Thinks that water will be different on he Moon.
17 November 2016 wogoga: An ignorant conclusion that water content has something to do with isotopic composition.
17 November 2016 wogoga: A colorful, highlighted lie about Herwartz et.al which points out different composition (oxygen isotopes) between lunar and terrestrial rocks.
 
Last edited:
What is the claim of the Moon hoax believers, did the Apollo missions orbit the Moon without landing, or is the entire Apollo program a big hoax, including Apollo 13 that came seriously close to becoming a disaster?

If the Apollo missions orbited the Moon, then the reentry speed would be the same as when they had landed on the Moon.
 
What is the claim of the Moon hoax believers, did the Apollo missions orbit the Moon without landing, or is the entire Apollo program a big hoax, including Apollo 13 that came seriously close to becoming a disaster?

If the Apollo missions orbited the Moon, then the reentry speed would be the same as when they had landed on the Moon.

Well, there are lots.
  • They never went at all, but faked it on a sooper sekrit movie set.
  • The earth is flat and the moon is small and only a couple of hundred km up. Spherical earth proponents had to fake it to support the idea that earth is a sphere.
  • The bible says there is a crystal dome of the firmament on which the moon resides therefore godless NASA science had to fake it on a sooper sekrit movie set.
  • They went but the spacecraft were unmanned, but landing was impossible. Thus the surface pictures and movies were faked.
  • They went and established militarised bases on the moon which had to be covered up.
  • They went and found lakes and trees and lush forests which had to be covered up.
  • they went and found alien spaceships lying around which had to be covered up.
  • They went and found whole alien bases and cities which had to be covered up.
  • Only Apollo 11 went and aliens forbid any landing or return missions which had to be covered up.

And many more variations. There isn't any single answer to the question.
 
In case of intercontinental ballistic missiles (ICBM), the objective is to reduce atmospheric friction in order not to lose speed. In case of a reentry, the objective is to get rid of kinetic energy by means of atmospheric friction. The goals are almost as different as "efficient braking" versus "reduction of frictional losses" in case of cars.
Nope. In all of those cases, the objective is not to get burnt to a crisp and thus be rendered useless.

Soyuz has been doing it since the 1960s. Somehow, you claim it is impossible for Apollo to do it. Because reasons.

ICBMs don't really care much about loss of speed. It doesn't matter how much they really lose, they will still be going fast enough to evade interception. They care more about surviving reentry. Which is why they have heat shields. Both Soyuz and Apollo heat shields are largely derived from this very technology. Somehow, you have decided that Soyuz works and Apollo does not on the basis of nothing at all.
 
Nope. In all of those cases, the objective is not to get burnt to a crisp and thus be rendered useless.

Indeed. The headwaters of the relevant academic literature studied what factors affected whether meteors burned up. One of its key findings was a rather counter-intuitive law showing some unexpected invariants among heat loads and factors. On that basis rests the engineering practice, which manipulates those factors to affect such goal variables as peak heating, favorable heating rates, and desired program goals. The joy in that invariance is being able to confidently manipulate one variable with the defensible expectation that other factors will necessarily adjust to maintain the invariance. Some of these are counter-intuitive.

ICBMs don't really care much about loss of speed. It doesn't matter how much they really lose, they will still be going fast enough to evade interception. They care more about surviving reentry.

True, but I would urge more emphasis on the tradeoff implied in your statement. We don't use blunted re-entry vehicles because we really do want to optimize toward high entry speed. It may be only a marginal increase in the ability to evade interception, but it's deemed a wide enough increase to warrant the shift in design methods and overall approach. And yes, we do have the technology to manage the colossal heating rates that occur, compared to a re-entering manned spacecraft.
 
Indeed. The headwaters of the relevant academic literature studied what factors affected whether meteors burned up. One of its key findings was a rather counter-intuitive law showing some unexpected invariants among heat loads and factors. On that basis rests the engineering practice, which manipulates those factors to affect such goal variables as peak heating, favorable heating rates, and desired program goals. The joy in that invariance is being able to confidently manipulate one variable with the defensible expectation that other factors will necessarily adjust to maintain the invariance. Some of these are counter-intuitive.



True, but I would urge more emphasis on the tradeoff implied in your statement. We don't use blunted re-entry vehicles because we really do want to optimize toward high entry speed. It may be only a marginal increase in the ability to evade interception, but it's deemed a wide enough increase to warrant the shift in design methods and overall approach. And yes, we do have the technology to manage the colossal heating rates that occur, compared to a re-entering manned spacecraft.
And we somehow end up in a place that Soyuz can do it, Mercury can do it, Gemini can do it, Voshkod can do it, Russian ICBMs can do it, US ICBMs can do it yet, the shuttle can do it and so on, yet for reasons unexplained, Apollo cannot. Why? Back in the day, both US and Russian spy satellites released canisters of actual film on return trajectories to be developed. Those had perforce reentry trajectory profiles.

To me, this speaks to a political agenda and has nothing to do with science.

Boiled down to it's essence, the claim at hand is that everyone could do it, except the US.

The reality is that everyone who could was. Including the US.
 
And we somehow end up in a place that Soyuz can do it, Mercury can do it, Gemini can do it, Voshkod can do it, Russian ICBMs can do it, US ICBMs can do it yet, the shuttle can do it and so on, yet for reasons unexplained, Apollo cannot. Why? Back in the day, both US and Russian spy satellites released canisters of actual film on return trajectories to be developed. Those had perforce reentry trajectory profiles.

To me, this speaks to a political agenda and has nothing to do with science.

Boiled down to it's essence, the claim at hand is that everyone could do it, except the US.

The reality is that everyone who could was. Including the US.

In a somewhat related matter, the X-15 could do it and the SR-71 could do it.
 
Thus the question whether "heat rejection via radiative means is a third-order term" depends on temperature.

No. You don't understand what is meant by "the problem." The problem is the design of a heat shield. The solution involves several factors working in concert. Rejection of heat by radiative heat transfer is a third-order term in the quantitative solution. You're trying to claim the gaseous ablation products cannot be suitably opaque as I claimed because then the heat shield wouldn't be able to radiate away heat. That's a knee-jerk response based on what you desperately want to be true, not what is true.


In the textbook provoking this thread (#1), the authors deal with three approaches to thermal-protection systems:

  • Heat sinks
  • Ablation
  • Radiative cooling
If you are right and "radiative heat transfer is a third-order term in the quantitative solution" then thermal protection in case of Apollo must almost fully rely on ablation, since involved thermal energy is far too enormous for being relevantly absorbed by heat sinks of the reentry capsule (#68).


But as Ive learned to expect no useful reply from wogoga I'll ask JayUtah: does the Orion/constellation stuff use substantially different technology for reentry shielding? The capsule is bigger, and designed for larger payloads up and down, does it still use slow-charring epoxy for an ablative reentry shield? I've not really followed the thing because it seems like NASA was designing a tool for a job that doesn't exist.

It's almost a carbon copy of Apollo's heat shield. No pun intended.


There is a huge difference between a heat shield losing roughly 100 kg of "slow-charring epoxy" and a heat shield losing e.g. 1000 kg carbon (#196, #336). Carbon has a sublimation temperature of 3915°K and a vaporization enthalpy of 355.8 KJ/mol ≈ 5p356 Joule per mole. Taking into account heat capacity, this results in a theoretical heat absorption capacity of more than 30 MJ/kg = 7p3 Joule per kg. Thus, by vaporizing 1000 kg = 3p1 kg, the heat shield can remove 30 GJ = 10p3 Joule of reentry heat. This would already result in around 10% = 9n1 = n1 of total heat of 330 Gigajoule = 11p33 J emerging during an Apollo reentry (#196).

And 3915°K also renders radiative cooling very effective: around 13 Megawatt/m2 = 7p13 Watt per square meter (#403), resp. 160 MW = 8p16 Joule/sec for the whole heat shield area. At this vaporization temperature, 2000 seconds would be enough to radiate away a quantity equal to total reentry heat.

Here some relevant NASA documentations concerning the suspicious material of the Apollo heat shields:

According to [3], Table B-3 – Normal Thermo-chemical Properties for the Apollo Heat Shield Material, density is 32 lbm/ft = 512 kg/m3, and effective heat of pyrolysis is 250 Btu/lbm = 0.51 MJ/kg = 5p51 Joule per kg.

If the whole 111 kg mass loss of Apollo 4 was due to vaporization of this Apollo heat shield material, these 111 kg could have removed not even 0.06 GJ = 7p6 Joule of total reentry heat of ~ 330 GJ = 11p33 Joule (#196), i.e. a portion of not even 0.02% = 6n2.

At least the order of magnitude of the value given in [3], Table B-3 is also confirmed by [1], TABLE 1. – ENTHALPY OF SIX CHARRING ABLATORS AND TWO CHARS. Enthalpy resp. thermodynamic energy with respect to 0°C = 273°K has been measured for the ablative material AVCOAT 5026/39. The highest temperate mentioned is 662°K = 389°C with an enthalpy of 0.6364 MJ/kg ≈ 5p64 Joule/kg and a mass loss of 27.5% = n275.

I conclude that all this stuff concerning labor-intensive processes, where each individual cell of the Apollo heat shield was filled by hand with a magic material was primarily a propaganda bluff.
Quote from NASA Applies Insights for Manufacturing of Orion Spacecraft Heat Shield, 2015:

The heat shield was composed of a titanium skeleton and carbon fiber skin that gave the crew module its circular shape on the bottom and provided structural support, on top of which a fiberglass-phenolic honeycomb structure was placed. The honeycomb structure had 320,000 tiny cells that were individually filled by hand with an ablative material called Avcoat designed to wear away as Orion returned to Earth through the atmosphere. During the labor-intensive process, each individual cell was filled by hand as part of a serial process, cured in a large oven, X-rayed and then robotically machined to meet precise thickness requirements.

However, during the manufacture of the heat shield for Orion's flight test, engineers determined that the strength of the Avcoat/honeycomb structure was below expectations.
​
And we all know where such wrong expectations come from: They stem from the belief that such a technology worked without problems already more than 40 years ago.

Cheers, Wolfgang
Athletics Records on the Moon
 
Last edited:
...then thermal protection in case of Apollo must almost fully rely on ablation

No, that's a very simplistic conclusion. There is a concert of effects happening in this design. And it's not in any way specific or original to Apollo. You're still laboring under false assumptions of the actual mechanisms of heat transfer at work. I've explained them to you twice, but you remain either ignorant or willfully disinterested. You can blabber all you want about what you think "must be" the case, but you still can't demonstrate any more than a beginning student's understanding of how these systems are actually designed and used. You aren't an unsung genius.

There is a huge difference...

No, all you've done is simply ignore the evidence and restate your claim. The TPS of the Orion spacecraft is substantially the same as the TPS of the Apollo spacecraft, which at the time was based on known and tested principles that predated even it. What you ignorantly propose to be a "propaganda bluff" is actually decades of practical experience. Your handwaving FUD about the test results not conforming to design estimates is just normal engineering practice. That's why the tests are done instead of just assuming the design assumptions were correct.

Further, the discrepancy was in the structural strength of the system, not its thermal properties. That has nothing to do with any of your claims, and is a problem we would expect to see when a validated design is scaled up. This happens all the time in aerospace -- something works fine at one scale and develops problems at a larger scale.

You would know this if you had any actual experience. Do you? What are your professional or academic qualifications in design engineering for aerospace? Have you personally contributed in a relevant way to designing any hardware destined to fly in space? Please provide your answer in your next post.
 
Among the functions of the ablative heat shield is to generate a coolant fluid to carry away heat. Decomposition of the shield material isn't the entire energy budget. It's just one stage in the process of shedding the incoming heat. The gasses generated by decomposition absorb heat from the shockwave and carry them away, hotter than they were when cooked off.
 
Among the functions of the ablative heat shield is to generate a coolant fluid to carry away heat. Decomposition of the shield material isn't the entire energy budget. It's just one stage in the process of shedding the incoming heat. The gasses generated by decomposition absorb heat from the shockwave and carry them away, hotter than they were when cooked off.

Didn't you or JayU already instruct woebegone of this? I certainly recall being informed of it in this thread. Maybe I recall wrong.
 
wogoga: Delusions do not trump the reality that the Apollo missions did not burn up

If you are right and "radiative heat transfer is a third-order term in the quantitative solution" then thermal protection in case of Apollo must almost fully rely on ablation, since involved thermal energy is far too enormous for being relevantly absorbed by heat sinks of the reentry capsule...
6 December 2016 wogoga: Delusions about thermal emery on an ignorant crank web site do not trump the reality that the Apollo missions did not burn up on reentry :eek:!
The rest of the post is just repeating the ignorant delusion that the Apollo spacecraft must have burned up when in fact they did not because you are persistently in denial about how heat shields work. The physics is basically that they ablate to form a protective, cool layer. It is not a fantasy abut entire shield vaporizing. You already know this (read this thread).
 
Last edited:
wogoga: A "propaganda bluff' conclusion based on ignorance, denial and delusion

I conclude that all this stuff concerning labor-intensive processes, where each individual cell of the Apollo heat shield was filled by hand with a magic material was primarily a propaganda bluff.
6 December 2016 wogoga: A "propaganda bluff' conclusion based on ignorance, denial and delusion.

The deluded part is that you have a list of NASA sources on the real research on real materials for constructing heat shields and you think that this is "magic" :jaw-dropp!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom