Kid re-wires clock, gets suspended from school for "bomb hoax"

What's bizarre is the desperation being evidenced by people who want to somehow rewrite the facts.

He's getting what he's getting because of the shabby treatment he received, not because of any demonstration of intrinsic brilliance.

If it hadn't had been for the disgusting overreaction of allegedly mature adults he wouldn't have gotten a thing.

Nice try at misdirection, though.
Did the kid suspended over the pop tart "gun" get this kind of reaction? The 6 year old suspended and accused of sexual harassment for kissing a classmate?

Wild overreactions on all sides of this, and frankly they're not doing this kid any favors by expecting great things from him in such a public way when he hasn't actually showed much aptitude in the subject he's being touted as a prodigy in. For his sake I hope he does succeed, but they're setting him up for failure.
 
Did the kid suspended over the pop tart "gun" get this kind of reaction? The 6 year old suspended and accused of sexual harassment for kissing a classmate?

Wild overreactions on all sides of this, and frankly they're not doing this kid any favors by expecting great things from him in such a public way when he hasn't actually showed much aptitude in the subject he's being touted as a prodigy in. For his sake I hope he does succeed, but they're setting him up for failure.

Eehn, it's comparable for pop-tart boy...

The 8-year-old Baltimore boy who was suspended for chewing his Pop-Tart into the shape of a gun was awarded a lifetime membership with the National Rifle Association Wednesday night.

http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2013/may/30/nra-gives-lifetime-membership-boy-suspended-pop-ta/
 
Did the kid suspended over the pop tart "gun" get this kind of reaction? The 6 year old suspended and accused of sexual harassment for kissing a classmate?

Wild overreactions on all sides of this, and frankly they're not doing this kid any favors by expecting great things from him in such a public way when he hasn't actually showed much aptitude in the subject he's being touted as a prodigy in. For his sake I hope he does succeed, but they're setting him up for failure.


It was indeed a ridiculous situation. The whole hand-cuffs and arrest thing takes it to a whole new level through. Or did you forget about that?

I don't know and don't care about this kid's real aptitude for engineering. It hasn't got anything to do with crazy-ass police overreach, which is something I do care about. That you continue to talk about it like it's an important part of this story is some kind of crazy too.
 
Why do you think he gets a tour of MIT, scholarship offer to attend Space Camp, invitation to the White House to show off his "cool clock", thousands in free swag from Microsoft, and an invitation to the Google Science Fair? Think about that last one, the 16 year old girl who won invented a better way to detect the ebola virus, while Ahmed upstages her by unscrewing the housing of a Radio Shack clock.

Wild overreactions all around!

See the post by Belz... immediately above yours. I think Ahmed is being offered these things as compensation for the ridiculous treatment he received at school, and to encourage him to maintain an interest in electronics/science/engineering in spite of the weird attitude he has seen from some "educators".

In what way has Ahmed upstaged Olivia Hallisey? Ahmed was a visitor to the fair, a guest, not a competitor.
 
If there's one thing I can't stand, it's wrongfully-arrested-by-the-police-and-later-vindicated privilege.
 
If there's one thing I can't stand, it's wrongfully-arrested-by-the-police-and-later-vindicated privilege.

Yeah!! Well, there seem to be some who think that the whole thing was planned in advance by Ahmed and his dad. They must have known about all the cool stuff he would be receiving. :)
 
This reminds me of something that happened in the early 1980s, maybe late 1970s. The girls at work said there was a guy in the county who made clocks. Wasn't that the most amazing thing? And they were going out to visit his workshop.

Well, I thought that was pretty cool, so I went along. I wouldn't have expected him to machine all the gears himself; just assembling them into a working clock was amazing enough.

When we got there, I discovered he bought ready-made clocks and made clock cases, into which he installed them. Just basic cabinetmaking. Afterwards, when I pointed this out to the others, they were unswayed and were just as impressed that he really "made clocks."
 
This reminds me of something that happened in the early 1980s, maybe late 1970s. The girls at work said there was a guy in the county who made clocks. Wasn't that the most amazing thing? And they were going out to visit his workshop.

Well, I thought that was pretty cool, so I went along. I wouldn't have expected him to machine all the gears himself; just assembling them into a working clock was amazing enough.

When we got there, I discovered he bought ready-made clocks and made clock cases, into which he installed them. Just basic cabinetmaking. Afterwards, when I pointed this out to the others, they were unswayed and were just as impressed that he really "made clocks."


I don't think it's incredibly misleading to say that person "makes clocks." Consider the audience -- most people think of the clock as the entire package: the housing, the face, the hands and the actual clock mechanism. Why would anyone build clockworks in this day and age, excepting enthusiastic hobbyists? You can buy the mechanism off the shelf for next to nothing, and the real value is in the visible structural and decorative elements. Even if you use the word clockmaker absolutely properly, it most likely will refer to a person who repairs factory-made clocks, kind of like a modern cobbler repairs, rather than makes, shoes.
 
It was indeed a ridiculous situation. The whole hand-cuffs and arrest thing takes it to a whole new level through. Or did you forget about that?

I don't know and don't care about this kid's real aptitude for engineering. It hasn't got anything to do with crazy-ass police overreach, which is something I do care about. That you continue to talk about it like it's an important part of this story is some kind of crazy too.
"Wild overreactions on all sides". That includes the handcuffing, did you miss that part?
 
Hasn't anyone here noticed that Ahmed's "invention" is merely a commercial alarm clock with the cover removed? It's a printed circuit board, it has a connection for 120vac and a 9v battery backup. The only thing he "invented" was how to unscrew the case and remount the insides in another case.

image

Yes but for a brown person of a family from one of the dusty third world countries that's a technological breakthrough in racket science.
 
So, the Police asked him what it was, and he told them the truth...

The police “questioned him about his intentions and the reason why he brought the device to the school”, and he refused to answer those questions.

Bombs usually require something explosive attached; plastique, gelignite, something that actually looks like explosive. If he had attached a large dollop of silly-putty to his clock and poked some wires into it, then perhaps the allegation that he was trying to fool people into thinking it was a bomb might carry some weight, but he didn't do that.

Anyone who looked at this device and thought it was a bomb has to have a few components loose upstairs.

A hoax bomb does not need to look exactly like a bomb to be successful. It only needs to look somewhat like a bomb. If that clock were left sitting around in an airport, I expect it would get a great deal of attention from security. Similarly, if it were left under a teacher’s desk or in a student’s locker it could quite likely cause alarm. People seeing an out of place object that looks bomb-like aren’t likely to scrutinize the details of the device before getting the heck out of there and alerting security. Of course the whole “hoax bomb” issue is a bit of a red herring I’ll address in another post.

He was told not to tell anyone about it. Perhaps he was just doing what he was told.

He was told not to show it to other teachers. I doubt he interpreted that has not explaining his intentions to police.

Also, he is obviously a smart kid. Perhaps he knows his constitutional rights....he doesn't have to answer any questions and the Police are not allowed to interview him without a parent or guardian present.

Perhaps. That isn’t bad advice. It is good advice not to talk to police without a lawyer, especially if you are being accused. Although that usually means the inconvenience of being detained or arrested and going down to the station until the lawyer shows up. I have no idea why the parents were involved before he was cuffed and hauled downtown. But h has not (to my knowledge) mentioned anything about not saying any more to the police because of his constitutional rights.
 
A hoax bomb does not need to look exactly like a bomb to be successful. It only needs to look somewhat like a bomb.

It also needs to be presented in a way that makes it likely that people will think it's a bomb, such as saying that it's a bomb. The kid didn't do that. He in fact did the exact opposite. There is no way one can fit this event with any definition of "hoax" that I can think of.
 
I....am not so sure about that. I respect what you say in the rest of your post and largely agree with it; but I'm pretty sure I saw news articles referring to the clock as "homemade", built from scratch, an "invention". And some of the responses he's gotten from noteworthy individuals seem to suggest they got the same impression - that he actually fabricated a clock from raw wires and PCBs somehow, as opposed to the truth which is that he took an already-built clock out of its case and put it in a new case.

The problem isn't even specifically with that detail. This whole situation has been badly reported from the beginning. A look a this very thread shows people joking about how the teachers and police thought the object was a bomb - as indeed, all the original press reports, being solely based on the statements of the student since he's the one who took the incident to the media, said was the case - when subsequent police reports have made it clear that the object was never believed to have been a bomb, but was merely suspected of having been mocked up to look like a Hollywood-style bomb. Ask yourself why, for instance, the situation was dealt with by a teacher taking the thing away, and then police officers taking the student out of class a few hours later as opposed to, say, a building evacuation and a bomb-squad response. But yet - "ha ha, they're so stupid, there aren't even any explosives in it!".

+1
 
One thing we have to keep in mind is that the teacher did not report the device as a hoax bomb. The teacher reported it as “possibly the infrastructure for a bomb”. That is, the teacher thought he was showing off the first stage of a bomb that he was creating. That is far more hokey and bizarre than the idea that it was a hoax bomb.

So the police have to respond to this concern that the kid has the “infrastructure for a bomb” and has some intention to actually create a bomb or perhaps some other devious plans to cause havoc and destruction at the school. They see that it is obviously not a bomb. But it does seem somewhat suspicious. It is somewhat bomb-like in nature. When the kid starts playing coy and won’t explain his intentions, it only raises their concern. What is the kid up to?

At this point I don’t why the kid didn’t explain his intentions, but I have expressed my theory that it was because his true intentions were to bring to school a somewhat bomb-like device knowing that somebody would freak out and think it was a bomb and he could then reveal that it was just a harmless clock and thereby expose their prejudice against his race and religion and give them something to think about before stereotyping him. It doesn’t take a mastermind to conceive of such a prank. He has publicly said he was upset that in middle school he was called the names “terrorist” and “bomb maker”.

I also don’t know why the police didn’t call in the parents at this point. But to get to the bottom of this, they decided to arrest or detain him and haul him off to the station.

To do that, they had to have some law that he could be charged with. While there are likely laws against possessing precursors to a bomb, those probably deal with certain chemicals that can be made into explosives and not a having the guts of a clock in a case. So they dug up the law against a hoax bomb, which is almost entirely dependent on the intentions of the suspect, which the kid was not revealing, and charged him with that.

The whole “hoax bomb” accusation is mostly just a pretense for the police to take him into custody until they sorted out what he was up to with this suspicious device. Once they sorted out that it was just a science project, that was the end of it.

I say “mostly” just a pretense because I think the kid created the device and brought it to school with the intention of causing alarm. Not as a traditional “hoax” but rather because he knew it would cause some people concern (justly or unjustly). Which is exactly what it did.

(Sorry for all the paragraphs for people that don’t like long posts, but I have limited times when I can be on the forum so I have to get everything out in one go. Maybe Just pretend each paragraph is a separate short post.)
 
It also needs to be presented in a way that makes it likely that people will think it's a bomb, such as saying that it's a bomb. The kid didn't do that. He in fact did the exact opposite. There is no way one can fit this event with any definition of "hoax" that I can think of.

I addressed that before and even quoted the specific law. The law makes it illegal to possess such a device with the ”intention” of causing alarm. So the police were trying to determine his intention. The intention was not clear and he wouldn’t address that when questioned, so they escalated the investigation.
 
I brought a WWII pineapple hand grenade to high school. It was hollowed out but still had the spring loaded handle with pin. The vice principal took it away from me, gave me a lecture about his time in Vietnam, but let me pick it up at the the end of the day:D
 
I brought a WWII pineapple hand grenade to high school. It was hollowed out but still had the spring loaded handle with pin. The vice principal took it away from me, gave me a lecture about his time in Vietnam, but let me pick it up at the the end of the day:D

You and Jrrarglblarg.

In high school I took an empty pineapple grenade to hand someone as a joke. Afterward I was in a stairwell trying to put the pin back in. My hands were shaking because I'd been laughing so hard. Vice principle came up and saw me, I showed the open bottom to him and said "it's not real" and he let me go about my business.

What’s with all the pineapple grenade hoaxes? In my school it was a bag of oregano to look like marijuana or a big rubber knife from the theater department to “accidentally” drop in class or flash around a bit to prank the square teachers.

I always wondered whether all the kids who brought in butterfly knives ever got them back.
 
Or perhaps he was just a terrified child and was too frightened to frame any other coherent answer for the four uniformed adults who had handcuffed him and were subjecting him to a hostile interrogation.

Dave

Probably more likely. Hanlon's razor and all that.
 
Why do you think he gets a tour of MIT, scholarship offer to attend Space Camp, invitation to the White House to show off his "cool clock", thousands in free swag from Microsoft, and an invitation to the Google Science Fair? Think about that last one, the 16 year old girl who won invented a better way to detect the ebola virus, while Ahmed upstages her by unscrewing the housing of a Radio Shack clock.

<snip>


It wasn't because of the clock in a pencil case.

It was because of the way he was treated.

If the school had simply taken the clock in a pencil case which they knew wasn't a bomb and didn't look like a bomb, and told him to come get it after school then he wouldn't have gotten any of the things you seem so upset by.

Your displeasure is misdirected.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom