Kid re-wires clock, gets suspended from school for "bomb hoax"

As to how we judge his treatment by the school and police, what he actually built or didn't build is somewhat relevant. For example, the highly credible accusation that he didn't build anything worthwhile at all should lead a skeptic to question his motive for bringing his "invention" to school.

I can't really come up with an innocent motive.

I must admit that I was willing to consider (and stated here) that he might have had some less than pure motives. Fortunately, Checkmite provided the information that convinced me that there was, in fact, an innocent motive, and that it was, in reality, exactly what the kid said it was.

Checkmite noted that his electronics bench at home was filled with other equally unimpressive "inventions", that were nothing more than case mods. In other words, that's the best the kid can do. Now all he needs is a bit of encouragement and education, and maybe he can do something a bit more impressive in the future. Fortunately, despite the best efforts of MacArthur High School, he has gotten more encouragement than he could possibly have hoped for. We don't know whether he has enough raw talent to do some truly impressive things, but even if he turns out to just be an electrician, he will at least have had the opportunity to give it his best shot.

Thank you, Checkmite, for providing the needed information to put my suspicions about this kid to rest.



But he also did nothing worthy of praise either.

And here I must vociferously disagree. He took the initiative to create something, however unimpressive that creation was. His parents clearly can't provide much in the way of assistance in that department, but they do what they can, providing him tools and working with him on cars.

Hopefully, his new school has a First Robotics Program. I want kids like that on my team. I know there are teams in Irving. I hope he finds one.
 
Second of all YES if they don't know what something is they are mandated to report it to the police.

I won't make the same mistake I made last time, by asking to see the policy that mandates it. That time, you seemed to think I wanted you to do my research for me. This time, I will be more precise.

I don't believe you, and I will not believe you unless I see something in writing that backs you up. That's really what I meant last time, too. So, I am not asking you to do any research for me. I'm just telling you that I do not believe your assertion.

Let me explain why.

There are plenty of times teachers see things and they "don't know what it is". They aren't mandated to do anything about such things, unless they believe that student safety is threatened. In that case, they are mandated to do more than just call the police. They are mandated to take whatever measures are necessary to protect the students. In the case of your "goo" example, if they were afraid it could be toxic, protection of the other students would require them to confiscate it to ensure it couldn't be ingested. In the case of a suspected explosive, they would be mandated to clear the building or somehow make sure that, if it were an explosive, no students would be harmed when it detonated.

As has been pointed out repeatedly, they did not take such measures. They did not take those measures because they had determined there was no threat. If there is no threat to safety, there is no need to call the police, unless they suspect that there is a crime. The crime that was mentioned in this case was the creation of a hoax bomb. However, we know it was not a hoax bomb, because to be a hoax, you have to be trying to get people to believe you. He told them it was a clock.

The administration was not following policy when it called the police. The police were not following the law when they arrested the boy.
 
Why do you think he gets a tour of MIT, scholarship offer to attend Space Camp, invitation to the White House to show off his "cool clock", thousands in free swag from Microsoft, and an invitation to the Google Science Fair?

Have you ever seen a feel good movie that features a nerdy high school kid being bullied? They end with the captain of the football team standing up for the nerdy kid and telling the bullies to take a hike.

That kid was bullied, and Barack Obama was the captain of the football team.

Same with some of the other people who joined in support. They've been on the wrong side of some bullying. Barry Obama was a smart, black, small stoner in high school. I've seen Hillary Rodham's picture as a young woman. I'm guessing she wasn't prom queen. I don't know what Mark Zuckerberg was like in high school, but I know he programmed computers and he wears grey T-shirts to work. I'm guessing he might have had a rough time in junior high.

In Ahmed, they saw one of their own. No, he isn't impressive, but neither were they, and they have empathy.
 
I must admit that I was willing to consider (and stated here) that he might have had some less than pure motives. Fortunately, Checkmite provided the information that convinced me that there was, in fact, an innocent motive, and that it was, in reality, exactly what the kid said it was.

Checkmite noted that his electronics bench at home was filled with other equally unimpressive "inventions", that were nothing more than case mods. In other words, that's the best the kid can do. Now all he needs is a bit of encouragement and education, and maybe he can do something a bit more impressive in the future. Fortunately, despite the best efforts of MacArthur High School, he has gotten more encouragement than he could possibly have hoped for. We don't know whether he has enough raw talent to do some truly impressive things, but even if he turns out to just be an electrician, he will at least have had the opportunity to give it his best shot.

Thank you, Checkmite, for providing the needed information to put my suspicions about this kid to rest.

I would tend to disagree. I am still convinced at least for now that his intent was to make people believe that he had assembled the electronics, thus implying skills he did not really possess, and not that he had merely put an extant clock into a new case. I don't think I'd personally be willing to call that a completely "innocent" motive.

But I will agree in one respect - that his motive wasn't criminal. I don't believe he intended to make a device that looked like a bomb; neither do I believe that his father encouraged him to take the device to school in the hopes of stirring up trouble or publicity of some kind.
 
At this point I don’t why the kid didn’t explain his intentions, but I have expressed my theory that it was because his true intentions were to bring to school a somewhat bomb-like device knowing that somebody would freak out and think it was a bomb and he could then reveal that it was just a harmless clock and thereby expose their prejudice against his race and religion and give them something to think about before stereotyping him.

I thought this plausible, until Checkmite posted the information that Ahmed had made several other "bomb-like devices" as part of his electronics hobby. Based on that, I think it was just one of those other parts rearrangements.
 
I would tend to disagree. I am still convinced at least for now that his intent was to make people believe that he had assembled the electronics, thus implying skills he did not really possess, and not that he had merely put an extant clock into a new case. I don't think I'd personally be willing to call that a completely "innocent" motive.

But I will agree in one respect - that his motive wasn't criminal. I don't believe he intended to make a device that looked like a bomb; neither do I believe that his father encouraged him to take the device to school in the hopes of stirring up trouble or publicity of some kind.

I don't think it's impossible. I think it's more likely that he literally didn't know any better. He did that sort of rearrangement of parts, which is sort of cool, but didn't know the slightest thing about the next step to take. In other words, he was very impressed with himself, despite some rather unimpressive accomplishments. This is a not uncommon phenomenon among youth raised in the "everyone gets a trophy" world.

Nevertheless, I will praise him for his initiative, and hope that someone provides him some real education so that, if he has what it takes, it is developed.
 
Same with some of the other people who joined in support. They've been on the wrong side of some bullying. Barry Obama was a smart, black, small stoner in high school. I've seen Hillary Rodham's picture as a young woman. I'm guessing she wasn't prom queen. I don't know what Mark Zuckerberg was like in high school, but I know he programmed computers and he wears grey T-shirts to work. I'm guessing he might have had a rough time in junior high.

In Ahmed, they saw one of their own. No, he isn't impressive, but neither were they, and they have empathy.

This is a not uncommon phenomenon among youth raised in the "everyone gets a trophy Nobel Peace Prize" world.

.

Makers. Takers. Fakers; no fourth category
 
I must admit that I was willing to consider (and stated here) that he might have had some less than pure motives. Fortunately, Checkmite provided the information that convinced me that there was, in fact, an innocent motive, and that it was, in reality, exactly what the kid said it was.

Do you have an explanation for why he said that he did not use the locking mechanism that came with the case and instead used a piece of cable to close the case so that it didn’t “look like a threat” and didn’t “look that much suspicious”?

I consider two possibilities:

1. He created an electronic device to impress his engineering teacher.
2. He created a device that looked somewhat bomb-like while actually being a harmless clock to incite alarm from someone and thereby expose their prejudice.

I can’t reconcile his claim that he took specific actions to make the device not look like a “threat” or “suspicious” with option 1.

When I consider all of the evidence, I find that it lines up very well with option 2. The evidence only lines up with option 1 if we start accepting exceptional explanations, and it takes a number of them. That is what I presented in my first post in this thread. Since then, more information has come out that further supports option 2.

I have no horse in this race. I’m just looking at the evidence.
 
I thought this plausible, until Checkmite posted the information that Ahmed had made several other "bomb-like devices" as part of his electronics hobby. Based on that, I think it was just one of those other parts rearrangements.

I missed that. Which post number was that?
 
You and Jrrarglblarg.



What’s with all the pineapple grenade hoaxes? In my school it was a bag of oregano to look like marijuana or a big rubber knife from the theater department to “accidentally” drop in class or flash around a bit to prank the square teachers.

I always wondered whether all the kids who brought in butterfly knives ever got them back.

Surplus World War 2 material was easily obtainable at flea markets when I was young
 
Do you have an explanation for why he said that he did not use the locking mechanism that came with the case and instead used a piece of cable to close the case so that it didn’t “look like a threat” and didn’t “look that much suspicious”?

I consider two possibilities:

1. He created an electronic device to impress his engineering teacher.
2. He created a device that looked somewhat bomb-like while actually being a harmless clock to incite alarm from someone and thereby expose their prejudice.

I can’t reconcile his claim that he took specific actions to make the device not look like a “threat” or “suspicious” with option 1.

When I consider all of the evidence, I find that it lines up very well with option 2. The evidence only lines up with option 1 if we start accepting exceptional explanations, and it takes a number of them. That is what I presented in my first post in this thread. Since then, more information has come out that further supports option 2.

I have no horse in this race. I’m just looking at the evidence.

How about, he created an electronic device to impress his engineering teacher, but he was aware that some people might mistake it for something else?
 
I must admit that I was willing to consider (and stated here) that he might have had some less than pure motives. Fortunately, Checkmite provided the information that convinced me that there was, in fact, an innocent motive, and that it was, in reality, exactly what the kid said it was.

I'm not quite sure how this helps unless you're saying that the kid is just completely clueless about his knowledge and abilities relative to his peers. That's certainly possible, perhaps even likely, but in that case all of this praise and support is likely to end badly.

Checkmite noted that his electronics bench at home was filled with other equally unimpressive "inventions", that were nothing more than case mods. In other words, that's the best the kid can do. Now all he needs is a bit of encouragement and education, and maybe he can do something a bit more impressive in the future. Fortunately, despite the best efforts of MacArthur High School, he has gotten more encouragement than he could possibly have hoped for. We don't know whether he has enough raw talent to do some truly impressive things, but even if he turns out to just be an electrician, he will at least have had the opportunity to give it his best shot.

It's ridiculous to blame the school as you do, given the information we have. Like I've said before, we've really only heard one side of the story because the school has confidentiality restrictions, as do the police to some extent. There's no reason to believe that the school in general and the engineering teacher in particular weren't supportive of Ahmed's interests.

<snip>

And here I must vociferously disagree. He took the initiative to create something, however unimpressive that creation was. His parents clearly can't provide much in the way of assistance in that department, but they do what they can, providing him tools and working with him on cars.

Worthy of encouragement, not praise. And not over-the-top praise. Some here have argued that he is being compensated for being a victim, not for doing anything wonderful. I think it's a combination, but even if it is simply compensation for victimhood, it's over-the-top. There is no evidence that Ahmed was discriminated against because of his ethnicity, and there is no evidence that he was treated poorly. Being wrongfully arrested happens to thousands of people every day, even kids barely into their teens, and our legal system already allows for remedies.

Of course I understand that this is just one of those weird viral social media thingies. And that the liberal blogosphere picked it up because they saw it as a great example of Islamophobia to highlight. Discussing that is actually what interests me most - the rush to judgment based on hearing only one side of the story, and the propagation of embellishments and hyperbole until they become such a part of conventional wisdom that to even question some of the "facts" leads to being attacked and denounced. Look at what happened to Richard Dawkins. Look at the response to the guy who made a Youtube video explaining politely that what the kid did was nonsense. Look at how detractors in this thread are treated.
 
It also needs to be presented in a way that makes it likely that people will think it's a bomb, such as saying that it's a bomb. The kid didn't do that. He in fact did the exact opposite. There is no way one can fit this event with any definition of "hoax" that I can think of.

There have been bank robbers who claimed an empty box or bag of random things was a bomb. Like most art, presentation is everything.

Ahmed had a pile of objects he claimed was a clock.
 
I won't make the same mistake I made last time, by asking to see the policy that mandates it. That time, you seemed to think I wanted you to do my research for me. This time, I will be more precise.

I don't believe you, and I will not believe you unless I see something in writing that backs you up. That's really what I meant last time, too. So, I am not asking you to do any research for me. I'm just telling you that I do not believe your assertion.

Let me explain why.

There are plenty of times teachers see things and they "don't know what it is". They aren't mandated to do anything about such things, unless they believe that student safety is threatened. In that case, they are mandated to do more than just call the police. They are mandated to take whatever measures are necessary to protect the students. In the case of your "goo" example, if they were afraid it could be toxic, protection of the other students would require them to confiscate it to ensure it couldn't be ingested. In the case of a suspected explosive, they would be mandated to clear the building or somehow make sure that, if it were an explosive, no students would be harmed when it detonated.

As has been pointed out repeatedly, they did not take such measures. They did not take those measures because they had determined there was no threat. If there is no threat to safety, there is no need to call the police, unless they suspect that there is a crime. The crime that was mentioned in this case was the creation of a hoax bomb. However, we know it was not a hoax bomb, because to be a hoax, you have to be trying to get people to believe you. He told them it was a clock.

The administration was not following policy when it called the police. The police were not following the law when they arrested the boy.



I love how you don't want to do your own research and your argument is "I don't believe you." A simple google search will pop up the schools letters home after the incident. It quite clearly spells it out there. But hey "I don't believe you" is such a better line.


You seem to be under the mistaken assumption that you were there when it happened and you have a reasonable argument. You ignore what the school stated, including a request that Ahmed's parents give them written permission to talk to the press which they have not done.

So this is utter nonsense. Yes schools are mandated to call the police if they see a suspicious item in school.

Again, this doesn't just apply to fake guns or weapons etc. It also applies to unknown liquids etc, packages that could be drugs etc.


Refusing to "believe" a fact doesn't make it not true.


Example, say a kid brings in a baggie of "Baking Soda" and wanted to use it in science class. The teacher finds it and turns it into the principal and they will indeed call the police.

What do you expect them to do, lick a pinkie and taste it to make sure that it's not cocaine???

These arguments reveal a total disconnect from the reality of what goes on in the schools.

They are not there to "figure out" gadgets, gizmos, unknown substances, weird packages, deconstructed clocks.

They are there to teach. The principals job is to ensure the safety of the students. The legal liabilities are so vast that they have enacted zero tolerance policies.

You don't believe that? Well knock yourself out then. LOL And you making up your own version of what they are mandated to do is utter nonsense. You have no idea what you are talking about.

Since you are so fond of evidence. Why don't you post your evidence for your theories about what teachers are "mandated" to do. If you do that (and actually read them) you will answer your own question.
 
Last edited:
That would make him way smarter than most people here give him credit for.
Yes, there are already some early reports that his father is a relentlessly self-improving boulangerie owner from Belgium.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom