Meadmaker
Unregistered
- Joined
- Apr 27, 2004
- Messages
- 29,033
As to how we judge his treatment by the school and police, what he actually built or didn't build is somewhat relevant. For example, the highly credible accusation that he didn't build anything worthwhile at all should lead a skeptic to question his motive for bringing his "invention" to school.
I can't really come up with an innocent motive.
I must admit that I was willing to consider (and stated here) that he might have had some less than pure motives. Fortunately, Checkmite provided the information that convinced me that there was, in fact, an innocent motive, and that it was, in reality, exactly what the kid said it was.
Checkmite noted that his electronics bench at home was filled with other equally unimpressive "inventions", that were nothing more than case mods. In other words, that's the best the kid can do. Now all he needs is a bit of encouragement and education, and maybe he can do something a bit more impressive in the future. Fortunately, despite the best efforts of MacArthur High School, he has gotten more encouragement than he could possibly have hoped for. We don't know whether he has enough raw talent to do some truly impressive things, but even if he turns out to just be an electrician, he will at least have had the opportunity to give it his best shot.
Thank you, Checkmite, for providing the needed information to put my suspicions about this kid to rest.
But he also did nothing worthy of praise either.
And here I must vociferously disagree. He took the initiative to create something, however unimpressive that creation was. His parents clearly can't provide much in the way of assistance in that department, but they do what they can, providing him tools and working with him on cars.
Hopefully, his new school has a First Robotics Program. I want kids like that on my team. I know there are teams in Irving. I hope he finds one.