Kid re-wires clock, gets suspended from school for "bomb hoax"

It's not "SECRET SOURCES" it's common sense. Stop being nonsensical. If you take money out of a school budget it's going to affect what money the school has to spend on important resources.
 
3% of a school budget is HUGE. Schools are already underfunded as it is. 15 million dollars lost from a school budget is the difference between updates computer technology in the classroom.

If the parents weren't doing a money grab they would donate it back.
Perhaps the school and district management could volunteer to be flogged instead? Thus hopefully modifying their behaviour and deterring others...
 
Looking at the actual lawsuit, it is the Irving Independent School District which is one of the named defendants. (Not Garland. My bad)

According to their 2015-16 budget (.pdf ) the percentage of one year's budget which the lawsuit would equal is about the same. If you look at the figures they also declare a $108,981,588 fund balance over and above their $381,786,119 adopted budget for the fiscal year.

This does not reflect a system so strapped for cash. It would seem that they could still manage an upgraded computer system if they really thought they needed one.

In addition, the City of Irving, TX is also a named defendant. Here's their budget (.pdf) for the same period.

So the school system wouldn't be carrying all the weight of a judgement in favor of the plaintiffs.

It looks to me like the school's kids wouldn't be so ********** after all.

But the school's admin might be a bit more careful about how they handle some disciplinary issues in the future. Which is, of course, the entire point of the lawsuit.

BTW. Are you ready to share your sources revealing how the family would spend the money yet?
Also, I assume the school district has insurance.
 
Two people have suggested this. It's an interesting point. Can someone prove that the money from lawsuits such as this are covered by insurance? I know insurance covers some things and it's possible that it would cover this. But I'd like to see evidence for that and not just speculation.
 
Two people have suggested this. It's an interesting point. Can someone prove that the money from lawsuits such as this are covered by insurance? I know insurance covers some things and it's possible that it would cover this. But I'd like to see evidence for that and not just speculation.


You didn't have a bit of trouble ignoring the evidence of the school district's own books. Why should anyone think you'd pay any attention to evidence about the sort of insurance municipal governments of any size usually get.
 
I see, so you don't have any evidence that this is true? Thanks.


Is that what you think I said?

I'm surprised that the oversized puppy hasn't leapt in to chastise you for this example of his cherished "Rule of So". But this is probably because it is actually a valid example, unlike the ones he normally singles out.

Liability insurance carried by municipalities which includes coverage against legal judgements is certainly common enough that its existence doesn't need much defending.

Since you seem to be unaware of this, here is one reference which mentions it as a common practice.

From a paper (.pdf) presented by Duke Law School on the subject of;
LIABILITY INSURANCE AND THE
TORT IMMUNITY OF STATE AND
LOCAL GOVERNMENT
​
A variety of reasons may impel government officials to purchase
liability insurance to cover immune activities:
i. The purpose of the insurance may be to obtain the carrier's
services in defending suits against the government entity.
2. The law relating to the particular activity insured may be unclear
as to the matter of immunity. The purpose of the insurance, then, may
be to place the risk of an adverse judicial determination on the carrier;
and even where immunity presently dearly attaches, the carrier wouldbear the risk that the law might be modified during the term of the
contract.
3. The purpose of the insurance may be to protect members of the
public injured by government employees.
4. Finally, the purpose of the insurance may be to protect govern-
ment agents who remain personally liable for their torts.
To satisfy the first two suggested purposes, the carrier need assume
only a limited responsibility; to achieve the last two, however, assump-
tion of full liability would be necessary. The first purpose suggested
would, in the light of the doctrine of sovereign immunity, be of little
consequence were it not coupled with a duty to investigate claims. Al-
though unnecessary for a totally immune state entity, this service would
be useful to a municipal government entity. The second purpose sug-
gested, too, would generally be entertained only by a municipal govern-
ment entity engaging in activities only partially immune. Neither of
the two purposes suggested, however, would normally appear to be of
sufficient moment to warrant the purchase of insurance. But since municipal government entities ordinarily purchase liability insurance covering nonimmune activities, coverage for immune activities might well also be included and the limited additional duties assumed by the carrier for a small extra premium charge.' 5 The difficulty of discrimi- nating the two types of activities may render this arrangement even more practical and convenient."'​

​

Whether or not the City of Irving or the Irving Independent School District have invested in such is a different issue.
 
Oh........so I was right when I said there's a difference between liability insurance for injuries on school grounds and this type of lawsuit.........imagine that. ;)
 
You do realize that other people can read and see that it says exactly what I said right?
 
For all you know, they might want the money to fund ISIS. Can you say with authority that they wouldn't?
For all you know, they might want to use the money to reach out to the Greys (they are the bad aliens, right?). Can you say with authority that they wouldn't?
 
Any word on how our budding genius is doing? He ought to be up to disassembling a toaster by now.
 
Or looked at another way, to protect the First Amendment.

Here's Popehat's take:

https://www.popehat.com/2017/01/11/clock-boy-gets-his-clock-cleaned-with-texas-anti-slapp-statute/

" it was patently opinion based on reported facts about an issue of public interest, and therefore protected by the First Amendment."

And they pretend to be lawyer or knows about law ? Libel and first amendment have nothing to do with each other. It may or may not be SLAPP (frankly after seeing what **** thrown on the family, from terrorist to diva, I tend to disagree) , but this is NOT an issue about government impacting those who spoke, it is about a private entity suing another for libel, and as such so far as I can see first amendment does not apply. First amendment does not protect you against libel in the least.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom