Kid re-wires clock, gets suspended from school for "bomb hoax"

Brown people are dangerous and should never be believed.

I think that it's that people who are treated shabbily should man up and not seek redress.

I still can't see why there's all the hate and contempt.

He's a kid who made the mistake of showing his teacher something he'd been working on. It wasn't astoundingly brilliant, but it showed interest and initiative, both of which should be fostered by a humane education system.

Any mistakes and overreactions were by his teachers and the school authorities.
 
I think that it's that people who are treated shabbily should man up and not seek redress.

I still can't see why there's all the hate and contempt.

He's a kid who made the mistake of showing his teacher something he'd been working on. It wasn't astoundingly brilliant, but it showed interest and initiative, both of which should be fostered by a humane education system.

Any mistakes and overreactions were by his teachers and the school authorities.

The US has become a very litigious place. One consequence is that it can be very expensive to just admit you were wrong. Even when you were wrong.

"I'm sorry. We overreacted. We were wrong." - an admission of guilt. Let's just see if we can bluff our way through it instead. It won't cost us any more and might cost us less.
 
The US has become a very litigious place. One consequence is that it can be very expensive to just admit you were wrong. Even when you were wrong.

"I'm sorry. We overreacted. We were wrong." - an admission of guilt. Let's just see if we can bluff our way through it instead. It won't cost us any more and might cost us less.

IIRC there was a study that showed a doctor's chance of being sued was inversely proportional to their bedside manner and had very little relationship to quality of the care.
 
I think that it's that people who are treated shabbily should man up and not seek redress.

I still can't see why there's all the hate and contempt.

He's a kid who made the mistake of showing his teacher something he'd been working on. It wasn't astoundingly brilliant, but it showed interest and initiative, both of which should be fostered by a humane education system.

Any mistakes and overreactions were by his teachers and the school authorities.

Perhaps it was just a coincidence then that his sister was suspended for making a hoax bomb threat, and the lil inventor deliberately disobeyed teachers instructions, and rather than being "inventive" it was incompetently done and in fact dangerous.
 
Perhaps it was just a coincidence then that his sister was suspended for making a hoax bomb threat, and the lil inventor deliberately disobeyed teachers instructions, and rather than being "inventive" it was incompetently done and in fact dangerous.

What is this, a skeptics forum? Get with the warm feelings already.
 
It's astounding how people just really, really hate this kid for daring to not like being mistreated.
 
It is almost as if you do not understand that the Lil Inventor and his fanatical family moved to Qatar, where I do not think that the Lil Inventor's father got a slave level job building World Cup Stadia.

Cha-Ching!

Still waiting for your point.

Brown people are dangerous and should never be believed.

I'm sure that's uncharitable. Let's wait and "see".
 
It's astounding how people just really, really hate this kid for daring to not like being mistreated.

I don't hate the kid. There's nothing to hate there.

In fact, the only thing that bugs me out of the whole mess is the idea that we can sue our way to justice.
 
I was a big Ahmed supporter, but the idea that he deserves 15 million dollars for his trouble is ludicrous.

I'm not sure why there needs to be any money involved at all.
 
The US has become a very litigious place. One consequence is that it can be very expensive to just admit you were wrong. Even when you were wrong.

"I'm sorry. We overreacted. We were wrong." - an admission of guilt. Let's just see if we can bluff our way through it instead. It won't cost us any more and might cost us less.


This is pretty much IT in a nutshell. I recently had to explain this to a woman whose son was killed when the car he was in was in a fender bender. They pulled off on the side of a road, unfortunately by a curve, and an off duty police officer came flying around the curve and hit the young man while he was standing outside the car.

The police officer sued the guy driving the car. His mother was devastated and couldn't believe that he would sue the driver after he killed someone. But I told her his lawyers probably made him do it to avoid the appearance of guilt.

He couldn't just come up to her and say he felt bad. He couldn't even give his condolences. It's amazing how the world has changed in common decency because of the litigious nature of our country. So sad.
 
I think that it's that people who are treated shabbily should man up and not seek redress.

I still can't see why there's all the hate and contempt.

He's a kid who made the mistake of showing his teacher something he'd been working on. It wasn't astoundingly brilliant, but it showed interest and initiative, both of which should be fostered by a humane education system.

Any mistakes and overreactions were by his teachers and the school authorities.

You don't believe there is a possibility the boy purposely did things and answered questions in a manner that caused the teachers and school authorities to react the way they did? You don't believe it is possible that based upon things we don't know maybe their decisions were not mistakes?
 
You don't believe there is a possibility the boy purposely did things and answered questions in a manner that caused the teachers and school authorities to react the way they did? You don't believe it is possible that based upon things we don't know maybe their decisions were not mistakes?

Deliberately having brown skin at school.
 
Deliberately having brown skin at school.

Of course it couldn't be anything else.

ETA: I didn't ask if it might have been that the school acting improperly based upon he looked like a "possible terrorist" to the teacher and /or school officials involved. Of course that is a possibility. I asked if it is possible the boy purposely did things and answered questions in a manner that caused the teachers and school authorities to react the way they did.
I believe this is also a real possibility. I believe the school stated there are other circumstances that were not released because of privacy issues.
 
Last edited:
I mentioned this before. I don't understand WHY everyone is jumping on the fact that the kid was "brown skinned" is what caused the teacher to react in such a way. In my opinion it reveals the unconscious racism of the people saying it. ( I say this as a mother of a kid that looks just like Ahmed. People always think they are being PC when they say stupid things like this, but in my opinion you sound more racist than the person you are accusing. What does his SKIN color have to do with anything? What does his religion have to do with anything? Who is the real bigot here?)

The vast majority of school shootings were done by WHITE students. So are you suggesting that if the teacher went up to a white kid who set something up that looked suspicious to her, she'd just pat him on the head and walk away?

If the kid was in a science or engineering class, or if the teacher herself was some sort of mechanically inclined person, then it's possible that once the teacher knew what it was she'd tell him "Unplug your toy Ahmend and get back to work."

The fact that she didn't know what it was means she was required to turn it into the principal.

Even if she knew that it was harmless, it was a handmade electronic device. Kids make mistakes. The device could have sparked up and started a fire.

Then she'd be getting in trouble for not being responsible enough to look out for the safety of the students in the classroom.

This is why they will not win a lawsuit against the school even though they might win one against the police officers. And this is probably why they are suing for so much money. They hope a "settlement" will net them a million if they sue for over 10 million.
 
Last edited:
so the kid's family is suing for an outrageous amount over a genuine, if overblown, incident? Looks like they assimilated well to the US and our ways to me!
 
I mentioned this before. I don't understand WHY everyone is jumping on the fact that the kid was "brown skinned" is what caused the teacher to react in such a way. In my opinion it reveals the unconscious racism of the people saying it. ( I say this as a mother of a kid that looks just like Ahmed. People always think they are being PC when they say stupid things like this, but in my opinion you sound more racist than the person you are accusing. What does his SKIN color have to do with anything? What does his religion have to do with anything? Who is the real bigot here?)
I usually suspect that is the reason. Another option is it fits their narrative.

I say this as the father of a "brown skinned" daughter, a Korean son, and another daughter who is fair skinned but has a few times been mistaken for middle eastern descent.

There is no question in my mind the first teacher did the correct thing. A reasonable assumption for that teacher was either it was made to look like a bomb or it could be a real bomb.
After that it gets a little blurry for me.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom