Kid re-wires clock, gets suspended from school for "bomb hoax"

I wouldn't be surprised if Ahmed actually was trying to prank his classmates that morning but didn't anticipate the overblown reaction from the principal. It seems he'd pulled some stuff in the past, like:

Ask at Sam Houston Middle School, where the boy from Sudan mastered electronics and English, once built a remote control to prank the classroom projector and bragged of reciting his First Amendment rights in the principal’s office.

It’s also the school where Ahmed racked up weeks of suspensions, became convinced an administrator had it in for him and — before he left for the high school where he turned famous — prompted Irving ISD to review claims of anti-Muslim bullying.

If you want to know about the boy before the fame, ask Ralph Kubiak: Ahmed’s seventh-grade history teacher and fellow outsider.

“He was a weird little kid,” said Kubiak, now 62 and retired. “I saw a lot of him in me. That thirst for knowledge … he’s one of those kids that could either be CEO of a company or head of a gang.”

http://www.dallasnews.com/news/comm...tic-inventions-and-a-fight-with-authority.ece

There's more at the link but it pretty much sounds like Ahmed was a bit of a prankster and a little annoying but overall a smart kid who wanted to fit in. He even rigged up a cell phone charger for a teacher. He may also have been bullied. And some of the bullying may have happened because he was Muslim. According to Ahmed, students called him "Bacon Boy", "Sausage Boy" and "ISIS Boy."

If the principal was concerned about the students' safety why didn't he pull the fire alarm and evacuate the school? A detention or suspension (which he got anyway) would have been punishment enough, even under the school's "hoax bomb" policy.

Last year Ibrahim Ahmad*, a high school kid here in Washington State followed a tradition of asking a date to the prom in a creative way by strapping a phony bomb to himself. She said yes but he got suspended and banned from the prom. Ahmad said he felt the suspension was a little racist, the school superintendent was furious over his actions but somehow school, student and parents managed to work through it. No police necessary. And no 15 million dollars.

* http://www.columbian.com/news/2015/apr/22/la-center-high-school-prom-bomb/
 
Last edited:
I usually suspect that is the reason. Another option is it fits their narrative.

I say this as the father of a "brown skinned" daughter, a Korean son, and another daughter who is fair skinned but has a few times been mistaken for middle eastern descent.

There is no question in my mind the first teacher did the correct thing. A reasonable assumption for that teacher was either it was made to look like a bomb or it could be a real bomb.
After that it gets a little blurry for me.


It's interesting that you and I have the same take on this. I wonder if the people who keep mentioning that it was because he had "brown skin" actually has any real experience with brown skinned people or they are just a token for their outrage that they like to throw around. It's pretty annoying.
 
I wouldn't be surprised if Ahmed actually was trying to prank his classmates that morning but didn't anticipate the overblown reaction from the principal. It seems he'd pulled some stuff in the past, like:



http://www.dallasnews.com/news/comm...tic-inventions-and-a-fight-with-authority.ece

There's more at the link but it pretty much sounds like Ahmed was a bit of a prankster and a little annoying but overall a smart kid who wanted to fit in. He even rigged up a cell phone charger for a teacher. He may also have been bullied. And some of the bullying may have happened because he was Muslim. According to Ahmed, students called him "Bacon Boy", "Sausage Boy" and "ISIS Boy."

If the principal was concerned about the students' safety why didn't he pull the fire alarm and evacuate the school? A detention or suspension (which he got anyway) would have been punishment enough, even under the school's "hoax bomb" policy.

Last year Ibrahim Ahmad*, a high school kid here in Washington State followed a tradition of asking a date to the prom in a creative way by strapping a phony bomb to himself. She said yes but he got suspended and banned from the prom. Ahmad said he felt the suspension was a little racist, the school superintendent was furious over his actions but somehow school, student and parents managed to work through it. No police necessary. And no 15 million dollars.

* http://www.columbian.com/news/2015/apr/22/la-center-high-school-prom-bomb/


The fact that the principal didn't ought to confirm to you all that they didn't think it was a bomb. Hello? Cognitive dissonance much?
 
so the kid's family is suing for an outrageous amount over a genuine, if overblown, incident? Looks like they assimilated well to the US and our ways to me!


As a percentage of the yearly budget for the Garland Independent School District, how outrageous is it?

I make it about 3%. (GISD 2015-16 budget (.pdf))

The primary purpose of such a lawsuit is not to enrich the plaintiffs but rather to discourage the defendants from repeating or continuing demonstrably bad practices.

3% of one year's budget hardly ranks as "outrageous".

'Slap on the wrist' seems like a more appropriate description.

I wonder if that is even enough to encourage them to change their ways?
 
3% of a school budget is HUGE. Schools are already underfunded as it is. 15 million dollars lost from a school budget is the difference between updates computer technology in the classroom.

If the parents weren't doing a money grab they would donate it back.
 
As a percentage of the yearly budget for the Garland Independent School District, how outrageous is it?

I make it about 3%. (GISD 2015-16 budget (.pdf))

The primary purpose of such a lawsuit is not to enrich the plaintiffs but rather to discourage the defendants from repeating or continuing demonstrably bad practices.

3% of one year's budget hardly ranks as "outrageous".

'Slap on the wrist' seems like a more appropriate description.

I wonder if that is even enough to encourage them to change their ways?

OK, it's a small percentage. Fair enough. I wonder how many programs that would fund? I'd call it more than a "slap on the wrist" but I agree with you that it's not an "outrageous amount."
 
As a percentage of the yearly budget for the Garland Independent School District, how outrageous is it?

I make it about 3%. (GISD 2015-16 budget (.pdf))

The primary purpose of such a lawsuit is not to enrich the plaintiffs but rather to discourage the defendants from repeating or continuing demonstrably bad practices.

3% of one year's budget hardly ranks as "outrageous".

'Slap on the wrist' seems like a more appropriate description.

I wonder if that is even enough to encourage them to change their ways?

I feel considering what harm was actually done and what wrongs may have been done the amount is outrageous.

But assuming real wrongs were done and the school actually has policies that could and should be changed the money will do little to causing the change.
If when all the facts are known people could actually be singled out who acted improperly they should be punished and trained.

The only people who would probably suffer are kids in programs that may be cut. Although I wonder if districts have insurance that cover these types of things.
 
3% of a school budget is HUGE. Schools are already underfunded as it is. 15 million dollars lost from a school budget is the difference between updates computer technology in the classroom.

If the parents weren't doing a money grab they would donate it back.


You already know what they plan to do with it?

Want to share your sources?
 
I know what most schools do with their budgets and how much they spend. It's the equivalent of an upgraded computer program for the schools.

But hey, Mohammed got upset so **** the kids right? Let's make sure Mohammed gets his money.
 
Where did you learn what they plan to do with the money if they get it?

What are you suggesting that they are going to do with the school's 3 percent of its budget (too bad they were not temporarily irritated by Apple, cha-Ching)?

Give me it back or something?
 
3% of a school budget is HUGE. Schools are already underfunded as it is. 15 million dollars lost from a school budget is the difference between updates computer technology in the classroom.

If the parents weren't doing a money grab they would donate it back.

I know what most schools do with their budgets and how much they spend. It's the equivalent of an upgraded computer program for the schools.

But hey, Mohammed got upset so **** the kids right? Let's make sure Mohammed gets his money.


Looking at the actual lawsuit, it is the Irving Independent School District which is one of the named defendants. (Not Garland. My bad)

According to their 2015-16 budget (.pdf ) the percentage of one year's budget which the lawsuit would equal is about the same. If you look at the figures they also declare a $108,981,588 fund balance over and above their $381,786,119 adopted budget for the fiscal year.

This does not reflect a system so strapped for cash. It would seem that they could still manage an upgraded computer system if they really thought they needed one.

In addition, the City of Irving, TX is also a named defendant. Here's their budget (.pdf) for the same period.

So the school system wouldn't be carrying all the weight of a judgement in favor of the plaintiffs.

It looks to me like the school's kids wouldn't be so ********** after all.

But the school's admin might be a bit more careful about how they handle some disciplinary issues in the future. Which is, of course, the entire point of the lawsuit.

BTW. Are you ready to share your sources revealing how the family would spend the money yet?
 
Last edited:
What are you suggesting that they are going to do with the school's 3 percent of its budget (too bad they were not temporarily irritated by Apple, cha-Ching)?

Give me it back or something?


I'm not suggesting anything. What gave you the idea I was?

All I did was question how tt knows what they plan to do with it.

Can you answer that question for her? If not, what is the point of your comment?

For all I know they might plan to set up a fund to help mistreated minority students who suffer abusive treatment from school systems and law enforcement.

Can you say with authority that they wouldn't?
 
Probably because your argument makes absolutely no sense. It's easy to understand that if money is part of a school budget and schools are underfunded then taking part of the school budget it going to be taking money AWAY from the students. It's going to hurt the students whether it's computers, text books, teachers, lunch, gym equipment, 15 million dollars pays for a lot.
 
Probably because your argument makes absolutely no sense. It's easy to understand that if money is part of a school budget and schools are underfunded then taking part of the school budget it going to be taking money AWAY from the students. It's going to hurt the students whether it's computers, text books, teachers, lunch, gym equipment, 15 million dollars pays for a lot.
Aren't things like lawsuit settlements often covered by insurance?
 
What are you suggesting that they are going to do with the school's 3 percent of its budget (too bad they were not temporarily irritated by Apple, cha-Ching)?

Give me it back or something?

You are unenlightened. Here is the way of the true skeptic:

1) Assume the best of the family
2) Assume the worst of the school district
3) Attack air marshals on sight
 
Aren't things like lawsuit settlements often covered by insurance?

I forgot that lawyers are free! And not all settlements are covered by insurance. If a kid fell down the stairs, that's different.

But that kind of argument is similar to someone saying it's OK to shoplift from Target because it's a multibillion dollar corporation.
 
Last edited:
I forgot that lawyers are free! And not all settlements are covered by insurance. If a kid fell down the stairs, that's different.

But that kind of argument is similar to someone saying it's OK to shoplift from Target because it's a multibillion dollar corporation.

Sure, as long as you don't overdo it. All things in moderation.
 
I'm not suggesting anything. What gave you the idea I was?

All I did was question how tt knows what they plan to do with it.

Can you answer that question for her? If not, what is the point of your comment?

For all I know they might plan to set up a fund to help mistreated minority students who suffer abusive treatment from school systems and law enforcement.

Can you say with authority that they wouldn't?

For all you know, they might want the money to fund ISIS. Can you say with authority that they wouldn't?
 
Probably because your argument makes absolutely no sense. It's easy to understand that if money is part of a school budget and schools are underfunded then taking part of the school budget it going to be taking money AWAY from the students. It's going to hurt the students whether it's computers, text books, teachers, lunch, gym equipment, 15 million dollars pays for a lot.


Except that I just demonstrated to you that this school doesn't appear to be underfunded. Not according to their own books.

So your initial premise is wrong. Who's not making sense?

Typical "think of the children" misdirection. Based on nothing.

Very underhanded tactic.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom