Rolfe, I can understand that completely but it started to look a little spooky.
Are you a Brit then?
BTW thanks a lot for replying so courteously and shaming me for being so harsh on you!
Oh, no offence taken. I can see the whole thing did look distinctly stalker-ish. However, two points. First, he got me a bit narked. And second, that information was exceedingly easy to come by.
I don't give a monkey's who any poster is, what their income is, or what sort of house they live in, until they start lying about it. And Malcolm, the ur-Truther, has been lying a lot.
He started that thread with the most jaw-dropping fantasy you've ever seen. The bits about the paedophile rings and the celebrity golf tournament were particularly inventive. But at the same time he announced that he was a recently-retired successful businessman, had an honours degree in Law, was extremely rich, had a very expensive car, was a member of Mensa, and had lived for a considerable time in the US. It all sounded a bit implausible, and frankly I didn't believe a word of it. The getting narked started when he announced,
a propos of nothing, that he could buy my house out from under me. I'd just completed the purchase of a new home, for quite a lot of money, and this got under my skin a bit. I also realised that while he was merrily assuming everyone on the forum was American, his speech patterns and attitudes suggested he was English.
If you'd seen anything I've posted in politics, you'd realise I'm a dedicated Scottish Nationalist. One day, "British" will have the same connotation as "Scandinavian", I hope. But even then, we'll be on the same island and have a lot in common, and the idea that Malcolm was perhaps only 200 miles away was a bit creepy. Even an Englishman making such a comprehensive fool of himself is not a pretty sight for any inhabitant of this land mass.
William--
Kudos on softening your views on Rolfe's behavior when shown additional evidence. I don't know if you've been following Malcolm's thread, but if you haven't, perhaps reading some of it would give you an idea of how incredibly obnoxious he can be.
Well, yes. It really got going when he announced that a certain picture of an emergency medical team in action must have been staged because someone was holding up an i/v bag.
Malcolm: Those bags are mildly pressurised and will work equally well above or below the patient. Holding high such bags was for films and TV only. .... What do you think I thought when I first saw the bagman?
What do you think every doctor, nurse, medic, paramedic etc in the world will also think when they see that?
Lots of posters, including me (at this point those with medical qualifications had not revealed these): No, Malcolm, that's the normal way they work, really.
Malcolm: This is a combined post to yourself, Rolfe and any other drip feeds.
Now I remember why I never fancied being a schoolteacher.
Altogether now, after me,
In order to have GRAVITY feed, you must first have GRAVITY.
No BIG hole in the top of the bag = no chance for GRAVITY to act = the photo is staged.
fls: I am a physician with tons of experience using IV's. .... It is usual and expected to hold up the IV bag. In fact, I might suspect the scene was staged if I
didn't see the iv bag held up, as it would be the automatic response.
Malcolm: 24 carat nonsense. In order for gravity to work, you need a source of GRAVITY.
Me: I'm a vet. And have extensive experience using these i/v infusions .... These bags have to be held up in order to work properly. .....
That's why not a single medic or vet or paramedic or firstaider on this forum or anywhere else thinks there's anything even slightly strange about the scene.
Malcolm: You're throwing your 'qualifications' about. I daresay some one here would call it an 'argument from authority'.
I call it attempting to win an arguement by demanding respect from a position of elitism.
Huntsman: I was a military medic for 14 years, including a recent deployment into Iraq for a year. I gave IVs there. They were gravity fed, and don't have holes in the tops of bags....
Malcolm: You won't mind joining forces with the vet then will you and we'll see who is ignorant and uneducated.
I refer you to my previous post and look forward to cleaning your clock along with the many others who slide away, either permanently or until they think the subject matter has changed sufficiently for them to have another go.
Anything but tell the truth and anything but face the truth.
And there was at least one other trained paramedic and several people with hospital experience who were all treated the same way. Then we got into the whole thing about needing a hole to let gravity in, and there being no gravity inside a TV.
So, narked. I admit it.
Even though he finally agreed that i/v bags are normally held up, he still refused point-blank to agree that they didn't need big holes in the top to let the gravity in, or that there is normal gravity inside a TV tube.
Wondering just who this maroon actually was, I idly Googled his name. And discovered that by a weird chance, he was the only person of that name, possibly in the world. And that it appeared to be him who featured in the only non-CT link appearing, a reference to his having been in court for insolvency relating to mortgage arrears.
Spitfire was the genius who found the main judgement in the case, and pointed out the judge's summing-up of the debating skills of Mr. Kirkman, who was representing himself.
Lord Justice Aldous said:
He lacks the ability to explain the matter so that a judge can understand it. .... I must urge Mr Kirkham to obtain legal advice. Having heard him address this Court, I have a feeling that, if he does not do so, it is likely his appeal will fail.
This lot was such comprehensive proof that Malcolm, the arch-Truther, had been telling a pack of lies, that I have to admit to succumbing to schadenfreude at this point. It was now clear that far from being a rich and successful businessman, Malcolm had lost his job and then lost his house to the mortgage lender because of arrears, and far from having an honours degree in Law he was an incompetent litigant-in-person.
Since he had also posted by then that he was located in or near Manchester, it was the work of seconds with the 192.com directory and Google maps to find his address and telephone number, who he lives with, and images of his house. Just to confirm that it wasn't a neighbourhood full of millionnaire businessmen. No, just a modest little street of modest little houses.
After very unconvincingly trying to pretend that actually that wasn't his real name, and getting his forum name changed, he just put everyone who had made the above points on ignore, and carried on.
I think he imagines if he can't see the posts pointing out his boastful lies, then nobody else can. He's broken my irony meter several times.
You will find no trickery of any kind with me. I have no need to play word games or anything else, I have the truth on my side. What you see is what you get....
You will find no tricks at all.
And so it goes on.
Don't care where he lives, and I'm sure it's a perfectly pleasant neighbourhood. Do care a lot that he lies about his personal circumstances, his finances, and his qualifications.
So, I've probably finished venting by now. But honestly, that was the easiest debunking of a pack of lies I've ever been a party to. And that includes Dana Ullman on Oliver Wendell Holmes Sr., but that's a whole other ball game.
Rolfe.