Journalist attacked by violent mob

White supremacists are scum and antifa are scum.

They kind of cancel each other out in a way.

When you take a ****, do you flush or do you take another **** on top of it to get rid of it?

So no, they don't " cancell each other out" , they are 2 turds in the same bowl. Nice try.
 
Lots of focus on what the anti-fascists were wearing and carrying in that article. The Proud Boys were carrying shields, weapons and wearing helmets as well. Might just want to mention that, for balance if nothing else.

Seems a smart idea of people are planning on attacking you. And as we can see there have been plenty of food based attacks. That are quickly escalating.

How dare people with unpopular opinion defend themselves.
 
They could start by suspending the praxis of giving demonstration permits to extreme right wing groups who only come to Portland because they know there will be violence. What these groups are doing have nothing to do with freedom of speech or the right to peacfully demonstrate, and everything to do with wanting to win a street fight over "leftists".

If they didn't engage in violence there would be none. Don't use abusive husband logic to make a point " you kept piss in me off so I had to hit you.". Grow up,violence isn't an appropriate response to speech.
 
I should probably be grateful. Portland is becoming the the magnet for all these violent nutjobs, so the rest of our cities don't have to deal with it nearly as much.

My prediction: Antifa will continue with the sticks and stones approach, injuring many but likely not killing any. Same for Patriot Prayer and their associates. Portland PD will continue to do nothing. Given their proclivity to bring guns, some goon from Patriot Prayer or some other right-wing group will eventually shoot some folks during a skirmish, and the policy will change.

If they didn't engage in violence there would be none. Don't use abusive husband logic to make a point " you kept piss in me off so I had to hit you.". Grow up,violence isn't an appropriate response to speech.

Illiberalism is the new-hotness.
 
Last edited:
How do you know what Andy Ngo has done? He's being portrayed as some journalist who just happened to be targeted by Antifa - something that is far from a given. He's a right wing agitator who regularly join extreme right wingers when they come to Portland to fight. He's not a journalist.



I don't know. I know from personal experience that crowd control of this kind is difficult. I also know that the best way to get it to stop is to stop handing out permits. The police know why the Nazis are coming to Portland. They are coming to fight.

Let's get rid off free speech and freedom of assembly.

But not for us, for those. ...other people.

You seem really eager to give up rights when they are not yours.
 
I'll give them a free pass to fight fascists, because that means someone does it. Law enforcement won't give them a free pass, however, and they should face punishment for what they do.

That makes you a hypocrite. You want groups of thugs to do what you want because you wouldn't give up your own right to protest which is what would happen if a law to do what you want was enacted, as in North America we don't make laws by someone's political beliefs.

My god, how do you see yourself as the good guy here you literally said " I don't care if other people do harm or get arrested as long as they fight my battles for me and I don't have to give anything up. ".
 
I love how "Letting Nazis keep marching in the streets" isn't "escalation" but marching against the Nazis is.

It's the same way someone punching you in the face over and over isn't "escalating" the fight but you hitting them back is.

No is more like how if someone calls you an ******* you are expected to not punch them in the face, but good try.
 
I really, really though that the "Paradox of Tolerance" was something everyone at least understood, even if they didn't completely agree with it.

Side A: "We want to kill all the Jews and impose a white supremacist genocidal government and we will use any measure to make that happen."
Side B: "We would rather you.... ya know NOT do that and we will use any measure to make that NOT happen."
Side C: "I can see no difference between Side's A and B. Why do you hate free speech?"
 
It might be if you were wearing an expensive suit or dress.

I just meant in terms of it being terrorism.


Please, everyone just stop quoting and responding to my recent posts. I take back every single thing I said in the last few days. I have tried to explain that I'm having a breakdown. I want to still be able to visit the forum, but if I have to keep cleaning up messes and fighting with people, I won't be able to. And then I won't have any space at all. Please, take pity on me.

Everyone seems to think I am their enemy because I am trying to be nobody's enemy.

I guess I didn't think of the expensive clothes thing because I wear rags.


EDIT: Like seriously, I just read my post over, and most of it was CRITICIZING antifa. And I've since been criticized for that. But you find the one remark that tried to balance things out and throw it back in my face
 
Last edited:
I really, really though that the "Paradox of Tolerance" was something everyone at least understood, even if they didn't completely agree with it.

Side A: "We want to kill all the Jews and impose a white supremacist genocidal government and we will use any measure to make that happen."
Side B: "We would rather you.... ya know NOT do that and we will use any measure to make that NOT happen."
Side C: "I can see no difference between Side's A and B. Why do you hate free speech?"

If I said I was a supervillian does that give you the right to beat me up because your city is in danger?

You have every right to stop them from enacting their plans, you don't have every right to stop them from talking about how big and scary they are.

That is a free society, they are allowed to swing their fist wherever they like, you can react if it connects.
 
You have every right to stop them from enacting their plans, you don't have every right to stop them from talking about how big and scary they are.

Oh I get it. You live in a fantasy world where "gather support and gain legitimacy" isn't "part of the plan."

But this board has taught me to try and find a girl that looks at you the way "free speech supporters" look at Nazis, so there's that.
 
I just meant in terms of it being terrorism.


Please, everyone just stop quoting and responding to my recent posts. I take back every single thing I said in the last few days. I have tried to explain that I'm having a breakdown. I want to still be able to visit the forum, but if I have to keep cleaning up messes and fighting with people, I won't be able to. And then I won't have any space at all. Please, take pity on me.

Everyone seems to think I am their enemy because I am trying to be nobody's enemy.

I guess I didn't think of the expensive clothes thing because I wear rags.

Hey man, take this from a social worker and someone who has been there, avoid posting here when you are in legit mental trouble. This place is the cheap whiskey of forums, fun when you are doing okay, horrible when you are going through mental issues.

No idea of our interactions in the past or your political leaning but if talking to a low level professional could help ( obviously in an unofficial capacity) send me a pm and I'll send you my Facebook info. My inbox here is a godawful mess but I'd be more than happy to listen.

And legit, don't care how your politics are, if I can help I will.
 
Oh I get it. You live in a fantasy world where "gather support and gain legitimacy" isn't "part of the plan."

But this board has taught me to try and find a girl that looks at you the way "free speech supporters" look at Nazis, so there's that.

It is, but it's the legal part.

You don't get self defense for punching someone when they say they have scary friends.

You don't get to stop a mugger when he is just walking on the sidewalk behind you.

That is a free society, you are protected by the law till you break it.
 
I really, really though that the "Paradox of Tolerance" was something everyone at least understood, even if they didn't completely agree with it.

Side A: "We want to kill all the Jews and impose a white supremacist genocidal government and we will use any measure to make that happen."
Side B: "We would rather you.... ya know NOT do that and we will use any measure to make that NOT happen."
Side C: "I can see no difference between Side's A and B. Why do you hate free speech?"

That "paradox of tolerance" idea sure is a nice handy way to ignore those pesky free speech rules...
 
Side A: "We want to kill all the Jews and impose a white supremacist genocidal government and we will use any measure to make that happen."
Side B: "We would rather you.... ya know NOT do that and we will use any measure to make that NOT happen."
Side C: "I can see no difference between Side's A and B. Why do you hate free speech?"

Where does Andy Ngo fall in this?
 
That "paradox of tolerance" idea sure is a nice handy way to ignore those pesky free speech rules...

The converse of that is actually being prepared.

If people actually feared groups of nazis roaming about they would arm and patrol their neighborhoods. But they know there is no legit threat, but they also want to punch someone they don't like so suddenly they are super scared of words.
 
It is, but it's the legal part.

You don't get self defense for punching someone when they say they have scary friends.

You don't get to stop a mugger when he is just walking on the sidewalk behind you.

That is a free society, you are protected by the law till you break it.

A few points.

- "Free Society" can't be demanded to a Bob-level "You don't really believe in it until you believe in so much it doesn't actually work." This idea that until I'm ready to watch someone else (never me oddly enough but someone else) be hurt by someone else's "free speech" I just don't believe in it enough does not sit particularly well with me.

- Belief in freedom of speech/expression is not a game of who can defend the most vile ideologies the most.

But those points are mostly academic and about the argument more then anything. There is a core, actual real world distinctioin I think it would help us to address.

To put it broadly (and I'll expand on this, give me a moment) you see Nazism (and other extreme ideologies) as declarations of unpopular opinions, while I see them as declarations of dangerous intent.

You've used the "You can't act until X" metaphor using crimes and while I actually don't think that metaphor works 100%, let offer you counterpoint using that I think does illustrate what I'm talking about.

No, if you stand on the corner holding a sign saying "I'm a bastard" I don't "get" to punch you.

If you stand on the stand on the street corner and declare your intent to commit a crime in the immediate future, we are allowed to react.

Even in legal systems with the broadest practical application of free speech, the concept of "a threat" exists in some way.

You can spout of unpopular opinions in societies that value "free speech." You cannot (nuances and hair splitting of exact circumstances aside) make threats.

In my opinion declaring yourself a Nazi is making a threat, not stating an opinion. You don't have to agree with this, but can you at least now see the distinction that I see?
 
Last edited:
Where does Andy Ngo fall in this?

I don't care.

Again, for the 50th billionth time on this board "LOOKIT LOOKIT I CAN HANDWRING OVER WHERE THE LINE EXACTLY IS!" doesn't impress me and doesn't change my opinion about things.

If I have a pitch black color swatch and a pure white color swatch you screaming "BUT LOOK IT THIS LIGHT GREY ONE AND THIS DARK GREY ONE! WHERE IS THE LINE!!!!!????" doesn't change anything.
 
Last edited:
Oh I get it. You live in a fantasy world where "gather support and gain legitimacy" isn't "part of the plan."

But this board has taught me to try and find a girl that looks at you the way "free speech supporters" look at Nazis, so there's that.

This board has taught me to find a girl that looks at me the way leftists look at violence, so there's that.

Is that an accurate description of your position? You like violence against your opponents? Probably not. That's probably a gross misrepresentation of what you really believe. But that's exactly what you're doing here, presenting a gross misrepresentation of your opponents.

You are capable of making better arguments than this. I've seen it before. But you're failing badly here.
 
You like violence against your opponents?

Opponents? No.

Enemies. Yes.

I'll now stand back so I don't get hit with "OOOOHOHHH LOOOOORDY BUT WHERE DO WE DRAW THE LINE!" shrapnel and surely some form of "WHATABOUT THE LEFT!" whataboutism ricochets.

I have not a ******* clue where we draw the line nor do I care. I know which side the group we've already fought the biggest war in history against is on.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom