It is, but it's the legal part.
You don't get self defense for punching someone when they say they have scary friends.
You don't get to stop a mugger when he is just walking on the sidewalk behind you.
That is a free society, you are protected by the law till you break it.
A few points.
- "Free Society" can't be demanded to a Bob-level "You don't really believe in it until you believe in so much it doesn't actually work." This idea that until I'm ready to watch someone else (never me oddly enough but someone else) be hurt by someone else's "free speech" I just don't believe in it enough does not sit particularly well with me.
- Belief in freedom of speech/expression is not a game of who can defend the most vile ideologies the most.
But those points are mostly academic and about the argument more then anything. There is a core, actual real world distinctioin I think it would help us to address.
To put it broadly (and I'll expand on this, give me a moment) you see Nazism (and other extreme ideologies) as declarations of unpopular opinions, while I see them as declarations of dangerous intent.
You've used the "You can't act until X" metaphor using crimes and while I actually don't think that metaphor works 100%, let offer you counterpoint using that I think does illustrate what I'm talking about.
No, if you stand on the corner holding a sign saying "I'm a bastard" I don't "get" to punch you.
If you stand on the stand on the street corner and declare your intent to commit a crime in the immediate future, we are allowed to react.
Even in legal systems with the broadest practical application of free speech, the concept of "a threat" exists in some way.
You can spout of unpopular opinions in societies that value "free speech." You cannot (nuances and hair splitting of exact circumstances aside) make threats.
In my opinion declaring yourself a Nazi is making a threat, not stating an opinion. You don't have to agree with this, but can you at least now see the distinction that
I see?