Journalist attacked by violent mob

Like the bullets at Balaklava!

The point is figuring out who is Antifa or antifa. If you're seriously proposing to name a group as terrorists, you have to be able to identify that group. People what act up in demonstrations are already subject to various laws. Can we name All Bigots as terrorists?

My point is not that they're right or wrong, but that with no formal organization, rules, by-laws, etc... WHO ARE YOU GOING TO "NAME" AS A TERRORIST ORGANIZATION. It's a group heading an encompasses all sorts of splinter groups around the world.

There are laws against what just happened in Portland. Naming one side in a political fracas as Terrorists is absurd.

Can we name all bigots as terrorists?

You and folks like you have been giving it your best effort.

Funny how when the shoe is on the other foot nuance is suddenly a thing. Almost like you view yourself as human. .. and the bigots as something else.
 
Milkshakes are harmless they said.

I'd like to point out that I, many times have pointed out that is only going to be a matter of time before milkshakes and eggs become objects designed to look like milkshakes and eggs.

And also I was told consistently this was stupid, and there is zero danger in acts like this. One poster even saying getting angry at it would be an extreme over reaction and that most people would smile back.

You can smile at assault all you want, personally I'd treat it like the attack it is.
 
What's been established time and time again is that liberals are possessed of 'moral relativism'. It isn't new, or unique to liberals, it's afflicted the morally-deficient and weak-minded throughout history.

That'll be those that, upon hearing my opinion that egging/milkshaking is assault, tagged me as a useful idiot for organised alt-right parties and a supporter and enabler for N(n)azis.
 
Hmm. Whether it's spelled with a capital letter or a lower-case letter seems like a weird point to focus on. Wikipedia spells it with a capital letter last time I checked.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antifa_(United_States)

Along the lines of "missing the point" I'd add that you've overlooked that that articles spells it with lowercase "a" many of the times it uses the word. The vast majority if you discount the times where it capitalized merely for being the first word of the sentence. The reason for that has been explained.
 
Last edited:
White supremacists are scum and antifa are scum.

They kind of cancel each other out in a way.
 
Terrorists don't break store windows and loot and assault people, they blow up buildings and hijack planes and kill people. Not all political violence is terrorism, you don't have to misapply the term "terrorism" in order to condemn bad behavior.

Yes.
 
I don't think violence solves anything,


Except for WWII, the American Civil War, numerous anti-imperialist uprisings, countless instances of self-defense, and so on. "Violence, naked force, has settled more issues in history than has any other factor."

I'm not going to say that every instance of antifa activists' use of force is productive, or even justified; but when you're facing an enemy who does not even acknowledge your humanity, who would be perfectly happy to kill you or otherwise make it so that you simply do not exist in their world, well you do what you do to ensure that you and those like you continue to survive.

And it's a very privileged position to sit back, ignore history, and say "Well, violence never solves anything, and both sides are the same," when you're not the target of the fascists and bigots who are trying to eliminate your very existence, or at best turn you into a slave and treat you as less than an animal. Non-violence in the face of an enemy who does not acknowledge your humanity is not noble, it's suicidal.

The problem with antifa is that it's a myriad of very different people, from very different backgrouns, with differing worldviews, and no coherent philosophy or strategy aside from "resist those who are trying to destroy us with whatever means we have". That means that different groups will have different ideas on how to accomplish their goals, and the fact that many tend to over-react to such a threat is hardly unexpected, and more a result of having more passion than experience. Branding them as "terrorists" is at best a gross misunderstanding of both antifa's purpose and the purpose of terrorism.

While it's critical to be judicious in the use of violent force, it's still a very important and valuable tool against those who would use violent force to erase you entirely. What antifa activists need is a regular organization with a coherent purpose and strong, charismatic leadership. Someone like Dr. King or Malcom X, Harvey Milk or Huey Newton. Or, ideally, all of the above.
 
Last edited:
Also the "cement in the milkshake" claim is one of the oddest things I've heard in a while, and anyone who has accepted it without evidence needs to improve their skepticism.
 
Jo Brand (who I once saw at a pub gig "before she was famous" and chatted with at the bar) recently made an edgy joke about "milkshaking" which many people didn't, er, get;

"... but I think that's because certain unpleasant characters are being thrown to the fore and they're very, very easy to hate.
And I'm kind of thinking, 'why bother with a milkshake when you could get some battery acid?'
I'm not going to do it, it's purely a fantasy, but I think milkshakes are pathetic, I honestly do, sorry
."

This rather demonstrates that the saying liberalism is mental illness is more than a pithy throwaway, it's demonstrably true, practically an aphorism.

I have no doubt that Jo Brand is a genuinely well-meaning person, a "nice" person as all liberals imagine themselves to be, and she's no dunce, but here she was blissfully unaware of the stark, almost deranged example of the moral relativism of liberalism she'd just mouthed.

It seems to take over the minds of those who submit to it, and is not unlike the 'submissiveness' to Islam that allows Muslims to hold such fantastically over-the-top double standards of morality for themselves and 'infidels'.
 
Except for WWII, the American Civil War, numerous anti-imperialist uprisings, countless instances of self-defense, and so on. "Violence, naked force, has settled more issues in history than has any other factor."

I'm not going to say that every instance of antifa activists' use of force is productive, or even justified; but when you're facing an enemy who does not even acknowledge your humanity, who would be perfectly happy to kill you or otherwise make it so that you simply do not exist in their world, well you do what you do to ensure that you and those like you continue to survive.
And it's a very privileged position to sit back, ignore history, and say "Well, violence never solves anything, and both sides are the same," when you're not the target of the fascists and bigots who are trying to eliminate your very existence, or at best turn you into a slave and treat you as less than an animal. Non-violence in the face of an enemy who does not acknowledge your humanity is not noble, it's suicidal.

The problem with antifa is that it's a myriad of very different people, from very different backgrouns, with differing worldviews, and no coherent philosophy or strategy aside from "resist those who are trying to destroy us with whatever means we have". That means that different groups will have different ideas on how to accomplish their goals, and the fact that many tend to over-react to such a threat is hardly unexpected, and more a result of having more passion than experience. Branding them as "terrorists" is at best a gross misunderstanding of both antifa's purpose and the purpose of terrorism.

While it's critical to be judicious in the use of violent force, it's still a very important and valuable tool against those who would use violent force to erase you entirely. What antifa activists need is a regular organization with a coherent purpose and strong, charismatic leadership. Someone like Dr. King or Malcom X, Harvey Milk or Huey Newton. Or, ideally, all of the above.


Well at least you are not over hyping the situation
 
Except for WWII, the American Civil War, numerous anti-imperialist uprisings, countless instances of self-defense, and so on. "Violence, naked force, has settled more issues in history than has any other factor."

I'm not going to say that every instance of antifa activists' use of force is productive, or even justified; but when you're facing an enemy who does not even acknowledge your humanity, who would be perfectly happy to kill you or otherwise make it so that you simply do not exist in their world, well you do what you do to ensure that you and those like you continue to survive.

And it's a very privileged position to sit back, ignore history, and say "Well, violence never solves anything, and both sides are the same," when you're not the target of the fascists and bigots who are trying to eliminate your very existence, or at best turn you into a slave and treat you as less than an animal. Non-violence in the face of an enemy who does not acknowledge your humanity is not noble, it's suicidal.

The problem with antifa is that it's a myriad of very different people, from very different backgrouns, with differing worldviews, and no coherent philosophy or strategy aside from "resist those who are trying to destroy us with whatever means we have". That means that different groups will have different ideas on how to accomplish their goals, and the fact that many tend to over-react to such a threat is hardly unexpected, and more a result of having more passion than experience. Branding them as "terrorists" is at best a gross misunderstanding of both antifa's purpose and the purpose of terrorism.

While it's critical to be judicious in the use of violent force, it's still a very important and valuable tool against those who would use violent force to erase you entirely. What antifa activists need is a regular organization with a coherent purpose and strong, charismatic leadership. Someone like Dr. King or Malcom X, Harvey Milk or Huey Newton. Or, ideally, all of the above.

Please don't call me privileged. I do not say that from a place of privilege, I say it from a place of terror. I want the fighting to stop.

It has gotten to the point where my few close friends think I should go to the doctor. I genuinely believe riots are going to break out, like, every night. I get these crazy, elaborate fears into my head and then they just remain. For example, I'm afraid that far-right loons will hack medical databases somehow and get lists of women who have had abortions in order to target them. I'm really afraid of what deepfake technology is going to do. I'm afraid of propaganda. I can't even watch porn anymore because it disturbs me. It's like I can't turn my mind off. I just see symbols of hatred and oppression and cultural sickness and violence in everything. I don't know how to stop obsessing about it, and no one wants to hear it.

So when I see people provoking these guys, I panic and want them to stop. I guess I do sort of think that the left would win more converts and defeat these creeps if they presented themselves as the calm, sensible ones? I guess that's what I think. I haven't really thought it through the whole way. I just am really freaked out.

I'm sorry if that didn't make sense. Honestly, you guys could probably ignore all my posts from the last couple of days. I'm not well. I'm definitely having severe anxiety overload since Thursday or so. (Haven't been able to eat, either.) I'm not thinking clearly, so I'm sorry if I was flippant.
 
Well at least you are not over hyping the situation


New Zealand may be a progressive paradise where everyone loves everyone else and they sit around singing old showtunes all day; but if you ever pull your head out of the sand and look at the rest of the world, I guarantee you you'll see just how idiotic that comment was.

Want to take a guess at how many black people and indigenous people are murdered by police every year in the US? And how many police actually face consequences for doing so? Want to take a guess how many immigrant children are still kept in cages, deprived of even the most basic hygiene and humanity? Did you miss the US Government effectively removing all civil rights protections for transpeople, and pushing to do so for LGBTQ people and women? Want to take a guess how many countries there are in the world were being LGBTQ is a capital offense?

Oh wait, you had that shooting thing there. I guess you forgot about that. Might want to look it up, to refresh your memory.

There are none so blind as those who will not see.
 
Please don't call me privileged. I do not say that from a place of privilege, I say it from a place of terror. I want the fighting to stop.



It has gotten to the point where my few close friends think I should go to the doctor. I genuinely believe riots are going to break out, like, every night. I get these crazy, elaborate fears into my head and then they just remain. For example, I'm afraid that far-right loons will hack medical databases somehow and get lists of women who have had abortions in order to target them. I'm really afraid of what deepfake technology is going to do. I'm afraid of propaganda. I can't even watch porn anymore because it disturbs me. It's like I can't turn my mind off. I just see symbols of hatred and oppression and cultural sickness and violence in everything. I don't know how to stop obsessing about it, and no one wants to hear it.



So when I see people provoking these guys, I panic and want them to stop. I guess I do sort of think that the left would win more converts and defeat these creeps if they presented themselves as the calm, sensible ones? I guess that's what I think. I haven't really thought it through the whole way. I just am really freaked out.



I'm sorry if that didn't make sense. Honestly, you guys could probably ignore all my posts from the last couple of days. I'm not well. I'm definitely having severe anxiety overload since Thursday or so. (Haven't been able to eat, either.) I'm not thinking clearly, so I'm sorry if I was flippant.
This just tells me that you are perfectly rational and sane, but your brain is in overthink things mode. I get that too, its bloody awful. Hope it passes quickly for you.
 
Jo Brand (who I once saw at a pub gig "before she was famous" and chatted with at the bar) recently made an edgy joke about "milkshaking" which many people didn't, er, get;

"... but I think that's because certain unpleasant characters are being thrown to the fore and they're very, very easy to hate.
And I'm kind of thinking, 'why bother with a milkshake when you could get some battery acid?'
I'm not going to do it, it's purely a fantasy, but I think milkshakes are pathetic, I honestly do, sorry
."

This rather demonstrates that the saying liberalism is mental illness is more than a pithy throwaway, it's demonstrably true, practically an aphorism.

I have no doubt that Jo Brand is a genuinely well-meaning person, a "nice" person as all liberals imagine themselves to be, and she's no dunce, but here she was blissfully unaware of the stark, almost deranged example of the moral relativism of liberalism she'd just mouthed.

It seems to take over the minds of those who submit to it, and is not unlike the 'submissiveness' to Islam that allows Muslims to hold such fantastically over-the-top double standards of morality for themselves and 'infidels'.


Met her at Jongleurs in Clapham (When the place existed), next to the Cornet (when it was called the Cornet) many many moons ago.

You are right. She is a cool person.

But that is a dumb joke
 
Terrorists don't break store windows and loot and assault people, they blow up buildings and hijack planes and kill people. Not all political violence is terrorism, you don't have to misapply the term "terrorism" in order to condemn bad behavior.

Yes. Thank you.
 
New Zealand may be a progressive paradise where everyone loves everyone else and they sit around singing old showtunes all day; but if you ever pull your head out of the sand and look at the rest of the world, I guarantee you you'll see just how idiotic that comment was.

Want to take a guess at how many black people and indigenous people are murdered by police every year in the US? And how many police actually face consequences for doing so? Want to take a guess how many immigrant children are still kept in cages, deprived of even the most basic hygiene and humanity? Did you miss the US Government effectively removing all civil rights protections for transpeople, and pushing to do so for LGBTQ people and women? Want to take a guess how many countries there are in the world were being LGBTQ is a capital offense?

Oh wait, you had that shooting thing there. I guess you forgot about that. Might want to look it up, to refresh your memory.

There are none so blind as those who will not see.

So to get this right you are saying US police all are....

....an enemy who does not even acknowledge your humanity, who would be perfectly happy to kill you or otherwise make it so that you simply do not exist in their world,

And your post was about the US

I am perfectly aware there are some dodgy places in the world, but don't try to shift the goal posts
 
So to get this right you are saying US police all are....



And your post was about the US

I am perfectly aware there are some dodgy places in the world, but don't try to shift the goal posts

For many people who aren't white, male, straight, older and somewhat financially secure like me, the U.S. is indeed one of those dodgy places.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom