Jeanette Winterson defends homeopathy

His biography on the Newcastle University website contains this gem:
The fact that folk such as we [i.e. writers] are able to help someone write a PhD in economics, say, is down to our sense of how language works, what structure is about, and how all forms of writing are planned, drafted, edited, and re-edited. If you have students who are struggling with essays or dissertations, do please send them along.
Or find someone else who can read as well as write, perhaps? The gulf between literature and science was never so clearly illustrated.
 
Denis MacEoin replies...

For those who may have missed it, Denis MacEoin has now replied to his critics in the comments section below his CiF piece in the Guardian:

I suppose it's time I added a comment to this thread. I put up a short article designed to provoke some sort of rational debate about a contentious scientific subject. I expected criticism, but I also expected reason, balance, and informed debate. I received the criticism in bucketloads, but none of the other things. Instead of a reasoned discussion, there is -- if you will scroll down -- little but invective, vitriol, spleen, and anger. I do not think I have read a single comment here that has been anything but bellicose, with vituperative language, ignorance parading as knowledge, and arrogance masquerading as scientific insight. This has not been a rational debate, and anyone who thinks it has should read back carefully. I am all too aware of what it is: this is the language, long familiar to me, of religious intemperance, the voice of orthodoxy screaming for the blood of heretics -- and, let me tell you, it is rank. I have read a comment in which someone suggests that my appearance shows that homeopathy really is harmful. How clever and astute! Others have drawn attention to religious beliefs I left behind in 1980: was it not enough that my article spelled out the fact that I am a sceptic and rationalist? Many have seen cause for sneering in referring to my original academic background. What the hell has that got to do with the arguments I advance above? I write as someone trained and experienced in academic rigour and rational argument, and as someone with a reasonable knowledge of homeopathy. I did not claim in my piece to be a scientist, nor did I wade in to the vast area of scientific specificities -- something I'm not qualified to do. But I am very well qualified to spot humbug, cant and smart-aleckness. In Ben Goldacre's piece, he mentioned veterinary homeopathy and dismissed it by claiming that pets respond to being taken special treatment, and that this too was placebo. This is obvious irrationality. Goldacre cannot advance a shred of evidence for what is, at face value, a very unlikely claim. And he makes a fatal mistake. Sir Karl Popper, the great philosopher of science, argues that we must not be content to tackle our opponents on their weakest points, but to debate them on their strongest. How then does that claim to placebo match something that is common practice in veterinary homeopathy on farms: the treatment of herds of dairy cows using remedies placed in their drinking water? Placebo? That is much more difficult to believe than accepting that homeopathic remedies do in fact work.

I don't think anyone actually grasped what I was saying about the problem with RCTs using just 'simple' homeopathy. Many of you argued that, since the orthodox RCT is perfect in some way, it was only proper for homeopathy to fit it, rather than develop a more complex form of RCT that might fit homeopathy. The first attitude is exactly what exponents of an orthodoxy advance when challenged by unfamiliar phenomena (read Thomas Kuhn on this). If homeopathy works, then it will prompt a paradigm shift in our understanding of medicine. Since there is a lot of prima facie evidence that it does work, it is incumbent on scientists to devise tests that treat it just ly. They must stick to Popper's principle of falsification, trying as hard as possible to prove homeopathy wrong, while being alert to evidence that it is a real phenomenon.

Someone suggested that there was no need for Ben Goldacre or anyone else to know much about homeopathy in order to investigate and disprove it. Really? Let me show the bareness of this argument. Very recently, I authored a report on British Islam for a leading think tank. Let's assume I knew next to nothing about Islam: could I have dealt with raw materials in several languages and written an analysis that required a knowledge of the historical and theological background. Of course not. The reason I was selected to write the report in the first place was my knowledge of the subject. Nothing can excuse Goldacre's inexperience of homeopathy as a practical medical discipline. Why are there so many doctor homeopaths? It is usually because they watched other homeopaths at work, gained some knowledge of the subject, and went on to immerse themselves in it. Goldacre has, to the best of my knowledge, held himself aloof from acquiring the knowledge and hands-on experience that would fit him to pursue accurate research in the subject.

This debate is not going to go away. Google the British Homeopathic Association and find on their website a very damning analysis of Goldacre's Lancet article. As yourself why Goldacre left out of his analysis one of the most important meta-analyses of homeopathic trials, a Lancet review that showed homeopathy achieving very high percentages of success. Until this becomes a proper two-sided debate in which all information is deployed, it will remain loud, boorish, and meretricious, and will get us nowhere near the truth.


http://commentisfree.guardian.co.uk...your_ignorance_is_showing.html#comment-945226
 
And he is wrong into the bargain. Homeopaths DO kill people. We have another thread here in this forum on just that topic.
 
It seems Denis has been writing more or less the same article in comment threads on posts about homeopathy for a while:

http://www.guardian.co.uk/notesandqueries/query/0,,-9542,00.html
http://thescotsman.scotsman.com/scotland.cfm?id=1387592006
http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/uk/health/article2584643.ece

Woo enthusiast Anthony Campbell has this article on his website

http://www.acampbell.ukfsn.org/essays/altmed/appeal.html

which quotes an article by MacEoin in Homeopathy and then says
MacEoin correctly identifies the dilemma that has always faced homeopathy. Either it tries to go it alone, and risks isolation, or it tries to integrate itself with orthodox medicine, in which case it risks being taken over. MacEoin has no doubt that independence is the right course, and he believes that this will eventually lead to a situation in which homeopathy will become "a distinctive, broadly-based medical system capable in the fullness of time of usurping the current role of allopathy...".

There must, he insists, be no compromise on essentials: "to seek for anything less than freedom to pursue the goal of raising homeopathy to the status of a primary system of medical treatment to which surgery and drug treatment will be complementary would be to betray the vision of generations of homeopaths and the hopes of thousands of patients like myself."


Meanwhile a testament to his wife's powers by one David J Rodgers is given here:

http://www.thewritingcentre.com/?p=716

I used to go through a pot-of-tea ritual with Dennis MacEoin, who wrote under the pseudonyms of Daniel Easterman and Jonathan Aycliffe. His wife, Beth, ‘saved my life’ with a homeopathic remedy when I turned up with a slice of my nose missing after some sloppy shaving, clutching a tissue sopping wet with blood. That’s a great way to make a good impression on a horror writer.

Tantalisingly we're not told whether she reattached the severed part of the nose or just stopped the bleeding.
 
...which quotes an article by MacEoin in Homeopathy and then says
MacEoin correctly identifies the dilemma that has always faced homeopathy. Either it tries to go it alone, and risks isolation, or it tries to integrate itself with orthodox medicine, in which case it risks being taken over. MacEoin has no doubt that independence is the right course, and he believes that this will eventually lead to a situation in which homeopathy will become "a distinctive, broadly-based medical system capable in the fullness of time of usurping the current role of allopathy...".

There must, he insists, be no compromise on essentials: "to seek for anything less than freedom to pursue the goal of raising homeopathy to the status of a primary system of medical treatment to which surgery and drug treatment will be complementary would be to betray the vision of generations of homeopaths and the hopes of thousands of patients like myself."


So much for "complementary" medicine.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom