"Jeanette Winterson in Blistering Attack on Homeopathy": Did the "Little Black Duck" get this right?
It's satire.
"Jeanette Winterson in Blistering Attack on Homeopathy": Did the "Little Black Duck" get this right?
Your post is actually quite refreshing. You admit there's no evidence, that you don't know or care about efficacy - you've read criticisms but would rather ignore them because you just want to feel better. If all the woos just admitted that, we'd leave them alone! But no, they have to find pseudo-scientific justifications for their BS that draw more people in who might otherwise realise it's all a load of bollocks. Ignoring the criticisms and then making stuff up and flogging (or advocating) it to people, especially in lieu of proper treatments, is what we object to.
I was once prescribed homeopathic treatmment by my doctor, who is a wise and brilliant man. (for shingles, which is something you never want to get). It worked completely - 2 days later and it was gone.
What does this mean?
What does it mean? Absolutely nothing. I too have suffered from shingles, I sympathise, it's not nice. The last time I had shingles, I took nothing, within a week it was gone.
It is self limiting (i.e. the visible symptoms go away), had it perhaps just run its course?
(I know that shingles never actually goes away, but the symptoms do.)
Just because something appears to work, doesn't mean that it does.
Part of her typical quote.
"In a solvent, such as water, nano particles can remain suspended, neither floating nor sinking, but permeating the solution. Such particles are also able to pass through cell walls, and they can cause biochemical change."
That's actually a brilliant pile of rubbish. I'm surprised that the makers of that bunk like "Head-On" and others don't actually try that whole line of Marketing.
"It works because the active ingredients are so small they can actually pass through cell walls and cause biochemical change."
The idiots would think, "that makes sense."
I was wondering what was going on in my doctors mind
You'll have to ask your Doctor that one, else we'll just be supposing.
I bit like Homeopaths I guess.
Part of her typical quote.
"In a solvent, such as water, nano particles can remain suspended, neither floating nor sinking, but permeating the solution. Such particles are also able to pass through cell walls, and they can cause biochemical change."
That's actually a brilliant pile of rubbish.
People are afraid of talking gibberish, afraid of writing things down which frighten them by their meaninglessness. Sometimes you have to do that.
I doubt it, she's got a personal homeopath who'll whisk up a dose of no snake venom at the drop of a hat and must be on a decent retainer (she mentions on her slightly terrifying website that she believes in paying her staff well 'cos she's working class), I'm sure he/she keeps her well briefed.Shouting about the sleeping pill demonstration to actual homoeopaths usually accomplishes nothing, because they will reply
A. That the pills do not make one drowsy, they cure insomnia. If one is suffering from insomnia, they will help, but they will do nothing to someone who isn't. (I don't remember being told why they won't cause proving symptoms....)
B. That a dose is a dose is a dose. The whole bottle or one pill, it's all the same. So it's not like scarfing 28 Temazepam in a sitting, not at all.
However, posed to a muddle-head like that woman, who is probably not versed in the subtle art of homoeopathic excuse-generating, it might actually cause a small pause for reflection.
Seconded.That is one of the best pieces of writing I've seen in a while.
Rolfe.
He has been married to homoeopath and health writer Beth MacEoin since 1975. Beth is the author of around 20 books on natural health, including the NMS book, Natural Medicine: A practical guide to family Health, which was published by Bloomsbury at the end of 1999, and "Homeopathy: Medicine for the 21st Century" (Kyle Cathie, 2006).
An advocate of alternative medicine since the 1960s, he has in more recent years taken a serious interest in the sociology and politics of medicine, and in the relations between CAM and conventional therapy. He regularly lectures to medical students on these topics. For many years, until its demise in 2003, he was chairman, then president of the Natural Medicines Society, a UK charity for the general public.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Denis_MacEoin
There have been many attacks on homeopathy recently, but Ben Goldacre's is the least scientific of the lot.
Last week, novelist Jeanette Winterson published an intelligent and lucid account of why she believes homeopathy works.
Read on…
http://commentisfree.guardian.co.uk/denis_maceoin/2007/11/your_ignorance_is_showing.html
Goldacre's article was laden with his usual sarcasm. In it, he paraded his superior knowledge and accused homeopaths of "killing patients" and being "morons".
When I’m feeling generous, I think: homeopathy could have value as placebo, on the NHS even, although there are ethical considerations, and these serious cultural side-effects to be addressed.
But when they’re suing people instead of arguing with them, telling people not to take their medical treatments, killing patients, running conferences on HIV fantasies, undermining the public’s understanding of evidence and, crucially, showing absolutely no sign of ever being able to engage in a sensible conversation about the perfectly simple ethical and cultural problems that their practice faces, I think: these people are just morons.
An update.
Denis MacEoin…
…attacks Ben Goldacre, but defends Jeanette Winterson in today’s Comments section of the Guardian:
There has never been a proper trial of homeopathy. There have been countless trials based on the methodology applied to orthodox medicines, as if homeopathy is a form of orthodox medicine. Some have been positive, most negative. This proves nothing, because what they have tested was never homeopathy in the first place.
In orthodox trials, all patients in the "real" group are given the same drug for the same length of time. Homeopaths do not work like that. For one condition, they may select one of a dozen or more remedies, chosen after long and detailed interviews. They see patients repeatedly over the course of months or years, refining and changing prescriptions, and watching a steady development that follows a strong internal logic. It is a long process. But this is how homeopathy works: mangling it for the chance to jump on the clinical trial bandwagon is not science. No scientist of repute carries out tests of A by running trials of B. All the vaunted meta-analyses that proclaim the ineffectiveness of homeopathy are scientifically illiterate, as Ben Goldacre seems to be in this instance.
A perfect description of how homoeopaths continue trying out sugar pills until the illness has cured itself!Denis MacEoin said:hey see patients repeatedly over the course of months or years, refining and changing prescriptions, and watching a steady development that follows a strong internal logic. It is a long process.