Jeanette Winterson defends homeopathy

Thing

...now with added haecceity!
Joined
Dec 25, 2005
Messages
510
Jeanette Winterson, so-so author who never met a woo idea she didn't like (she used Tarot to choose which house to buy, I seem to remember) is paid by the Gaurdian to write a long, rambling, self important article defending homeopathy and gives the fee to the Maun homeopathy project, a clinic in Botswana.

http://www.guardian.co.uk/g2/story/0,,2209998,00.html

Typical quote:
Objections to homeopathy begin with what are viewed as the impossible dilutions of the remedies, so that only nano amounts of the original active substance remain, and in some cases are only an imprint, or memory. Yet our recent discoveries in the world of the very small point to a whole new set of rules for the behaviour of nano-quantities. Thundering around in our Gulliver world, we were first shocked to find that splitting the atom allowed inconceivable amounts of energy to be released. Now, we are discovering that the properties of materials change as their size reaches the nano-scale. Bulk material should have constant physical properties, regardless of its size, but at the nano-scale this is not the case. In a solvent, such as water, nano particles can remain suspended, neither floating nor sinking, but permeating the solution. Such particles are also able to pass through cell walls, and they can cause biochemical change.
She also boasts that she reads 'New Scientist' every week.
 
Last edited:
Jeanette Winterson, so-so author who never met a woo idea she didn't like (she used Tarot to choose which house to buy, I seem to remember) is paid by the Gaurdian to write a long, rambling, self important article defending homeopathy and gives the fee to the Maun homeopathy project, a clinic in Botswana.

http://www.guardian.co.uk/g2/story/0,,2209998,00.html

Hey, Oranges are Not the Only Fruit was a great book! As to the rest, this is why I don't take medical advice from authors.


She also boasts that she reads 'New Scientist' every week.

She boasts that she 'takes' New Scientist every week. From what she's written, I'm not so sure about reading it ;).
 
Last edited:
She also sees herself as trying to prevent a new "Dark Ages". Here's an excerpt from an interview published in the Bookseller 17th August 2007, p.19:
I think of myself as a little scribe in the great abbeys of Cluny or Fontainbleu during the Dark Ages, desperately trying to hold onto something to pass on to another generation – I do! Because I think there is a bit of a Dark Ages in some ways, and I do think things need protecting and valuing.


I'm not convinced that she's part of the solution.

Here's another newspaper article: http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/life_and_style/health/complementary_medicine/article1160470.ece
 
Last edited:
Jeanette Winterson, so-so author who never met a woo idea she didn't like (she used Tarot to choose which house to buy, I seem to remember) is paid by the Gaurdian to write a long, rambling, self important article defending homeopathy and gives the fee to the Maun homeopathy project, a clinic in Botswana.

-snip-

She also boasts that she reads 'New Scientist' every week.


According to Dana Ullman (MPH) she’s one of the literary greats...
http://www.homeopathicrevolution.com/pages/table_of_contents.jsp

He puts her right up there with Yeats, Tennyson, Dickens, and Barbara Cartland.
 
Last edited:
This seems to be partly why tests used for conventional medicines fail when used to test homeopathy. Sceptics will say it is the medicines that fail, and not the trials, but if the medicines really are ineffective, why is it that so many people who have tried homeopathy have found that it makes a difference to their wellbeing?

Yes that's right, it's the tests that are broken, and the more people that believe something the truer it gets, absolutely spot on there. :rolleyes:
 
After taking one homeopathy tablet before going to bed,I fell into a particularly deep sleep and awoke to find my weeks long illness gone. Coincidence? placebo? Maybe - I didn't care, I was just glad to be well again.

My family were impressed and when my mum became ill she visited the same Homeopath and had a positive experience as well.

The Doctors had failed both myself and my mum - not his fault, he just didn't have anything that worked for us.

Would I use Homeopathy again? Sure, if the Doctor can't help.

But it doesn't work?

Well, I'll give it a go, anyway. It's my time and money.

It makes no sense?

I agree.
 
It makes no sense?
I agree.

I assume by "sick" you don't mean appendicitis or something that average, healthy adults won't simply get over in the normal course of things. Please make sure you seperate those categories and only take homeopathic meds for things like a cold or sore throat. You'll save your loved ones a traumatic trip to the ER. Also I beg you not to have or treat any children for illnesses.
 
Hey, Oranges are Not the Only Fruit was a great book!
I found the TV adaptation to be very entertaining, it told an interesting story well, but the book I feel contains a lot of extraneous fluff which they were wise to cut out.

Anyway, couldn't she do more for the world by funding that elusive successful test of homeopathy that finally causes it to be accepted by the mainstream?
 
Nano? Wow, she really has no clue what she is talking about.


My thoughts exactly. Every day I measure concentrations in biological fluids down to the nmol/l range. Some analytes even go down as far as pmol/l. (One thousandth of a nanomole.) Nothing unusual about it, and plenty biologically active. Whether taking a dose of a fraction of an ml of a solution in the nmol/l bracket would do anything is another story of course, but I doubt if she's thought so far.

Scientifically illiterate.

Pity she didn't mention Rao and Roy, really.

Rolfe.
 
She boasts that she 'takes' New Scientist every week. From what she's written, I'm not so sure about reading it.

Obviously, she took a page from one issue, succussed it with water to make a mother tincture, then diluted it down to C30, and she takes some of -that- every week.
 
After taking one homeopathy tablet before going to bed,I fell into a particularly deep sleep and awoke to find my weeks long illness gone. Coincidence? placebo? Maybe - I didn't care, I was just glad to be well again.

My family were impressed and when my mum became ill she visited the same Homeopath and had a positive experience as well.

The Doctors had failed both myself and my mum - not his fault, he just didn't have anything that worked for us.

Would I use Homeopathy again? Sure, if the Doctor can't help.

But it doesn't work?

Well, I'll give it a go, anyway. It's my time and money.

It makes no sense?

I agree.

Your post is actually quite refreshing. You admit there's no evidence, that you don't know or care about efficacy - you've read criticisms but would rather ignore them because you just want to feel better. If all the woos just admitted that, we'd leave them alone! But no, they have to find pseudo-scientific justifications for their BS that draw more people in who might otherwise realise it's all a load of bollocks. Ignoring the criticisms and then making stuff up and flogging (or advocating) it to people, especially in lieu of proper treatments, is what we object to.
 
Part of her typical quote.

"In a solvent, such as water, nano particles can remain suspended, neither floating nor sinking, but permeating the solution. Such particles are also able to pass through cell walls, and they can cause biochemical change."

That's actually a brilliant pile of rubbish. I'm surprised that the makers of that bunk like "Head-On" and others don't actually try that whole line of Marketing.

"It works because the active ingredients are so small they can actually pass through cell walls and cause biochemical change."

The idiots would think, "that makes sense."
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom