Israel to attack Iran to draw in USA?

At this stage Iran wants a cease-fire because it wants its nuclear research to mature and does not not need another battle on their hands.
They're talking about the war in Lebanon. That was the ceasefire referred to.

The international community will destroy their nuclear achievements to date if they started a war with Israel. But don't worry, I'm sure that as soon as they have nuclear capabilities Israel wil be the first to taste it and America probably second, third or fourth. Wait your turn, we're first. You'll taste the fruits of your ignorance after us.

Paranoia, again.
As someone said, above. If Iran wants nukes, it's to deter attack. That will give them more influence in the region, etc. Given the examples of North Korea and Iraq, it would seem sensible. But the IAEA has found no evidence of a nuclear weapons programme.

You will sometime (and I hope it will be soon) have to realize that what Iran says to the international community is made up of many many lies: The recent ones I can remember:
1. Iran has no homosexuals like you have in the U.S.
2. Iran does not support terror.
3. Women are very highly regarded in Iran. They are honored more than the men.

Those are just 3 examples that have been prooven to be lies.

There are plenty of lies from Bush, too.
 
FireGarden said:
Paranoia, again.
As someone said, above. If Iran wants nukes, it's to deter attack. That will give them more influence in the region, etc. Given the examples of North Korea and Iraq, it would seem sensible. But the IAEA has found no evidence of a nuclear weapons programme.
Paranoia, right. I would rather be paranoid and not have to deal with a nuclear Iran than to turn my back and do nothing now and taste a nuclear stew later.
Is there a probability that even with nukes, Iran will persue peace in the middle east and use its nuclear knowledge for energy alternatives only? I guess there is a small possibility for that but I'm not willing to take the chance.

Let's see: nuclear capabilities and the possible destruction (or near destruction) of Israel on one hand or non nuclear Iran and be called unfair by some on the other hand. The choice is difficult but I'll take what's behind curtain #1. thank you.

Yair
 
Even if you were correect, Ahmadinejad wishes to replace a democratic government with an Islamic theocracy. The South African analogy would be accurate if you were advocating the current regime be ousted in favor of an apartheid regime.

No he does not. He has specifically said he wants people in the region to have a vote.

The citizens of Gaza and the West Bank have their lives controlled by a government they cannot vote for. This has been the case for a very long time.

If Israel's control of Palestinian areas is an occupation, then the settlements (all of them) are illegal. If it is an annexation, then the situation is one of Apartheid -- as Jimmy Carter says.

Is that the "democracy" you want to protect?

How many Jews live in the Palestinian-controlled West Bank and Gaza? How many Christians? How many Buddhists?

The Christians, being richer, left. Most of them, anyway. Many Muslim Palestinians have left, too.

Hanan Ashrawi is Christian. Her father was a founder member of the PLO. Yasser Arafat's wife was Christian.

There have been many famous Palestinian Christians, including Edward Said who was a critic of Arafat. When did Said talk about descrimination of Palestinian Christians?
 
As someone said, above. If Iran wants nukes, it's to deter attack. That will give them more influence in the region, etc. Given the examples of North Korea
Yes, I remember pre-nuclear N. Korea. Nearly every year the US would attack it. But now we don't since the Dear Leader single-handedly created a bomb.
 
FireGarden said:
There are plenty of lies from Bush, too.
a comparison between Bush and Ahmadinejad is not worth commenting on.
Why?
I leave that to you.
Hint: It does not have anything to do whether I support Bush's administration or not.
 
FireGarden said:
The citizens of Gaza and the West Bank have their lives controlled by a government they cannot vote for. This has been the case for a very long time.
you have your facts wrong. The palestinians have voted the Hammas for their leadership.
 
Yes, I remember pre-nuclear N. Korea. Nearly every year the US would attack it. But now we don't since the Dear Leader single-handedly created a bomb.

The fear of attack counts for a lot.
How do you think Dear Leader got to fund a nuclear programme while his people starved?

N Korea got a much better deal than Iraq. Why do you suppose that is?
 
you have your facts wrong. The palestinians have voted the Hammas for their leadership.

Hamas does not control their lives.
Hamas does not control borders; it does not control the import of essentials like food, fuel and electricity.

Having local leadership does not mean having control of the government that controls your life.
 
No he does not. He has specifically said he wants people in the region to have a vote.
He wants one country to have the "right' to vote another out of existence. This would be like letting the citizens of the US, Canada, and Mexico vote to see which country gets to survive. Hey, looks like the USA just expanded peacefully! :rolleyes:

The citizens of Gaza and the West Bank have their lives controlled by a government they cannot vote for. This has been the case for a very long time.
Yes, it's tragic that they can only vote for one terrorist group over another. Hamas or Islamic Jihad or Fatah? Tough choice...

If Israel's control of Palestinian areas is an occupation, then the settlements (all of them) are illegal.
Since when? Jordan and Egypt used those areas to attack Israel, they lost the war and the territory. The West Bank and Gaza would stillbe part of those respective countries if they hadn't decided to get rid of those money-grubbing, Allah-dissin' Jews.

If it is an annexation, then the situation is one of Apartheid -- as Jimmy Carter says.
No, it's one of holding territory gained in a war.

Is that the "democracy" you want to protect?
Given the alternative, which we see now in Jew-free Gaza and other middle east countries, absolutely!

The Christians, being richer, left. Most of them, anyway. Many Muslim Palestinians have left, too.
Wonder why that was?

Hanan Ashrawi is Christian. Her father was a founder member of the PLO. Yasser Arafat's wife was Christian.

There have been many famous Palestinian Christians, including Edward Said who was a critic of Arafat. When did Said talk about descrimination of Palestinian Christians?
Doesn't matter what the past was. The current Palestinian state is for Muslims only, and they're fighting each other over which particular sect gets to be allowed to stay there. Sounds like a hellhole to me, but you have those rose-colored glasses on again.
 
The fear of attack counts for a lot.
How do you think Dear Leader got to fund a nuclear programme while his people starved?
Because Dear Leader doesn't give a damn about the welfare of his people.

N Korea got a much better deal than Iraq. Why do you suppose that is?
N. Korea managed to go over 50 years without invading one of its neighbors, mainly because of the presence of US troops in S. Korea.
 
He wants one country to have the "right' to vote another out of existence. This would be like letting the citizens of the US, Canada, and Mexico vote to see which country gets to survive. Hey, looks like the USA just expanded peacefully! :rolleyes:

So there is something wrong with nations voting for independence/federalism/unity?

Yes, it's tragic that they can only vote for one terrorist group over another. Hamas or Islamic Jihad or Fatah? Tough choice...

None of which will have as much control of the lives of Palestinians as the Israeli government has. That's the point.


Since when? Jordan and Egypt used those areas to attack Israel, they lost the war and the territory. The West Bank and Gaza would stillbe part of those respective countries if they hadn't decided to get rid of those money-grubbing, Allah-dissin' Jews.


No, it's one of holding territory gained in a war.

Hold the territory. Israel is welcome to it as far as I'm concerned.

The issue is one of not giving citizens a right to vote on the government that controls their lives. That is not democracy.

If the West Bank and Gaza belong to Israel, then Israel operates a system of Apartheid. If those areas do not, then the remaining settlements are all illegal.

Doesn't matter what the past was. The current Palestinian state is for Muslims only, and they're fighting each other over which particular sect gets to be allowed to stay there. Sounds like a hellhole to me, but you have those rose-colored glasses on again.

The past does matter.
Especially if you want a solution to the current problem rather than sling mud and demonise.
 
FireGarden said:
Hamas does not control their lives.
Yes they do. They people pay taxes to the Hammas government. What this money is being used for is Hammas' to decide. Can you guess what's it used for?
If you guessed correctly you would know why Israel stopped transferring humaniterian money to the Hammas and instead gives it to the Fatah which has Abbas as its leader and seems to want to take steps towards peace. (we can only hope so).


Hamas does not control borders; it does not control the import of essentials like food, fuel and electricity.
Palestinians do not have a state of their own since they have not proven they can maintain any kind of agreement between themselves. They fight eachother over who rules the territory. Then they increase the number of rockets fired to Israel. Would you give them a country so that Iran II can rise?
 
FireGarden, you see the Palestinians as citizens of Israel and so must have the right to vote if Israel is a democracy. But they are NOT citizens of Israel. They are an ethnic group who want independence which Israel and the internation community want them to have. But this will happen IF and only IF they can prove that they are willing to settle down peacefully and not attack Israel with rockets and suicide bombers on a daily basis which forces Israel to retaliate (no country will sit quietly while its people are being targeted and murdered). This is the circle of death which has been going on for so long. And why don't they stop firing at Israel? Because they want the land that Israel resides on too. Hammas and Iran are the same in that they both want in the termination of Israel.
Do you know what poverty goes on in the Palestinian territories? Do you think it's because the world doesn't give them money to take care of themselves? The international community provides them with million and millions of dollars each year but that money is spent on weapons and war against eachother and against Israel.
Arafat has been known to have 100 million dollars in his bank account in Swiss (which his wife now has). He took large parts of the money given to the Palestinians to his own bank account because he did not really care about his people. The same is continuing now after he's gone.
I beg you to comprehend this. It is very sad and gives no hope to the region but those are facts and it's a reality.
 
Would you give them a country so that Iran II can rise?

If I thought they were only going to be as bad as Iran? Sure. Iran hated Iraq but never spent its free time and capital lobbing missiles into Iraq just to see who they could kill.
 
yairhol,
Luckily, there are Israelis who can see the truth of what is going on:
http://zope.gush-shalom.org/home/en/channels/press_releases/1190230043/

“With our own hands we are uniting a million and half people against us, in bitterness and hatred” says Gush Shalom (Israeli Peace Bloc). “The inhabitants of the Gaza Strip are completely dependent on Israel for their most basic livelihood. This complete dependence was created, consciously and deliberately, by all governments of Israel since 1967. The state of Israel cannot now just shrug off its responsibility for the fate of the inhabitants of Gaza.”

I guess they meant morally, for that last, because in practise Israel does seem to be getting away with it.
 
yairhol,
Luckily, there are Israelis who can see the truth of what is going on:
http://zope.gush-shalom.org/home/en/channels/press_releases/1190230043/

I guess they meant morally, for that last, because in practise Israel does seem to be getting away with it.
FireGarden.

Somewhat OT, but what is a FireGarden? Garden, or Garten in German, is sort of like a yard, or a back yard, in American usage.

Fire Garden implies a yard or garden where one burns things. ( I looked up the Steve Vai album, and not being familiar with the music, don't get the ref.) Type is shown as progressive rather than metal, so nothing to see there.

What do you burn in your garden?

DR
 
FireGarden.
......What do you burn in your garden?


Probably raked-up leaves. You left out Azerbajain, which comes from the ancient Persian (Farsi) compound noun meaning "garden of burning flowers", a name resulting from the pre-1905 common spontaneous combustion of ever-released natural gas and oil fumes throught Azerbajain
 
Probably raked-up leaves. You left out Azerbajain, which comes from the ancient Persian (Farsi) compound noun meaning "garden of burning flowers", a name resulting from the pre-1905 common spontaneous combustion of ever-released natural gas and oil fumes throught Azerbajain

Cool! Thanks, Gurdur, for putting the E into JREF.

Azerbaijan is the original fire garden, if I understand you correctly. Did I get that right?

DR
 
....Azerbaijan is the original fire garden, if I understand you correctly. Did I get that right?

In the world, yes. I don't know if FireGarden meant that or not.

Azerbaijan was a sacred land to the Zoroastrians of Persia and the Parsees of India because of that (huge amounts of vented natural gas spontaneously combusting all the time).

Of interest, Zoroastrian monasteries in Azerbaijan often had beds made out of hard-packed earth at least 4 feet high above ground, to stop the sleeper being asphyxiated by natural gas venting from the ground.

Azerbaijan is a weird place, and often full of angry dildos. However, Azerbaijani women and coffee are often simply beautiful.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom