Academic journals publish the reports of original research. A researcher(s) formulate a hypothesis, figure out a way to test that hypothesis and proceed to gather the information necessary for the test. They then analyze the results and form a conclusion as to how the results relate to their original hypothesis.
Peer-review means that other scientists with expertise in the relevant area are asked to review the research and give their opinion as to whether the original hypothesis asks a valid and useful question, whether appropriate means of testing the hypothesis were used, if there are errors in the execution or analysis of the study, if the results support the conclusions made by the authors, as well as matters of form in the write-up.
I'm not entirely sure what part your term "proven, factual data" is meant to refer to.
I don't understand what you are asking here. Are reports on good quality research sometimes published in non-peer-reviewed academic journals?
Linda
Hi Linda: Thank you for the explanation. It seems that your summary corresponds with my understanding of peer-reviewed journals.
I should probably rephrase "proven, factual data": Plainly, studies that follow the strict guidelines of science or EBM with credible and verifiable results.
The problem
(as Dr. Harriet Hall wrote in the most recent edition of Skeptic Magazine) is that flawed studies are published in medical journals and released to the press, which result in public hysteria.
Hall provides an example of a study of Aspartame that was riddled with flaws in its design, results, and its number of test subjects. In this particular Aspartame study's results: 8% of the study "subjects" went blind. The 8% was actually one person -with a retinal detachment.
(and this one subject was in the placebo group!) ....Yet, this study was published in a medical journal.
Another example: Remember the intercessory prayer study that also passed into a medical journal?
(Actually, I believe there were 2 such studies that wound up published in medical journals, and later withdrawn.)
Can you see the problem??
Regarding scientific journals: My question is simply if such flawed studies as these are as frequently permitted in scientific journals as they are in medical journals? I have read in various sources that the answer to this question is no -but am open to hearing otherwise.
I understand the need to share research with peers, but my feeling is that there are many other venues where professionals can exchange such data for further studies until the research meets the criteria that, in my opinion, should be required before published in these esteemed journals.
If it is permissable for flawed or incomplete studies to be published in peer-reviewed journals, then were can someone like myself
(who is admittedly not well versed in reading & assessing studies) find truthful and accurate information? Where can I find the "final word" on medical and scientific studies?
Please don't come down on me for the words: "final word." I am simply asking where, if not in peer-reviewed academic journals, can i find the most accurate and verifiable truths accepted by the experts of these fields?