Is this new ammo for the alternative medicine crowd?

{snip} Although I still hold strongly to my opinion that esteemed peer-reviewed academic journals should not permit flawed and/or incomplete studies to be published in them. But, I suppose this is simply an opinion (which I feel is a good one for the reasons I have stated). {snip}
Publications in good journals may be inadequately refereed for a variety of reasons beyond the control of the journal. Even properly vetted articles may prove to be wrong in the light of new evidence. A hallmark of science is constant questioning and re-evaluation. You don't find that with the alt med crowd.
 
{snip} I just can't do 'kiss-ass' convincingly. Perhaps JJM can teach me?
A RULE: I cannot teach you something unless I know more than you do about the subject.

That is why it is amusing that you carry-on about vaccination. My ignorance of the topic is the reason that I don't carry-on about it (I have cited some expert opinion).

Maybe this could be a lesson for you: "If there is a topic you truly understand, just stick with that."

Write that down on a post-it and stick it ... someplace prominent in your cubicle.
 
Based on science, DM is a placebo.

Careful. DM is not a placebo, except as it has been studied in these inadequate clinical trials at (probably) inadequate doses.

It is used, quite effectively I might add, as an NMDA antagonist in chronic pain, and works quite well for many patients. It is also the enantiomer of levomethorphan, a potent narcotic. To assert that DM has no biologic activity other than a "placebo" is a statement of ignorance, not scientific fact.

-Dr. Imago
 
Funny how when JJM cites expert opinion it is valid, but when I cite studies (such as those from the Cochrane Collaboration on flu vaccine effectiveness) they are *not* valid, especially when they conflict with some of our resident "experts'" beliefs.

http://www.bcmj.org/ranking-and-reliability-evidence

4. Testimonials from friends, celebrities, or authority figures

Such testimonials have no more inherent reason to be reliable than ordinary testimonials but are widely used in advertising. Sports heroes and entertainers commonly are used to capture one’s attention. Word-of-mouth recommendations from friends also would fall into this category. Information from many lecturers, both academic and commercial (e.g., Deepak Chopra or Andrew Weil) is another example. The information in public presentations from such popular lecturers is often delivered skillfully, enthusiastically, and in an entertaining style but it is still just a testimonial. Expert opinion is named as the least reliable source of evidence in the ranking of reliability of sources for use in evidence-based medicine.[1,2]
 
Although I still hold strongly to my opinion that esteemed peer-reviewed academic journals should not permit flawed and/or incomplete studies to be published in them. But, I suppose this is simply an opinion (which I feel is a good one for the reasons I have stated).

I've been thinking on this a bit more, as I've been attempting to criticize the article that Dana Ullman has been putting up as evidence of homeopathy in these threads. I was originally going to start a new thread, but this issue is relevant to this topic and relevant to the article in the OP.

Your concerns are valid when it comes to the conclusions drawn by the authors. But, the practice of evidence-based medicine essentially ignores the conclusion. It is an opportunity for the authors to attempt to persuade to their point-of-view, but none of it is taken into consideration. What we are really interested in is the methods and the results. I often don't even read the conclusion unless I have a specific need for more information that I hope may be found there. So, whether or not the authors' conclusions are reasonable isn't really important. However, for many people (including physicians who are just trying to gather information quickly), the conclusion is the only part of the study they do consider. And it was unreasonable for me to dismiss the importance of that.

I think this is a valid concern as I have also frequently made the complaint that the authors' conclusions are not supported by the results. And I think that it is something that could be improved without sacrificing quality or progress.

This problem is what drives the argument we are having with Mr. Ullman (as he presents the conclusions from these studies as evidence, while we point out that those conclusions are not supported by the results). It is driving the argument on this thread. And it drives the arguments in many of the other threads here when some people present conclusions as evidence instead of results and there is a discrepancy between the two.

Thanks for bringing this up. It was very useful to me.

Linda
 
Last edited:
Linda, this is an extremely pertinent point.
It is quite apparent that one can design the best studies available that are free of all apparent bias, but when the results are scrutinised, it is quite relevant who the authors are when it comes to writing the conclusion to the paper. People are prone to see what they want to see, and bias creeps back in. This applies to orthodox medicine as well as homeopathy.

This weeks BMJ is a must for you to read. It has a paper on this very subject. It appears that if a metanalysis has been performed, and it is left to just the pharmaceutical company writers to formulate the conclusions, they will show bias in interpreting the metanalysis results. However this bias disappears if there are non-pharmaceutical co-authors.

PS - the BMJ issue is also about the dreaded C word. :)
(Don't tell Ivor...)
 
Last edited:
This weeks BMJ is a must for you to read. It has a paper on this very subject. It appears that if a metanalysis has been performed, and it is left to just the pharmaceutical company writers to formulate the conclusions, they will show bias in interpreting the metanalysis results. However this bias disappears if there are non-pharmaceutical co-authors.


Are their conclusions supported by the results? :cool:
 
I've been thinking on this a bit more, as I've been attempting to criticize the article that Dana Ullman has been putting up as evidence of homeopathy in these threads. I was originally going to start a new thread, but this issue is relevant to this topic and relevant to the article in the OP.

Your concerns are valid when it comes to the conclusions drawn by the authors. But, the practice of evidence-based medicine essentially ignores the conclusion. It is an opportunity for the authors to attempt to persuade to their point-of-view, but none of it is taken into consideration. What we are really interested in is the methods and the results. I often don't even read the conclusion unless I have a specific need for more information that I hope may be found there. So, whether or not the authors' conclusions are reasonable isn't really important. However, for many people (including physicians who are just trying to gather information quickly), the conclusion is the only part of the study they do consider. And it was unreasonable for me to dismiss the importance of that.

I think this is a valid concern as I have also frequently made the complaint that the authors' conclusions are not supported by the results. And I think that it is something that could be improved without sacrificing quality or progress.

This problem is what drives the argument we are having with Mr. Ullman (as he presents the conclusions from these studies as evidence, while we point out that those conclusions are not supported by the results). It is driving the argument on this thread. And it drives the arguments in many of the other threads here when some people present conclusions as evidence instead of results and there is a discrepancy between the two.

Thanks for bringing this up. It was very useful to me.

Linda


Thanks Linda, I am happy to know I am not alone in this thinking. Of course you found much better words and supporting issues to drive the point home... :wackygoofy:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom