Is this new ammo for the alternative medicine crowd?

{snip} And [fls] not a bad teacher, as teachers go. At least, when I've looked further, she seems to have be mostly spot on on. But it would be wrong to be a respectful, awestruck student. That is no way to learn anything.
Agreed.
 
The [personal observation] tag is a cop out, so I have removed them for you. ;)

Gee, thanks.

And she's not a bad teacher, as teachers go. At least, when I've looked further, she seems to have be mostly spot on on. But it would be wrong to be a respectful, awestruck student. That is no way to learn anything.

In light of new information, Ivor reassesses the probability of Linda taking him off her ignore list down to near zero.

Oh well...:D

Wish her good luck with her marathon next month and remind her she can't use an iPod/MP3 player while running in the race - it's against the rules in the US.

BTW, being frequently correct and being a good teacher are two different things. I know plenty of people who are the former, very few who are the latter.
 
BTW: What is wrong with my "a"? What does it appear like on the screen? Please, not another computer glitch! :mghissyfit

I was just teasing you about the repeated "a's" in the last part of the post (especially with the repeated "a's" in your name). :)

Linda
 
{snip} BTW, being frequently correct and being a good teacher are two different things. I know plenty of people who are the former, very few who are the latter.
Why am I not surprised you think that?
 
Last edited:
I really appreciate the opportunity to share my ideas on the JREF forums. But I truly, honestly understand that not everyone is interested in hearing them, and nobody is under any obligation to pay attention to them - that is, I don't badger anyone to respond to me or hold it against them if they're not interested (although I will question their judgement ;)).

And if I'm passing on information, the last thing I want is for you to take my word for it. I am generally meticulous about what I say, so in a pinch you won't go wrong if you trust it. But I'm opposed to that on principle. Everybody should be in the habit of double-checking information, even that from a trusted source. And I love being told I'm wrong - I get all tingly and excited by the challenge (not so much if it turns out that I actually am wrong, but that last time that happened, Clinton was still in office).

But I do apologize for not doing a good job of resisting the opportunity to be a smart-ass. Especially, when there's wordplay involved. It is a weakness, and it is likely I will continue to do it, much to my chagrin. I am easily amused.

ETA: It would probably not be surprising to discover that teaching runs in my family (including both of my parents), I grew up wanting to be a teacher, and I have been a teacher for a number of years (university appointments in Medicine).

Linda
 
Last edited:
Gee, thanks.


Don't mention it.

In light of new information, Ivor reassesses the probability of Linda taking him off her ignore list down to near zero.

:confused:
Oh, I see. Well, sorry for exposing your undercover activities. :nope:


Wish her good luck with her marathon next month and remind her she can't use an iPod/MP3 player while running in the race - it's against the rules in the US.


I wonder will she beat my record of 3 hours and 18 minutes and 38 seconds?
Now who on earth would run with an ipod?
Good time to do some serious thinking and problem solving I say.

BTW, being frequently correct and being a good teacher are two different things. I know plenty of people who are the former, very few who are the latter.


Well, yes, I have to admit she rubbed me up the wrong way the first time we met.

But she is like a good song. You don't think much of it initially but, with repeated listening, the musical quality shines through and it stays with you forever. Unlike most modern pop songs which love you and leave you within a day.

Okay, I'm getting a little rediculous here. :D
 
<snip>

:confused:
Oh, I see. Well, sorry for exposing your undercover activities. :nope:

No problem. It was an attempt at statistical humor. As far as Linda is concerned, I will forever be the kid in the class with his hand up who she never picks to answer the question.:D

<snip>

Well, yes, I have to admit she rubbed me up the wrong way the first time we met.

But she is like a good song. You don't think much of it initially but, with repeated listening, the musical quality shines through and it stays with you forever. Unlike most modern pop songs which love you and leave you within a day.

Okay, I'm getting a little rediculous here. :D

See, that's my problem (or at least one of them): I just can't do 'kiss-ass' convincingly. Perhaps JJM can teach me?
 
The [personal observation] tag is a cop out, so I have removed them for you. ;)

And she's not a bad teacher, as teachers go. At least, when I've looked further, she seems to have be mostly spot on on. But it would be wrong to be a respectful, awestruck student. That is no way to learn anything.

Most of the contributors to this thread are no doubt far more knowledgeable on these subject matters than I am. I have zero problem with playing "student" while always keeping an "open mind" (which is my definition for a "skeptical mind").

I have been reading Linda's posts for a little while now, and she seems to be (as some of you have noted) "spot on" most of the time -if not all.

Although I still hold strongly to my opinion that esteemed peer-reviewed academic journals should not permit flawed and/or incomplete studies to be published in them. But, I suppose this is simply an opinion (which I feel is a good one for the reasons I have stated).

Linda: Ackt! You were simply complaining about all the "a's" in my name? LOL! You nearly had me ready to take my keyboard apart! (BTW: I feel it is quite appropriate that my name contains so many "a's" ---as I am currently a straight-A student, aaaaand I made "top of the class" this semester in English.) :yahoo:yahoo:yahoo

*smug grin*
*bowing*
 
Although I still hold strongly to my opinion that esteemed peer-reviewed academic journals should not permit flawed and/or incomplete studies to be published in them. But, I suppose this is simply an opinion (which I feel is a good one for the reasons I have stated).

I agree with that opinion. I was wondering why you were under the impression that they did not already do that.

:yahoo:yahoo:yahoo

*smug grin*
*bowing*

Congratulations. :)

Linda
 
Linda, before you answer, remember to read his disclaimer.
;)
 
Last edited:
Ivor,

I don't care that you don't like me. I do care that you continue to derail threads in order to let people know what you think is wrong with me. I think that defending my character is out-of-place in these discussions, I feel uncomfortable doing so (which is probably why I tend to make light of it), and it embarrasses me (a lot) when other people are compelled to say nice things about me.

Please stop.

Linda
 
Now if it would get someone to respond to all the other points pointed out above, I would retract all statements about lies, errors and misunderstandings. But by all means, continue focusing on people, and not facts.

I'm always hopeful skeptics can talk about reality, rather than personalities.

Based on science, DM is a placebo.
 
Last edited:
fls said:
Ivor,

I don't care that you don't like me.

Now what's given you that idea? You’re ignoring me, remember?

I do care that you continue to derail threads in order to let people know what you think is wrong with me. I think that defending my character is out-of-place in these discussions, I feel uncomfortable doing so (which is probably why I tend to make light of it), and it embarrasses me (a lot) when other people are compelled to say nice things about me.

Please stop.

Linda

I shall tiptoe around you in future.:cool:
 
Based on science, DM is a placebo.

I did a quick power calculation to determine whether your statement is reasonable. It may interest you to know that the study from the OP, and the study you mentioned earlier, comparing DM to placebo and diphenhydramine, had a power of 13% to detect a small difference and a power of 60% to detect a medium-sized difference. That is, there is an 87% chance that you would miss a small real effect, and a 40% chance that you would miss a medium-sized real effect. Based on science, there is an 87% chance that your statement above is wrong.

Linda
 
...and it embarrasses me (a lot) when other people are compelled to say nice things about me.


I can't speak for anyone else, but the first "nice" thing I said was a simple statement of fact, which I didn't think would be embarrassing.
The second thing was an analogy I couldn't resist said as a joke with a good element of truth, it that makes sense. My last sentence was meant to defuse the potentially embarrassing element if the joke was missed.
I guess it didn't work.

If it's any consolation, I still prefer listening to Jethro Tull. :D
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom