Is there proof we exist?

My answer to that question is that it doesn't matter. As far as we can tell we exist so we should act like we exist because to act otherwise is not using the best information we have. Therefore it really doesn't matter is we exist or not since we should act as though we exist.

You mean I shouldn't act like I don't exist then? Okay, I guess I'll stop acting like I don't exist then. :)
 
The Proof Is In The Pudding

Is there proof we exist?


That depends entirely on what your threshold of 'proof' is.

Some people are easy to convince of anything. Individual intelligence plays an important role in trying to convince someone of something.

For example, how do you 'PROVE' your mathematical theory is correct to another person who cannot read your math symbols? All that person sees is meaningless, strange, cryptic symbols and remains unconvinced for obvious reasons. One might wonder, do symbols actually constitute proof of anything? Under such circumstances, what would possibly convince the other person that you were correct?


Perhaps you should ask yourself some questions first:

"If I do exist, what kind of evidence would it take to convince me?"

"If I do not exist, what kind of evidence would it take to convince me?"


Any 'proof' would have to be validated by scientific methods. That's where it gets really sticky in defining what you mean by 'proof'.

Logically speaking, all of our experienced 'reality' is a 'lie', since when more closely examined, nothing is really what we perceive it to be in the final analysis.

In that context, no proof is definitive whether we answer 'yes' or 'no' to that question.

Blame Quantum Mechanics for that! QM is evil !
LOL

I think it's one of those endless philosophical questions with no possible satisfactory answer.

Not to be a stick in the mud, but I've often wondered if questions that cannot ever hope for an answer are worthy of prolonged debate - especially questions that have lasted for thousands of years and are no more answerable today than they were several millennia ago.

But, one can dream.

:)
 
Last edited:
I think a satisfactory answer could be looked for by answering the question:

Would a perfect simulation of a particular existance be any less real than what it simulates?

If I am just a simulation, I am still just as real as if I wasn't a simulation. The sum total of my experiences is going to be what I am in either case.
 
Sure I would have. My dream would be supplying it for me. Dreams do that.

Well said and maybe so RandFan but the thing that's going to plague you in the morning is whether it was your dream that supplied it or mine!
 
The Perfect 9.999999999999999999999999999999999

... Would a perfect simulation of a particular existance be any less real than what it simulates?

It couldn't know unless it (the simulation) could examine the external thing it was supposed to be simulating and make a comparison.

How could your video game character examine your 'real' world to determine his status as pertains to his possible reality as opposed to the reality of his creator?

From his viewpoint, you would be a supernatural being he could only speculate about forever, but never meet on equal grounds of 'reality'.

In his world, only the Pastor Woo and his congregation would believe in you.

Evidently, two different 'realities' cannot be directly compared in any meaningful way.


Do dead people ask, "Am I dead or is it all just a very realistic dream?"

Maybe being able to contemplate reality is proof in itself of reality.
 
Last edited:
Problem with that: some amount of that finite processing resource would be required to maintain the illusion.

True, but you could argue that the more the mind was stimulated the more useful processing could be done. It's a little bit pseudoscientific bollocks, but this is The Matrix we're talking about.
 
BTW, the philosophical term for this issue is "epistomology", and it's been debated for centuries, so it shouldn't be hard to find all the lousy theories (in addition to mine) that you want on it.
A strange implication of an objective world is events occuring prior to being born - you look back into time witnessing events through pictures and film, all happening in a universe in which you did not exist yet. Your awareness was nowhere, nothing, at the time. You were uncreated - yet events happened. It's utterly absurd in an existential sense.
 
looked up epistomology interesting.

am i paraphrasing this right ? your saying prior to occuping here. you can look back into time and witness events that happened prior to your trip.
 
looked up epistomology interesting.

am i paraphrasing this right ? your saying prior to occuping here. you can look back into time and witness events that happened prior to your trip.
Well, obviously lots of high-adventure happened before brother Philip ever existed. The big bang, dinosaurs, the second world war, you name it - which implies:

1) You die, but the world and the ten-thousand forms of taxes remain.

2) By chance/transmigration/fate, you come into form again at a particular place and time, in some form of universe (hopefully one with beer). After surviving childhood, you notice you are alive, but have no idea what's going to happen to you afterward.

3) While huffing butane on a dare during your teenage years, you realize your own "self" is a fiction and is co-dependent with the natural enviornment.

4) While stubbing your toe on a rusty nail, which quickly becomes infected, requiring hospitalization - and also requiring you to listen to bedridden and in pain, "Lala" by Ashlee Simpson on a radio station you cannot change every three hours, you express annoyance at this undignified condition.

5) Realizing with some degree of faith you've got more mojo going on than a two-stroke engine, you set out to find some way nature provides to a) either live in a better place or b) stop this from happening again altogether.
 
Last edited:
It couldn't know unless it (the simulation) could examine the external thing it was supposed to be simulating and make a comparison.
.
.

That's the point of the question. Even if you were simply a perfect simulation, you would have no basis for drawing that conclusion. Hence, no frame of reference (or state of existence) should allow one to come to any definitive answer as to whether or not your reality is a 'real one'.

If on the other hand you were to say that no perfect simulation is ever possible, because true reality includes complexities that cannot be exactly defined, hence cannot be exactly simulated. That would be your definition of the true reality corresponding to a true existence:

The true existence of reality is that which cannot be simulated.
 
It's a little bit pseudoscientific bollocks, but this is The Matrix we're talking about.

That's why I was going the unprovability or malicious intents routes, no pseudoscience required, beyond the fantasy spun to the inhabitants.

I actually have a lot of respect for sci-fi authors who can incorporate good science into their work. Kim Stanley Robinson did an excellent job of this in the Mars books. I'm trying to work out an FTL system for an interstellar civilization, and it's hard to achieve all 3 objectives: i) make it non-woo-ish, ii) not copy every other sci-fi out there, and iii) result in an interesting setting, appropriate for the stories I want to tell. It's hard!

It's worse when people go the other way around, trying to pull gobbledygook from sci-fi and presenting it as a theory of reality :mad: . That technique does a favour, neither to science, nor science fiction. Any pseudoscience is designed to support the fiction in the first place, not the other way around. Sci-fi is better at inspiration than explanation...
 
Am I Real Or Am I Memorex ?

... Even if you were simply a perfect simulation, you would have no basis for drawing that conclusion. Hence, no frame of reference (or state of existence) should allow one to come to any definitive answer as to whether or not your reality is a 'real one'.



If you were a "perfect" simulation, how could you be differentiated from the genuine article?

The argument goes full-circle.

:)
 
Exactly!

Since a perfect simulation cannot be distinguished from what it simulates.. you have to first answer the question: can a perfect simulation exist?

The answer to that, is what lets you come to a conclusion regarding the OPs question.

If a perfect simulation is possible, then no reality is the 'real one'.

If a perfect simulation is impossible, then that which cannot be simulated is the 'real one'.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom