Is there proof we exist?

To the one poster who asked whether my favorite movies are the matrix trilogy...for pies sake no...no no no and an everlasting NO. I hated all 3 of the matrix movies...

See...

and I kinda liked the first one. The 'power system' was a terribly executed idea (so bad, in fact, that it prevents the Matrix from being my all-time favorite). It combined that sort-of fun 2:00 am discussion about the meaning of reality (or afternoon discussion if you're VN), with some nice action/adventure. It had a little bit of everything for everyone... with sunglasses added for style... :cool:

The other two were average sci-fi, and drek at that!
 
Basically I'm asking, why can't we simulate or force dreams?
Now? Or Ever?

For now we don't understand the hardware and code well enough. In the future I don't see why not.

Your getting ever closer to the Matrix movies. That's ok. So, your questions are not meant to illicit information there is somewhere you are taking us?
 
Well.

No matter whether we really exist or not, or whether the universe is really out there or not, there are a few things to be aware of.

Whether real or illusion, what we experience has consequences that appear to be "real". We feel pain, discomfort, hunger, happiness, pleasure, etc. So far, we haven't been made aware of any other "real" besides what we experience. Thus, the only pragmatic conclusion is that, whether real or not, we shoudl treat what we experience as reality; as it appears to affect us as if it were "really real".
 
yep

Well IMO Sony is on the right track. I'd rather have a version of counter strike where I can smell the crack in the crackhouse map....ok mayeb not that far...but you get the idea. As for vr hookers...well, I look down on that concept as much as it seems you do DragonBallZ.;)

I'd much rather see technology go towards something fun than something perverted. If your that obsessed...ya know...their IS an opposite sex out there...or atleast I've heard. :confused:
 
Stop paying your bills for a while, and keep an eye on your mail. You'll receive all sorts of proof that you exist.
 
Ok, so here is my next question that requires more knowledge than I have on hand in a small town in Missouri.

Is there proof we exist?
Are you not really asking "why" we exist?

Dunno.

As to whether or not; take this posted reply as proof positive. How much more evidence would you like?

You could try to kill yourself and see if we still exist. Some people call that religion.
 
Last edited:
Well.

No matter whether we really exist or not, or whether the universe is really out there or not, there are a few things to be aware of.

Whether real or illusion, what we experience has consequences that appear to be "real". We feel pain, discomfort, hunger, happiness, pleasure, etc. So far, we haven't been made aware of any other "real" besides what we experience. Thus, the only pragmatic conclusion is that, whether real or not, we shoudl treat what we experience as reality; as it appears to affect us as if it were "really real".
Agreed, and remember this, no matter where you go, there you are.
 
So, my question is, in an existence where basically our mind tells us everything we know...how do we know that our mind is telling the truthe, or that its all a big lie?

Krelnius, the Matrix has you ;)

Cheers - Mattus
 
Everytime I hear a question like this, I want to poke the asker repeatedly with a very sharp stick until they conceed that they do exist...or until they get blood on my shoes. One or the other.
 
to paraphrase Pierre-Simon Laplace: "I have no need for this hypothesis".

The postulation that nothing that my senses tell me is real, but is instead a vivid hallucination is bereft of useful information. As all I can experience is this world, how am I helped by the idea that this world is not real?

When faced with a vivid, all-encompassing, coherent hallucination that behaves like reality, you might as well call it reality.
 
and I kinda liked the first one. The 'power system' was a terribly executed idea (so bad, in fact, that it prevents the Matrix from being my all-time favorite).

absolutely. From the moment I saw the first one, I wondered why they went with "power" as the reason for keeping humans around. Why not use cows? The Cow Matrix would have all of the power and none of the risk.

Wouldn't it have been a much better idea for humans to be farmed for their processing power? The brain is a remarkable thing. It's a much stronger science fiction idea for brainpower to be farmed rather than heat.
 
Wouldn't it have been a much better idea for humans to be farmed for their processing power? The brain is a remarkable thing. It's a much stronger science fiction idea for brainpower to be farmed rather than heat.

Problem with that: some amount of that finite processing resource would be required to maintain the illusion.

I thought of 3 fictional scenarios that might convey a more 'realistic' feel

i) They're trapped in an n-deep stack of simulations. The machine war, itself, was a lie (of course, as we've discussed on this board it's a useless description of reality... but that could be part of the horror!)
ii) The lead AI went 'off' during the war and came up with a sadistic way to torture humans (dangle victory in front of awakened eyes), at a power expense!
iii) A human group was controlling the machines and simulation! What enslavement!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom