Is there proof we exist?

My answer to that question is that it doesn't matter. As far as we can tell we exist so we should act like we exist because to act otherwise is not using the best information we have. Therefore it really doesn't matter is we exist or not since we should act as though we exist.

When I first got my own place, I tried to act as if the junk mail I found in my mailbox didn't exist. Despite my best efforts, it persisted in its apparent existence, clogging my mailbox to the point that it was difficult to pull out my legitimate mail. Finally, an alleged object that appeared to the the mailman lectured me on the importance of taking ALL my mail out of the mailbox, not just that whose existence I had faith in. Now I put it in the trash, which supposedly goes to a landfill, but I haven't perceived this first hand.

I'm still not convinced that junkmail exists. But it helps to pretend that it does. ;)
 
There's the proof we need. Proof by junk Mail.
All we need is the latin for "I receive Junk e-mail" so we can add "ergo Sum" to it. Problem solved, and probably a fun T-Shirt to sell...


Now, for my actual ramblings on the topic.

It seems to me that the problem is "Who are we proving our existance to?". without an Outside observer to submit proof to, and trying to prove it conclusivly to ourselves is, well, circular isn't the proper term, but does kind of get redundant.

hmm. not quite so clear. My thinking is along the lines of "Since I can interact with my computer, I determine it exists." I can interact with other people, so we form sort of a mutual-existance pact. As more and more things are added to the M-E pact, it gets to as close of a proof as we're likely to get.

Maybe I'm not making sense. anyone able to clean it up for me?

Trif
 
Trifikas said:
hmm. not quite so clear. My thinking is along the lines of "Since I can interact with my computer, I determine it exists." I can interact with other people, so we form sort of a mutual-existance pact. As more and more things are added to the M-E pact, it gets to as close of a proof as we're likely to get.
There you go! You can define real as meaning something like "anything that interacts with anything else." Now we can say things are real without getting bogged down in the mind-numbingly annoying ontological question about "what stuff actually is."

~~ Paul
 
You can define real as meaning something like "anything that interacts with anything else." Now we can say things are real without getting bogged down in the mind-numbingly annoying ontological question about "what stuff actually is."

~~ Paul

The wave function of a free particle is dispersive... or summat :D

However, some particles (such as the ions in an ionic crystal) are likely localized.

So... could an answer to the Woo Interpretation of QM be something like: rather than having conscious observers, we can define reality as things and their interactions. This would necessitate:
i) Things cannot be fully defined as wholly separate from their interactions
ii) Interactions cannot be fully defined as wholly separate from their things
iii) As one is studied more intently, less is known about the other separately

I call it Jimmy's Thingness Uncertainty Principle! :D
 
The problem with Descartes line is its incompleteness. There are people who cannot think - and yet are, demonstrably , there.

Where did Descartes go when he was not thinking?

Thinking cannot define existence, though it can test it.

I suspect the thread is another of the one shot wonders we are seeing lately. I take such posts seriously because we never know who else is reading it. There may be real people out there thinking the same things. But if they don't interact with the forum, we don't know they exist.
 
The problem with Descartes line is its incompleteness. There are people who cannot think - and yet are, demonstrably , there.

Where did Descartes go when he was not thinking?

Thinking cannot define existence, though it can test it.

I suspect the thread is another of the one shot wonders we are seeing lately. I take such posts seriously because we never know who else is reading it. There may be real people out there thinking the same things. But if they don't interact with the forum, we don't know they exist.

See, I took Descartes to mean, "if you can think you" are rather than "when you think, you are" as a way of proving to self that you exist.
 
Is there proof we exist?
No.

Also, I don't see a way to refute this... I mean...how could u tell a dream from reality if you never knew the difference?
Welcome to two thousand years of philosophical inquiry. Thanks for joining us. See early Greek philosophers, solipsism, Descartes and mountains of other mental masturbatory thought (not that that's a bad thing BTW.) I dig it big time.

In any event, this is how we resolve the issue. I (that's me) Locks you (that's you) in a room without food, water or toilet until you agree that reality is real and you promise to forever abandon solipsism.

Does it prove anything? No.

Will in convince you? It will either kill you or convince you. Both have roughly the same outcome of ending any serious entertainment of such thoughts.

ETA: No, it might not even convince you. You might be lying to get out still believing that it is all in your mind.

So in the end whether we believe in reality or not it doesn't matter. The fidler plays and we dance...or die.
 
Last edited:
Shemp said:
If somebody comes up with a proof that we DON'T exist, would you please let me know so I don't have to pay my income taxes?
I'll let you know, but don't forget that you have to pay your nonexistent income taxes, then.

~~ Paul
 
hey

Hey come on give me some credit, I came back see? I just visit like once every day or 2 is all. I'm lazy. ;)

Now as for my response to...everyone...this post was kinda my follow up post to my post on why we dream. I consider dreams and the idea that all reality is basically in the mind to be easily linked to eachother for arguments sake.

Obviously the idea that we have to take reality for what it is...is correct...I mean, true there is no proof that we don't exist...but the idea itself means that it can't be proven...its kind of like saying there is a bar and grill in another universe...or Christianity somewhat....the claim itself is believable because it is a lot like saying God did everything....then when someone says "Wow! Look at that!" a believer can jsut say "Yep. God did it." and when someone says to prove Gods existance they can simply say "God wants his believers to take him on faith, but we know he is there!"

To the one poster who asked whether my favorite movies are the matrix trilogy...for pies sake no...no no no and an everlasting NO. I hated all 3 of the matrix movies...I think their a bunch of rip offs of modern and even some classic anime. Especially the action scenes...really obvious DragonBallZ influence there with some scenes being close to a "copy & paste" job. But please...do not get me start on how badly I hate those movies.

Moving on...I just had another question for you guys! Woot! Here it is...

Ok, this isnt it, a little reason first. I've read before that with certain parts of the brain being linked to certain sensory input such as smell, taste, and touch that by stimulating areas on the brain that someone can be made to think that something is happening when its not...like an old smell or taste or sensation etc. This sounds like crap to me and I can't remember where I read it, but if it was true then if such a technology was fine tuned to a science couldnt we simulate entire dreams by sequencing the reactions? Oh...and like...putting the person asleep and paralyzing them...or something?

Basically I'm asking, why can't we simulate or force dreams?
 
I hated all 3 of the matrix movies...I think their a bunch of rip offs of modern and even some classic anime.
aha! So you saw the 2nd and 3rd one, even though you saw the 1st one!
really obvious DragonBallZ influence there with some scenes being close to a "copy & paste" job.
oh boy..

Moving on...I just had another question for you guys! Woot! Here it is...

I've read before that with certain parts of the brain being linked to certain sensory input such as smell, taste, and touch that by stimulating areas on the brain that someone can be made to think that something is happening when its not...like an old smell or taste or sensation etc. This sounds like crap to me and I can't remember where I read it, but if it was true then if such a technology was fine tuned to a science couldnt we simulate entire dreams by sequencing the reactions?
It's not technicaly possible yet, but it is researched, and patent for the idea has been pursued by Sony about a year ago
http://www.swissbiotechassociation.ch/files/countryprofile/ST_NewsJ_April_2005.pdf
search for 'matrix' in the PDF, it's copy protected, can't copy and paste.
another link:
http://www.newscientist.com/article.ns?id=mg18624944.600
Interestingly, sony wants to use the idea for .. computer games! I'm thinking it would do for cool interactive TV and perfect virtual reality.
My friends think the best implementation of the idea is to create... virtual brothels.

Interesting, that in Japan you can just patent an idea like that, without any technology etc. being developed. Won't it just stop the progress in this particular area?
 
Ok, so here is my next question that requires more knowledge than I have on hand in a small town in Missouri.

Is there proof we exist?

Not only is there one proof, there's ninety proof.
If that's not proof enough, there's 140 proof.
If you need more proof than that, there's Everclear, at 200 proof.
 
dreaming soon

dont belive anything you hear and only half of what you see. delveing into dreams is a pretty tricky busness. dont even know whats going on when we're awake yet. and how do we know we're here "this side of the other side" the answer comes and goes as you age.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom