Split Thread Is there an underground oligarchy ruling the world?

So then it is a good thing that monetary policy is set by the Fed rather than politicians. Glad we got that cleared up.
 
Sure, under a corrupt, corporate-controlled government like we currently have, but not under an honest government truly working in the best interests of the people it represents.

In a healthy, growing economy with normal population increases, the supply of money would need to expand in tandem with the expansion of available goods and services. This expansion of the money supply could be spent right into the economy by the government without creating any inflation whatsoever.

Your government has almost zilch to say about how other nations value your currency.

But besides that... now we get to the real core of the thing...

Without the people 'breeding' as you so flatteringly said, this scheme won't work. And I am not mentioning a Malthusian trap for the 'continued growth scheme'.

And then, the next thing that comes up is the longevity (or do you want to discard older people or deny them healthcare after supporting that growth).
At some point the people that can not produce will outnumber the people that can.

And the resources for creating goods is also a fun matter: the US will either have to be cheaper to have fun with exporting goods (i.e. accept a ridiculous inflation) or it will have to trade and play nice with the others to keep up the current level of living.
And they won't play nice if the US is just running the printing mills.

So, again, what you are proposing is nothing but 'a way to ruin, but fast and furious'.
 
Without the people 'breeding' as you so flatteringly said, this scheme won't work.

False, as economic growth is not necessarily dependent on population growth. In fact, an economy can grow even with a falling population if increases in productivity outpace decreases in population.

And then, the next thing that comes up is the longevity (or do you want to discard older people or deny them healthcare after supporting that growth). At some point the people that can not produce will outnumber the people that can.

Why would the number of non-producers outgrow the number of producers? What are you basing this claim on?

And the resources for creating goods is also a fun matter: the US will either have to be cheaper to have fun with exporting goods (i.e. accept a ridiculous inflation) or it will have to trade and play nice with the others to keep up the current level of living.
And they won't play nice if the US is just running the printing mills.

I can't figure out what you are trying to say here. "The U.S. will either have to be cheaper to have fun with exporting goods"? What?

So, again, what you are proposing is nothing but 'a way to ruin, but fast and furious'.

I'm not convinced you have any idea what you are even trying to say. I know I don't.
 
No, not really. You haven't made a convincing argument for having a private banking cartel in control of the nation's monetary policy. When you do, let me know.

First, I don't think that a "private banking cartel" sets the monetary policy. You do. And you have been completely unable to support this.

Second you agreed that the Federal Reserve system is better than having our politicians set monetary policy. Well, unless you think that making the dollar worthless is a better system.
 
No, not really. You haven't made a convincing argument for having a private banking cartel in control of the nation's monetary policy. When you do, let me know.

That might be because the case made has nothing to do with your fantasy of a cartel being in control of policy.

If on the other hand you look at the case made, for policy dictating how much has to be borrowed, regardless of source, the answer is yes.

Exactly why he should make a good case for your "cartel" and not forthe actual practice of the Fed is beyond me.
 
Now that's the understatement of the week.



Straw man. I never claimed they were, but they still qualified as "concentration camps" based on the terminology the British used to describe them during the Second Boer War.

Anyway you slice it, Roosevelt put innocent AMERICAN citizens in internment/concentration camps without due process or regard for their human rights. As such, he was a scumbag president.
Missing the point as usual. Concentration camps is a term coined by the British that has a specific definition... that Internment Camps (which has it's own definition) does not share.

To continue the previous analogy, Internment Camps are closer to jay walking than genocide on the moral scale.
 
Missing the point as usual. Concentration camps is a term coined by the British that has a specific definition... that Internment Camps (which has it's own definition) does not share.

To continue the previous analogy, Internment Camps are closer to jay walking than genocide on the moral scale.

The two meanings are close, and are often conflabulated, but are different. Especially in the legal terms of the Geneva conventions (third and fourth I think). The difference is often overlooked, but important, especially when making a claim that the two are identical.

The most pertinent example would be the conditions in the camps where Jewish settlers were held while the state of Israel was being created, and the conditions of the Nazi concentration camps (that did more than anything else to widen the gap between the meanings). Neither are nice, neither should be hoped for, but they are in different shades of immorality.
 
SpringHallConvert said:
False, as economic growth is not necessarily dependent on population growth. In fact, an economy can grow even with a falling population if increases in productivity outpace decreases in population.

Why would the number of non-producers outgrow the number of producers? What are you basing this claim on?

I can't figure out what you are trying to say here. "The U.S. will either have to be cheaper to have fun with exporting goods"? What?

I'm not convinced you have any idea what you are even trying to say. I know I don't.

Afaik it was you that mentioned population growth for a healthy economy.

The number of non-producers outgrowing the producers is called the 'urn' model in demographics and that is what happens when the population does not produce enough offspring.
I am basing that on generic understanding of demographics and the CIA World factbook.

I guess you understand that the economic growth needs to both compensate for the longevity (non producing people, like pensioners, who have nothing to barter, only accumulated wealth) and for the decrease in producers.

As you seem to be unable to understand the fact that the US is not an economic island, let me rephrase it:

If the US starts printing enough cash to keep it's own economy running, the value of the dollar outside the US decreases.

This makes production of a lot of products too expensive for the US to have them outsourced in, let's say, China.

But to produce a lot of these products within the US, it would need to buy the raw materials from, let's say, China.

But because the dollar then is not solid in value, those prices would become prohibitively high, therefore closing off that avenue.

As for the exporting... if the US wants to compete in exporting enough to make up for the loss in income because of the failing dollar, it needs to export other goods or labour.
Since most labour and other goods are available quite cheap elsewhere, the average US employee needs to accept a lower income, or it will not be possible to compete.

Having spelled all that out, I see funny contradictions in what you claim, as well as a lack of decent research.

But have at it kiddo.
 
Our hypothesis is that the world is governed as advertised . From that it would follow that there is no entity such as you describe and with no such entity then there cannot be confirming evidence of that nonexistance(for another eg. its similar to proving you are not an ET living in a human body.)

Your position that such an entity does exist would require that evidence of said oligarchy also exists.

You claim that such an all powerful entity would be able to manipulate all information such that proof of its existance will not be found and can only be implied by examining the world around us.
Once again you demonstrate your complete inability to grasp the concept of null hypothesis.
................
Really, which position sounds 'religious' no all powerfull invisible rulers? (our position) OR an all powerful invisible pantheon of such rulers? (your position)Perhaps the top guy is named "Zeus"?

This is an interesting statement. The informational gatekeepers in the government and media have marketed a concept of how the world works to you and you've totally bought into it. They've effectively sold you a type of reality - the current paradigm under which we live - which you believe is true. You even acknowledge this by characterizing this marketing campaign as a form of advertising.

You're a mind control victim and you don't even know it. Maybe you do subconsciously, which is why you used the word 'advertised' the way you did, but not a conscious level.

Once again you demonstrate your complete inability to grasp the concept of null hypothesis

Shall it be explained yet again? I certainly tire of trying to have you grasp this relatively simple concept of science and logic.


You claim we are mind controlled slaves and that you know-the-truth.
You claim a cadre of powerful people form an oligarchy that rules the world unseen, yet you seem completely incapable of providing any evidence of the state of the world that you believe is 'the truth'.


Instead you claim that the evidence is all around us and can be therefore easily implied as 'the truth'.

That sounds so very familiar. I have been told that the existance of God is also implied by the evidence all around us.

What sets you aparrt from such true believers SHC? What sets your belief apart from the style of the religious? What can you provide in way of evidence that your belief should in fact be shared by those here?

What makes your concept of how the world works compelling to you? What marketing have you bought into? What events, concepts and evidence was used in that marketing? Or did you arrive at this yourself? Was it an epiphany of your own? Something must have convinced you that the world did not function the way it is accepted as functioning by the ast majority, what were they?

I have missed a few pages of this thread, and have little time right now to do so. If you have supplied such evidence then perhaps you'd care to link me to said post, or perhaps someone else can do so for me since you rarely, if ever, actually respond to requests or questions.
 
Last edited:
First, I don't think that a "private banking cartel" sets the monetary policy.

Then you need to support this. Where's your evidence?

Second you agreed that the Federal Reserve system is better than having our politicians set monetary policy.

False. Link?

Well, unless you think that making the dollar worthless is a better system.

That's what the Federal Reserve has been doing ever since 1913 - making the dollar worthless. A 1913 U.S. dollar has lost roughly 95% of its value since then.
 
Why is gold any more meaningful than a bank note?

It is not vegetable oil or some other consumable, it only has an arbitrary value assigned by desire.

For one thing, gold has a limited supply that doesn't quickly change, which mirrors the economy and the supply of goods and services. It can't be printed up and counterfeited and expanded just by pushing a button on a printing press. Gold represents human labor, as each ounce, on average, requires considerable labor to extract from the ground. Gold is consistent as money, and its use as money goes back thousands of years.

Why is interest bearing debt-money superior?
 
No. The null stands there is no cartel. You have to support the assertion there is an organised cartel. The burden of proof is yours.

False. Since the Federal Reserve represents a cartel of private banks, with Federal Reserve stock being owned by member private banks, you need to show they are not dictating monetary policy. Prove it.
 
False. Since the Federal Reserve represents a cartel of private banks, with Federal Reserve stock being owned by member private banks, you need to show they are not dictating monetary policy. Prove it.
Prove you don't understand how the Federal Reserve works? You already have.
 
Last edited:
No. The null stands there is no cartel. You have to support the assertion there is an organised cartel. The burden of proof is yours.

I guess that the troll will not provide information and say you have to prove what you say....so he can hand wave it away

lol
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom