Split Thread Is there an underground oligarchy ruling the world?

False. Since the Federal Reserve represents a cartel of private banks, with Federal Reserve stock being owned by member private banks, you need to show they are not dictating monetary policy. Prove it.

Untill you prove the highlighted part there is no reason to assume it is so. How do you not get this? There is a distinction between stock being owned by private banks (if that is how you choose to simplify it) and those banks being an organised cartel. You have not shown there is an organised cartel. Then the assumption is not that they are dictating policy, the null would be: "Cartel X buys stock the same way they buy any other stock for profit". You would have to show there was a link between this stock being bought and the direction of policy to prove your assertion that the cartel influences policy through ownership of stock.

The burden of proof is STILL yours.
 
No. It looks like you are having a hard time proving your assertions.

Ah but that isn't his point, his real point is to dismiss anything you say and tell you are [standard troll insult x], etc ad nauseum - haven't you notice this pattern yet?
 
This secret oligarchy operates very much like mysticism, religion and other paranormal stuff. It only leaves vague, non-testable evidence of its existence, and that evidence has to be inferred and interpreted by those with special insight and knowledge, not mere mortals. Maybe it's quantum?
 
Nope, it's yours. Prove that the private banks who own the stock of the Federal Reserve aren't dictating monetary policy for the whole country, since this is what you believe.

Prove it.
Nope. You claim private banks own the stock of the Federal Reserve are dictating monetary policy for the whole country.

Prove it.
 
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ol3mEe8TH7w

At 7:40 in the linked video Alan Greenspan states that the fed is indapendant and thus doesn't answer to congress.

Another way to prove that the fed is private is to check the phone book and see them listed under private as opposed to other government agencies.
 
Nope. You claim private banks own the stock of the Federal Reserve are dictating monetary policy for the whole country.

Prove it.

Nope. Don't need to, since you can't prove the Federal Reserve works the way you think it works.

Denied.
 
Not sure about that phone book method. We had another poster here who "proved" that the US government was secretly a corporation because they had a business telephone number.
 
At 7:40 in the linked video Alan Greenspan states that the fed is indapendant and thus doesn't answer to congress.

But, but, but... The Federal Reserve chairman position is appointed by the president! At least, that's what we are told! That means the president is really the one who dictates monetary policy. No, wait. Since the people vote for the president, that means it's really the people who dictate monetary policy! Yeah, that's it!

Government truth for the win!

Another way to prove that the fed is private is to check the phone book and see them listed under private as opposed to other government agencies.

But, but, but... paper money is better than gold-backed money! I heard it on TV!
 
Last edited:
Not sure about that phone book method. We had another poster here who "proved" that the US government was secretly a corporation because they had a business telephone number.

Maybe the U.S. government is secretly a corporation?

It certainly seems to operate like one.
 
But, but, but... The Federal Reserve chairman position is appointed by the president! At least, that's what we are told! That means the president is really the one who dictates monetary policy. No, wait. Since the people vote for the president, that means it's really the people who dictate monetary policy! Yeah, that's it!

Government truth for the win!



But, but, but... paper money is better than gold-backed money! A heard it on TV!

I'm waiting for someone to say ''but prove it' lol.
 
Then you need to support this. Where's your evidence?

Still having problems with the concept of the null hypothesis, huh, troll.

False. Link?

You are a liar. In this post, you agreed that our politicians would turn the dollar into some worthless currency. And so you agree that the Federal Reserve is better. Unless you want the dollar to be worthless.

That's what the Federal Reserve has been doing ever since 1913 - making the dollar worthless. A 1913 U.S. dollar has lost roughly 95% of its value since then.

It doesn't matter what the value is relative to what it was 100 years ago. It matters what it is relative to other currencies. And guess what, the dollar is the dominant currency in the world. And really, you are a *********** moron if you can't keep your money ahead of inflation anyway.
 
How does the troll know that the private banks own stock in the regional Federal Reserve banks? Apparently, he is perfectly fine using official sources when he thinks it suits his purposes. But when those same sources explain how monetary policy is actually set, he just ignores it.

Pathetic.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom