Split Thread Is there an underground oligarchy ruling the world?

So FDR was an evil liar but told the truth when it is convenient to your paranoid delusions. Assuming he even said that. I doubt you can prove it.

Yes, Roosevelt was an evil, lying scoundrel when he addressed the American people. You can read many of his 1940 presidential campaign speeches in which he promised to keep the United States out of the war in Europe. In fact, that was one of the main platforms of his campaign. Of course, as soon as he was re-elected, he aggressively went back on that promise and got the U.S. heavily involved in the War in the Atlantic against Germany.

But Roosevelt wasn't addressing the American people in the quote I referenced earlier in the thread. He was addressing Colonel Edward Mandell House, one of his and Woodrow Wilson's closest advisors. Here is that quote again, taken from a personal letter Roosevelt wrote to House in 1933:

The real truth of the matter is, as you and I know, that a financial element in the larger centers has owned the Government ever since the days of Andrew Jackson — and I am not wholly excepting the Administration of W. W. The country is going through a repetition of Jackson's fight with the Bank of the United States — only on a far bigger and broader basis.

http://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Franklin_D._Roosevelt

I see no reason to doubt the authenticity or honesty of the quote. If you do, go ahead and explain why. Feel free to also explain why a sitting president would refer to the U.S. government as being "owned" by a financial element.
 
I will accept that he actually wrote that. It is hardly proof that the evil Jews bankers secretly control everything though.

When are you going to get around to proving that the Federal Reserve is controlled by privates banks?
 
In context

Letter to Edward M. House
Warm Springs, November 21, 1933

My dear Friend:

Dan showed me your letter, and the next day I sent for the Sprague person. To tell you the honest truth I had had no intention of hurting Sprague's feelings by not sending for him, but equally honestly I did not send for him because of the very simple reason that I had entirely forgotten his existence for at least a month.

On several occasions after his return from London, I had long talks with him and tried to get from him some concrete proposal or suggestion which would help us to lift the price level and therefore the debt burden under which the Country, especially the West and South, was staggering. He gave me me absolutely no constructive thought— only the same old suggestions about open market purchases and stabilization of the dollar with the pound. Everyone who is not blind knows that the open market purchases have practically no immediate effect and only a very doubtful long-range effect; also that every time stabilization on the old level of about $4.50 was mentioned, cotton, wheat, corn and everything else started to go down. A continuation of the fall of the price level which ran from the middle of September to the middle of October would have brought the whole Recovery Program toppling about our ears.

Sprague is a nuisance. He carries no real weight except with the Bank of England crowd and some of our New York City bankers, and I regard his suggestion of a meeting as absolutely disloyal. In any event, I kept him from formally delivering a silly letter to me, had Woodin talk with him and subsequently Morgenthau, Jr. Sprague has said that if he resigned, Government bonds would go down five points! Now let me tell you something cheerful.

This Southland has a smile on its face. Ten cent cotton has stopped foreclosures, saved banks and started people definitely on the upgrade. That means all the way from Virginia to Texas. Sears-Roebuck sales in Georgia are 110 per cent above 1932.

Another angle: Hugh Johnson has just telephoned me to be sure to read the latest Dun & Bradstreet Report. He says every section of the country is showing definite gain.

I had a nice talk with Jack Morgan the other day and he and he seemed more worried about Tugwell's speech than about anything else, especially when Tugwell said, "From now on property rights and financial rights will be subordinated to human rights." J.P.M. did not seem much troubled over the gold purchasing, and confessed that he had been completely misled in regard to the Federal expenditures. The real truth of the matter is, as you and I know, that a financial element in the larger centers has owned the Government ever since the days of Andrew Jackson— and I am not wholly excepting the Administration of WW — The country is going through a repetition of Jackson's fight with the Bank of the United Stated - only on a far bigger and broader basis. I am having a grand rest and am catching up on much needed sleep. Take care of yourself and do write me soon
 
In context

I'm not sure what extra context the quote needs. Roosevelt essentially admitted in very clear language to our government being "owned" by a "financial element" in "the larger centers". My best guess as to what he meant:

Owned - Controlled by, dominated by, beholden to, in the back pocket of, etc...

Financial element - Super-wealthy person/s, financiers, money trust, financial coterie, etc...

Larger centers - Centers of finance, commerce, or trade, Wall Street, New York, City of London, etc...
 
I'm not sure what extra context the quote needs. Roosevelt essentially admitted in very clear language to our government being "owned" by a "financial element" in "the larger centers". My best guess as to what he meant:

Owned - Controlled by, dominated by, beholden to, in the back pocket of, etc...

Financial element - Super-wealthy person/s, financiers, money trust, financial coterie, etc...

Larger centers - Centers of finance, commerce, or trade, Wall Street, New York, City of London, etc...
Why do you believe this particular government source. Would it be because you like it? Isn't that a bias on your part?

You need to learn about consistency. If it's from the government or media it's no good, right?
 
I will accept that he actually wrote that. It is hardly proof that the evil Jews bankers secretly control everything though.

Maybe not, but it certainly seems to suggest that things aren't quite as they seem. Imagine the uproar if Roosevelt had given a speech in which he announced to the American people that our government "has been owned by a financial element in the larger centers ever since the days of Andrew Jackson". How do you think the American people would have reacted then? How do you think the American people would react now if told the same thing by a U.S. president?

It's a pretty astonishing quote.

When are you going to get around to proving that the Federal Reserve is controlled by privates banks?

Who else would control the Federal Reserve? The stock of the Federal Reserve is most certainly owned by the private member banks within the Federal Reserve System. I highly doubt the wealthy private bankers/robber barons who acted to create the Federal Reserve a hundred years ago would have done so if it meant they would be giving up control of their shares (leverage) or the influence they would have over the Federal Reserve's policies.
 
Who else would control the Federal Reserve? The stock of the Federal Reserve is most certainly owned by the private member banks within the Federal Reserve System. I highly doubt the wealthy private bankers/robber barons who acted to create the Federal Reserve a hundred years ago would have done so if it meant they would be giving up control of their shares (leverage) or the influence they would have over the Federal Reserve's policies.

Why do you believe the Federal Reserve is privately owned. All evidence shows otherwise. Do you have special evidence to the contrary? If so, produce it.
 
Maybe not, but it certainly seems to suggest that things aren't quite as they seem. Imagine the uproar if Roosevelt had given a speech in which he announced to the American people that our government "has been owned by a financial element in the larger centers ever since the days of Andrew Jackson". How do you think the American people would have reacted then? How do you think the American people would react now if told the same thing by a U.S. president?

It's a pretty astonishing quote.

Frankly, I am not too concerned about what FDR said in some letter 80 years ago. Especially when we cannot be sure exactly what he meant.

Who else would control the Federal Reserve? The stock of the Federal Reserve is most certainly owned by the private member banks within the Federal Reserve System. I highly doubt the wealthy private bankers/robber barons who acted to create the Federal Reserve a hundred years ago would have done so if it meant they would be giving up control of their shares (leverage) or the influence they would have over the Federal Reserve's policies.

So you have got no evidence whatsoever. Shocker. I don't really give a **** about your incredulity. It means nothing. It is true that the member banks own shares of each of the 12 regional Federal Reserve Banks . But this does not mean that they control the Federal Reserve. I would say why, but I would like to give you the opportunity to make yourself look like a fool some more first. Proceed.
 
Why do you believe this particular government source.

Because it comes from a personal letter between two government insiders. The American people were not supposed to be the audience.

Would it be because you like it? Isn't that a bias on your part?

Why would I like finding out that the government I pay taxes to is owned by an unknown "financial element"? If anything, I hate the quote and what it means for this country. It means our government is no longer representing our interests. It's representing the interests of whoever "owns" it.

You need to learn about consistency. If it's from the government or media it's no good, right?

Again, it depends a lot on the intended audience. If I am the intended audience, I expect to be lied to or misled. If Edward Mandell House was the intended audience, I expect that Roosevelt would level with him, because House was deeply connected to Beltway politics and couldn't be fooled on such matters anyway.
 
Because it comes from a personal letter between two government insiders. The American people were not supposed to be the audience.

How do you know this? How do you know this was not some disinfo to overthrow our system? Sounds like you're a conspiracy theorist.

It would help if you actually told us your criteria for deciding what to trust.
 
Yes, Roosevelt was an evil, lying scoundrel when he addressed the American people. You can read many of his 1940 presidential campaign speeches in which he promised to keep the United States out of the war in Europe. In fact, that was one of the main platforms of his campaign. Of course, as soon as he was re-elected, he aggressively went back on that promise and got the U.S. heavily involved in the War in the Atlantic against Germany.

Wrong. When he was being reelected there was no way he could have known that America would get dragged into another World War. So he wasn't lying, he was just unable to reasonably keep his promise.
 
Why would I like finding out that the government I pay taxes to is owned by an unknown "financial element"? If anything, I hate the quote and what it means for this country. It means our government is no longer representing our interests. It's representing the interests of whoever "owns" it.

"liking" something and having confirmation bias are two unrelated things. It's just something you "believe", with no evidence to support it whatsoever. You can't even define what evidence would change your mind because it is impossible. Your posts are the ramblings of the quintessential cult member. You're the sheep. Calling those who actually CAN think for themselves sheep is simply some kind of woo woo circuit breaker.
 
Last edited:
Frankly, I am not too concerned about what FDR said in some letter 80 years ago. Especially when we cannot be sure exactly what he meant.

Well, what else could he have meant by saying our government was "owned"? There is no alternative explanation. He meant what he said and said what he meant. Our government is and has been "owned by an unknown financial element" for a very long time.

So you have got no evidence whatsoever. Shocker. I don't really give a **** about your incredulity. It means nothing.

The evidence is the system itself. Our government is constitutionally authorized to coin its own money, but doesn't do so. It ceded this authority to a private banking cartel in 1913. Instead of creating money free of debt or interest, our government has allowed private banks to create interest bearing debt money, which the government must borrow and go into debt to finance its operations.

No honest government serving the public's interest would do such a thing.

It is true that the member banks own shares of each of the 12 regional Federal Reserve Banks . But this does not mean that they control the Federal Reserve. I would say why, but I would like to give you the opportunity to make yourself look like a fool some more first. Proceed.

The fact of the matter is, you can't say why because you don't know. You live in a fairytale world where the government exercises primary control over a privately-owned banking cartel. It doesn't work that way, because the billionaire bankers behind the Federal Reserve control both the government and the Federal Reserve. As I stated earlier in the thread, hardly anybody can get elected at the federal level without favorable corporate media coverage and favorable corporate campaign donations. As such, the public sector will always be dependent on the private sector, which is why Roosevelt plainly stated that our government is "owned by a financial element".

The private sector (Big Business) rules the country, while the public sector (Big Government) is just a puppet used to mesmerize and distract the masses from this reality.
 
Wrong. When he was being reelected there was no way he could have known that America would get dragged into another World War. So he wasn't lying, he was just unable to reasonably keep his promise.

False. The Germans didn't drag the United States into the Atlantic war in the middle of 1941. Roosevelt made that decision. Roosevelt made the decision to use U.S. military assets to protect British merchant shipping in the North Atlantic.

Roosevelt could have kept his promise. The problem is, he never intended to.
 
False. The Germans didn't drag the United States into the Atlantic war in the middle of 1941. Roosevelt made that decision. Roosevelt made the decision to use U.S. military assets to protect British merchant shipping in the North Atlantic.

Roosevelt could have kept his promise. The problem is, he never intended to.

I wouldn't get involved in a discussion about WWII history with some of these folks. They will eat you alive. Just some friendly advice.
 
"liking" something and having confirmation bias are two unrelated things. It's just something you "believe", with no evidence to support it whatsoever. You can't even define what evidence would change your mind because it is impossible. Your posts are the ramblings of the quintessential cult member. You're the sheep. Calling those who actually CAN think for themselves sheep is simply some kind of woo woo circuit breaker.

False, the evidence is the current system itself, which is clearly not representing the interests of the American people. Roosevelt's quote just bears this out.
 
I wouldn't get involved in a discussion about WWII history with some of these folks. They will eat you alive. Just some friendly advice.

I would. I've seen their best and wasn't impressed.

The fact is, Roosevelt dragged the United States into the war in the Atlantic and, by doing so, went against his 1940 campaign campaign promises. No amount of excuse-making or mocking on the part of the Roosevelt jock-sniffers will change that.
 
Well, what else could he have meant by saying our government was "owned"? There is no alternative explanation. He meant what he said and said what he meant. Our government is and has been "owned by an unknown financial element" for a very long time.

Don't know. Unlike you I don't pretend to have the supernatural ability to know exactly what a vague quote from 80 years ago means.

The evidence is the system itself. Our government is constitutionally authorized to coin its own money, but doesn't do so. It ceded this authority to a private banking cartel in 1913.

The US Treasury still coins/prints money, genius.

Instead of creating money free of debt or interest, our government has allowed private banks to create interest bearing debt money, which the government must borrow and go into debt to finance its operations.

The Government doesn't have to borrow any money to finance operations. It only does because the morons in Congress spend money than it takes it. This doesn't have to be the case and isn't always the case.

The fact of the matter is, you can't say why because you don't know. You live in a fairytale world where the government exercises primary control over a privately-owned banking cartel. It doesn't work that way, because the billionaire bankers behind the Federal Reserve control both the government and the Federal Reserve. As I stated earlier in the thread, hardly anybody can get elected at the federal level without favorable corporate media coverage and favorable corporate campaign donations. As such, the public sector will always be dependent on the private sector, which is why Roosevelt plainly stated that our government is "owned by a financial element".

The private sector (Big Business) rules the country, while the public sector (Big Government) is just a puppet used to mesmerize and distract the masses from this reality.

Let me guess you googled and figured out how the Fed actually works. And now you're altering you conspiracy theory from saying that the private banks directly control the Fed to saying that the same evil billionaire Jews that own the banks (even though the largest of these banks are actually publicly traded) control the government, and thus who is appointed to the Fed's Board of Governors. Of course, you have no proof whatsoever for this either. Although both Bernanke and Greenspan are Jews. Probably all you need to implicate them, right?
 
Last edited:
False. The Germans didn't drag the United States into the Atlantic war in the middle of 1941. Roosevelt made that decision. Roosevelt made the decision to use U.S. military assets to protect British merchant shipping in the North Atlantic.

Roosevelt could have kept his promise. The problem is, he never intended to.

There's a world of difference in rendering humanitarian aid and what you are erroneously suggesting. Just in case there was any confusion on the mater.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom