Is the swine flu going to be pandemic?

Flu's True Severity Is Still Unknown - Don't Leap to Conclusions, WHO Warns (as does skep, repeatedly ;) )
Regardless of how dangerous it proves to be, the new swine flu virus is almost certain to eventually infect every continent and country, although that may take years. Studies in the 1930s found that 97 percent of people born before 1920 had antibodies to the Spanish influenza virus. That's evidence that virtually everyone alive in the three years it circulated -- 1918, 1919 and 1920 -- was at one point infected, even if they didn't know it.
That is mind boggling!

4. Why have so many people died in Mexico, but virtually nobody anywhere else?
a swarm of public health experts — including several from the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention — have descended upon Mexico in search of an answer. This is especially a head-scratcher because experts have found no difference in samples of the virus collected in Mexico and the United States.

One theory is that many more people have had the virus in Mexico than health officials realize, and the number of cases there could well eclipse the number anywhere else in the world. If so, that country's death toll — more than a dozen confirmed deaths and many more suspected ones — would make sense.
Yes, it would, funny that.

Other theories have been floated — and ruled out — for the number of deaths in Mexico:

_ Lab tests of Mexican patients found no sign of complications from a second infection.

_ CDC investigators have not seen any obvious problem with low-quality health care.

_ The CDC found no evidence of an over-the-counter medicine or folk remedy compounding the problem.

_ Complications from Mexico City's altitude or air pollution are unlikely because severe cases have been reported in parts of Mexico at low altitude and with cleaner air.
 
Last edited:
222 kids in the Queens NY school reported to the nurse's office with illness within 4 days of the first 10 that reported to the nurse. The school has ~3,000 counting students and staff. And, the 222 count would not include kids who were ill but didn't report to the nurse, less a few reports that would have been the baseline for seeing the school nurses.

That is a very high attack rate considering a couple things. If the virus were circulating in the community there would be several contact points. This occurred from a relatively small initial group of contagious kids.

And because the incubation period is relatively short, we see that the 222 kids were infected in a fairly short window. And, there were many more than the 222 who reported to the nurses office including many staff and family members.

Swine-Origin Influenza A (H1N1) Virus Infections in a School --- New York City, April 2009

This example demonstrates an attack rate significantly higher than seasonal flu averages among close and casual contacts.

I think we should be specific when we're talking about the attack rate. It'll vary from casual, to close, to household.

Why do you think the CDC said it was looking to be similar to seasonal flu in terms of attack rate?
They've implied in previous media conferences that they've been collecting data on the attack rate in households of confirmed cases. I wonder if that's where they're pulling their numbers from?
 
So from scanning posts # 120-163, it looks like similar virii confer immunity- that is why few deaths from Spanish flu in the oldsters, and in the current epidemic, no hospitalizations in Mexico in people older than 60. Plus the datum above that 97% of folks contemporary with the Spanish flu epidemic had antibodies, many never having any symptoms. So we have lots of herd immunity, due to our long lifespans. What is the meian age in America? Half of our population has had 35 years to build immunity to all those germs?

But pigs grown in a commercial setting have a 'generation span' of what, 2-3 years? Not much herd immunity conferred there. So a disease can run rampant in pigs, and not be so successful in humans.

Hmmm, median age in Mexico?
 
Extrapolate from confirmed cases, yes, of course, along with ALL the other data.
Which other data?

With infections such as human H5N1...

...Select populations were sampled for H5N1 antibodies to detect uncounted cases...

That's just one example of how one uses data like the WHO laboratory confirmed case count.
But, as you point out:
There is currently no antibody test...

So that example isn't of much use here, is it?

Let's take these three observations together:
The number of cases in Mexico are likely in the tens of thousands.
Most of the cases began to show up in the US in only the last 2 weeks
the incubation period is relatively short
The only logical conclusion I can reach -- consistent with all three of those -- is that the virus is slowing down.
 
The only logical conclusion I can reach -- consistent with all three of those -- is that the virus is slowing down.

Can you explain your logic?
 
I think we should be specific when we're talking about the attack rate. It'll vary from casual, to close, to household.
Definitely, but the data is not always available.

From the looks of it the CDC took the opportunity to collect a lot of data about the NY school outbreak that will be useful once they publish the analysis.

Why do you think the CDC said it was looking to be similar to seasonal flu in terms of attack rate?
They've implied in previous media conferences that they've been collecting data on the attack rate in households of confirmed cases. I wonder if that's where they're pulling their numbers from?
I think you need to be careful when reading this stuff. Which is coming from a casual remark, and individual opinion, a reporter's interpretation, a political motive such as calming down a run on the ED by worried well, or a published study result?
 
News from Mexico (true story):

SOAP OPERA KISSING SUSPENDED BECAUSE OF THE FLU

...

In television, the disease has left its mark on one Mexico's favorite pastimes: soap operas. Producers have decided to suspend kissing scenes to avoid the risk of infection.

...


And here is a preview of the new mask to ward off the flu:

Mask_small.jpg
 
Which other data?
Do you know how many times I have repeated this? It's getting old. It's bad enough when someone who doesn't know a thing about epidemiology tries to tell you they do. But when you take the time to share your expertise with people and they just gloss over what you've written and ask you to post what you already have several times, there comes a point where enough is enough.

Sorry, enough is enough.

Here are some suggestions:

Read a book: Investigating Disease Patterns: The Science of Epidemiology (Scientific American Library)

Get a degree: Master of Science in Epidemiology Program

Pay for a journal article: Epidemiology, Science as Inquiry and Scientific Literacy
 
Which other data?
Do you know how many times I have repeated this? It's getting old. It's bad enough when someone who doesn't know a thing about epidemiology tries to tell you they do (and I don't mean just you). But when you take the time to share your expertise with people and they just gloss over what you've written and ask you to post what you already have several times, there comes a point where enough is enough.

Sorry, enough is enough.

Here are some suggestions for you, WC and GreNME, and I'm sorry because you are not as bad as those two, but the three of you don't seem intent on learning anything, just on arguing about a science you have no expertise in. I appreciate the comment about the false dichotomy to WC in the other thread. But I don't understand why you keep asking me which other data.

Read a book: Investigating Disease Patterns: The Science of Epidemiology (Scientific American Library)

Get a degree: Master of Science in Epidemiology Program

Pay for a journal article: Epidemiology, Science as Inquiry and Scientific Literacy



And if the issue is you just skipped a lot of the posts, here are those containing your answer repeating the data my assessments have been based on. The one's with the ** are most to the point.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=4673014#post4673014

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=4674288#post4674288

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=4674379#post4674379

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=4674440#post4674440

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=4671546#post4671546

** http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=4668198#post4668198

** http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=4666897#post4666897

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=4666928#post4666928

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=4664824#post4664824

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=4664895#post4664895

** http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=4664898#post4664898

** http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=4659048#post4659048
 
Last edited:
I've lost track which thread had the discussion about antibodies in the population already but it seems the science forum is the best place to put this article:

Research: Seniors may have some swine flu immunity
A leading influenza scientist says preliminary research suggests people 60 and older may have some protection against the new swine flu.

The head of the influenza division at the U.S. Centers for Disease Control says work being done in the Atlanta labs shows older people have some antibodies that may offer protection against the swine H1N1 virus.

CDC labs have been studying blood samples from people of varying ages to see if previous exposures to human H1N1 viruses or having had flu shots might give people some protection against this new flu. ...

...Dr. Nancy Cox says her team is seeing higher levels of antibodies that are reactive with the virus in people starting at about age 50, but the rise is more noticeable in people 60 and older.

Interesting. Someone asked if the 1976 swine flu vaccine might have provided some crossover antibodies but that isn't likely since a single dose of vaccine wouldn't be expected to produce antibodies that lasted 30 years. It could represent antibodies to a genetic component in the virus that circulated in another flu strain 50-60 years ago..
 
Last edited:
Interesting. Someone asked if the 1976 swine flu vaccine might have provided some crossover antibodies but that isn't likely since a single dose of vaccine wouldn't be expected to produce antibodies that lasted 30 years. It could represent antibodies to a genetic component in the virus that circulated in another flu strain 50-60 years ago..

Yep, I've seen the suggestion that Hong Kong in the 1960s and the one in 1957 might be the cause of pre-existing resistance.

The same thing happened with another, later 'flu.

Interesting little buggers - wouldn't you love to be a virus geneticist right now?
 
:rolleyes:

If you're implying I've said any such thing, the false accusation's getting old.

I think he's kidding you, based on a possible interpretation of your words - which he quoted:
There is currently no antibody test than can tell us past infection either. Some company will have to develop that specific antibody test in the future if we are to ever have one.
I've bolded the part that could be read a few different ways.
:)
 
A perusal of selected sources....

Sources:
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2009/05/01/AR2009050101777.html

http://www.cdc.gov/media/transcripts/2009/t090501.htm

http://www.scientificamerican.com/article.cfm?id=capturing-a-killer-flu-virus&page=1

It seems the pandemic is inevitable if not already existing and that it will eventually infect everyone.

So the real questions now are:
1) How rapidly is it spreading.
2) What is the case fatality rate.

The 1918 Spanish Flu encircled the globe and and infected at least 97% of the word's population within three years. The overall fatality rate was 2-2.5%, but in military camps it was as high as 10% and amonst the innuit is was as high as 70%

Fatality rates:

Seasonal flu: 0.1 percent.
Hong Kong flu 1968: 0.1 percent.
Asian flu 1957: 0.2-0.5 percent.
Spanish Flu 1918: 2.0-2.5 percent.
Mexican flu 2009: ?

The early signs from the United States and a few European countries where the strain is spreading suggest it is not unusually dangerous, as there have been few deaths so far. If that continues to be true, then it may help explain the mysteriously high mortality in Mexico. It may be that Mexico already has had hundreds of thousands, and possibly millions, of cases -- all but the most serious hidden in the "noise" of background illness in a crowded population.

What we have found by looking very carefully at the sequences of the new H1N1 virus is that we do not see the markers for virulence that we're seeing in the 1918 virus. However, we know that there's a great deal that we do not yet understand about the virulence of the 1918 virus or other influenza viruses that have a more severe clinical picture in humans.

Also the new virus is susceptible to the anti-virals, Relenza and Tamiflu. Of course the virus may mutate and become resistant to the anti-virals and it could also mutate into a more virulent form over time.

The first outbreaks, the spring wave, of the Spanish Flu pandemic seemingly arose in and around military camps in the U.S. in March 1918. The second, main wave of the global pandemic occurred from September to November 1918, and in many places yet another severe wave of influenza hit in early 1919.

Most of the people who died during the pandemic succumbed to pneumonia caused by opportunistic bacteria that infected those already weakened by the flu. But a subset of influenza victims died just days after the onset of their symptoms from a more severe viral pneumonia that left their lungs either massively hemorrhaged or filled with fluid. Furthermore, most deaths occurred among young adults between 15 and 35 years old, a group that rarely dies from influenza. Strikingly, people younger than 65 years accounted for more than 99 percent of all "excess" influenza deaths (those above normal annual averages) in 1918–1919.

Why they mutate:

The life cycle and genomic structure of influenza A virus allow it to evolve and exchange genes easily. The virus's genetic material consists of eight separate RNA segments encased in a lipid membrane studded with proteins. To reproduce, the virus binds to and then enters a living cell, where it commandeers cellular machinery, inducing it to manufacture new viral proteins and additional copies of viral RNA. These pieces then assemble themselves into new viruses that escape the host cell, proceeding to infect other cells. No proofreading mechanism ensures that the RNA copies are accurate, so mistakes leading to new mutations are common.

Why it's called H1N1:

Different circulating influenza A viruses are identified by referring to two signature proteins on their surfaces. One is hemagglutinin (HA), which has at least 15 known variants, or subtypes. Another is neuraminidase (NA), which has nine subtypes. Exposure to these proteins produces distinctive antibodies in a host, thus the 1918 strain was the first to be named, "H1N1," based on antibodies found in the bloodstream of pandemic survivors. Indeed, less virulent descendants of H1N1 were the predominant circulating flu strains until 1957, when an H2N2 virus emerged, causing a pandemic. Since 1968, the H3N2 subtype, which provoked the pandemic that year, has predominated.

What the H and N do:

The HA and NA protein subtypes present on a given influenza A virus are more than just identifiers; they are essential for viral reproduction and are primary targets of an infected host's immune system. The HA molecule initiates infection by binding to receptors on the surface of certain host cells. The NA protein enables new virus copies to escape the host cell so they can go on to infect other cells.

What mutations can occur:

This is based on a study of the 1918 flu virus.
A virus can have a mutation in the HA gene that produces the HA protein and infection by such a virus can cause disease in multiple organs (not just the lung) and even the central nervous system, with a very high mortality rate. A mutation in the NA gene can have a similar effect. Both require only one or two mutations.
The 1918 virus also contained what is known as an NSI protein which is able to block the host immune response.
The 1918 virus' gene sequences are consistent neither with direct reassortment from a known avian strain nor with adaptation of an avian strain in swine. If the 1918 virus acquired novel genes through a different mechanism than subsequent pandemic strains, this could have important public health implications.

Why the 15-35 age group are more susceptible:

The unusual mortality among young people during the 1918 pandemic might be explained if the virus shared features with earlier circulating strains to which older people had some immunity.
There is also the "cytokine storm" theory.


http://www.newscientist.com/article/mg20227063.800-swine-flu-the-predictable-pandemic.html?page=2

This has to be wrong:
The influenza virus constantly evolves, and pandemics happen every few decades when the flu virus gets new surface proteins that people have little immunity to, generally because they come from an animal strain. The lack of immunity means the virus affects more people more severely.
In fact that just makes it more infectious. It could be very infectious but still quite benign.
Every victim must infect more than one other person for the virus to spread.
:boggled:

They are also suggesting people be prosecuted for not coughing or sneezing into tissues and be required by law to take tissues with them wherever they go.
I'm starting to wonder about NewScientist!!!

Virologists were shocked this past flu season when ordinary human H1N1 spontaneously developed near-total resistance to Tamiflu. Swine H1N1 could well do the same, particularly if it starts swapping genes with the human virus.
Some possible treatments:

Monoclonal Antibodies?

Our best hope might lie in monoclonal antibodies, which could both prevent infection and help fight it. These immune proteins can be engineered to recognise a specific virus, and then churned out in production plants... large amounts could be produced in a matter of weeks. Several companies are already mass-producing flu monoclonals for ordinary H5N1, and could be switched to swine flu.


Anti-inflammatory drugs?

Flu kills mainly by triggering a cytokine storm - runaway inflammation in the immune system. The steroids normally used to reduce inflammation don't work, because they also suppress the immune responses you need to fight the virus [but] non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs called Cox2 Inhibitors [may do so]


Vaccines?

...report for the International Federation of Pharmaceutical Manufacturers and Associations...says that in the next four months we can make a billion doses of pandemic vaccine at best, but more probably 340 million doses. This is not nearly enough for the world's people.
They also mention DNA vaccine and Universal vaccines but these are out of the time frame for the present pandemic


Some good news:

Analysis of the viral genome indicates that it does not carry any of the genetic determinants associated with high virulence in other influenza viruses. Genetic analysis suggests that the virus is unable to grow in areas beyond the respiratory tract...


But with a caution:

However...we cannot be sure what to expect.
The virus might be expected to change within the coming months in ways that adapt it to its new host. If the virus persists until the advent of the next influenza season, or takes hold in the southern hemisphere where influenza season is getting underway right now, we might also have to look out for further reassortment events between this virus and the currently circulating human influenza A H3N2 or H1N1 strains.
 
[snip rant]
[snip link dump]
I say that what we know about what this virus is doing is based on two things: data, and extrapolation from data. In the strictest sense, the data are limited to confirmed cases; everything else is extrapolation (and speculation). You make reference to "ALL the other data", but the only example of this other data you find worth mentioning is one which does not apply at this stage of this event. If "other data" was simply a poor choice of words on your part, and what you meant was "all the sophisticated extrapolation and speculation that trained epidemiologists are capable of performing on the limited data available", then you might try simply saying "I made a poor choice of words there; beyond confirmed cases, there really aren't any actual data".
 
I think he's kidding you, based on a possible interpretation of your words - which he quoted:

I've bolded the part that could be read a few different ways.
:)
I was very tired last night. I had truly gone to a lot of effort to share what I know about infectious disease, contagiousness and influenza only to have a number of totally ignorant unsupported responses ignore everything I posted and repeat total crap again and again. Everything including reasonable or in jest replies started to all look like unsupported ignorant crap.


I apologize for any posts I misread or false assumptions about people I may have made, (not to include an apology for calling any of the ignorant crap ignorant crap. ;) ) I think many of us experience it from time to time. When you are well versed in a science and you have some fool totally unaware they don't have a clue about a topic they are convinced they do know about. It wears on you.


I'm refreshed now. :D
 
I say that what we know about what this virus is doing is based on two things: data, and extrapolation from data. In the strictest sense, the data are limited to confirmed cases; everything else is extrapolation (and speculation). You make reference to "ALL the other data", but the only example of this other data you find worth mentioning is one which does not apply at this stage of this event. If "other data" was simply a poor choice of words on your part, and what you meant was "all the sophisticated extrapolation and speculation that trained epidemiologists are capable of performing on the limited data available", then you might try simply saying "I made a poor choice of words there; beyond confirmed cases, there really aren't any actual data".
I'm going to try one more time and assume that in spite of the fact you don't know what you are talking about, you are sincerely trying to asses the data and apply critical thinking skills. I have not used a poor choice of words. You have a limited concept of what 'data' is and what conclusions are possible to draw from epidemiological data.

But you are making a big mistake here and I can't help you if you won't make an effort to understand what mistake you are making. The data is not limited to confirmed cases. There are many many pieces of hard evidence in epidemiology besides confirmed cases.

Since you don't believe me, here is an example straight out of the mouth of the NYC Health Department (emphasis mine):

An epidemiologic update on the H1N1 (SO) outbreak in New York City
A cluster of influenza-like illness at Public School Q177 and St. Francis Preparatory School are epidemiologically related; the two schools are in close proximity to one another in Queens. Both schools have been closed. All confirmed cases can be epidemiologically linked either to exposure to an ill person associated with the two schools or to travel to Mexico.

However, DOHMH has now identified two probable cases without apparent epidemiologic links: a 14-year-old Queens resident, and a 20-year-old visitor to New York City. These findings, along with other suggestive surveillance data presented below, suggest that community transmission of H1N1 (SO) is now occurring in New York City.
It is hard data that you have cases which cannot be linked. It is not quantitative data, it is qualitative data which is just as solid in this case as any quantified data. The data I referred to in numerous discussions of this which I posted links for you to re-read instead of asking me to post again and again was similar to this. You cannot have a confirmed case with no connection to any other confirmed case unless there were unconfirmed cases in between. And the terminology, "suggests" is common epidemiological language and just as a 'scientific theory' does not imply 'doubt', neither does this evidence.

You cannot get confirmed cases in dozens of distant geographic locations all over the world in a single week from the small number of confirmed cases reported in Mexico. You cannot make that epidemiological model work.

You cannot have a virus contagious enough to infect over 200 students in a school in 4 days which genetically matches that confirmed in Mexico City crowded with millions of inhabitants and expect to only see 1,000 of those citizens infected. You cannot make that epidemiological model work.

If you have hundreds of students in a school sick with similar symptoms in a very short window of time and you find 80% of 50 tests done were positive for a single virus strain, that is data most of them have the same thing. We know that because that hypothesis has been tested many many times and confirmed to be a valid assumption for an epidemiologist to make.

What is pure speculation is to say you can predict how many severe cases you will or will not see in an infection which has only so far spread to several hundred people at the very beginning of an epidemic. Not if the pattern for that infection is to kill 0.1% to 3% of the infected population, and one that infects ~10-40% of the population in any single epidemic. And according to the antibody studies after the 1918 flu pandemic, 90+% of the population had evidence of past infection within 3 years of the novel strain's appearance. (Citation posted earlier.) Even the mildest seasonal influenza in the last decade killed 19,000 people.


I highly recommend if you are truly interested in learning something here rather than just confirming what you think you already know, that you read the whole NYPHD page and see all the evidence both objective and subjective, as well as established epidemiological models that these public health epidemiologists use to assess contagious disease outbreaks.



Oh ya, and read Billy Joe's post because he has it right too.
 
Last edited:
....
Most of the people who died during the pandemic succumbed to pneumonia caused by opportunistic bacteria that infected those already weakened by the flu....
"Weakened" is an understatement. Just to nip a myth in the bud here:

Predominant Role of Bacterial Pneumonia as a Cause of Death in Pandemic Influenza: Implications for Pandemic Influenza Preparedness
Contemporary views of the natural history of severe influenza during the 1918–1919 influenza pandemic.By examining influenza autopsy materials from a range of patients in different stages of disease, pathologists in 1918–1919 identified the primary lesion in early severe influenza‐associated pneumonia as desquamative tracheobronchitis and bronchiolitis extending diffusely over all or much of the pulmonary tree to the alveolar ducts and alveoli, associated with sloughing of bronchiolar epithelial cells to the basal layer, hyaline membrane formation in alveolar ducts and alveoli, and ductal dilation [20, 24, 27, 29–33].

Primary “panbronchitis” [35] was thought to reflect rapidly spreading epithelial cytolytic infection of the entire bronchial tree [32, 35, 36]; this was thought to have led to the secondary spread of enormous numbers of bacteria along the denuded bronchial epithelium to every part of the bronchial tree, following which focal bronchiolar infections broke through into the lung parenchyma. Secondary bacterial invasion and zones of vasculitis, capillary thrombosis, and necrosis surrounding areas of bronchiolar damage were seen in severe cases.
It's common speculation that with antibiotics, far fewer people would have died in 1918. This paper suggests that while bacteria might have filled the lungs of these people before they died, the virus did so much damage initially that the belief all they needed was modern antibiotics remains doubtful.
 
...
http://www.newscientist.com/article/mg20227063.800-swine-flu-the-predictable-pandemic.html?page=2

This has to be wrong:
In fact that just makes it more infectious. It could be very infectious but still quite benign.
:boggled:
....
It is wrong.

There is an incredible amount of bad information out there along with the good. Even a couple infectious disease docs interviewed on the news were giving bad information about the N95 respirators. I notice that even within a specialty there are subspecialties. Infection control is a subspecialty within infectious disease. I know a lot more about infection control than infectious disease pathology. A lot of infectious disease doctors know more about the disease process than disease transmission. The specialists the news media should be interviewing are the epidemiologists and public health doctors.
 
Last edited:
:rolleyes:

If you're implying I've said any such thing, the false accusation's getting old.

I was just playing. See what I quoted below:

There is currently no antibody test than can tell us past infection either. Some company will have to develop that specific antibody test in the future if we are to ever have one.

Just for giggles I took "one" to be "future" rather than "antibody test" as you intended.

ETA: Chillzero caught it. I really should catch up completely before posting.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom