Moderated Inside the latest Clinton pay for play scandal

I see in addition to previous virtues, sunmaster14 became great statistician. I guess it is like creationists suddenly becoming proffessional biologists in internet debates.



There are other possibilities, like you misusing data or outright making them up. For example, your "Million [rich people in world that would be interested in meeting with Hillary], I think" is pretty obviously pulled out of your nether regions.

Other thing: someone considering meeting with Hillary would be more likely to throw some money to her foundation than random person even if that someone would not expect anything in return. Your "must believe in my made up statistic" argument crashes and burns.

Good show. Despite your incivility, you have come up with an alternative explanation. Yes, I have thought about that, and the AP could test it given their data. All they have to determine is if the donations came before or after the meetings, on average. Of course, that alternative explanation could be even more inculpatory for Hillary. It strikes me as more quid pro quo-ish for somebody to make a donation after a meeting with her. Wouldn't you agree?

Feel free to continue innuendo and handwaving without any actual evidence whatsoever. It is, after all, all you have - smear and bs.

The actual evidence I have is the evidence the AP presented, which is, you know, actual. I'm just analyzing it from a statistical perspective.
 
I see no reason for that to be done by phone. You communicate by phone when either (a) something is urgent, (b) you need to have real-time back and forth to flesh out an issue, or (c) you don't want there to be a record of the communication. None of those apply to updates on Foundation activities, unless of course they were illicit ones.

I wonder why anyone using a phone to talk to Hillary Clinton has to have an urgent
reason, or they are hiding illicit activities (not wanting a record of the conversation).

The reason the telephone is such a great communication device is because:

anyone with a phone can "have real-time back and forth to flesh out an issue"

when you are far enough away to make shouting at your correspondent seem silly.

Can anyone point to evidence of this "pay to play"?

This is what I understand of these allegations:

1. Make big donation to Clinton Foundation.
2. Get an audience with Hillary Clinton.
3. ???
4. Proof of pay for play.

What is the play?
 
I wonder why anyone using a phone to talk to Hillary Clinton has to have an urgent
reason, or they are hiding illicit activities (not wanting a record of the conversation).

The reason the telephone is such a great communication device is because:

anyone with a phone can "have real-time back and forth to flesh out an issue"

when you are far enough away to make shouting at your correspondent seem silly.

Can anyone point to evidence of this "pay to play"?

This is what I understand of these allegations:

1. Make big donation to Clinton Foundation.
2. Get an audience with Hillary Clinton.
3. ???
4. Proof of pay for play.

What is the play?

:eye-poppi

Seriously? The proof of pay for play is step two, obviously.

Plus, as I have pointed out repeatedly, there was supposed to be a Chinese wall between the foundation and Hillary.
 
:eye-poppi

Seriously? The proof of pay for play is step two, obviously.

Plus, as I have pointed out repeatedly, there was supposed to be a Chinese wall between the foundation and Hillary.


No evidence that an audience with Hillary led to any actual "play".
Certainly I thought the play would profit the donor in more substantial
ways, other than meeting one or both of the Clintons.

I have missed your claim of a supposed "Chinese wall" between the foundation and Hillary.

Why should there be a chinese wall between Hillary and the charitable
foundation?

Is it a legal issue?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_wall

This wikipedia entry notes that the objection to the term "Chinese wall":

In Peat, Marwick, Mitchell & Co. v. Superior Court (1988), Presiding Justice Harry W. Low, a Chinese American,[6] wrote a concurring opinion specifically in order "to express my profound objection to the use of this phrase in this context". He called the term a "piece of legal flotsam which should be emphatically abandoned", and suggested "ethics wall" as a more suitable alternative. He maintained that the "continued use of the term would be insensitive to the ethnic identity of the many persons of Chinese descent".[5][7]

Alternative phrases include "screen",[8] firewall, "cone of silence", and "ethical wall". "Screen" or the verb "to screen" is the preferred term of the American Bar Association Model Rules of Professional Conduct.[9][10][11][12]


Let's call it an ethics wall. :)

I can see how just the appearance of any conflict of interest would not
look good, and an ethics wall would be in place.

Unless there is more evidence that Hillary breached any ethical wall, I remain
unconvinced of this pay for play.
 
No evidence that an audience with Hillary led to any actual "play".
Certainly I thought the play would profit the donor in more substantial
ways, other than meeting one or both of the Clintons.

I have missed your claim of a supposed "Chinese wall" between the foundation and Hillary.

Why should there be a chinese wall between Hillary and the charitable
foundation?

Is it a legal issue?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_wall

This wikipedia entry notes that the objection to the term "Chinese wall":




Let's call it an ethics wall. :)

I can see how just the appearance of any conflict of interest would not
look good, and an ethics wall would be in place.

Unless there is more evidence that Hillary breached any ethical wall, I remain
unconvinced of this pay for play.

This is hilarious if it wasn't so serious. Neither Bill Clinton, Hillary Clinton or Chelsea Clinton received any income from the foundation. They weren't paid a salary, they didn't earn speaking fees from it. Nope, it was WORK to help others not just in the US but all over the world.

Yet Big Dog and SunMaster portray it as some evil nefarious act that should make us not trust Hillary Clinton and her motives.

Yep, that's all there is. And not a word from either of them about the GOP nominee who scammed thousands of people out of their money. And Hillary is the one with an ethics problem? WTF?
 
This is hilarious if it wasn't so serious. Neither Bill Clinton, Hillary Clinton or Chelsea Clinton received any income from the foundation. They weren't paid a salary, they didn't earn speaking fees from it. Nope, it was WORK to help others not just in the US but all over the world.

This assumes that monetary rewards are the only potential rewards. Connections, Favors, and Prestige are other potential benefits.

This isn't to say that she did or didn't receive those other potential benefits. Only that them not personally receiving monetary benefits is insufficient to claim they didn't get anything out of it.
 
No evidence that an audience with Hillary led to any actual "play".
Certainly I thought the play would profit the donor in more substantial
ways, other than meeting one or both of the Clintons.

I have missed your claim of a supposed "Chinese wall" between the foundation and Hillary.

Why should there be a chinese wall between Hillary and the charitable
foundation?

Is it a legal issue?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_wall

This wikipedia entry notes that the objection to the term "Chinese wall":




Let's call it an ethics wall. :)

I can see how just the appearance of any conflict of interest would not
look good, and an ethics wall would be in place.

Unless there is more evidence that Hillary breached any ethical wall, I remain
unconvinced of this pay for play.

I have posted links to the ethics agreements that Hillary and the Foundation signed in this thread
 
CNN had the AP editor on.

Question: Wasn't the Tweet false? (The Tweet said more than half of Clinton's meetings were with donors without mentioning they meant of a tiny fraction of the actual meetings.)
AP Editor: We're better at reporting and not good yet at Tweeting.

What a load of crap.

Question: Did you feel the need to publish something after an extensive investigation of Clinton's meeting schedule found nothing?
AP Editor: We found the potential for quid pro quo.
Question: But you found no evidence the donors got anything at all in exchange for the donations?
AP Editor: The potential is the story.

I wouldn't be holding my breath if I were waiting for an Oct surprise to sink Clinton.
 
This is hilarious if it wasn't so serious. Neither Bill Clinton, Hillary Clinton or Chelsea Clinton received any income from the foundation. They weren't paid a salary, they didn't earn speaking fees from it. Nope, it was WORK to help others not just in the US but all over the world.

Yet Big Dog and SunMaster portray it as some evil nefarious act that should make us not trust Hillary Clinton and her motives.

Yep, that's all there is. And not a word from either of them about the GOP nominee who scammed thousands of people out of their money. And Hillary is the one with an ethics problem? WTF?

Meeting one of the Clintons after a huge donation to their charitable organization is not my definition of pay for play.

In politics, pay to play refers to a system, akin to payola in the music industry, by which one pays (or must pay) money to become a player.

From the wiki https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pay_to_play: In Politics


Typically, the payer (an individual, business, or organization) makes campaign contributions to public officials, party officials, or parties themselves, and receives political or pecuniary benefit such as no-bid government contracts, influence over legislation,[2][3] political appointments or nominations,[4][5] special access[6] or other favors. The contributions, less frequently, may be to nonprofit or institutional entities,[7] or may take the form of some benefit to a third party, such as a family member of a governmental official.[8]

I guess you could call access to the Clintons as play, but that would be
stretching the definition to the nth degree.

Is there any evidence that access to the Clintons resulted in anything like
actual political, pecuniary, influence, political appointments, or other favors?

I agree with you acbytesla, there is nothing there.
"Hillary is bad, therefore, pay for play."

Where are the ethical agreements that Hillary signed?
 
CNN had the AP editor on.

Question: Wasn't the Tweet false? (The Tweet said more than half of Clinton's meetings were with donors without mentioning they meant of a tiny fraction of the actual meetings.)
AP Editor: We're better at reporting and not good yet at Tweeting.

What a load of crap.

Question: Did you feel the need to publish something after an extensive investigation of Clinton's meeting schedule found nothing?
AP Editor: We found the potential for quid pro quo. Question: But you found no evidence the donors got anything at all in exchange for the donations?
AP Editor: The potential is the story.

I wouldn't be holding my breath if I were waiting for an Oct surprise to sink Clinton.

The potential for quid pro quo is the story?
Actual evidence not needed, just the potential is enough for smearing
Hillary Clinton.

:jaw-dropp
 
This assumes that monetary rewards are the only potential rewards. Connections, Favors, and Prestige are other potential benefits.

This isn't to say that she did or didn't receive those other potential benefits. Only that them not personally receiving monetary benefits is insufficient to claim they didn't get anything out of it.

Seriously?

This is the former President and First Lady, US Senator and Secretary of State. Please explain what connections or favors could possibly be provided to them that they couldn't get anyway without the Foundation?
 
Yes, I have thought about that, and the AP could test it given their data. All they have to determine is if the donations came before or after the meetings, on average. Of course, that alternative explanation could be even more inculpatory for Hillary.

Which word from "even if that someone would not expect anything in return" you don't understand? In that case it doesn't matter much when that donation was made.

It strikes me as more quid pro quo-ish for somebody to make a donation after a meeting with her. Wouldn't you agree?
More innuendo and vague accusations, as expected. You do not yet know how many were paid before and how many after, yet you already throw mud. "quid pro quo-ish"? Guilty until guilty indeed.
 
Here's the thing. Hillary and Bill Clinton used their status to help people all over the world as opposed to using a charity to enrich themselves. About the worst thing you could say that happened is somebody wanted to meet the Secretary of State and future President of the United States so bad that they gave a large sum of money to help people. Oh, the nightmare. :rolleyes:
 
Here's the thing. Hillary and Bill Clinton used their status to help people all over the world as opposed to using a charity to enrich themselves. About the worst thing you could say that happened is somebody wanted to meet the Secretary of State and future President of the United States so bad that they gave a large sum of money to help people. Oh, the nightmare. :rolleyes:

You have no evidence of that. I suspect actually that their charity has been hugely inefficient and has had a net negative impact on the world because of the opportunity cost. There are better ways of raising and distributing charitable funds than using a political slush fund run by two people who have a long history of self-dealing.
 
Last edited:
Which word from "even if that someone would not expect anything in return" you don't understand? In that case it doesn't matter much when that donation was made.

Sorry but in the real world, there are tens of thousands of charities to choose from. I think it would be an amazing coincidence that somebody, just by accident, chooses to donate to the Clinton Foundation after, or in advance of, a meeting with Secretary of State Hillary Clinton.

In the most, ahem ... charitable, but still plausible, interpretation of the situation, Hillary used her office to proselytize and shill for the Clinton Foundation. That would have certainly breached ethics rules, although not, perhaps, criminal laws.
 
You have no evidence of that. I suspect actually that their charity has been hugely inefficient and has had a net negative impact on the world because of the opportunity cost. There are better ways of raising and distributing charitable funds than using a political slush fund run by two people who have a long history of self-dealing.

The potential is enough for you.

Political slush fund evidence?

Something more than your suspicions please.
 
Sorry but in the real world, there are tens of thousands of charities to choose from. I think it would be an amazing coincidence that somebody, just by accident, chooses to donate to the Clinton Foundation after, or in advance of, a meeting with Secretary of State Hillary Clinton.

In the most, ahem ... charitable, but still plausible, interpretation of the situation, Hillary used her office to proselytize and shill for the Clinton Foundation. That would have certainly breached ethics rules, although not, perhaps, criminal laws.
No the most charitable version is that people due to meet with Clinton tried to get on her good side by making a donation, what you and others have failed to show is that making such donations either obtained such meetings, or favourable treatment in Clinton's capacity as Secretary of State.

You have no evidence of that. I suspect actually that their charity has been hugely inefficient and has had a net negative impact on the world because of the opportunity cost. There are better ways of raising and distributing charitable funds than using a political slush fund run by two people who have a long history of self-dealing.

As has been pointed out ad nauseam those who job it is to vet charities have given the Clinton Foundation high marks. Can you provide any reason to ignore that in favour of 'I suspect'?
 
Last edited:
Sorry but in the real world, there are tens of thousands of charities to choose from. I think it would be an amazing coincidence that somebody, just by accident, chooses to donate to the Clinton Foundation after, or in advance of, a meeting with Secretary of State Hillary Clinton.

In the most, ahem ... charitable, but still plausible, interpretation of the situation, Hillary used her office to proselytize and shill for the Clinton Foundation. That would have certainly breached ethics rules, although not, perhaps, criminal laws.

Where is the pay for play?

Please provide evidence that any donation has provided an actual benefit
politically, personally, financially to anyone.

Your interpretation is odd.

What ethics rules have been breached?
Be specific.

The Clinton Foundation accepts donations.
Connect the donations to any breach of ethics rules.

One of the Clintons, getting donations for the charitable foundationbearing their name is using their name to get donations?
 
Where is the pay for play?

Please provide evidence that any donation has provided an actual benefit
politically, personally, financially to anyone.

Your interpretation is odd.

What ethics rules have been breached?
Be specific.

The Clinton Foundation accepts donations.
Connect the donations to any breach of ethics rules.

One of the Clintons, getting donations for the charitable foundationbearing their name is using their name to get donations?

Tsk, the mere vague, unsupported, 'I suspect' is enough to hang Clinton, while at the same time Trump being a fraudster merits a 'meh'.
 
Where is the pay for play?

Please provide evidence that any donation has provided an actual benefit
politically, personally, financially to anyone.

Your interpretation is odd.

What ethics rules have been breached?
Be specific.

The Clinton Foundation accepts donations.
Connect the donations to any breach of ethics rules.

One of the Clintons, getting donations for the charitable foundationbearing their name is using their name to get donations?

At this point I can only assume you have not read the ethics agreements they signed and promptly blew off.

Oh well....
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom