Moderated Inside the latest Clinton pay for play scandal

What is the point of such a sorting? Hundreds of people got to see Hillary without paying a penny. Just pushing the agenda of some foreign governments. Some probably made threats, too.

The AP story was such a joke and they have been pilloried by pretty much every news organization because of it.
 
What is the point of such a sorting? Hundreds of people got to see Hillary without paying a penny. Just pushing the agenda of some foreign governments. Some probably made threats, too.

Because it indicates that, if you're not associated with a government, then your probability of getting a meeting with Secretary of State Clinton was very low. Unless, of course, you were a donor to the Clinton Foundation.

To put things in perspective, compare how many donors to the Clinton Foundation there are in the world to how many non-donors there are. What do you think the ratio is?

Actually, I compiled their numbers from their website.

871 people or entities have given $100,000 or more.
1437 people or entities have given $50,000 or more.

As you get to lower and lower contribution amounts, the number of contributors goes up fast. For example, there are over 300,000 people or entities who have given up to $1,000.

Still, I bet $1,000 doesn't get you on the VIP treatment list. Douglas Band probably only makes phone calls on behalf of donors who give $50,000. So let's call it a pool of 1,437 donors.

How many private, non-donors in the world are there? Maybe 7.4 billion? How many of those are rich people or important people in some way who would love to have a meeting with the US Secretary of State? A million I would think. And yet, roughly half of the people Hillary met with out of that pool of private, rich, important people were drawn from a pool of no more than 1,437 of $50,000 or greater Clinton Foundation donors.

Note that I've ignored the fact that many governmental people, or entities, were big donors, so there may be many donors, with whom Clinton met, who did not get counted in the private meeting total. Admittedly, I've also restricted my count of donors to those who gave $50,000 or more. I suspect, though, that few of the people the AP identified were smaller donors.
 
Last edited:
Could there be a bigger scandal over ABSOLUTELY NOTHING?

About the only thing the Clintons receive from their Foundation is the pride of knowing that they are helping people. Bill, Hillary and Chelsea receive NO INCOME from the Foundation and yet people are in a tizzy over whether people who could have easily met Hillary were also donors to a major International charity? Somebody, please wake me when it is something serious
 
Because it indicates that, if you're not associated with a government, then your probability of getting a meeting with Secretary of State Clinton was very low. Unless, of course, you were a donor to the Clinton Foundation.

To put things in perspective, compare how many donors to the Clinton Foundation there are in the world to how many non-donors there are. What do you think the ratio is?

Actually, I compiled their numbers from their website.

871 people or entities have given $100,000 or more.
1437 people or entities have given $50,000 or more.

As you get to lower and lower contribution amounts, the number of contributors goes up fast. For example, there are over 300,000 people or entities who have given up to $1,000.

Still, I bet $1,000 doesn't get you on the VIP treatment list. Douglas Band probably only makes phone calls on behalf of donors who give $50,000. So let's call it a pool of 1,437 donors.

How many private, non-donors in the world are there? Maybe 7.4 billion? How many of those are rich people or important people in some way who would love to have a meeting with the US Secretary of State? A million I would think. And yet, roughly half of the people Hillary met with out of that pool of private, rich, important people were drawn from a pool of no more than 1,437 of $50,000 or greater Clinton Foundation donors.

Note that I've ignored the fact that many governmental people, or entities, were big donors, so there may be many donors, with whom Clinton met, who did not get counted in the private meeting total. Admittedly, I've also restricted my count of donors to those who gave $50,000 or more. I suspect, though, that few of the people the AP identified were smaller donors.

Let's make this simple, do you have a shred of evidence that one of those people got a meeting with Clinton because they made a donation to the Foundation? No prevarication, no hyperbole, a simple yes or no will suffice.
 
Let's make this simple, do you have a shred of evidence that one of those people got a meeting with Clinton because they made a donation to the Foundation? No prevarication, no hyperbole, a simple yes or no will suffice.

Yes, unless you don't actually believe in statistics, the statistics alone provides compelling evidence. Yet more evidence is the fact that Douglas Band (the head executive of the Clinton Foundation) made, on average, about one phone call per week to the Secretary of State's office during Hillary's tenure there. That is apparently far more than any other person did.
 
Yes, unless you don't actually believe in statistics, the statistics alone provides compelling evidence. Yet more evidence is the fact that Douglas Band (the head executive of the Clinton Foundation) made, on average, about one phone call per week to the Secretary of State's office during Hillary's tenure there. That is apparently far more than any other person did.

So NO then.
 
Yes, unless you don't actually believe in statistics, the statistics alone provides compelling evidence. Yet more evidence is the fact that Douglas Band (the head executive of the Clinton Foundation) made, on average, about one phone call per week to the Secretary of State's office during Hillary's tenure there. That is apparently far more than any other person did.
So basically the guy running the Clinton foundation called Clinton on a regular basis. And from this you conclude he was acting as a go between for arranging meetings, rather than, oh I don't know, updating her on how the Foundation's various projects were going?

What makes this bizarre is you desperately want to push this innuendo about Clinton while ignoring the fact Trump is facing a fraud trial. Plenty of Trump threads here, all the opportunity you could want to express your outrage at his conning people out of money they couldn't afford for his phoney university.
 
Last edited:
So basically the guy running the Clinton foundation called Clinton on a regular basis. And from this you conclude he was acting as a go between for arranging meetings, rather than, oh I don't know, updating her on how the Foundation's various projects were going?

I see no reason for that to be done by phone. You communicate by phone when either (a) something is urgent, (b) you need to have real-time back and forth to flesh out an issue, or (c) you don't want there to be a record of the communication. None of those apply to updates on Foundation activities, unless of course they were illicit ones.

What makes this bizarre is you desperately want to push this innuendo about Clinton while ignoring the fact Trump is facing a fraud trial. Plenty of Trump threads here, all the opportunity you could want to express your outrage at his conning people out of money they couldn't afford for his phoney university.

I'll make three points:

1) I choose to write a post when I have something I want to say. The fact that I haven't chosen to write much about Trump University is that I haven't had something I wanted to say on the issue. This could be because I don't care, or it could be because there are 20 other people already mentally masturbating to the topic, and I don't really like circle jerks.

2) You are derailing this thread with your tu quoquery or accusations of hypocrisy. It is unacceptable from the perspective of critical reasoning, and it is also against the membership agreement.

3) If you believed in statistics like I do, you would realize that Hillary is very likely to be the next President, so the problems with her corruption are much more important and relevant, which is one of the reasons I am focused on them.
 
I guess you're admitting you don't believe in statistics. It makes me wonder why you're taking so much comfort in the polls that have Hillary ahead.

There are lies, damn lies and statistics. Those raw numbers mean nothing unless you can do more than add innuendo to them.
 
There are lies, damn lies and statistics. Those raw numbers mean nothing unless you can do more than add innuendo to them.

The very fact that I'm using raw numbers shows that there are no lies. You have the same information I have (or can verify it quite easily). This isn't like global warming data where the raw numbers have gone through a complicated grinder before you get to see them.

In statistics, you start with a hypothesis and then you see, given the data, what is the probability that such data would arise by random chance, given that the null hypothesis were true instead.

Here, the hypothesis is that large Clinton Foundation donors were given preferential access to the US Secretary of State. The null hypothesis is that there was no preferential treatment and that the data we have arose by chance.

We have, by my estimates, at least 500 times as many private, important people than private important donors, who would have liked to have a meeting with the US Secretary of State, yet roughly half of those who did get such a meeting were in the 500 times smaller pool. If you accept my estimates of the relative sizes of those pools, then I think you'd have to conclude that the null hypothesis can be rejected soundly.
 
I see no reason for that to be done by phone.

Basically your basis for finding this suspicious is, 'if I ran the zoo...'


1) I choose to write a post when I have something I want to say. The fact that I haven't chosen to write much about Trump University is that I haven't had something I wanted to say on the issue.

Which speak volumes about your agenda

2) You are derailing this thread with your tu quoquery or accusations of hypocrisy. It is unacceptable from the perspective of critical reasoning, and it is also against the membership agreement.

Nope from the perspective of critical reasoning it's sound, if you are concerned about corruption in high office then you should surely be highly concerned about an accused fraudster. that you ignore this points to a significant bias that needs to be accounted for in your arguments and selection of evidence.

3) If you believed in statistics like I do, you would realize that Hillary is very likely to be the next President, so the problems with her corruption are much more important and relevant, which is one of the reasons I am focused on them.

Except as others have pointed out your grasp of statistics is questionable at best.
 
Last edited:
BTW: to illustrate at least one flaw in using the 'raw numbers' Sunmaster14, you have provided no basis of comparison to judge whether this is anything out of the ordinary. To illustrate. Imagine this opinion poll was published:

Clinton 50%
Trump 50%

Is that good or bad for Clinton? Answer is of course how does it compare with previous polls by the same pollsters asking the same question to a similar sample size and composition of potential voters? That's the problem with raw numbers, they are meaningless without a baseline to measure them against.
 
The very fact that I'm using raw numbers shows that there are no lies. You have the same information I have (or can verify it quite easily). This isn't like global warming data where the raw numbers have gone through a complicated grinder before you get to see them.

In statistics, you start with a hypothesis and then you see, given the data, what is the probability that such data would arise by random chance, given that the null hypothesis were true instead.

Here, the hypothesis is that large Clinton Foundation donors were given preferential access to the US Secretary of State. The null hypothesis is that there was no preferential treatment and that the data we have arose by chance.

We have, by my estimates, at least 500 times as many private, important people than private important donors, who would have liked to have a meeting with the US Secretary of State, yet roughly half of those who did get such a meeting were in the 500 times smaller pool. If you accept my estimates of the relative sizes of those pools, then I think you'd have to conclude that the null hypothesis can be rejected soundly.

And it still means nothing. It is simply innuendo
 
I see in addition to previous virtues, sunmaster14 became great statistician. I guess it is like creationists suddenly becoming proffessional biologists in internet debates.

Yes, unless you don't actually believe in statistics, the statistics alone provides compelling evidence.

There are other possibilities, like you misusing data or outright making them up. For example, your "Million [rich people in world that would be interested in meeting with Hillary], I think" is pretty obviously pulled out of your nether regions.

Other thing: someone considering meeting with Hillary would be more likely to throw some money to her foundation than random person even if that someone would not expect anything in return. Your "must believe in my made up statistic" argument crashes and burns.

Feel free to continue innuendo and handwaving without any actual evidence whatsoever. It is, after all, all you have - smear and bs.
 
<snip>

Which speak volumes about your agenda

My agenda? The fact that you think I have an agenda here other than learning, testing my ideas, and perhaps honing my razor sharp wit, then you are indeed projecting your own partisanship onto me.

Nope from the perspective of critical reasoning it's sound, if you are concerned about corruption in high office then you should surely be highly concerned about an accused fraudster. that you ignore this points to a significant bias that needs to be accounted for in your arguments and selection of evidence.

First, this forum is pretty strict about staying on topic. I have gotten many yellow cards for straying just a little bit off topic. Although that says more about moderator bias against me than anything else, it remains the case that I am highly constrained in what I can address in any particular thread.

Second, what makes you think I'm ignoring Trump's potential for corruption? I think he has been corrupt in the past, although perhaps not illegally so, and he is highly susceptible to corruption in the future. At the same time, however, I think that Republican Presidents would be subjected to far greater scrutiny in the media, as well as bipartisan Congressional scrutiny, than Hillary would be. Democratic Presidents can count on a pliant mainstream media and the Democrats in Congress to shield them from accusations of corruption. Republican Presidents cannot. And particularly Trump cannot.

Except as others have pointed out your grasp of statistics is questionable at best.

I suspect that my grasp of statistics is being questioned by people who don't even know the difference between a biased estimator and an unbiased one, or even what the hell an estimator is in the first place.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom