Moderated Inside the latest Clinton pay for play scandal

It's worse than that.

He just glossed over the very first point I made.


It helps 11.5 million people, including 800,000 children, with HIV/AIDS get their medication at 90% lower cost -- more than half the adults and three-quarters of the children getting treatment in the world to treatment in the world today.

It helps East African farmers get better seeds and fertilizers.

I guess this is nothing.

Yeah, I'm done with such a pointless discussion.
 
People here have asserted without any evidence that the Clinton Foundation is a wonderful and efficient charity that saves lives and does all kinds of great work. I call BS on that claim. Where is the evidence? And, yes, I have read through their most recent annual reports, and I've yet to find anything that doesn't look like BS. When the Clintons are in government, they use government resources to further their own ambitions. Why should they behave any differently with resources they raised themselves?

Perhaps you should identify those portions that you deem "BS". You've been provided with at least one reference point - the Charity Watch ratings. I think Guiidestar and others may have reports on them. None of these are conclusive, but I like to temper my justice with a little jurisprudence. How do I weigh the information available against assertions from "a guy on the internet wth a proven agenda".

Which annual reports? Do you mean "Annual Report" or their 990s? Be specific. What line items set your spidey senses tingling? Or is it that big picture of Bill and Chelsea that sets you off? I think anyone can find things in their financials that they don't like, but the fact that I think they spend too much on X* does not lead to a conclusion of corruption.

Like your brief sojourn into statistical probability, all you have to do is provide actual items that you wish to discuss. "Well, I've seen their financials and they look like BS to me" doesn't really cut it. Do you audit NGOs professionally? You'll forgive me if I take a rather jaded view of your areas of expertise. So far, they haven't proved to be immune from your political bias.

* say, facilities and rents(occupancy fees and office expenses) for the management/general...
 
What total bs.

The Clinton Foundation has helped a great many people.

It helps 11.5 million people, including 800,000 children, with HIV/AIDS get their medication at 90% lower cost -- more than half the adults and three-quarters of the children getting treatment in the world today.
It helps East African farmers get better seeds and fertilizers.
It supported Nepal's reconstruction after the 2015 earthquakes.
It has connected more than 500,000 Latin Americans to job training and entrepreneurship opportunities.
It has helped in reconstruction in Haiti after the devastating earthquake.

It received an A rating from Charity Watch and spends only 12 percent on overhead and 2 percent on Fundraising.

So the idea that it is a slush fund for the Clinton's is TOTAL CRAP.

You have convinced me Hillary is the reincarnation of the Blessed Teresa of Calcutta
 
Sorry but in the real world, there are tens of thousands of charities to choose from. I think it would be an amazing coincidence that somebody, just by accident, chooses to donate to the Clinton Foundation after, or in advance of, a meeting with Secretary of State Hillary Clinton.
Looks like you indeed didn't understand any word from

someone considering meeting with Hillary would be more likely to throw some money to her foundation than random person even if that someone would not expect anything in return.

No one speaks about any ooh suspicioussss coincidences but you. I explicitly said "more likely". I didn't handwaved it as accident. This sentence estabilishes relation between donation and meetings - and shows it is possible for that relationship to be of neutral variety.

In other words, it is not enough to point out that person X had meeting with Y and person X donated to Y's charity. This relation in itself cannot be used as any "evidence"/"proof" of any wrongdoing. Not that it stops HDS sufferers from trying, of course.

Feel free to search for more innuendo and vague accusations. All bark, no bite, like one certain big dog.
 
Where is the pay for play?

Please provide evidence that any donation has provided an actual benefit
politically, personally, financially to anyone.

Your interpretation is odd.

What ethics rules have been breached?
Be specific.

The Clinton Foundation accepts donations.
Connect the donations to any breach of ethics rules.

One of the Clintons, getting donations for the charitable foundationbearing their name is using their name to get donations?

Thousand bucks says the "pay for play" was the opportunity to take a selfie with Hillary if so-and-so gave X amount of dollars.

:)
 
You have no evidence of that. I suspect actually that their charity has been hugely inefficient and has had a net negative impact on the world because of the opportunity cost. There are better ways of raising and distributing charitable funds than using a political slush fund run by two people who have a long history of self-dealing.

That's "Controlled Demolition took down the WTC" level silliness.

Say what you want about the Clintons, but their charity has made a huge amount of difference FOR GOOD in the world. That is an indisputable fact. Every single charity watch gives them high marks. Very high marks.
 
What total bs.

The Clinton Foundation has helped a great many people.

It helps 11.5 million people, including 800,000 children, with HIV/AIDS get their medication at 90% lower cost -- more than half the adults and three-quarters of the children getting treatment in the world today.
It helps East African farmers get better seeds and fertilizers.
It supported Nepal's reconstruction after the 2015 earthquakes.
It has connected more than 500,000 Latin Americans to job training and entrepreneurship opportunities.
It has helped in reconstruction in Haiti after the devastating earthquake.

It received an A rating from Charity Watch and spends only 12 percent on overhead and 2 percent on Fundraising.

So the idea that it is a slush fund for the Clinton's is TOTAL CRAP.

Irrelevant. Those people are brown, so they don't count.

:rolleyes:
 
if you are asserting there was some quid pro quo for donations then please do what none of you fellow travellers have done and provide evidence.

These people are Clinton Truthers™

A moniker which conveniently can be shortened to CT, which is the sub-forum where most of this Clinton Foundation drivel should be.
 
Lolz, no hillary fan read the ethics agreements.

I read them.

Post some more strawman.

Here's the thing.

When people are so ignorantly and fervently against something, one thing they miss is that the evidence the rest of us are supposed to read to support the argument virtually never actually does.

How many times have we seen on this forum, mostly in the CT section, Forumite X says "go to this link for the source" and it doesn't actually support the argument? Almost constantly.

That's where we are with this. The default position is that their citations and sources do not actually back up their argument.
 
People here have asserted without any evidence that the Clinton Foundation is a wonderful and efficient charity that saves lives and does all kinds of great work. I call BS on that claim. Where is the evidence? And, yes, I have read through their most recent annual reports, and I've yet to find anything that doesn't look like BS. When the Clintons are in government, they use government resources to further their own ambitions. Why should they behave any differently with resources they raised themselves?

Here's your evidence.

http://charity.org/workplace-giving/charity-partners/william-j-clinton-foundation


Please ignore ASAP.
 

LOL. If your point is that the Clinton Foundation expends considerable resources in making high production value videos to try to pass off their "charitable" work as effective or meaningful in any material way, then I concede the point.

I've watched the first two videos at any rate. The first one basically says nothing, but it does show Chelsea Clinton planting a tree (whoopie!) and somebody else brushing red paint over something painted white using a handful of ineffective strokes. I guess we learned that Chelsea got a free vacation in Africa out of that little venture. She probably planted a couple of trees (which, by the way, is an utterly useless thing to do) and then went on safari for the next week.

The second video shows some farmer ho was able to triple his income by increasing his planting area by a factor of 4. Not sure what the Clinton Foundation had to do with that, but in the end you had this farmer planting a couple of acres of vegetables essentially by hand in El Salvador so that the local supermarket could use his stuff instead of, presumably, commercially grown vegetables from elsewhere. If the Foundation facilitated the function of the free market, and that result was achieved because a barrier to free trade was struck down, then that's great. But if it was achieved through subsidies and political pressure, then that's bad. In general, I'd say that any person planting vegetables by hand on several acres of land is probably wasting global resources. There are much better ways of growing food.
 
Last edited:
LOL. If your point is that the Clinton Foundation expends considerable resources in making high production value videos to try to pass off their "charitable" work as effective or meaningful in any material way, then I concede the point.

I've watched the first two videos at any rate. The first one basically says nothing, but it does show Chelsea Clinton planting a tree (whoopie!) and somebody else brushing red paint over something painted white using a handful of ineffective strokes. I guess we learned that Chelsea got a free vacation in Africa out of that little venture. She probably planted a couple of trees (which, by the way, is an utterly useless thing to do) and then went on safari for the next week.

The second video shows some farmer ho was able to triple his income by increasing his planting area by a factor of 4. Not sure what the Clinton Foundation had to do with that, but in the end you had this farmer planting a couple of acres of vegetables essentially by hand in El Salvador so that the local supermarket could use his stuff instead of, presumably, commercially grown vegetables from elsewhere. If the Foundation facilitated the function of the free market, and that result was achieved because a barrier to free trade was struck down, then that's great. But if it was achieved through subsidies and political pressure, then that's bad. In general, I'd say that any person planting vegetables by hand on several acres of land is probably wasting global resources. There are much better ways of growing food.

In essence, what you're admitting is that there is no evidence that you'll accept that the foundation does good.

In the future, please include that caveat when you ask for evidence so we know how to respond to your request.
 
It's worse than that.

He just glossed over the very first point I made.


It helps 11.5 million people, including 800,000 children, with HIV/AIDS get their medication at 90% lower cost -- more than half the adults and three-quarters of the children getting treatment in the world today.

It helps East African farmers get better seeds and fertilizers.

I guess this is nothing.
Helps? They didn't cure AIDS. They didn't permanently solve food supply in Africa. They're weaseling! /sunmaster mode
 
In essence, what you're admitting is that there is no evidence that you'll accept that the foundation does good.

In the future, please include that caveat when you ask for evidence so we know how to respond to your request.

Here's a link to the annual report of a real charity. Note the concrete listing of achievements:

32,000 shelter stays
980,000 meals served
500,000 relief items delivered
95,000 smoke alarms installed
215,000,000 vaccinations against measles
5,100,000 units of blood collected
7,000,000 blood products created

etc. etc.

These are real achievements, not fluff. If I donated $1,000 to the Red Cross (and I have), then I too could say that I helped with all of these achievements. Just like the Clinton Foundation helps.
 
These are real achievements, not fluff. If I donated $1,000 to the Red Cross (and I have), then I too could say that I helped with all of these achievements. Just like the Clinton Foundation helps.
Let's take this quote at face value. It means either you wasted your $1,000 by giving it to the Red Cross or you agree the Clinton Foundation is doing worthwhile things.

Put on your dancing shoes, get out your slide rule, put on your mind reading tin foil and and do your thing.
 
Here's a link to the annual report of a real charity. Note the concrete listing of achievements:

32,000 shelter stays
980,000 meals served
500,000 relief items delivered
95,000 smoke alarms installed
215,000,000 vaccinations against measles
5,100,000 units of blood collected
7,000,000 blood products created

etc. etc.

These are real achievements, not fluff. If I donated $1,000 to the Red Cross (and I have), then I too could say that I helped with all of these achievements. Just like the Clinton Foundation helps.

Sad.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom