If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
In my post comparing the TT and experiment gravitational loads, four errors in Coles’s experiment claiming to prove that the collapse of the TT should have been arrested are identified.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=11187414#post11187414


For comparing KE:
Error 5: In the Towers the entire floor weight falls on the floor below. In Cole only half the weight falls to the floor below, the other half remains supported by the ledgers.


Error 6: In the TT the floors fell ~152” between each impact, picking up velocity at each floor, whereas in Cole’s experiment the boards fall ~2 1/2 “ (1 1 /2” boards at ~ 4” oc) . The difference in velocity and KE between the TT collapses and Cole’s experiment is enormous. In Cole’s experiment the incremental boards’ resistance is eventually greater than the small KE from this short fall. If this were a question in my high school physics test I would work on it.


Cole’s experiment that claims the collapse of the TT should have been arrested after a few floors errs due to the failure to correctly proportion the scale, and model the experiment to the actual conditions.


Cole could just as easily claim that his experiment proves that heavier than air objects can’t fly.


Before I comment on this, please provide links to Cole's videos you are referring to. If you are only talking about this video - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TJNzaMRsN00 , then just let me know. I'm not going to reply if I don't know exactly which video you are referring to.
 
If he was trying to do that then he fails on two accounts. First he used a weight so there is no "crush up" able to occur, and second, even Bazant, et al don't believe that the WTC Collapse was a crush down, crush up. What they wrote in their paper was a limiting case for the collapse so that certain information could be gained about the collapse. It speaks to limits, not to what actually happened, something that you'd know if you read the paper and understood it.
Watch the video again. In the experiments with the pizza stands he is not using a weight. He is using other "floors". If you don't understand the experiment, why do you keep claiming it is wrong?
 
That applies squarely to Cole's video. That's something that I already noted and you ignored. The conclusions he draws from his experiments are not valid, because his experiments don't apply to his claims.
How? Please provide proof that "his experiments don't apply to his claims."
 
No, crush down, crush up are mentioned in a paper, not a model. The paper was written by Bazant, et al.

Computer models, without experiments to show they are correct, are meaningless.

That paper was not written by Banzant, you are wrong, it was written by Dr. Frank Greening, and David B. Benson, based on Banzant s limited case. Of column buckling for start of collapses, as an abstract, to a computer program that utilized connection failure, to strip the floors, and transfer energy into the column welds.

It was experimentially and mathematically proven that connection failure brought down the buildings.

Cole has not even attempted a valid model of connection failures, are you saying he is to incompetent an engineer to do engineering?

I will agree with you then Cole is Incompetent, he can not build connections like those in the towers and test at what energy level they break.

Testing an actual connection, exact size, A325 bolts and actual arc welds of the same thickness and quality, gives you the strength of the connections, the strength of the connections will give you the resistance to collapse.

The Gravitational PE, converted to Kenetic energy by it's momentum, must be equal to the resistance of the structure below the falling mass for the collapses to arrest.

Do you agree that If gravitational potential energy converted to kenetic energy is not equal to the resistance provided by the lower structure, that the towers must collapse, this is a very simple principal, are you prepared to state you don't understand that 1-1=0?
 
It was experimentially and mathematically proven that connection failure brought down the buildings.

Show me the experiment that shows connection failure brought down the buildings in exactly the same way as what we can see in the videos of the collapse.
 
We are discussing the collapse of buildings that killed almost 3000 people. It was the worst attack on America ever. Don't you think proof is relevant when someone makes a claim?



How is Cole demonstrating material performance? He's not. He is trying to replicate observed motion.



OK. You have made a statement. Please provide proof to support your claim. You are an engineer. It seems obvious that you should understand the importance of proof.


If you are performing an experiment to replicate the direction of acceleration or the sequence of net forces, how do these limits substantively affect the results to the point where they are no longer relevant?

No I don't think "proof" applies. Collapse was a collection of know phenomena of materials under various forms of stress... mechanical, thermal and chemical.

Mick produced an experiment which models the motion because of proper understanding and selection of scale/strength of materials. Cole does not.

I am not an engineer... I am an architect. Neither uses proof in their work. Both apply settled engineering principles and materials' properties.

If you don't set up your experiment and use the principles of scale and selection of materials your model/experiment will demonstrate something other than what you think it does. That is what Cole did.
 
Show me the experiment that shows connection failure brought down the buildings in exactly the same way as what we can see in the videos of the collapse.

It was done years ago for Benson and Greening, all you have to do is break connections, and calculate the energy values, Engineers have done thousands of experiments on connection failures, all you have to do is Google them.

There are Litterally thousands of engineering papers that show Cole is a fraud.www.citg.tudelft.nl › Afdelingen › doc

Some even written before Cole was even hatched-born, from the egg of stupidity.
Experiments, documented going back all the way to Maxwell and Newton.
 
FalseFlag said:
The force of gravity between the Earth and the building are equal and opposite to each other.

This statement is wrong. The force of gravity is only one of the forces involved. The normal force is the other one. If you truly understood physics, you would never have made that statement using those words. Let me explain.


WilliamSeger's statement is correct.

A normal force (which is electromagnetic in origin, as with all familiar contact forces between solids) also exists and is involved in the basic scenario of a mass at rest upon the earth's surface, but that does not contradict WilliamSeger's statement that the gravitational forces between the building and the earth are equal and opposite to each other.

Your ability to provide false explanations for false claims ceases to matter at that point.
 
Last edited:
WilliamSeger's statement is correct.

A normal force (which is electromagnetic in origin, as with all familiar contact forces between solids) also exists and is involved in the basic scenario of a mass at rest upon the earth's surface, but that does not contradict WilliamSeger's statement that the gravitational forces between the building and the earth are equal and opposite to each other.

Your ability to provide false explanations for false claims ceases to matter at that point.

And this is the point where FF loses any and all credibility. This is essentially the 3rd law, the Earth pulls on the building just as much as the building pulls on the Earth, the Earth doesn't move due to the 2nd law (acceleration is indirectly related to mass), and the normal force (which is provided, simplistically) by the surface of the Earth, cancels out the gravitational force between the center of the Earth and the building on a typical day. That wasn't a typical day, as connections between the floors snapped and 10-20 stories were dropped onto the floors at a shot, increasing the momentum of each of the dropping floors, making it impossible for the connections to withhold the travelling mass.
 
WilliamSeger's statement is correct.

A normal force (which is electromagnetic in origin, as with all familiar contact forces between solids) also exists and is involved in the basic scenario of a mass at rest upon the earth's surface, but that does not contradict WilliamSeger's statement that the gravitational forces between the building and the earth are equal and opposite to each other.

Your ability to provide false explanations for false claims ceases to matter at that point.

The earth pulls on the top mass with an equal strength to the top masses pull on the earth,
Inducing stress on the structure.

William is wrong I am afraid, in the context of the model we refer too, for every action there is an equal and opposite reaction, the action is the movement of the top mass the reaction to that is the destruction of structure between the earth and the falling mass.

Gravity is a force acting upon mass not a reaction to the force, in the model we are discussing.

There will be a reaction to gravity but that will be determined by the set of energy values that are involved.

That is why I keep asking FF, for a mathematical model, which he refuses to provide.
 
How? Please post a link to a credible source proving Cole is wrong.

FalseFlag, it's time you put up, now. You've been asked to understand the basic principles involved, and the question of burden of proof. You have not done so. At this point no one has to spend any amount of time or energy to educate you. Do it yourself.
 
In the experiments with the pizza stands he is not using a weight. He is using other "floors". If you don't understand the experiment, why do you keep claiming it is wrong?

Because he's using pizza stands.

How can any experiment not agree with reality?

I can design an experiment that "proves" that planes can't fly.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom