If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
How can any experiment not agree with reality?

When it is poorly set up and unrepresentative of what it's supposed to be testing.

Let's say I decide to conduct an experiment to determine if an iceberg could have sunk the Titanic. Throwing ice cubes at a steel cookie tray would be an unrealistic experiment to see if ice can damage steel and as such would not reflect reality. In this situation the Experiment is wrong.

Similarly, as Cole's experiments don't represent the WTC they are not in agreement with reality because they don't reflect what Cole is attempting to show.
 
Last edited:
When it is poorly set up and unrepresentative of what it's supposed to be testing.

Let's say I decide to conduct an experiment to determine if an iceberg could have sunk the Titanic. Throwing ice cubes at a steel cookie tray would be an unrealistic experiment to see if ice can damage steel and as such would not reflect reality. In this situation the Experiment is wrong.

Similarly, as Cole's experiments don't represent the WTC they are not in agreement with reality because they don't reflect what Cole is attempting to show.

Exactly All Cole's experiments are seriously flawed, or down right Fraudulent for an engineer.

Either he is incompetent in the sciences or he is fraudulent take your pick those are the only
two valid options possible.
 
Watch the video again. In the experiments with the pizza stands he is not using a weight. He is using other "floors". If you don't understand the experiment, why do you keep claiming it is wrong?

because regardless of what he drops on any of them, none of the models he used are representative on the WTC in materials or construction. If the construction of the model doesn't match the construction of the real thing, then the model is pointless as far as discussing the real thing, and I'm not even dealing with the issues that scaling creates for you. Cole ignores all of this and just makes up a bunch of models that have nothing to do with the WTC structures at all. Using Cole's system, I can declare that my stack of Jenga blocks can be representative of the WTC Towers and demand you prove me wrong. You can't just invent a structure, and try and assign it to the WTC. You have to use the structure it had.
 
WilliamSeger's statement is correct.

A normal force (which is electromagnetic in origin, as with all familiar contact forces between solids) also exists and is involved in the basic scenario of a mass at rest upon the earth's surface, but that does not contradict WilliamSeger's statement that the gravitational forces between the building and the earth are equal and opposite to each other.

Your ability to provide false explanations for false claims ceases to matter at that point.
Excuse me
I want to know more about the "Normal Force". What the heck are you talking about?
It cannot be significant, compared to g, since I have (a) never heard of it, and (b) never see a calcuation using it
 
Excuse me
I want to know more about the "Normal Force". What the heck are you talking about?
It cannot be significant, compared to g, since I have (a) never heard of it, and (b) never see a calcuation using it

'Normal' in this sense means the component of the force at 90° to the point of contact, I believe.
 
That is a g force.

Only if the force involved is parallel to the force of gravity, like the force experienced by the tyres of a car standing on flat ground. If you lean a heavy object against a wall at a skinny angle (at the point of contact) then the wall/object action/reaction are far less than G would suggest.
 
What? Do you even understand what you are trying to say?



So many posts that are sticky-worthy. If Cole's model doesn't replicate the "widely accepted" scenarios, what is the ONLY LOGICAL CONCLUSION? Yes, caps are appropriate. The only logical conclusion is that the "widely accepted scenarios", based on words and not experiments, are wrong.

No, other similar experiments demonstrate that Cole's conclusions don't apply to those experiments. Therefore Cole's conclusions are wrong wrt Newtons laws.
 
Last edited:
Only if the force involved is parallel to the force of gravity, like the force experienced by the tyres of a car standing on flat ground. If you lean a heavy object against a wall at a skinny angle (at the point of contact) then the wall/object action/reaction are far less than G would suggest.
Um. No.
The sum of vertical reactions is m*g.
The sum of the horizontal reactions is zero, with each reaction being m*g* sin (angle)
 
2 forces- gravity and the normal force?

WTF? Over...

The "normal force" is the component of the forces acting upon an object in contact with a surface. The "normal force" is perpendicular to the surface; for an object is sitting on a horizontal surface, the normal force is equivalent to, and opposes, the weight of the object. As a practical matter, the "normal force" is simply an expression of the ability of the surface to support the object.
 
The fact that you continue to have any issue with scale in regards to an experiment involving direction of net force is undeniable proof you do not understand Cole's experiment.
I've just started to watch Cole's second video.

He chooses an arbitrary and very short separation between planks. It can be shown that separation between floors is a determinant factor in whether the collapse will arrest or not. Larger distances mean the falling block will have a better chance to recover speed thanks to the acceleration of gravity, and end up impacting the next plank with more, rather than less, speed.

He didn't lay his planks at a distance of 12 feet from each other, and his choice of distance causes arrest. He doesn't justify that weird choice with maths derived from the scaling of the WTC towers.

Cole-arrest.jpg


He just disregards scale issues when he chooses the separation between planks.

Furthermore, the very fact that the mass of one plank is not enough to cause the collapse of the rest, is indication that his model is not representative of the collapses. Take a look at the Metabunk thread that JayDeeHess has posted at least a couple of times, to see an experiment that proves Cole's one wrong.

Here's a video from that thread:



That video shows an instance of an experiment (still ongoing as far as I can tell) that proves that Cole's conclusion:

Cole-conclusion.jpg


is WRONG !


ETA:
How? Please provide proof that "his experiments don't apply to his claims."
Done.

The Metabunk thread: https://www.metabunk.org/towards-a-...ive-collapse-of-the-wtc-towers-on-9-11.t7396/

(It's behind a CloudFlare barrier so I can only read it by using some special means).
 
Last edited:
The "normal force" is the component of the forces acting upon an object in contact with a surface. The "normal force" is perpendicular to the surface; for an object is sitting on a horizontal surface, the normal force is equivalent to, and opposes, the weight of the object. As a practical matter, the "normal force" is simply an expression of the ability of the surface to support the object.
It is rather obvious, at least to me, that a lot of folks who are posting here don't do much loads analysis
...
Or build any kind of structure.
 
A very large group of persons, the great majority of which have the qualifications you call for, have rejected the conclusions you support.
In this forum alone, that includes a fair number of engineers and architects, by the way (I've counted at least 8 9 engineers and 3 4 architects, and those are only the ones I know off the top of my head). The only engineer I can recall who posts here and has affine ideas is Tony Szamboti. It's a very small sample, but it means that in this forum alone the proportion is at least 11 12 13:1.

[ETA: that doesn't count physicists, of which I know of at least three).
 
Last edited:
Where you go wrong is when you assume that if floor 2 starts to accelerate downwards, the forces during impact were not equal. We know they had to be equal and in the opposite direction of each other.
Newton's first law proves that your understanding of Newton's third law is wrong.

Had the forces been equal, the movement would stop there.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom